Editorial Board Self-Publishing Rates in Czech Economic Journals
- 138 Downloads
This article investigates whether editorial board members of selected economic journals publish their research papers in their ‘own’ journal. Journals were selected from the Journal Citation Report® from the categories Business; Business, Finance; and Economics. Only research articles published between 2012 and 2015 were included in the analysis. We recorded ratios concerning the share of articles authored by editorial board members, the share of editorial board members publishing in their own journals and ratios representing their publication output. The average share of articles authored by editorial board members ranges from 0.6 to 17.5%. The average share of editorial board members publishing in their own journals ranges from 5.6 to 24.4%. Considering only editorial board members publishing in their own journals, the share of their articles in their journals ranges from 8.2 to 71.4%. While the share of board members publishing only in their own journals, to the number of board members publishing in their own journals, the ratio in a quarter of journals is equal to zero, with a maximum reach of 85.7%. All observed ratios are significantly positively correlated with the gap between impact factor and impact factor without Journal Self Cites; and negatively correlated with the Article Influence Score. A cluster of journals in which a high proportion of editorial board members publish and simultaneously these members publish in their own journal at a high rate was identified.
KeywordsEditors Editorial boards Journals Bibliometrics Economics The Czech Republic
This study was supported by Research Program of the Department of Accounting and Finance (RVO160).
- Arnold, E. (2011). International audit of research, development and innovation in the Czech Republic: Synthesis report. http://audit-vav.reformy-msmt.cz/download-document/58-synteticka-zaverecna-zprava-aj. Accessed April 3, 2017.
- Colussi, T. (2015). Social ties in Academia: A friend is a treasure. Institute for the Study of Labor, Discussion Paper No. 9414.Google Scholar
- Donovan, B. (1998). The truth about peer review. ICSU Press Workshop. http://www.bodley.ox.ac.uk/icsu/donovanppr.htm. Accessed January 15, 2017.
- Harzing, A., & Metz, I. (2011). Gender and geographic diversity in the editorial board of the journal of international business studies. AIB Insights, 11(3), 3–7.Google Scholar
- Hilmer, M. J., & Hilmer, C. E. (2011). Do editors favor their students’ work? A test of undue favoritism in top economics journals. Economics Bulletin, 31(1), 53–65.Google Scholar
- Hoey, J. (1999). When editors publish in their own journals. Canadian Medical Association Journal, 161(11), 1412–1413.Google Scholar
- Jurajda, Š., Kozubek, S., Münich, D., & Škoda, S. (2015a). An international comparison of the quality of academic publication output in the Czech Republic. Praha: Národohospodářský ústav AV ČR.Google Scholar
- Jurajda, Š., Kozubek, S., Münich, D., & Škoda, S. (2015b). Medzinárodné porovnanie kvality publikačného výkonu vedných odborov na Slovensku. Praha: Národohospodářský ústav AV ČR.Google Scholar
- Jurajda, Š., & Münich, D. (2015). Oborová publikační výkonnost pracovišť výzkumných organizací v České republice v letech 2008–2012. Praha: Národohospodářský ústav AV ČR.Google Scholar
- Macháček, M., & Kolcunová, E. (2005). Publish or perish? On the importance of publishing on the economic sciences tenure-track in the Czech Republic. Finance a úvěr—Czech Journal of Economics and Finance, 55(11–12), 563–577.Google Scholar
- Macháček, M., Kolcunová, E., & Závacká, J. (2015). Publishing performance of Czech Academic Economists: (just) a matter of time? In M. R. López, & J. Graves (Eds.), Investigaciones de economía de la educación (vol 10(10), pp. 271–283).Google Scholar
- Münich, D. (2006). Recent publication productivity of czech economists. Finance a úvěr—Czech Journal of Economics and Finance, 56(11–12), 522–533.Google Scholar