Reexamining the Ethics of Nuclear Technology
- 824 Downloads
This article analyzes the present status, development trends, and problems in the ethics of nuclear technology in light of a possible revision of its conceptual foundations. First, to better recognize the current state of nuclear technology ethics and related problems, this article focuses on presenting a picture of the evolution of the concepts and recent achievements related to technoethics, based on the ethics of responsibility. The term ‘ethics of nuclear technology’ describes a multidisciplinary endeavor to examine the problems associated with nuclear technology through ethical frameworks and paradigms. Second, to identify the reasons for the intensification of efforts to develop ethics in relation to nuclear technology, this article presents an analysis of the recent situation and future prospects of nuclear technology deployment. This includes contradictions that have aggravated nuclear dilemmas and debates stimulated by the shortcomings of nuclear technology, as well as the need for the further development of a nuclear culture paradigm that is able to provide a conceptual framework to overcome nuclear challenges. Third, efforts in the field of nuclear technology ethics are presented as a short overview of particular examples, and the major findings regarding obstacles to the development of nuclear technology ethics are also summarized. Finally, a potential methodological course is proposed to overcome inaction in this field; the proposed course provides for the further development of nuclear technology ethics, assuming the axiological multidisciplinary problematization of the main concepts in nuclear engineering through the basic ethical paradigms: analytical, hermeneutical, and poststructuralist.
KeywordsEthics Responsibility Nuclear technology Holistic approach Engineering Dilemma Challenges
- Andrianov, A. (2011). Approaches to and methods for quantitative assessment of nuclear proliferation risk (p. 132). Obninsk: INPE NRNU MEPhI.Google Scholar
- Andrianov, A. (2014). Towards sustainable nuclear power development. ATW: International Journal for Nuclear Power, 59(5), 287–293.Google Scholar
- Code of Ethics of ANS. Accessed 2014. http://www.ans.org/about/coe/.
- Gorokhov, V. (1995). The philosophy of technology. In V. Styopin, Gorokhov, V., Rosov, M. (Eds.) The philosophy of science and technology (pp. 289–377). Moscow, [in Russian].Google Scholar
- Granoff, J. (2000) (Ed.). Nuclear weapons, ethics, morals, and law. Accessed 2013. http://gsinstitute.s3.amazonaws.com/assets/gsi/docs/BYU.pdf.
- International Atomic Energy Agency (2007). Establishing a code of ethics for nuclear operating organizations. IAEA Nuclear Energy Series No. NG-T-1.2, IAEA, Vienna.Google Scholar
- International Atomic Energy Agency (2008a). Nuclear security culture. IAEA Nuclear Energy Series No.7, IAEA, Vienna.Google Scholar
- International Atomic Energy Agency (2008b). Nuclear energy basic principles, IAEA Nuclear Energy Series No. NE-BP, IAEA, Vienna.Google Scholar
- International Atomic Energy Agency (2009). Nuclear power objectives: Achieving the nuclear energy basic principles, IAEA Nuclear Energy Series No. NP-O, IAEA, Vienna.Google Scholar
- International Atomic Energy Agency (2011a). Nuclear energy general objectives, IAEA Nuclear Energy Series No. NG-O, IAEA, Vienna.Google Scholar
- International Atomic Energy Agency (2011b). Nuclear fuel cycle objectives, IAEA Nuclear Energy Series No. NF-O, IAEA, Vienna.Google Scholar
- International Atomic Energy Agency (2011c). Radioactive waste management objectives, IAEA Nuclear Energy Series No. NW-O, IAEA, Vienna.Google Scholar
- International Atomic Energy Agency, Status and Trends of Nuclear Technologies—Report of the International Project on Innovative Nuclear Reactors and Fuel Cycles (INPRO). IAEA TECDOC 1622, Vienna.Google Scholar
- INPRO web-page, The International Project on Innovative Nuclear Reactors and Fuel Cycles. Available online: http://www.iaea.org/INPRO/.
- Jonas, H. (1979). Der Prinzip Verantwortung, Stuttgart.Google Scholar
- Kanke, V. (2003). Ethics of responsibility. Future Moral Theory. Moscow, ‘Logos’ [in Russian].Google Scholar
- Kanke, V. (2009). The general philosophy of science. Moscow, ‘Omega-L’ [in Russian].Google Scholar
- Kanke, V. (2010). Modern ethics, 3rd edition. Moscow, ‘Omega-L’ [in Russian].Google Scholar
- Kanke, V. (2013). Methodology of scientific knowledge. Moscow, ‘Omega-L’ [in Russian].Google Scholar
- Kötter, R. (1986). Modell und ökonomishe Rationalitat. In E. Hodl, G Muller (Hrsg.) Die Neoklassik und ihre Kritik (pp. 41–59). Frankfurt, a. M.Google Scholar
- Lenk, H. (1986) (Hrsg). Technikbewertung. Philosophische und psychologische Prespektiven. Frankfurt a. M.: Suhrkamp.Google Scholar
- Lenk, H., Ropohl, G. (Hg.) (1993) VDI-Ausschuss: Grundlagen der Technikbewertung, Richtlinie VDI 3780. Technikbewertung: Begriffe und Grundlagen/Technik und Ethik. 2 Aufl. Stuttgart, pp. 334–363.Google Scholar
- Lenk, H., Ropohl, G. (1993). Technik zwischen Koennen und Sollen. In Lenk H., Ropohl G. (Hg.). Technik und Ethik (pp. 5–21). 2 Aufl. Stuttgart, 1993.Google Scholar
- Mitcham, C. (1995). Chto takoe filosofiia tekhniki?. Moscow: Aspekt Press.Google Scholar
- Murogov, V. (2014). Culture of nuclear nonproliferation: multiple-author monograph. Moscow: NRNU MEPhI.Google Scholar
- Nuclear Energy Agency (2002), NEA news No 20.2.Google Scholar
- Nye, J. (1986). Nuclear ethics. New York: The Free Press. ISBN 0-02-923091-8.Google Scholar
- Ostreykovsky, V. (1999). Operation of nuclear power plants. Moscow [in Russian].Google Scholar
- Robertson, J. (2003). Nuclear energy—an ethical choice. Accessed 2014. http://www.nwmo.ca/uploads_managed/MediaFiles/628_2-CJ.A.L.Robertson_NuclearEnergy-AnEthicalChoice.pdf.
- Schuurman, E. (2010). Responsible ethics for global technology. Axiomathes, 20:107–127, Springer.Google Scholar
- Smil, V. (2010). Energy myths and realities: Bringing science to the energy policy debate. Washington, DC: American Enterprise Institute.Google Scholar
- UNESCO Bangkok (2012). Ethics and nuclear energy technology, ethics and climate change in Asia and the Pacific (ECCAP) Project, Working Group 12 Report, Bangkok 138 pp.Google Scholar
- Word Nuclear Association, Safety of Nuclear Power Reactors, http://www.world-nuclear.org/info/Safety-and-Security/Safety-of-Plants/Safety-of-Nuclear-Power-Reactors/.
- Word Nuclear Association, Fast Neutron Reactors, http://www.world-nuclear.org/info/Current-and-Future-Generation/Fast-Neutron-Reactors/.