Advertisement

Cliometrica

, Volume 3, Issue 1, pp 1–26 | Cite as

Contract enforcement, capital accumulation, and Argentina’s long-run decline

  • Leandro Prados de la Escosura
  • Isabel Sanz-Villarroya
Original Paper

Abstract

Argentina has slipped from being among the ten world’s richest countries by the eve of World War I to its current position close to mid-range developing countries. Why did Argentina fall behind? We employ a structural model to investigate the extent to which the enforceability of contracts and the security of property rights, as measured by Clague et al.’s “contract intensive money” (CIM), conditioned broad capital accumulation and, subsequently, economic performance in Argentina. Our results suggest that poor contract enforcement played a significant role at the origins of Argentina’s unique experience of long-run decline.

Keywords

Contract intensive money Economic decline Argentina 

JEL Classification

D23 N16 N26 N46 O43 

Notes

Acknowledgments

Earlier versions of this essay were presented at the Columbia University Seminar in Economic History, the 5th World Congress of Cliometrics (Venice 2004), the XIX Jornadas de Historia Económica, San Martín de los Andes (Argentina), the VII Encuentro de Economía Aplicada, Vigo (Spain), and the International Society for New Institutional Economics Conference (Barcelona 2005). We gratefully acknowledge criticism and suggestions by Lee Alston, Samuel Amaral, Albert Carreras, Roberto Cortés Conde, Alan Dye, Michael Edelstein, Andrés Gallo, Pablo Martín Aceña, Patrick O’Brien, Carlos Rodríguez Braun, Albrecht Ritschl, Joan Rosés, Mar Rubio, Blanca Sánchez-Alonso, Richard Sylla, Alan Taylor, Joachim Voth, and Jeffrey Williamson. We alone are responsible for the remaining errors. Pablo Spiller kindly allowed us to use his series of Supreme Court Justices’ length of tenure. We acknowledge financial support from Spain’s Ministry of Education and Science, research project SEC2002-01596 and Comunidad Autónoma de Madrid, research project CCG06-UC3M/HUM-0872.

References

  1. Adelman J (1994) Frontier development. Land, labour, and capital on the Wheatlands of Argentina and Canada, 1890–1914. Clarendon Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  2. Alhadeff P (1986) Economic controversies. In: Platt DCM, Di Tella G (eds) The political economy of Argentina: 1880–1946, Macmillan/St. Antony’s College, LondonGoogle Scholar
  3. Alston LJ, Gallo A (2003) The erosion of the rule of law in Argentina 1930–1947. Institute of behavioral sciences, University of Colorado, BoulderGoogle Scholar
  4. Alston LJ, Gallo A (2006) The erosion of checks and balances in Argentina: an explanation for Argentina’s economic slide from the top ten. Institute of behavioral sciences, University of Colorado, BoulderGoogle Scholar
  5. Alvaredo F (2006) The rich in Argentina over the twentieth century: 1932–2004, MPRA paper no. 650, 2006. http://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/650/
  6. Astorga P, Bergés AR, Fitzgerald EVK (2003) The Oxford Latin American economic history database. The Latin American Centre at Oxford University. http://oxlad.qeh.ox.ac.uk/
  7. Bai J, Perron P (1998) Estimating and testing linear models with multiple structural changes. Econometrica 66:47–78CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Barro RJ (2000) Inequality and growth in a panel of countries. J Econ Growth 5:5–32CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Berensztein S, Spector H (2003) Business, government, and law. In: Della Paolera G, Taylor A (eds) A new economic history of Argentina, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 324–368Google Scholar
  10. Bueno De Mesquita B, Root HL (2000) When bad economics is good politics. In: Bueno De Mesquita B, Root HL (Eds) Governing for prosperity. Yale University Press, New Haven, pp 1–16Google Scholar
  11. Clague C, Keefer P, Knack S, Olson M (1999) Contract-intensive money: contract enforcement, property rights, and economic performance. J Econ Growth 4:181–211CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Collins WJ, Williamson JG (2001) Capital goods prices and investment, 1870–1950. J Econ Hist 61(1):59–94CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Colomer JM (2004) Taming the tiger. Voting rights and political instability in Latin America. Lat Am Polit Soc 46(2):29–58CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Cortés Conde R (1997) La economía argentina en el largo plazo (siglos XIX y XX). Editorial Sudamericana, Buenos AiresGoogle Scholar
  15. Cortés Conde R (1998a) Fiscal crisis and inflation in XIX century Argentina. Documento de Trabajo n° 18, Universidad de San AndrésGoogle Scholar
  16. Cortés Conde R (1998b) Progreso y declinación de la economía Argentina. Fondo de Cultura Económica, Buenos AiresGoogle Scholar
  17. Della Paolera G (1994) Experimentos monetarios y bancarios en Argentina: 1861–1930. Revista de Historia Económica 12(3):539–90Google Scholar
  18. Della Paolera G, Ortiz J (1995) Dinero, intermediación financiera y nivel de actividad en 110 años de historia económica argentina. Documentos de Trabajo, Universidad Torcuato Di TellaGoogle Scholar
  19. Della Paolera G, Taylor AM (1999) Economic recovery from the Argentine great depression: institutions, expectations and the change of macroeconomic regime. J Econ Hist 59(3):567–599Google Scholar
  20. Della Paolera G, Taylor AM (2001) Straining at the anchor. The Argentine Currency Board and the search for macroeconomic stability, 1880–1935. University of Chicago Press, ChicagoGoogle Scholar
  21. Della Paolera G, Taylor AM, Bózolli CG (2003) Historical Statistics. In: Della Paolera G, Taylor AM (eds) A new economic history of Argentina. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 376–85 (plus CD-Rom)Google Scholar
  22. Díaz Alejandro CF (1965) Precios Relativos y Formación de Capital en la República Argentina. Documento de Trabajo no. 29, Instituto Torcuato Di TellaGoogle Scholar
  23. Díaz Alejandro CF (1970) Essays in Argentine Economic History. Yale University Press, New HavenGoogle Scholar
  24. Díaz Alejandro CF (1985) Argentina, Australia and Brazil before 1929. In: Platt DCM, Di Tella G (eds) Argentina, Australia and Canada: studies in comparative development, 1870–1965. Macmillan/St. Antony’s College, London, pp 95–109Google Scholar
  25. Di Tella G (1986) Economic controversies in Argentina from the 1920s to the 1940s. In: Platt DCM, Di Tella G (eds) The political economy of Argentina: 1880–1946. Macmillan/St. Antony’s College, London, pp 120–132Google Scholar
  26. Di Tella G, Dornbusch R (1989) The political economy of Argentina, 1946–1983. University of Pittsburgh Press, PittsburghGoogle Scholar
  27. Di Tella G, Zymelman M (1967) Las etapas del desarrollo económico argentino. Editorial Universitaria de Buenos Aires, Buenos AiresGoogle Scholar
  28. Duncan T, Fogarty J (1984) Australia and Argentina: on parallel paths. Melbourne University Press, VictoriaGoogle Scholar
  29. Elías VJ (1978) Sources of economic growth in Latin American countries. Rev Econ Stat 60(3):362–370CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Ferns HS, Gallo E, Watkins M (1993) The prairies and the pampas: a review colloquium. Bus Hist Rev 67:279–299CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Ferrer A (1996) La economía argentina. Fondo de Cultura Económica, Buenos AiresGoogle Scholar
  32. Gallo E (1983) La pampa gringa. La colonización agrícola de Santa Fe, 1870–1879. Editorial Sudamericana, Buenos AiresGoogle Scholar
  33. Gerchunoff P, Fajgelbaum P (2006) ¿Por qué Argentina no fue Australia? Una hipótesis sobre un cambio de rumbo. Editorial Siglo XXI, Buenos AiresGoogle Scholar
  34. Gerchunoff P, Llach L (1998) El ciclo de la ilusión y el desencanto: un siglo de políticas económicas argentinas. Editorial Ariel, Buenos AiresGoogle Scholar
  35. Gregory AW, Hansen BE (2003) Residual-based test for cointegration in models with regime shifts. J Econ 70:99–126Google Scholar
  36. Hopenhayn HA, Neumeyer PA (2003) The Argentine great depression 1975–1990. Universidad di Tella working paperGoogle Scholar
  37. Iaryczower M, Spiller PT, Tommasi M (2002) Judicial independence in unstable environments, Argentina 1935–1998. Am J Polit Sci 46(4):699–716CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. International Labor Office (ILO): Statistical yearbooks (various years)Google Scholar
  39. Instituto de Estudios Económicos sobre la Realidad Argentina y Latinoamericana (IEERAL) (1986) Estadísticas de la evolución económica de Argentina 1913–1984. Estudios 9:103–184Google Scholar
  40. International Monetary Fund [IMF] (2003) International financial statistics CD-Rom. International monetary fund, Washington DCGoogle Scholar
  41. Knack S, Keefer P (1995) Institutions, and economic performance: cross country test using alternative institutional measures. Econ Polit 7:207–227CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Kydland FE, Zarazaga C (2002) Argentina’s lost decade. Rev Econ Dyn 5(1):152–165CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Maddison A (2003) The world economy: historical statistics. OECD, ParisGoogle Scholar
  44. Mankiw NG, Romer D, Weil DN (1992) A contribution to the empirics of economic growth. Q J Econ 107(2):407–437CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Mitchell BR (1995) International historical statistics. The Americas, 1750–1988. Stockton Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  46. North DC (1990) Institutions, institutional change and economic performance. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  47. O’Connell A (1986) Free trade in one country: the case of Argentina in the 20s. In: Platt DCM, Di Tella G (eds) The political economy of Argentina: 1880–1946. Macmillan/St. Antony’s College, LondonGoogle Scholar
  48. OECD (2004) OECD National Accounts. OECD, Geneva, http://www.oecd.org/
  49. Platt DCM, Di Tella G (1985) Argentina, Australia and Canada: studies in comparative development, 1870–1965. Macmillan/St. Antony’s College, LondonGoogle Scholar
  50. Platt DCM, Di Tella G (1986) The political economy of Argentina: 1880–1946. Macmillan/St. Antony’s College, LondonGoogle Scholar
  51. Prados de la Escosura L (2000) International comparisons of real product, 1820–1990: an alternative data set. Explor Econ Hist 37(1):1–41CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Prados de la Escosura L (2007) Inequality and poverty in Latin America. A long-run exploration. In: Hatton TJ, O’Rourke KH, Taylor AM (eds) The new comparative economic history. MIT Press, Cambridge, pp 291–315Google Scholar
  53. Prados de la Escosura L, Sanz-Villarroya I (2006) Contract enforcement and Argentina’s long-run decline, Universidad Carlos III de Madrid Working Papers in Economic History 06–03, 2006Google Scholar
  54. Prescott EC (1998) Needed: a theory of total factor productivity. Int Econ Rev 39(3):528–552CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. Reinhart C, Rogoff KS (2004) The modern history of exchange rate arrangements: a reinterpretation. Q J Econ 119(1):1–48CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Rock D (1987) Argentina 1516–1987. From Spanish colonization to Raúl Alfonsín. University of California Press, BerkeleyGoogle Scholar
  57. Sánchez-Alonso B (2000) Those who left and those who stayed behind: explaining emigration from the regions of Spain, 1880–1914. J Econ Hist 60(3):730–755CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Sanz-Villarroya I (2004) Las tendencias a largo plazo de la economía argentina: 1875–2000. Revista de Historia Económica 22(1):177–205Google Scholar
  59. Sanz-Villarroya I (2005) The convergence process of Argentina with Australia and Canada: 1875–2000. Explor Econ Hist 42:439–458CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Solberg CE (1987) The prairies and the pampas: Agrarian policy in Canada and Argentina: 1880–1930. Stanford University Press, StanfordGoogle Scholar
  61. Spiller P, Tommasi M (2007) The institutional foundations of public policy in Argentina. Cambridge University Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  62. Statistics Canada: historical statistics of Canada, 2004. http://www.statcan.ca/
  63. Sylla R, Rousseau P (2003) Financial systems, economic growth, and globalization. In: Bordo MD, Taylor AM, Williamson JG (eds) Globalization in historical perspective. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp 373–413Google Scholar
  64. Taylor AM (1992) External dependence, demographic burdens and Argentine economic decline after the Belle Époque. J Econ Hist 52(4):907–936CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  65. Taylor AM (1994) Tres fases del crecimiento económico argentino. Revista de Historia Económica 12(3):649–683CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  66. Taylor AM (1998a) Argentina in the world capital market: saving, investment and the international capital mobility in the twentieth century. J Dev Econ 57(1):147–184CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  67. Taylor AM (1998b) On the cost of inward-looking development: price distortions, growth and divergence in Latin America. J Econ Hist 58(1):1–19Google Scholar
  68. Taylor AM, Williamson JG (1994) Capital flows to the new world as an intergenerational transfer. J Polit Econ 102(2):348–371CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  69. Temple J (1999) The new growth evidence. J Econ Lit 37(1):112–156Google Scholar
  70. Urquhart MC (1986) New estimates of gross national product, Canada, 1870–1926: some implications for Canadian development. In: Engerman SL, Gallman RE (eds) Long-term factors in American economic growth, NBER studies in income and wealth, 51. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp 9–94Google Scholar
  71. Vamplew W (1987) Australians: historical statistics. Fairfax, Syme and Weldon, CanberraGoogle Scholar
  72. Vitelli G (1990) Las lógicas de la economía argentina: inflación y crecimiento. Prendergast, Buenos AiresGoogle Scholar
  73. Williamson JG (1995) The evolution of global markets since 1830: background evidence and hypotheses. Explor Econ Hist 32(1):141–196 (updated)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  74. Williamson JG (1997) Globalization and inequality, past and present. World Bank Res Obs 12(2):117–135Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer-Verlag 2008

Authors and Affiliations

  • Leandro Prados de la Escosura
    • 1
  • Isabel Sanz-Villarroya
    • 2
  1. 1.Historia Económica e Instituciones and Instituto FiguerolaUniversidad Carlos III de MadridMadridSpain
  2. 2.Estructura Económica, Economía Pública e Historia EconómicaUniversidad de ZaragozaZaragozaSpain

Personalised recommendations