Journal of Bioethical Inquiry

, Volume 10, Issue 2, pp 267–272 | Cite as

Bringing Compassion to the Ethical Dilemma in Killing Kangaroos for Conservation

Comment on “Conservation Through Sustainable Use” by Rob Irvine
Case Studies

Abstract

Ethical debate on the killing of kangaroos has polarised conservation and animal welfare science, yet at the heart of these scientific disciplines is the unifying aim of reducing harm to non-human animals. This aim provides the foundation for common ground, culminating in the development of compassionate conservation principles that seek to provide mechanisms for achieving both conservation and welfare goals. However, environmental decision-making is not devoid of human interests, and conservation strategies are commonly employed that suit entrenched positions and commercial gain, rather than valuing the needs of the non-human animals in need of protection. The case study on the wild kangaroo harvest presents just such a dilemma, whereby a conservation strategy is put forward that can only be rationalised by ignoring difficulties in the potential for realising conservation benefits and the considerable welfare cost to kangaroos. Rather than an open debate on the ethics of killing game over livestock, in this response I argue that efforts to bring transparency and objectivity to the public debate have to date been obfuscated by those seeking to maintain entrenched interests. Only by putting aside these interests will debate about the exploitation of wildlife result in humane, compassionate, and substantive conservation benefits.

Keywords

Sustainable use Compassionate conservation Animal welfare Kangaroos Conservation strategies Entrenched interests 

References

  1. Ampt, P., and A. Baumber. 2006. Building connections between kangaroos, commerce and conservation in the rangelands. Australian Zoologist 33(3): 398–409.Google Scholar
  2. Arnold, G.W., A. Grassia, D.E. Steven, and J.R. Weeldenburg. 1991. Population ecology of western grey kangaroos in a remnant of wandoo woodland at Baker’s Hill, southern Western Australia. Wildlife Research 18(5): 561–575.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Baumber, A., R. Cooney, P. Ampt, and K. Gepp. 2009. Kangaroos in the rangelands: Opportunities for landholder collaboration. Rangeland Journal 31(1): 161–167.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Bayliss, P., and D. Choquenot. 2003. The numerical response: Rate of increase and food limitation in herbivores and predators. In Wildlife population growth rates, ed. R.M. Sibly, J. Hone, and T.H. Clutton-Brock, 148–179. Cambridge: University of Cambridge Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Bekoff, M. (ed.). 2013. Ignoring nature no more: The case for compassionate conservation. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
  6. Ben-Ami, D., D.B. Croft, D. Ramp, and K. Boom. 2010. Advocating kangaroo meat: Towards ecological benefit or plunder? THINKK Report. Sydney: Institute for Sustainable Futures, University of Technology, Sydney.Google Scholar
  7. Ben-Ami, D., K. Boom, L. Boronyak, D.B. Croft, D. Ramp, and C. Townend. 2011. Welfare implications of commercial kangaroo killing: Do the ends justify the means? THINKK Report. Sydney: Institute for Sustainable Futures, University of Technology, Sydney.Google Scholar
  8. Bilton, A.D., and D.B. Croft. 2004. Lifetime reproductive success in a population of female red kangaroos (Macropus rufus) in the sheep rangelands of western New South Wales: Environmental effects and population dynamics. Australian Mammalogy 26(1): 45–60.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Boom, K., and D. Ben-Ami. 2013. Kangaroos at a crossroads: Environmental law and the kangaroo industry. Environmental Planning and Law Journal 30(2): 162–181.Google Scholar
  10. Boom, K., D. Ben-Ami, D.B. Croft, N. Cushing, D. Ramp, and L. Boronyak. 2012. “Pest” and resource: A legal history of Australia’s kangaroos. Animal Studies Journal 1(1): 17–40.Google Scholar
  11. Ceballos, G., A. Garcia, and P.R. Ehrlich. 2010. The sixth extinction crisis: Loss of animal populations and species. Journal of Cosmology 8(June): 1821–1831.Google Scholar
  12. Chapman, M. 2003. Kangaroos and feral goats as economic resources for graziers: Some views from south-west Queensland. Rangeland Journal 25(1): 20–36.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Cloete, P.C., P.R. Taljaard, and B. Grové. 2007. A comparative economic case study of switching from cattle farming to game ranching in the northern cape province. South African Journal of Wildlife Research 37(1): 71–78.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Cooney, R., M. Archer, A. Baumber, et al. 2012. THINKK again: Getting the facts straight on kangaroo harvesting and conservation. In Science under siege, ed. P.B. Banks, D. Lunney, and C.R. Dickman, 150–160. Mosman: Royal Zoological Society of New South Wales.Google Scholar
  15. Cooney, R., A. Baumber, P. Ampt, and G.R. Wilson. 2009. Sharing Skippy: How can landholders be involved in kangaroo production in Australia? Rangeland Journal 31(3): 283–292.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Coulson, G. 2009. Behavioural ecology of red and grey kangaroos: Caughley’s insights into individuals, associations and dispersion. Wildlife Research 36(1): 57–69.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Croft, D.B. 2004. Kangaroo management: Individuals and communities. Australian Mammalogy 26(1): 101–108.Google Scholar
  18. Croft, D.B., and K. Boom. 2011. It’s raining kangaroos: The ups and downs of kangaroo management. The Conversation, Novermber 14. http://theconversation.edu.au/its-raining-kangaroos-the-ups-and-downs-of-kangaroo-management-3976.
  19. Dawson, T.J. 2012. Kangaroos, 2nd edition. Melbourne: CSIRO Publishing.Google Scholar
  20. Draper, C., and M. Bekoff. 2013. Animal welfare and the importance of compassionate conservation—a comment on McMahon et al 2012. Biological Conservation 158: 422–423.Google Scholar
  21. du Toit, J.T., R. Kock, and J. Deutch. 2010. Wild rangelands: Conserving wildlife while maitaining livestock in semi-arid ecosystems. Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell.Google Scholar
  22. Dubois, S., and D. Fraser. 2013. Rating harms to wildlife: A survey showing convergence between conservation and animal welfare views. Animal Welfare 22(1): 49–55.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Dubois, S., and H.W. Harshaw. 2013. Exploring “humane” dimensions of wildlife. Human Dimensions of Wildlife 18(1): 1–19.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Ehrlich, P.R. 2009. Ecoethics: Now central to all ethics. Journal of Bioethical Inquiry 6(4): 417–436.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Favreau, F.-R., A.W. Goldizen, and O. Pays. 2010. Interactions among social monitoring, anti-predator vigilance and group size in eastern grey kangaroos. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 277(1690): 2089–2095.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Fisher, D.O., S.P. Blomberg, and I.P.F. Owens. 2003. Extrinsic versus intrinsic factors in the decline and extinction of Australian marsupials. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 270(1526): 1801–1808.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Fox, C.H., and M. Bekoff. 2011. Integrating values and ethics into wildlife policy and management—lessons from North America. Animals 1(1): 126–143.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Fraser, D. 2010. Toward a synthesis of conservation and animal welfare science. Animal Welfare 19(2): 121–124.Google Scholar
  29. Fraser, D., and A.M. MacRae. 2011. Four types of activities that affect animals: Implications for animal welfare science and animal ethics philosophy. Animal Welfare 20(4): 581–590.Google Scholar
  30. Gaston, K.J. 2005. Biodiversity and extinction: Species and people. Progress in Physical Geography 29(2): 239–247.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Godfray, H.C.J., J.R. Beddington, I.R. Crute, et al. 2010. Food security: The challenge of feeding 9 billion people. Science 327(5967): 812–818.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Goest, J.L., D. Keltner, and E. Simon-Thomas. 2010. Compassion: An evolutionary analysis and empirical review. Psychological Bulletin 136(3): 351–374.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Grigg, G. 2002. Conservation benefit from harvesting kangaroos: Status report at the start of a new millennium. A paper to stimulate discussion and research. In A zoological revolution: Using native fauna to assist in its own survival, ed. D. Lunney and C.R. Dickman, 53–76. Mosman: Royal Zoological Society of New South Wales.Google Scholar
  34. Hardman, J. 1996. The wild harvest and marketing of kangaroos. Brisbane: Queensland Department of Primary Industries.Google Scholar
  35. Herbert, C.A., and A. Elzer. 2011. Review of scientific literature relevant to the commercial harvest management of kangaroos. Sydney: Kangaroo Management Program, Office of Environment and Heritage, Department of Premier and Cabinet (NSW).Google Scholar
  36. Higginbottom, K.B., and D.B. Croft. 1999. Social learning in marsupials. In Mammalian social learning: Comparative and ecological perspecitives, ed. H.O. Box and K.R. Gibson, 80–101. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
  37. Iles, J., J. Kelleway, T. Kobayashi, et al. 2010. Grazing kangaroos act as local recyclers of energy on semiarid floodplains. Australian Journal of Zoology 58(3): 145–149.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Irvine, R. 2012. Conservation through sustainable use: The wild kangaroo harvest plan. Journal of Bioethical Inquiry 9(4): 509–510.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Jamieson, D. 2002. Morality’s progress: Essays on humans, other animals, and the rest of nature. Oxford: Clarendon.Google Scholar
  40. Kreuter, U., M. Peel, and E. Warner. 2010. Wildlife conservation and community-based natural resource management in southern Africa’s private nature reserves. Society and Natural Resources 23(6): 507–524.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Lindsey, P.A., S.S. Romañach, and H.T. Davies-Mostert. 2009. The importance of conservancies for enhancing the value of game ranch land for large mammal conservation in southern Africa. Journal of Zoology 277(2): 99–105.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Lunney, D. 2010. A history of the debate (1948–2009) on the commercial harvesting of kangaroos, with particular reference to New South Wales and the role of Gordon Grigg. Australian Zoologist 35(2): 383–430.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Lunney, D. 2012. Wildlife management and the debate on the ethics of animal use. II. A challenge for the animal protection movement. Pacific Conservation Biology 18(2): 81–99.Google Scholar
  44. McLeod, S.R. 1997. Is the concept of carrying capacity useful in variable environments? Oikos 79(3): 529–542.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Mjadwesch, R. 2011. Nomination to list the large macropods as threatened species under the NSW Threatened Species Conservation Act 1995. Report to the NSW Scientific Committee. http://www.kangaroosatrisk.net/uploads/1/0/8/3/10831721/mjadwesch2011_nsw_nomination.pdf.
  46. Munn, A.J., T.J. Dawson, S.R. McLeod, D.B. Croft, M.B. Thompson, and C.R. Dickman. 2008. Field metabolic rate and water turnover of red kangaroos and sheep in an arid rangeland: An empirically derived dry-sheep-equivalent for kangaroos. Australian Journal of Zoology 57(1): 22–28.Google Scholar
  47. Paquet, P.C., and C.T. Darimont. 2010. Wildlife conservation and animal welfare: Two sides of the same coin. Animal Welfare 19(2): 177–190.Google Scholar
  48. Pople, A.R., and G. Grigg. 1999. Commercial harvesting of kangaroos in Australia. Canberra: Environment Australia.Google Scholar
  49. Ramp, D., D. Ben-Ami, K. Boom, and D.B. Croft. 2013. Compassionate conservation: A paradigm shift for wildlife management in Australasia. In Ignoring nature no more: The case for compassionate conservation, ed. M. Bekoff, 295–315. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
  50. Silcock, J.L., and R.J. Fensham. 2013. Arid vegetation in disequilibrium with livestock grazing: Evidence from long-term exclosures. Austral Ecology 38(1): 57–68.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Thomsen, D.A., and J. Davies. 2007. Rules, norms and strategies of kangaroo harvest. Australasian Journal of Environmental Management 14(2): 123–130.Google Scholar
  52. Thorne, L. 1998. Kangaroos: The non-issue. Society and Animals 6(2): 167–182.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Vitousek, P.M., P.R. Ehrlich, A.H. Ehrlich, and P.A. Matson. 1986. Human appropriation of the products of photosynthesis. Bioscience 36(2): 368–373.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Vucetich, J.A., and M.P. Nelson. 2007. What are 60 warblers worth? Killing in the name of conservation. Oikos 116(8): 1267–1278.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. Wiggins, N.L., G.J. Williamson, H.I. McCallum, C.R. McMahon, and D.M.J.S. Bowman. 2010. Shifts in macropod home ranges in response to wildlife management interventions. Wildlife Research 37(5): 379–391.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media Dordrecht 2013

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.School of the EnvironmentUniversity of TechnologySydneyAustralia

Personalised recommendations