Gender Bias in Resident Assessment in Graduate Medical Education: Review of the Literature
- 78 Downloads
Competency-based medical education relies on meaningful resident assessment. Implicit gender bias represents a potential threat to the integrity of resident assessment. We sought to examine the available evidence of the potential for and impact of gender bias in resident assessment in graduate medical education.
A systematic literature review was performed to evaluate the presence and influence of gender bias on resident assessment. We searched Medline and Embase databases to capture relevant articles using a tiered strategy. Review was conducted by two independent, blinded reviewers. We included studies with primary objective of examining the impact of gender on resident assessment in graduate medical education in the USA or Canada published from 1998 to 2018.
Nine studies examined the existence and influence of gender bias in resident assessment and data included rating scores and qualitative comments. Heterogeneity in tools, outcome measures, and methodologic approach precluded meta-analysis. Five of the nine studies reported a difference in outcomes attributed to gender including gender-based differences in traits ascribed to residents, consistency of feedback, and performance measures.
Our review suggests that gender bias poses a potential threat to the integrity of resident assessment in graduate medical education. Future study is warranted to understand how gender bias manifests in resident assessment, impact on learners and approaches to mitigate this bias.
KEY WORDSgender bias implicit bias gender assessment evaluation residency training graduate medical education postgraduate medical education
Compliance with Ethical Standards
Conflict of Interest
The authors declare that they do not have a conflict of interest.
- 4.Wehner MR, Nead KT, Linos K, Linos E. Plenty of moustaches but not enough women: cross sectional study of medical leaders. BMJ 2015:16;351:h6311.Google Scholar
- 5.Sarsons H. Interpreting signals in the labor market: evidence from medical referrals. Job Market Paper. 2017 Nov 28.Google Scholar
- 17.Ross S, Poth CN, Donoff M, Humphries P, Steiner I, Schipper S, Janke F, Nichols, D. Competency-Based Achievement System: Using formative feedback to teach and assess family medicine residents’ skills. Can Fam Physician 2011; 57(9): e323–e330.Google Scholar
- 20.American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists. Professional associate questionnaire. Washington (DC): ACOG; 2003. Available at: https://www.acog.org/About-ACOG/ACOG-Departments/CREOG/CREOG-Search/CREOGCOMPENTENCY-PRESENTATIONS. Retrieved April 1, 2018.Google Scholar
- 32.Carnes M, Devine PG, Baier L, Byars-Winston A, Fine E, Ford CE, Forsher P, Isaac C, Kaatz A, Magua W, Palta M, Sheridan J. Effect of an Intervention to Break the Gender Bias Habit for Faculty at One Institution: A Cluster Randomized, Controlled Trial Acad Med 2015; 90(2): 221–230.Google Scholar
- 33.Lavy V, Sand E. On the origins of gender human capital gaps: Short and long term consequences of teachers’ stereotypical biases. National Bureau of Economic Research; 2015 Jan 30. https://doi.org/10.3386/w20909.