Art and Bioethics: Shifts in Understanding Across Genres
This paper describes and discusses overlapping interests and concerns of art and bioethics and suggests that bioethics would benefit from opening to contributions from the arts. There is a description of recent events in bioethics that have included art, and trends in art that relate to bioethics. The paper outlines art exhibits and performances within two major international bioethics congress programs alongside a discussion of the work of leading hybrid and bio artists who experiment with material (including their own bodies) at the ambiguous intersections between art, bio art and bioethics. Their work seeks to engage audiences in challenging ethical precepts and assumptions about life and existence. We consider the response of art and social theorists and compare these with the responses of bioethicists to comparable cases in bioethics. We note divergent views within the arts and within bioethics in relation to some pivotal questions including questions about what limits, if any, can apply in particular cases and on what basis. This approach allows for a transfer of information and perspectives, challenges assumptions in both art and bioethics and opens up a space for future exchange and dialogue along the shifting borders between these genres.
KeywordsHumanities [K01] Art [K01.093] Medicine in Art [K01.093.530] Ethics [K01.316] Bioethics [K01.316.070] Hybrid art Bioart
- Ars Electronica. 2010. website: http://new.aec.at/prix/en/kategorien/?cat=Hybrid%2520Art. (last accessed November).
- Arts Science Encounters. 2009. Recording in collaboration with Cafe Scientifique website: http://www.shef.ac.uk/arts-science/recordings. (last accessed December 2010).
- Barash, Bailey. 2006. ‘203 Days’. University of Connecticut Health Center website: http://fitsweb.uchc.edu/Days/days.html. (last accessed November 2010).
- Bioethics Network. 2010. website: http://www.bioethics-international.org/iab-2.0/index.php?show=networks. (last accessed May).
- Brickwood, C., B. Ferran, D. Garcia, and T. Putnam (eds.). 2007. (Un)common ground: Creative encounters across sectors and disciplines. Amsterdam: BIS Publishers.Google Scholar
- Broadhurst Dixon, J., and E. J. Cassidy, eds. 1998. Virtual futures: Cyberotics, technology and posthuman pragmatism. London and New York: Routledge. http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0415133807/qid%3D980123857/sr%3D1-1/ref%3Dsc%5Fb%5F1/103-8486940-7546219/digitalartsource/104-9993805-5743152. (last accessed November 2010).Google Scholar
- Cassell, E.J. 1984. The place of the humanities in medicine. New York, Hastings-on-Hudson: The Hastings Center.Google Scholar
- Catts, O., and I. Zurr. 2008. The ethics of experiential engagement with the manipulation of life. In Tactical biopolitics: Art, activism, and technoscience, eds B. da Costa and K. Philip, 125–142. Cambridge, Massachusetts; and London, UK: The MIT Press. Available at http://www.scribd.com/doc/25895911/8822-Tactical-Bio-Politics-Art-Activism#fullscreen:on. (last accessed November 2010).Google Scholar
- Clutterbuck, G. 2010. website: http://www.avicam.com/profile/clutterbuck.php. (last accessed November).
- Cohen, H. 2002. Bioscience moves into galleries as bio art. The Scientist 16(22): 57.Google Scholar
- CoNE. 2010. website: http://critical-art.net/Original/cone/coneWeb/welcome/bg1.html. (last accessed November).
- Dotinga, R. 2000. Salon (29 August): 1–2. Available at http://www.salon.com/health/feature/2000/08/29/amputation/. (last accessed November 2010).
- Dragon Breath Theatre Company. 2010. website: http://www.dragonbreaththeatre.com/. (last accessed November).
- Dyer, C. 2000. Surgeon amputated healthy legs. BMJ 320(7231): 332.Google Scholar
- Elliott, C. 2003. Better than well: American medicine meets the American Dream. New York and London: Norton.Google Scholar
- ESTOOLS. 2010. website: http://www.estools.eu/estools/index. (last accessed November).
- Freeman, J. 2010. website: http://www.translatingnature.org/. (last accessed November).
- Gonick, L. and M. Wheelis. 1991. The cartoon guide to genetics: A soft approach to hard science. http://bancroft.berkeley.edu/Exhibits/Biotech/cartoon.html. (last accessed November 2010).
- Jeffries, S. 2009. Guardian (1 July): http://www.orlan.net/download/guardian_july09.pdf. (last accessed November 2010).
- Koller, K. 2010. website: http://www.katherinekoller.ca/. (last accessed November).
- Kulunčić, A. 1999–2000. “Closed Reality—Embryo.” Created by A. Kulunčić (artist), T. Lane (designer), G. Sabol (sociologist), M. Puzar (programmer), I. Martinović (photographer): http://embryo.inet.hr/. (last accessed November 2010).
- Kulunčić, A. 2010. website: http://www.andreja.org/curric.html. (last accessed November).
- Lestel, D. 2007. Liberating life from itself: Bioethics and aesthetics of animality. In Signs of life—bio art and beyond, ed. E. Kac, 151–160. Cambridge, Massachusetts: MIT Press.Google Scholar
- Orlan. 2010. website: www.orlan.net. (last accessed November).
- Savulescu, J. 2006. Autonomy, the good life and controversial choices. In The Blackwell guide to medical ethics, ed. R. Rhodes, L. Francis, and A. Silvers. New York: Blackwell.Google Scholar
- Sen, A. 2009. The idea of justice. London and New York: Penguin.Google Scholar
- Spaulding, E. 2008. Vision for bioaesthetics. http://bioethics.com/. Scroll to Author/Eric Spaulding/entry for 2 February 2008/A Living Art, Part 3 (last accessed November 2010).
- Stelarc. 2010. website: http://web.stelarc.org/.(last accessed November, 2010); and http://www.stelarc.va.com.au/projects/extra_ear/index.htm (last accessed November).
- Stracey, F. 2009. Bio-art: the ethics behind the aesthetics. Nature Reviews Molecular Cell Biology 10: 496–500. Google Scholar
- SymbioticA. 2010. website: http://www.symbiotica.uwa.edu.au/. (last accessed November).
- Toffoletti, K. 2007. Cyborgs and Barbie Dolls—Feminism, popular culture and the posthuman body. London: I. B. Tauris.Google Scholar
- Virilio, P. 1988. Interview with Paul Virilio. Block 14 Special Issue Edition 5—The Work of Art in the Electronic Age: 4–7.Google Scholar
- Webster, S. 2006. Art, science and the public. In. Engaging Science: Thoughts, deeds, analysis and action, ed. J. Turney London, UK: Wellcome Trust: 74–79.Google Scholar
- Zylinska, J. 2009. Bioethics in the age of new media. Cambridge, Massachusetts: MIT Press.Google Scholar