Advertisement

Cliometrica

pp 1–41 | Cite as

How much did uncertainty shocks matter in the Great Depression?

  • Gabriel P. MathyEmail author
Original Paper

Abstract

The USA in the 1930s experienced unprecedented uncertainty. Uncertainty shocks buffeted the economy during recessionary periods, but these shocks receded during the recovery periods of the Great Depression. Using vector autoregressions on monthly data for 1919–1941, I show that a one standard deviation increase in uncertainty decreased investment, GDP, industrial output, employment, hours worked, wages, and the price level. I perform a historical decomposition simulation to see how much uncertainty shocks mattered for explaining movements in major variables during the Depression. Roughly 40–70% of the simulated decline in output can be explained by uncertainty shocks in the Great Depression.

Keywords

Uncertainty shocks Great Depression Historical decomposition 

JEL Classification

D80 E32 N12 

Notes

Acknowledgements

I have benefited from fruitful conversations with Gustavo Cortes, Chris Meissner, Ellis Tallman, Nicholas Bloom, and many others, and have had many useful discussions at seminars and conferences. All errors remain my own.

Supplementary material

11698_2019_190_MOESM1_ESM.pdf (47 kb)
Supplementary material 1 (pdf 48 KB)

References

  1. Abel AB, Dixit A, Eberly JC, Pindyck RS (1996) Options, the value of capital, and investment. Q J Econ 111(3):753–77Google Scholar
  2. Alexopoulos M, Cohen J (2015) The power of print: uncertainty shocks, markets, and the economy. Int Rev Econ Finance 40:8–28Google Scholar
  3. Arellano C, Bai Y, Kehoe P (2010) Financial markets and fluctuations in volatility, Working Paper. Federal Reserve Bank of MinneapolisGoogle Scholar
  4. Bachmann R, Bayer C (2013) “Wait-and-see” business cycles? J Monet Econ 60(6):704–719Google Scholar
  5. Bachmann R, Moscarini G (2011) Business cycles and endogenous uncertainty, Working Paper. Yale UniversityGoogle Scholar
  6. Bachmann R, Elstner S, Sims ER (2013) Uncertainty and economic activity: evidence from business survey data. Am Econ J Macroecon 5(2):217–249Google Scholar
  7. Baker SR, Bloom N, Davis SJ (2015) Measuring economic policy uncertainty, Technical Report. National Bureau of Economic ResearchGoogle Scholar
  8. Baker SR, Bloom N, Davis SJ (2016) Measuring economic policy uncertainty. Q J Econ 131(4):1593–1636Google Scholar
  9. Barsky RB, Sims ER (2009) News shocks, Technical Report. National Bureau of Economic ResearchGoogle Scholar
  10. Barsky RB, Sims ER (2011) News shocks and business cycles. J Monet Econ 58(3):273–289Google Scholar
  11. Basu S, Bundick B (2017) Uncertainty shocks in a model of effective demand. Econometrica 85(3):937–958Google Scholar
  12. Beaudry P, Portier F (2004) An exploration into Pigou’s theory of cycles. J Monet Econ 51(6):1183–1216Google Scholar
  13. Beaudry P, Portier F (2006) Stock prices, news, and economic fluctuations. Am Econ Rev 96(4):1293–1307Google Scholar
  14. Beaudry P, Portier F (2007) When can changes in expectations cause business cycle fluctuations in neo-classical settings? J Econ Theory 135(1):458–477Google Scholar
  15. Beaudry P, Portier F (2014) News-driven business cycles: insights and challenges. J Econ Lit 52(4):993–1074Google Scholar
  16. Bernanke BS (1983a) Irreversibility, uncertainty, and cyclical investment. Q J Econ 98(1):85–106Google Scholar
  17. Bernanke BS (1983b) Nonmonetary effects of the financial crisis in propagation of the Great Depression. Am Econ Rev 73(3):257–76Google Scholar
  18. Black F, Scholes M (1973) The pricing of options and corporate liabilities. J Polit Econ 81:637–654Google Scholar
  19. Bloom N (2007) Uncertainty and the dynamics of R&D. Am Econ Rev 97(2):250–255Google Scholar
  20. Bloom N (2009) The impact of uncertainty shocks. Econometrica 77(3):623–685Google Scholar
  21. Bloom N (2014) Fluctuations in uncertainty. J Econ Perspect 28(2):153–76Google Scholar
  22. Bloom N, Bond S, Van Reenen J (2007) Uncertainty and investment dynamics. Rev Econ Stud 74(2):391–415Google Scholar
  23. Bloom N, Floetotto M, Jaimovich N, Saporta-Eksten I, Terry SJ (2012) Really uncertain business cycles, Working Paper. National Bureau of Economic ResearchGoogle Scholar
  24. Bordo MD, Choudhri EU, Schwartz AJ (2002) Was expansionary monetary policy feasible during the Great Contraction? An examination of the gold standard constraint. Explor Econ Hist 39(1):1–28Google Scholar
  25. Bossie A (2019) Monetary and fiscal interactions in the USA during the 1940s. Cliometrica.  https://doi.org/10.1007/s11698-019-00182-1 Google Scholar
  26. Burbidge J, Harrison A (1985) An historical decomposition of the great depression to determine the role of money. J Monet Econ 16(1):45–54Google Scholar
  27. Caballero RJ, Pindyck RS (1996) Uncertainty, investment, and industry evolution. Int Econ Rev 37(3):641–62Google Scholar
  28. Caggiano G, Castelnuovo E, Groshenny N (2014) Uncertainty shocks and unemployment dynamics in US recessions. J Monet Econ 67:78–92Google Scholar
  29. Cecchetti SG, Karras G (1994) Sources of output fluctuations during the interwar period: further evidence on the causes of the Great Depression. Rev Econ Stat 76(1):80–102Google Scholar
  30. Christiano LJ, Eichenbaum M, Evans CL (1999) Monetary policy shocks: what have we learned and to what end? In: Taylor JB, Woodford M (eds) Handbook of macroeconomics, part A, vol 1. Elsevier, pp 65–148Google Scholar
  31. Christiano LJ, Motto R, Rostagno M (2003) The great depression and the Friedman–Schwartz hypothesis. J Money Credit Bank 35(6b):1119–1197Google Scholar
  32. Christiano LJ, Motto R, Rostagno M (2013) Risk shocks, Working Paper. National Bureau of Economic ResearchGoogle Scholar
  33. Cole HL, Ohanian LE (2004) New deal policies and the persistence of the Great Depression: a general equilibrium analysis. J Polit Econ 112(4):779–816Google Scholar
  34. Cortes GS, Weidenmier MD (2017) Stock volatility and the Great Depression, Technical Report. National Bureau of Economic ResearchGoogle Scholar
  35. Cutler DM, Katz DQ, Sheiner L, Wooldridge J (1989) Stock market volatility, cross-section volatility, and stock returns, Working paper. Massachusetts Institute of TechnologyGoogle Scholar
  36. Dixit A (1992) Investment and hysteresis. J Econ Perspect 6(1):107–132Google Scholar
  37. Dixit A (1993) Art of smooth pasting. Routledge, LondonGoogle Scholar
  38. Dixit A, Goldman SM (1970) Uncertainty and the demand for liquid assets. J Econ Theory 2(4):368–382Google Scholar
  39. Dixit A, Pindyck RS (1994) Investment under uncertainty. Princeton University Press, PrincetonGoogle Scholar
  40. Eichengreen B (1996) Golden Fetters: the gold standard and the Great Depression, 1919–1939. Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  41. Eichengreen B, Sachs J (1985) Exchange rates and economic recovery in the 1930s. J Econ Hist 45(04):925–946Google Scholar
  42. Fackler JS, Parker RE (1994) Accounting for the Great Depression: a historical decomposition. J Macroecon 16(2):193–220Google Scholar
  43. Ferderer JP (1993) The impact of uncertainty on aggregate investment spending: an empirical analysis. J Money Credit Bank 25(1):30–48Google Scholar
  44. Ferderer JP, Zalewski DA (1994) Uncertainty as a propagating force in the Great Depression. J Econ Hist 54(4):825–849Google Scholar
  45. Ferderer JP, Zalewski DA (1999) To raise the golden anchor? Financial crises and uncertainty during the Great Depression. J Econ Hist 59(3):624–658Google Scholar
  46. Fernández-Villaverde J, Guerrón-Quintana PA, Kuester K, Rubio-Ramírez J (2011) Fiscal volatility shocks and economic activity, Working Paper. National Bureau of Economic ResearchGoogle Scholar
  47. Fernández-Villaverde J, Guerrón-Quintana P, Kuester K, Rubio-Ramírez J (2015) Fiscal volatility shocks and economic activity. Am Econ Rev 105(11):3352–3384Google Scholar
  48. Field AJ (2003) The most technologically progressive decade of the century. Am Econ Rev 93(4):1399–1413Google Scholar
  49. Fisher I (1933) The debt-deflation theory of great depressions. Econometrica 1(4):337–357Google Scholar
  50. Flacco PR, Parker RE (1992) Income uncertainty and the onset of the Great Depression. Econ Inq 30(1):154–171Google Scholar
  51. Friedman M, Schwartz AJ (1971) A monetary history of the United States, 1867–1960. Princeton University Press, PrincetonGoogle Scholar
  52. Gilchrist S, Sim JW, Zakrajšek E (2014) Uncertainty, financial frictions, and investment dynamics, Working Paper. National Bureau of Economic ResearchGoogle Scholar
  53. Goel RK, Ram R (1999) Variations in the effect of uncertainty on different types of investment: an empirical investigation. Aust Econ Pap 38(4):481–92Google Scholar
  54. Gordon RJ, Krenn R (2010) The end of the Great Depression 1939–41: policy contributions and fiscal multipliers, Working Paper. National Bureau of Economic ResearchGoogle Scholar
  55. Granger CWJ (1969) Investigating causal relations by econometric models and cross-spectral methods. Econometrica 37(3):424–438Google Scholar
  56. Greasley D, Madsen JB (2006) Investment and uncertainty: precipitating the Great Depression in the United States. Economica 73(291):393–412Google Scholar
  57. Greasley D, Madsen JB, Oxley L (2001) Income uncertainty and consumer spending during the Great Depression. Explor Econ Hist 38(2):225–251Google Scholar
  58. Guiso L, Parigi G (1999) Investment and demand uncertainty. Q J Econ 114(1):185–227Google Scholar
  59. Hamilton JD (1987) Monetary factors in the Great Depression. J Monet Econ 19(2):145–169Google Scholar
  60. Harrison SG, Weder M (2006) Did sunspot forces cause the Great Depression? J Monet Econ 53(7):1327–1339Google Scholar
  61. Hoover H (1952) Memoirs: the Great Depression, 1929–1941, vol 3. Macmillan, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  62. Hsieh C-T, Romer CD (2006) Was the Federal Reserve constrained by the gold standard during the Great Depression? Evidence from the 1932 open market purchase program. J Econ Hist 66(01):140–176Google Scholar
  63. Hu Z (1995) Stock market volatility and corporate investment, Working Paper. International Monetary FundGoogle Scholar
  64. Jurado K, Ludvigson SC, Ng S (2015) Measuring uncertainty. Am Econ Rev 105(3):1177–1216Google Scholar
  65. Kehoe TJ, Prescott EC (2002) Great Depressions of the 20th century. Rev Econ Dyn 5(1):1–18Google Scholar
  66. Kehoe TJ, Prescott EC et al (2008) Using the general equilibrium growth model to study great depressions: a reply to Temin. Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis, Research Department, Minneapolis, MNGoogle Scholar
  67. Kellogg R (2014) The effect of uncertainty on investment: evidence from Texas oil drilling. Am Econ Rev 104(6):1698–1734Google Scholar
  68. Keynes JM (1936) The general theory of employment, interest and money. Macmillan, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  69. Knotek ES II, Khan S (2011) How do households respond to uncertainty shocks. Economic Review - Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City, Kansas City, pp 63–92Google Scholar
  70. Leahy JV, Whited TM (1996) The effect of uncertainty on investment: some stylized facts. J Money Credit Bank 28(1):64–83Google Scholar
  71. Leduc S, Liu Z (2016) Uncertainty shocks are aggregate demand shocks. J Monet Econ 82:20–35Google Scholar
  72. Leland HE (1968) Saving and uncertainty: the precautionary demand for saving. Q J Econ 82(3):465–473Google Scholar
  73. Lennard J et al (2018) Uncertainty and the great slump, Technical Report. Lund University, Department of Economic HistoryGoogle Scholar
  74. L’Huillier J-P, Yoo D (2017) Bad news in the Great Depression, the Great Recession, and other US recessions: a comparative study. J Econ Dyn Control 81:79–98Google Scholar
  75. Lopez JA, Mitchener KJ (2018) Uncertainty and hyperinflation: European inflation dynamics after World War I, Technical Report. National Bureau of Economic ResearchGoogle Scholar
  76. Majd S, Pindyck RS (1987) Time to build, option value, and investment decisions. J Financ Econ 18(1):7–27Google Scholar
  77. Mathy GP (2016) Stock volatility, return jumps and uncertainty shocks during the Great Depression. Financ Hist Rev 23(2):165–192Google Scholar
  78. Mathy GP (2018) Hysteresis and persistent long-term unemployment: the American Beveridge Curve of the Great Depression and World War II. Cliometrica 12(1):127–152Google Scholar
  79. Mccallum BT (1988) Robustness properties of a rule for monetary policy. In: Carnegie-Rochester conference series on public policy, vol 29(1), pp 173–203Google Scholar
  80. McDonald R, Siegel D (1986) The value of waiting to invest. Q J Econ 101(4):707–727Google Scholar
  81. McMillin WD, Parker RE (1994) An empirical analysis of oil price shocks in the interwar period. Econ Inq 32(3):486–497Google Scholar
  82. Merton R (1985) On the current state of the stock market rationality hypothesis, No. 1717-85. Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT), Sloan School of ManagementGoogle Scholar
  83. Nabar M, Nicholas T (2010) Uncertainty and innovation at the time of the Great Depression, Working Paper. Harvard Business SchoolGoogle Scholar
  84. Nakamura E, Sergeyev D, Steinsson J (2017) Growth-rate and uncertainty shocks in consumption: cross-country evidence. Am Econ J Macroecon 9(1):1–39Google Scholar
  85. Nodari G (2014) Financial regulation policy uncertainty and credit spreads in the US. J Macroecon 41:122–132Google Scholar
  86. Officer RR (1973) The variability of the market factor of the New York Stock Exchange. J Bus 46(3):434–53Google Scholar
  87. Ohanian LE (2001) Why did productivity fall so much during the Great Depression? Am Econ Rev 91(2):34–38Google Scholar
  88. Ohanian LE (2009) What-or who-started the great depression? J Econ Theory 144(6):2310–2335Google Scholar
  89. Pindyck RS (1988) Irreversible investment, capacity choice, and the value of the firm. Am Econ Rev 78(5):969–85Google Scholar
  90. Pindyck RS (1991) Irreversibility, uncertainty, and investment. J Econ Lit 29(3):1110–1148Google Scholar
  91. Pindyck RS (1993) Investments of uncertain cost. J Financ Econ 34(1):53–76Google Scholar
  92. Raunig B, Scharler J (2011) Stock market volatility, consumption and investment; an evaluation of the uncertainty hypothesis using post-war U.S. data. Working Papers 168. Oesterreichische Nationalbank (Austrian Central Bank)Google Scholar
  93. Romer CD (1990) The great crash and the onset of the Great Depression. Q J Econ 105(3):597–624Google Scholar
  94. Romer CD (1992) What ended the great depression? J Econ Hist 52(04):757–784Google Scholar
  95. Rudebusch GD (1998) Do measures of monetary policy in a VAR make sense? Int Econ Rev 39(4):907–931Google Scholar
  96. Schwert GW (1989) Why does stock market volatility change over time? J Finance 44(5):1115–53Google Scholar
  97. Schwert GW (1990) Business cycles, financial crises, and stock volatility, Working Paper. National Bureau of Economic ResearchGoogle Scholar
  98. Sims CA (1980a) Comparison of interwar and postwar business cycles: Monetarism reconsidered. Am Econ Rev 70(2):250–257Google Scholar
  99. Sims CA (1980b) Macroeconomics and reality. Econometrica 48(1):1–48Google Scholar
  100. Stock JH, Watson MW (2012) Disentangling the channels of the 2007–2009 recession. In: Brookings Papers on Economic Activity: Spring 2012, p 81Google Scholar
  101. Temin P (1976) Did monetary forces cause the Great Depression?. Norton, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  102. Temin P (2008) Real business cycle views of the Great Depression and recent events: a review of Timothy J. Kehoe and Edward C. Prescott’s Great Depressions of the Twentieth Century. J Econ Lit 43:669–684Google Scholar
  103. Temin P (2009) Using the general equilibrium growth model to study Great Depressions: a rejoinder to Kehoe and Prescott. Working Paper 09-04. Massachusetts Institute of Technology Department of EconomicsGoogle Scholar
  104. Uhlig H (2005) What are the effects of monetary policy on output? Results from an agnostic identification procedure. J Monet Econ 52(2):381–419Google Scholar
  105. Veronesi P (1999) Stock market overreactions to bad news in good times: a rational expectations equilibrium model. Rev Financ Stud 12(5):975–1007Google Scholar
  106. Weder M (2006a) A heliocentric journey into Germany’s Great Depression. Oxf Econ Pap 58(2):288–316Google Scholar
  107. Weder M (2006b) The role of preference shocks and capital utilization in the Great Depression. Int Econ Rev 47(4):1247–1268Google Scholar
  108. Wicker ER (1966) A reconsideration of Federal Reserve policy during the 1920–1921 depression. J Econ Hist 26(02):223–238Google Scholar
  109. Wigmore BA (1987) Was the Bank holiday of 1933 caused by a run on the dollar? J Econ Hist 47(3):739–755Google Scholar
  110. Ziebarth NL (2012) Misallocation and productivity during the Great Depression, Working Paper. Northwestern UniversityGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer-Verlag GmbH Germany, part of Springer Nature 2019

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.American UniversityWashingtonUSA

Personalised recommendations