Advertisement

Does CEO (over)compensation influence corporate reputation?

  • Ann-Christine Schulz
  • Miriam FlickingerEmail author
Original Paper

Abstract

This paper investigates the impact of CEO excess compensation on corporate reputation. Past research has focused mainly on understanding how CEO overpayment is related to firm performance. As a consequence, we know relatively little about the implications of paying excess compensation for other important firm outcomes such as corporate reputation. By analyzing a sample of S&P 100 firms over the period 1995–2010, we show that overpayment in total compensation has a weak positive effect on a firm’s reputation while overpayment in stock options has a significant and negative impact on corporate reputation. Moreover, we find that the negative impact of CEO excess compensation in stock options is augmented if there has been a CEO change during the previous year, whereas this effect is lessened by CEO tenure. These results demonstrate that the relationship between excessive CEO compensation and corporate reputation is complex. It is influenced by the type of compensation and by specific CEO characteristics that invite greater public attention and scrutiny.

Keywords

Corporate reputation CEO compensation Excess compensation Overpayment 

JEL Classification

M12 L21 

References

  1. Abrahamson E (1996) Management fashion. Acad Manag Rev 21(1):254–285Google Scholar
  2. Abrahamson E, Fairchild G (1999) Management fashion: lifecycles, triggers, and collective learning processes. Adm Sci Q 44(4):708–740Google Scholar
  3. Aguilera RV, Filatotchev I, Gospel H, Jackson G (2008) An organizational approach to comparative corporate governance: costs, contingencies, and complementarities. Organ Sci 19(3):475–492Google Scholar
  4. Aiken LS, West SG (1991) Multiple regression: testing and interpreting interactions. Sage, Newbury ParkGoogle Scholar
  5. Alchian AA, Demsetz H (1972) Production, information costs, and economic organization. Am Econ Rev 62(5):777–795Google Scholar
  6. Ang AR, Hodrick RJ, Xing Y, Zhang X (2006) The cross-section of volatility and expected returns. J Fin 61(1):259–299Google Scholar
  7. Balafas N, Florackis C (2014) CEO compensation and future shareholder returns: evidence from the London stock exchange. J Empir Fin 27:97–115Google Scholar
  8. Bansal P, Clelland I (2004) Talking trash: legitimacy, impression management, and unsystematic risk in the context of the natural environment. Acad Manag J 47(1):93–103Google Scholar
  9. Barkema HG, Gomez-Mejia LR (1998) Managerial compensation and firm performance: a general research framework. Acad Manag J 41(2):135–145Google Scholar
  10. Barney JB (1991) Firm resources and sustained competitive advantage. J Manag 17(1):99–120Google Scholar
  11. Basdeo DK, Smith KG, Grimm CM, Rindova VP, Derfus PJ (2006) The impact of market actions on firm reputation. Strateg Manag J 27(12):1205–1219Google Scholar
  12. Beasley MS (1996) An empirical analysis of the relation between the board of director composition and financial statement fraud. Account Rev 71(4):443–465Google Scholar
  13. Beasley MS, Carcello JV, Hermanson DR, Lapides PD (2000) Fraudulent financial reporting: consideration of industry traits and corporate governance mechanisms. Account Horiz 14(4):441–454Google Scholar
  14. Bebchuk LA, Fried JM (2003) Executive compensation as an agency problem. J Econ Perspect 17(3):71–92Google Scholar
  15. Bebchuk LA, Fried JM (2004) Pay without performance: the unfulfilled promise of executive compensation. Harvard University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  16. Bebchuk LA, Fried JM (2006) Pay without performance: overview of the issues. Acad Manag Perspect 20(1):5–24Google Scholar
  17. Bebchuk LA, Fried JM, Walker D (2002) Managerial power and rent extraction in the design of executive compensation. Univ Chicago Law Rev 69:751–846Google Scholar
  18. Bednar MK, Love EG, Kraatz M (2015) Paying the price? The impact of controversial governance practices onmanagerial reputation. Acad Manag J 58(6):1740–1760Google Scholar
  19. Belkaoui A, Pavlik E (1991) Asset management performance and reputation building for large US firms. Br J Manag 2(4):231–238Google Scholar
  20. Benjamin BA, Podolny JM (1999) Status, quality, and social order in the California wine industry. Adm Sci Q 44(3):563–589Google Scholar
  21. Bergh DD, Ketchen JDJ, Boyd BK, Bergh J (2010) New frontiers of the reputation–performance relationship: insights from multiple theories. J Manag 36(3):620–632Google Scholar
  22. Bermiss YS, Zajac EJ, King BG (2014) Under construction: how commensuration and management fashion affect corporate reputation rankings. Organ Sci 25(2):591–608Google Scholar
  23. Bizjak J, Lemmon M, Nguyen T (2011) Are all CEOs above average? An empirical analysis of compensation peer groups and pay design. J Financ Econ 100(3):538–555Google Scholar
  24. Black F, Scholes M (1973) The pricing of options and corporate liabilities. J Polit Econ 81(3):637–654Google Scholar
  25. Brammer S, Pavelin S (2006) Corporate reputation and social performance: the importance of fit. J Manage Stud 43(3):435–455Google Scholar
  26. Brammer S, Millington A, Pavelin S (2009) Corporate reputation and women on the board. Br J Manag 20(1):17–29Google Scholar
  27. Brick IE, Palmon O, Wald JK (2006) CEO compensation, director compensation, and firm performance: evidence of cronyism? J Corp Financ 12(3):403–423Google Scholar
  28. Brown B, Perry S (1994) Removing the financial performance halo from Fortune’s “most admired” companies. Acad Manag J 37(5):1347–1359Google Scholar
  29. Burns N, Kedia S (2006) The impact of performance-based compensation on misreporting. J Financ Econ 79(1):35–67Google Scholar
  30. Cadman B, Carter ME, Hillegeist S (2010) The incentives of compensation consultants and CEO pay. J Account Econ 49(3):263–280Google Scholar
  31. Carberry EJ, King BG (2012) Defensive practice adoption in the face of organizational stigma: impression management and the diffusion of stock option expensing. J Manag Stud 49(7):1137–1167Google Scholar
  32. Chatterjee A, Hambrick DC (2011) Executive personality, capability cues, and risk taking: how narcissistic CEOs react to their successes and stumbles. Adm Sci Q 56(2):202–237Google Scholar
  33. Conyon MJ (2014) Executive compensation and board governance in US firms. Econ J 124(574):F60–F89Google Scholar
  34. Conyon MJ, Murphy KJ (2000) The prince and the pauper? CEO pay in the United States and United Kingdom. Econ J 110(467):640–671Google Scholar
  35. Conyon MJ, Gregg P, Machin SJ (1995) Taking care of business: executive compensation in the UK. Econ J 105(430):704–714Google Scholar
  36. Cooper MJ, Gulen H, Rau PR (2016) Performance for pay? The relation between CEO incentive compensation and future stock price performance. Working paper available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1572085, Accessed 12 Nov 2016
  37. Core JE, Guay W, Larcker DF (2008) The power of the pen and executive compensation. J Financ Econ 88(1):1–25Google Scholar
  38. Daily CM, Dalton DR, Cannella AA Jr (2003) Corporate governance: decades of dialogue and data. Acad Manag Rev 28(3):371–382Google Scholar
  39. Deephouse DL (2000) Media reputation as a strategic resource: an integration of mass communication and resource-based theories. J Manag 26(6):1091–1112Google Scholar
  40. Demsetz H, Lehn K (1985) The structure of corporate ownership: causes and consequences. J Polit Econ 93(6):1155–1177Google Scholar
  41. Desai VM (2014) The impact of media information on issue salience following other organizations’ failures. J Manag 40(3):893–918Google Scholar
  42. Desai VM (2016) The behavioral theory of the (governed) firm: corporate board influences on organizations’ responses to performance shortfalls. Acad Manag J 59(3):860–879Google Scholar
  43. Devers CE, Cannella AA Jr, Reilly GP, Yoder ME (2007) Executive compensation: a multidisciplinary review of recent developments. J Manag 33(6):1016–1072Google Scholar
  44. Devers CE, McNamara G, Wiseman RM, Arrfelt M (2008) Moving closer to the action: examining compensation design effects on firm risk. Organ Sci 19(4):548–566Google Scholar
  45. DiPrete TA, Eirich GM, Pittinsky M (2010) Compensation benchmarking, leapfrogs, and the surge in executive pay. Am J Sociol 115(6):1671–1712Google Scholar
  46. Donoher WJ, Reed R, Storrud-Barnes SF (2007) Incentive alignment, control, and the issue of misleading financial disclosures. J Manag 33(4):547–569Google Scholar
  47. Dowling GR (2016) Defining and measuring corporate reputation. Eur Manag Rev 13:207–223Google Scholar
  48. Eberl M, Schwaiger M (2005) Corporate reputation: disentangling the effects on financial performance. Eur J Mark 39(7/8):838–854Google Scholar
  49. Eisenhardt KM (1989) Agency theory: an assessment and review. Acad Manag Rev 14(1):57–74Google Scholar
  50. Ezzamel M, Watson R (1998) Market comparison earnings and the bidding-up of executive cash compensation: evidence from the United Kingdom. Acad Manag J 41(2):221–231Google Scholar
  51. Fama EF (1980) Agency problems and the theory of the firm. J Polit Econ 88(2):288–307Google Scholar
  52. Fama EF, Jensen MC (1983) Separation of ownership and control. J Law Econ 26(2):301–326Google Scholar
  53. Faulkender M, Yang J (2010) Inside the black box: the role and composition of compensation peer groups. J Financ Econ 96(2):257–270Google Scholar
  54. Faulkender M, Yang J (2013) Is disclosure an effective cleansing mechanism? The dynamics of compensation peer benchmarking. Rev Financ Stud 26(3):806–839Google Scholar
  55. Finkelstein S, Hambrick DC (1988) Chief executive compensation: a synthesis and reconciliation. Strateg Manag J 9(6):543–558Google Scholar
  56. Finkelstein S, Hambrick DC (1989) Chief executive compensation: a study of the intersection of markets and political processes. Strateg Manag J 10(2):121–134Google Scholar
  57. Flanagan DJ, O’Shaughnessy KC (2005) The effect of layoffs on firm reputation. J Manag 31(3):445–463Google Scholar
  58. Focke F, Maug E, Niessen-Ruenzi A (2017) The impact of firm prestige on executive compensation. J Financ Econ 123(2):313–336Google Scholar
  59. Fombrun CJ (1996) Reputation: realizing value from the corporate image. Harvard Business School, BostonGoogle Scholar
  60. Fombrun C, Shanley M (1990) What’s in a name? Reputation building and corporate strategy. Acad Manag J 33(2):233–258Google Scholar
  61. Fong EA (2010) CEO pay fairness as a predictor of stakeholder management. J Bus Res 63(4):404–410Google Scholar
  62. Fong EA, Misangyi VF, Tosi HL (2010) The effect of CEO pay deviations on CEO withdrawal, firm size, and firm profits. Strateg Manag J 31(6):629–651Google Scholar
  63. Fong EA, Xing X, Orman WH, Mackenzie WI (2015) Consequences of deviating from predicted CEO labor market compensation on long-term firm value. J Bus Res 68(2):299–305Google Scholar
  64. Fortune (2011) How can we address excessive CEO pay? Apr 13: http://fortune.com/2011/04/13/how-can-we-address-excessive-ceo-pay. Accessed 12 Nov 2016
  65. Frooman J (1999) Stakeholder influence strategies. Acad Manag Rev 24(2):191–205Google Scholar
  66. Goergen M, Renneboog L (2011) Managerial compensation. J Corp Financ 17(4):1068–1077Google Scholar
  67. Gomez-Mejia L, Wiseman RM (1997) Reframing executive compensation: an assessment and outlook. J Manag 23(3):291–374Google Scholar
  68. Graffin SD, Carpenter MA, Boivie S (2011) What’s all that (strategic) noise? Anticipatory impression management in CEO succession. Strateg Manag J 32(7):748–770Google Scholar
  69. Hammond SA, Slocum JW (1996) The impact of prior firm financial performance on subsequent corporate reputation. J Bus Ethics 15(2):159–165Google Scholar
  70. Harris J, Bromiley P (2007) Incentives to cheat: the influence of executive compensation and firm performance on financial misrepresentation. Organ Sci 18(3):350–367Google Scholar
  71. Hayes RM, Schaefer S (2009) CEO pay and the Lake Wobegon effect. J Financ Econ 94(2):280–290Google Scholar
  72. Hayward MLA, Rindova VP, Pollock TG (2004) Believing one’s own press: the causes and consequences of CEO celebrity. Strateg Manag J 25(7):637–653Google Scholar
  73. Hill AD, Upadhyay AD, Beekun RI (2015) Do female and ethnically diverse executives endure inequity in the CEO position or do they benefit from their minority status? An empirical examination. Strateg Manag J 36(8):1115–1134Google Scholar
  74. Holmstrom B (1979) Moral hazard and observability. Bell J Econ 10(1):74–91Google Scholar
  75. Jensen MC, Meckling WH (1976) Theory of the firm: managerial behavior, agency costs and ownership structure. J Financ Econ 3(4):305–360Google Scholar
  76. Jensen MC, Murphy KJ (1990) CEO incentives—it’s not how much you pay, but how. Harvard Bus Rev 68(3):138–149Google Scholar
  77. Johnson WC, Xie W, Yi S (2014) Corporate fraud and the value of reputations in the product market. J Corp Financ 25:16–39Google Scholar
  78. Joutsenvirta M (2013) Executive pay and legitimacy: changing discursive battles over the morality of excessive manager compensation. J Bus Ethics 116(3):459–477Google Scholar
  79. Kang E (2008) Director interlocks and spillover effects of reputational penalties from financial reporting fraud. Acad Manag J 51(3):537–555Google Scholar
  80. Kaplan SN (2008) Are U.S. CEOs overpaid? Acad Manag Perspect 22(2):5–20Google Scholar
  81. Karpoff JM, Lee DS, Martin GS (2008) The cost to firms of cooking the books. J Financ Quant Anal 43(3):581–612Google Scholar
  82. Khurana R (2002) The curse of the superstar CEO. Harvard Bus Rev 80(9):60–66Google Scholar
  83. Kuhnen CM, Niessen A (2012) Public opinion and executive compensation. Manag Sci 58(7):1249–2172Google Scholar
  84. Lee GK, Paruchuri S (2008) Entry into emergent and uncertain product-markets: the role of associative rhetoric. Acad Manag J 51(6):1171–1188Google Scholar
  85. Love EG, Kraatz M (2009) Character, conformity, or the bottom line? How and why downsizing affected corporate reputation. Acad Manag J 52(2):314–335Google Scholar
  86. Lungeanu R, Zajac EJ (2016) Venture capital ownership as a contingent resource: how owner–firm fit influences IPO outcomes. Acad Manag J 59(3):930–955Google Scholar
  87. Malmendier U, Tate G (2009) Superstar CEO’s. Quart J Econ 124(4):1593–1638Google Scholar
  88. Martin GP, Gomez-Mejia LR, Wiseman RM (2013) Executive stock options as mixed gambles: revisiting the behavioral agency model. Acad Manag J 56(2):451–472Google Scholar
  89. McDonald ML, Khanna P, Westphal JD (2008) Getting them to think outside the circle: corporate governance, CEOs’ external advice networks, and firm performance. Acad Manag J 51(3):453–475Google Scholar
  90. McGuire JB, Schneeweis T, Branch B (1990) Perceptions of firm quality: a cause or result of firm performance. J Manag 16(1):167–180Google Scholar
  91. Misangyi VF, Acharya AG (2014) Substitutes or complements? A configurational examination of corporate governance mechanisms. Acad Manag J 57(6):1681–1705Google Scholar
  92. Mizruchi MS (1983) Who controls whom? An examination of the relation between management and boards of directors in large American corporations. Acad Manag Rev 8(3):426–435Google Scholar
  93. Money (2016) Most Americans can’t guess the average CEO’s salary. Can you? Feb 5: http://time.com/money/4209388/average-ceo-salary-survey/. Accessed 12 Nov 2016
  94. Monks RAG, Minow N (2011) Corporate Governance. Wiley, ChichesterGoogle Scholar
  95. Moriarty J (2009) How much compensation can CEOs permissibly accept? Bus Ethics Q 19(2):235–250Google Scholar
  96. Murphy KJ (1986) Incentives, learning, and compensation: a theoretical and empirical investigation of managerial labor contracts. RAND J Econ 17(1):59–76Google Scholar
  97. Murphy KJ (1999) Executive compensation. In: Ashenfelter O, Card D (eds) Handbook of labor economics. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp 2485–2563Google Scholar
  98. Murphy KJ (2002) Explaining executive compensation: managerial power versus the perceived cost of stock options. Univ Chic Law Rev 69(3):847–869Google Scholar
  99. Murphy KJ (2013) Executive compensation: where we are and how we got there. In: Constantinides GM, Harris M, Stulz RM (eds) Handbook of the economics of finance 2a: Corporate finance. Elsevier Science, North Holland, pp 211–356Google Scholar
  100. Murphy KJ, Zábojník J (2004) CEO pay and appointments: a market-based explanation for recent trends. Am Econ Rev 94(2):192–196Google Scholar
  101. Musteen M, Datta DK, Kemmerer B (2010) Corporate reputation: do board characteristics matter? Br J Manag 21(2):498–510Google Scholar
  102. O’Reilly CA III, Main BG (2010) Economic and psychological perspectives on CEO compensation: a review and synthesis. Ind Corp Change 19(3):675–712Google Scholar
  103. O’Reilly CA III, Main BG, Crystal GS (1988) CEO compensation as tournament and social comparison: a tale of two theories. Adm Sci Q 33(2):257–274Google Scholar
  104. Page B, Jacobs L (2009) Class war? What Americans really think about economic inequality. University of Chicago Press, ChicagoGoogle Scholar
  105. Pan Y, Wang TY, Weisbach MS (2015) Learning about CEO ability and stock return volatility. Rev Financ Stud 28(6):1623–1666Google Scholar
  106. Pandher G, Currie R (2013) CEO compensation: a resource advantage and stakeholder-bargaining perspective. Strateg Manag J 34(1):22–41Google Scholar
  107. Paywatch (2016) AFL-CIO Executive Paywatch. http://www.aflcio.org/Corporate-Watch/Paywatch-2016. Accessed 12 Nov 2016
  108. Philippe D, Durand R (2011) The impact of norm-conforming behaviors on firm reputation. Strateg Manag J 32(9):969–993Google Scholar
  109. Piketty T, Saez E (2013) Top incomes and the great recession: recent evolutions and policy implications. IMF Econ Rev 61(3):456–478Google Scholar
  110. Pollock TG, Rindova VP (2003) Media legitimation effects in the market for initial public offerings. Acad Manag J 46(5):631–642Google Scholar
  111. Porac JF, Wade JB, Pollock TG (1999) Industry categories and the politics of the comparable firm in CEO compensation. Adm Sci Q 44(1):112–144Google Scholar
  112. Raithel S, Schwaiger M (2015) The effects of corporate reputation perceptions of the general public on shareholder value. Strateg Manag J 36(6):945–956Google Scholar
  113. Rao H (1994) The social construction of reputation: certification contests, legitimation, and the survival of organizations in the American automobile industry: 1895–1912. Strateg Manag J 15(S1):29–44Google Scholar
  114. Roberts PW, Dowling GR (2002) Corporate reputation and sustained superior financial performance. Strateg Manag J 23(12):1077–1093Google Scholar
  115. Rodriguez-Ariza L, Martinez-Ferrero J, Bermejo-Sanchez M (2016) Consequences of earnings management for corporate reputation. Account Res J 29:457–474Google Scholar
  116. Rose C, Thomsen S (2004) The impact of corporate reputation on performance: some Danish evidence. Eur Manag J 22(2):201–210Google Scholar
  117. Rosen S (1981) The economics of superstars. Am Econ Rev 71(5):845–858Google Scholar
  118. Sageder M, Mitter C, Feldbauer-Durstmüller B (2018) Image and reputation of family firms: a systematic literature review of the state of research. RMS 12(1):335–377Google Scholar
  119. Sanders WG (2001) Incentive alignment, CEO pay level, and firm performance: a case of ‘heads I win, tails you lose’? Hum Resour Manag 40(2):159–170Google Scholar
  120. Sanders WG, Hambrick DC (2007) Swinging for the fences: the effects of CEO stock options on company risk taking and performance. Acad Manag J 50(5):1055–1078Google Scholar
  121. Sarstedt M, Wilczynski P, Melewar TC (2013) Measuring reputation in global markets—A comparison of reputation measures’ convergent and criterion validities. J World Bus 48(3):329–339Google Scholar
  122. Schulz AC, Johann S (2018) Downsizing and the fragility of corporate reputation: an analysis of the impact of contextual factors. Scand J Manag 34:40–50Google Scholar
  123. Scott WR (2001) Institutions and organizations, 2nd edn. Sage, Thousand OaksGoogle Scholar
  124. Seo J, Gamache DL, Devers CE, Carpenter MA (2015) The role of CEO relative standing in acquisition behavior and CEO pay. Strateg Manag J 36(12):1877–1894Google Scholar
  125. Shapiro C (1982) Consumer information, product quality, and seller reputation. Bell J Econ 13(1):20–35Google Scholar
  126. Shapiro C (1983) Premiums for high quality products as returns to reputations. Quart J Econ 98(4):659–679Google Scholar
  127. Shleifer A, Vishny RW (1986) Large shareholders and corporate control. J Polit Econ 94(1):461–488Google Scholar
  128. Shleifer A, Vishny RW (1997) A survey of corporate governance. J Financ 52(2):737–783Google Scholar
  129. Staw BM, Epstein LD (2000) What bandwagons bring: effects of popular management techniques on corporate performance, reputation, and CEO pay. Adm Sci Q 45(3):523–556Google Scholar
  130. Tadelis S (1999) What’s in a name? Reputation as a tradeable asset. Am Econ Rev 89(3):548–563Google Scholar
  131. Tosi HL, Werner S, Katz JP, Gomez-Mejia LR (2000) How much does performance matter? A meta-analysis of CEO pay studies. J Manag 26(2):301–339Google Scholar
  132. Treadway DC, Adams GL, Ranft AL, Ferris GR (2009) A meso-level conceptualization of CEO celebrity effectiveness. Leadersh Quart 20(4):554–570Google Scholar
  133. van Essen M, Otten J, Carberry EJ (2015) Assessing managerial power theory: a meta-analytic approach to understanding the determinants of CEO compensation. J Manag 41(1):164–202Google Scholar
  134. Vergne JP, Wernicke G, Brenner S (2018) Signal incongruence and its consequences: a study of media disapproval and CEO overcompensation. Organ Sci.  https://doi.org/10.1287/orsc.2018.1209 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  135. Villalonga B, Amit R (2006) How do family ownership, control and management affect firm value? J Financ Econ 80(2):385–417Google Scholar
  136. Wade JB, O’Reilly CA III, Pollock TG (2006a) Overpaid CEOs and underpaid managers: fairness and executive compensation. Organ Sci 17(5):527–544Google Scholar
  137. Wade JB, Porac JF, Pollock TG, Graffin SD (2006b) The burden of celebrity: the impact of CEO certification contests on CEO pay and performance. Acad Manag J 49(4):643–660Google Scholar
  138. Walker K (2010) A systematic review of the corporate reputation literature: definition, measurement, and theory. Corp Reput Rev 12(4):357–387Google Scholar
  139. Walsh JP (2008) CEO compensation and the responsibilities of the business scholar to society. Acad Manag Perspect 22(2):26–33Google Scholar
  140. Wang M-S (2016) Idiosyncratic volatility, executive compensation and corporate governance: examination of the direct and moderate effects. RMS 10(2):213–244Google Scholar
  141. Wright P, Kroll M, Krug JA, Pettus M (2007) Influences of top management team incentives on firm risk taking. Strateg Manag J 28(1):81–89Google Scholar
  142. Xiaomeng Z, Bartol KM, Smith KG, Pfarrer MD, Khanin DM (2008) CEOs on the edge: earnings manipulation and stock-based incentive misalignment. Acad Manag J 51(2):241–258Google Scholar
  143. Zyglidopoulos SC (2005) The impact of downsizing on corporate reputation. Br J Manag 16(3):253–259Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer-Verlag GmbH Germany, part of Springer Nature 2018

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.University of Applied Sciences for Management and Communication (FH Wien der WKW)ViennaAustria
  2. 2.Department of ManagementAarhus UniversityAarhus VDenmark

Personalised recommendations