Medical Professionalism: Conflicting Values for Tomorrow's Doctors
- 761 Downloads
New values and practices associated with medical professionalism have created an increased interest in the concept. In the United Kingdom, it is a current concern in medical education and in the development of doctor appraisal and revalidation.
To investigate how final year medical students experience and interpret new values of professionalism as they emerge in relation to confronting dying patients and as they potentially conflict with older values that emerge through hidden dimensions of the curriculum.
Qualitative study using interpretative discourse analysis of anonymized student reflective portfolios. One hundred twenty-three final year undergraduate medical students (64 male and 59 female) from the University of Cambridge School of Clinical Medicine supplied 116 portfolios from general practice and 118 from hospital settings about patients receiving palliative or end of life care.
Professional values were prevalent in all the portfolios. Students emphasised patient-centered, holistic care, synonymous with a more contemporary idea of professionalism, in conjunction with values associated with the ‘old’ model of professionalism that had not be directly taught to them. Integrating ‘new’ professional values was at times problematic. Three main areas of potential conflict were identified: ethical considerations, doctor-patient interaction and subjective boundaries. Students explicitly and implicitly discussed several tensions and described strategies to resolve them.
The conflicts outlined arise from the mix of values associated with different models of professionalism. Analysis indicates that ‘new’ models are not simply replacing existing elements. Whilst this analysis is of accounts from students within one UK medical school, the experience of conflict between different notions of professionalism and the three broad domains in which this conflict arises are relevant in other areas of medicine and in different national contexts.
KEY WORDSmedical professionalism medical education qualitative research students’ reflections
The authors would like to thank the students who gave their consent for their portfolios to be in this study. We are grateful to the students and other colleagues who have provided feedback on previous drafts, including Diana F. Wood, John Benson, Thelma Quince and James Brimicombe. We further thank the James Knott Family Trust for funding this research, with additional funding from the General Practice and Primary Care Research Unit at the University of Cambridge.
Conflict of Interest
The study was approved by the ethical committee of the University of Cambridge Psychology Research Ethics committee. All participants signed an informed consent form.
- 3.Levenson R, Dewar S, Shepherd S. Understanding Doctors: Harnessing Professionalism. London: King's Fund; 2008.Google Scholar
- 5.Royal College of Physicians. Doctors in Society: Medical Professionalism in a Changing World. London: Royal College of Physicians; 2005.Google Scholar
- 6.American Board of Internal Medicine. Project Professionalism. Philadelphia, Pennsylvania: American Board of Internal Medicine; 1995.Google Scholar
- 8.General Medical Council. Tomorrow's Doctors: Outcomes and Standards for Undergraduate Medical Education. GMC; 2009.Google Scholar
- 12.Rosen R, Dewar S. On Being a Doctor: Redefining Medical Professionalism for Better Patient Care. London: King's Fund; 2004.Google Scholar
- 16.Ginsburg S, Regehr G, Hatala R, McNaughton N, Frohna A, Hodges B, et al. Context, conflict, and resolution: a new conceptual framework for evaluating professionalism. Acad Med. 2000;75:S6–11.Google Scholar
- 17.Lief HI, Fox RC. Training for “detached concern” in medical students. In: Lief HI, Lief VF, Lief NR, eds. The Psychological Basis of Medical Practice. New York: Harper and Row; 1963:12–35.Google Scholar
- 19.Halpern J. From Detached Concern to Empathy: Humanizing Medical Practice. Oxford: Oxford Univ. Press; 2001.Google Scholar
- 20.Feest K, Forbes K. Today's Students, Tomorrow's Doctors: Reflections from the Wards. Oxon: Radcliffe Publishing Ltd.; 2007.Google Scholar
- 22.Lane U. Revalidation: Project Initiation Document. 2009. Available at: www.gmc-uk.org/Project_Initiation_document.pdf_25397052 Accessed July 8, 2010.
- 23.Irvine D. The relationship between teaching professionalism and licensing and accrediting bodies. In: Cruess RL, Cruess SR, Steinert Y, eds. Teaching Medical Professionalism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 2009:185–99.Google Scholar
- 24.Williams CM, Wilson CC, Olsen CH. Dying, death, and medical education: student voices. J Palliat Med. 2005;8:372–81.Google Scholar
- 25.Rosenbaum ME, Lobas J, Ferguson K. Using reflection activities to enhance teaching about end-of-life care. J Palliat Med. 2005;8:1186–95.Google Scholar
- 27.Merton R, Reader G, Kendall P. The Student-Physician: Introductory Studeies in the Sociology of Medical Education. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press; 1957.Google Scholar
- 28.Becker HS, Geer B, Hughes HC, Strauss AL. Boys in White: Student Culture in Medical School. New Brunswick: Transaction Publishers; 2007.Google Scholar
- 29.Sinclair S. Making Doctors. Oxford: Berg; 1997.Google Scholar
- 30.Helman C. The dissection room. In: Body Myths. London: Chatto and Windus; 1991:114-23Google Scholar
- 31.Good BJ. Medicine, Rationality, and Experience: An Anthropological Perspective. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 1994.Google Scholar
- 33.Brosnan C. Pierre Bourdieu and the theory of medical education: thinking ‘relationally’ about medical students and medical curricula. In: Brosnan C, Turner B, eds. Handbook of the Sociology of Medical Education. Oxon: Routledge; 2009.Google Scholar
- 35.Lock M, Gordon D, eds. Biomedicine Examined. Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Kluwer Academic Publishers; 1988.Google Scholar
- 38.Block SD, Billings JA. Becoming a Physician: Learning from the Dying. New Engl J Med. 2005;353:1313–5.Google Scholar
- 43.Wear D. "Face-to-face with it": medical students' narratives about their end-of-life education. Acad Med 2002;77:271–7.Google Scholar
- 44.Hafferty FW. Into the Valley: Death and the Socialization of Medical Students. New Haven: Yale University; 1991.Google Scholar
- 45.Linde C. Working the Past—Narrative and Institutional Memory. New York: Oxford University Press; 2009.Google Scholar
- 46.Doyle D. Foreword. In: Randall F, Downie RS, eds. Palliative Care Ethics: A Good Companion. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 1996:vii–ix.Google Scholar
- 49.Dyrbye LN, Thomas MR, Shanafelt TD. Medical student distress: causes, consequences, and proposed solutions. Mayo Clinic Proceedings 2005;80:1613.Google Scholar
- 50.Caplan RP. Stress, anxiety, and depression in hospital consultants, general practitioners, and senior health service managers. Br Med J. 1994;309:1261–3.Google Scholar
- 51.Van De Camp K, Vernooij-Dassen MJFJ, Grol RPTM, Bottema BJAM. How to conceptualize professionalism: a qualitative study. Med Teach. 2004;26:696–702.Google Scholar