Journal of Bioethical Inquiry

, Volume 8, Issue 2, pp 155–163 | Cite as

Futility Determination as a Process: Problems with Medical Sovereignty, Legal Issues and the Strengths and Weakness of the Procedural Approach



Futility is not a purely medical concept. Its subjective nature requires a balanced procedural approach where competing views can be aired and in which disputes can be resolved with procedural fairness. Law should play an important role in this process. Pure medical models of futility are based on a false claim of medical sovereignty. Procedural approaches avoid the problems of such claims. This paper examines the arguments for and against the adoption of a procedural approach to futility determination.


Futility Law Susbtitute decision-making Best interests Substituted judgment Sovereignty Professionalism 


  1. Beauchamp, T.L., and J.F. Childress. 2009. Principles of biomedical ethics, 5th ed. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  2. Burns, J.P., and R.D. Truog. 2007. Futility: a concept in evolution. Chest 132(6): 1987–1993.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Callahan, D. 1991. Medical futility, medical necessity: the problem without a name. Hastings Cent Rep 21(4): 30–35.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Dzielak, R.J. 1995. Physicians lose the tug of war to pull the plug: the debate about continued futile medical care. J Marshall L Rev 28: 733–767.Google Scholar
  5. Faunce, T.A., and C. Stewart. 2005. The Messiha and Schiavo cases: third-party ethical and legal interventions in futile care disputes. Med J Aust 183(5): 261–263.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  6. Fine, R.L. 2009. Point: the Texas Advance Directives Act effectively and ethically resolves disputes about medical futility. Chest 136(4): 968–971.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Gabbay, E., J. Calvo-Broce, K.B. Meyer, et al. 2010. The empirical basis for determinations of medial futility. J Gen Intern Med 25: 1083–1089.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Kerridge, I., K. Mitchell, and J. McPhee. 1997. Defining medical futility in ethics, law and clinical practice: an exercise in futility? J Law Med 4(3): 235–242.Google Scholar
  9. Kerridge, I., M. Lowe, and C. Stewart. 2009. Ethics and law for the health professions. Sydney: Federation.Google Scholar
  10. Kuhse, H. 1997. Caring: nurses, women and ethics. Oxford: Blackwell.Google Scholar
  11. Levine, E.M. 1994. A new predicament for physicians: the concept of medical futility, the physician’s obligation to render appropriate treatment, and the interplay of the medical standard of care. J Law Health 9(1): 69–108.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  12. Luce, J.M. 2010. A history of resolving conflicts over end-of-life care in intensive care units in the United States. Crit Care Med 38(8): 1623–1629.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Medical Professionalism Project. 2002. Medical professionalism in the new millennium: a physician’s charter. Med J Aust 177(5): 263–265.Google Scholar
  14. Meisel, A., and K.L. Cerminara. 2004. The right to die: the law of end-of-life decision-making. New York: Aspen.Google Scholar
  15. Moratti, S. 2009. The development of “medical futility”: towards a procedural approach based on the role of the medical profession. J Med Ethics 35: 369–372.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Murphy, B.F. 2008. What has happened to clinical leadership in futile care discussions? Med J Aust 188(7): 418–419.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  17. O’Callaghan, N. 2008. When Atlas shrugs: may the State wash its hands of those in need of life-sustaining medical treatment? Health Matrix 18(2): 291–372.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  18. Parker, M. 2010. Futile choices: wooing doctors to acknowledge the law in Queensland. J Law Med 18(1): 32–37.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  19. Pope, T.M. 2007. Medical futility statutes: no safe harbor to unilaterally refuse life-sustaining treatment. Tenn Law Rev 75(1): 1–81.Google Scholar
  20. Pope, T.M. 2010. Surrogate selection: an increasingly viable, but limited, solution to intractable futility disputes. St. Louis U J Health L Pol’y 3(2): 183–252.Google Scholar
  21. Pope, T.M., and E.A. Waldman. 2007. Mediation at the end of life: getting beyond the limits of the talking cure. Ohio State J Dispute Resolut 23(1): 143–194.Google Scholar
  22. Schmitt, C. 2005. Political theology: four chapters on the concept of sovereignty. Trans. G. Schwab. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
  23. Schneiderman, L.J., N.S. Jecker, and A.R. Jonsen. 1990. Medical futility: its meaning and ethical implications. Ann Intern Med 112(12): 949–954.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  24. Skene, L. 2005. The Schiavo and Korp cases: conceptualising end-of-life decision-making. J Law Med 13(2): 223–229.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  25. Smith, G.P. 2005. The Christian religion and biotechnology: a search for principled decision-making. Dordrecht: Springer.Google Scholar
  26. Smith, M.L. 2008. Medical inappropriateness review: appropriately performed by a medical committee. Health Matrix 18: 237–244.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  27. Stewart, C. 2006. Problems with substitute decision-making in NSW. J Bioeth Inq 3(3): 127–131.Google Scholar
  28. Stewart, C. 2009. End-of-life decisions in NSW: the saga continues. J Bioeth Inq 6(2): 153–158.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Truog, R.D. 2007. Tackling medical futility in Texas. N Engl J Med 357: 1–3.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Truog, R.D. 2009. Counterpoint: the Texas advance directives act is ethically flawed—medical futility disputes must be resolved by a fair process. Chest 136(4): 968–971.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Wilkinson, D. 2009. The self-fulfilling prophesy in intensive care. Theor Med Bioeth 30(6): 401–410.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Wilkinson, D., and J. Savulescu. 2011. Knowing when to stop: futility in the ICU. Curr Opin Anaesth:. doi: 10.1097/ACO.0b013e328343c5af.Google Scholar
  33. Willmott, L., B. White, and S. Then. 2010. Withholding and withdrawing life-sustaining medical treatment. In Health law in Australia, ed. B. White, F. McDonald, and L. Willmott, 450–491. Sydney: Thomson Reuters.Google Scholar
  34. Wyatt, A. 1998. Toward professionalism: an analysis of ambulance practice. Australas J Emerg Care 5(1): 16–20.Google Scholar
  35. Younger, S.J. 1988. Who defines futility? J Am Med Assoc 260(14): 2094–2095.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2011

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Sydney UniversitySydneyAustralia

Personalised recommendations