Association Between a Serotonin Transporter Gene Variant and Hopelessness Among Men in the Heart and Soul Study
- 689 Downloads
Hopelessness is associated with mortality in patients with cardiac disease even after accounting for severity of depression. We sought to determine whether a polymorphism in the promoter region of the serotonin transporter gene (5-HTTLPR) is associated with increased hopelessness, and whether this effect is modified by sex, age, antidepressant use or depression in patients with coronary heart disease.
We conducted a cross-sectional study of 870 patients with stable coronary heart disease. Our primary outcomes were hopelessness score (range 0-8) and hopeless category (low, moderate and high) as measured by the Everson hopelessness scale. Analysis of covariance and ordinal logistic regression were used to examine the independent association of genotype with hopelessness.
Compared to patients with l/l genotype, adjusted odds of a higher hopeless category increased by 35% for the l/s genotype and 80% for s/s genotype (p-value for trend = 0.004). Analysis of covariance demonstrated that the effect of 5-HTTLPR genotype on hopelessness was modified by sex (.04), but not by racial group (p = 0.63). Among men, odds of higher hopeless category increased by 40% for the l/s genotype and by 2.3-fold for s/s genotype (p-value p < 0.001), compared to no effect in the smaller female sample (p = 0.42). Results stratified by race demonstrated a similar dose-response effect of the s allele on hopelessness across racial groups.
We found that the 5-HTTLPR is independently associated with hopelessness among men with cardiovascular disease.
KEY WORDShopelessness depression 5-HTTLPR cross-sectional Everson hopelessness scale
Hopelessness, defined as a sense of futility and negative future orientation, is associated with worse medical outcomes1, 2, 3, 4. Among patients with cardiovascular disease, hopelessness predicts incident myocardial infarction and cardiovascular mortality2. Although it is widely accepted that hopelessness is a typical feature of depression5, there is substantial evidence for the functional independence of hopelessness and depression6,7. Furthermore, hopelessness is more common than depression1,2, and the strength of the association between hopelessness and adverse cardiovascular outcomes has been found to be distinct from and stronger than that associated with depression1,8.
Several factors impact patients’ sense of hope, including socioeconomic status, family support, severity of illness and co-morbidities. Genetic predisposition is also likely to play a role, and in recent years, there has been increased interest in investigating the genetic component of both psychiatric disorders and healthy psychiatric characteristics. A breakthrough in this research has been the description of the short (s) allele of 5-HTTLPR (serotonin transporter length polymorphic region), a common functional polymorphism in the promoter region of the serotonin transporter gene (SLC6A4). Compared to the longer (l) allele variant, the s allele results in less efficient transcription of the serotonin transporter gene9,10, increased cardiac reactivity11, and it has been associated with less resilience to the depressogenic effects of adverse life events12, poorer response to selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor (SSRI) antidepressant therapy13, and with clinical and subclinical depression14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23.
Previously, Otte and colleagues found that the short allele of 5-HTTLPR predicted major depressive disorder, higher perceived stress, and norepinephrine secretion in the Heart and Soul Study22. However, the association between the 5-HTTLPR polymorphism and depression has more recently been called into question, with a meta-analysis demonstrating no evidence of interaction between the s allele and stressful life events on development of depression24. Given the heterogeneity of depression, one possible explanation for these discordant results is that 5-HTTLPR may be associated with some aspects of depression, and not with others. For example, Gonda and colleagues15 recently described an association between the s allele of 5-HTTLPR and several elements of “neuroticism-related traits” including anxiety, depression, hopelessness, guilt, hostility, aggression, and somatization in a group of healthy women. Thus, the genetic basis of the components of sub-clinical depression may offer insights into this controversy. Further, emerging data has suggested that serotonergic function modulated by 5-HTTLPR may vary according to age and sex, where patients over 25 years of age and men with s allele carriage have been found to be at increased risk of SSRI non-response compared to younger patients and women25,26. Sex differences in 5-HTTLPR moderation of response to SSRI antidepressants, tryptophan depletion and stressful life events have also been observed25,27,28.
No study has evaluated whether the 5-HTTLPR s allele is associated with increased susceptibility to hopelessness among patients with chronic illness. We sought to determine whether presence of the s allele is associated with greater propensity to hopelessness in patients with chronic cardiovascular disease independent of depression. The following were our objectives: 1) to determine the independent association between the 5-HTTLPR s allele and hopelessness and 2) to determine whether the effect between 5-HTTLPR s allele and hopelessness was moderated by race, sex, social support or presence of depression.
Sites and subjects
We studied patients enrolled in the Heart and Soul Study, details of which have been published previously29. Briefly, participants were prospectively enrolled at 2 Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) medical centers (San Francisco VA Medical Center and VA Palo Alto Health Care System), one university center (University of California, San Francisco) and nine public health clinics in the Community Health Network of San Francisco. Eligible patients had at least one of the following: a history of myocardial infarction, angiographic evidence of ≥50% stenosis in one or more coronary vessels, history of coronary revascularization or prior evidence of exercise-induced ischemia by treadmill or nuclear testing. All study participants completed a self-administered questionnaire during a daylong study appointment. The study was approved by the appropriate institutional review boards and written informed consent was obtained from all participants after complete description of the study.
This analysis includes 870 (85%) of the 1,024 participants in the Heart and Soul Study. Of the 154 patients excluded, five did not complete the hopelessness survey, one did not provide information on race, 116 patients did not have genotyping, and thirty-two patients had at least one rare 5-HTTLPR variant (generally 18 or 20 repeats), the transcriptional efficiency of which is unknown30.
Sample collection, DNA extraction and storage, amplification and genotyping procedures are described elsewhere22. Resulting genotypes of 5-HTTLPR were described as l/l, l/s or s/s. Laboratory personnel were blind to hopelessness scores.
We assessed current hopelessness using the Everson two-item hopelessness scale, a previously validated instrument2. The scale contains the following questions: 1) “I feel that it is impossible to reach the goals I would like to strive for”, and 2) “The future seems to me to be hopeless, and I can’t believe that things are changing for the better”. Responses are scored as 0 (absolutely disagree), 1 (somewhat disagree), 2 (cannot say), 3 (somewhat agree), and 4 (absolutely agree), with a summary score ranging from 0 to 8 (higher scores indicate greater hopelessness). We categorized hopelessness as defined by Everson et al.2: Low (0-2), moderate (3-5), high (6-8).
Other Patient Characteristics and Covariates
Self-reported age, race, gender, marital status, income, education, smoking and alcohol use were determined by self-administered questionnaire. Race categories included on the survey were 1) Hispanic, Latino, or Latin American; 2) Asian or Pacific Islander; 3) Black or African American; 4) White or Caucasian; 5) Another group not listed. We used the terms: “Latino”, “Asian”, “African American”, “White” and “Other” to describe the groups throughout the manuscript. We measured height and weight and calculated body mass index. Participants were instructed to bring all medication to their appointment where study personnel recorded and categorized medications using Epocrates Rx (San Mateo, California). We measured depressive symptoms using the 9-item Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ-9) score31,32, a self-report instrument that has excellent validity for diagnosing depression in patients with coronary disease33, and which also predicts adverse cardiovascular outcomes34. We also ascertained the presence of a current major depressive disorder using the Computerized Diagnostic Interview Schedule35 for DSM-IV (CDIS-IV). Participants with a major depressive episode in the past month were informed of this diagnosis, instructed to discuss their symptoms with their primary care provider, and provided a list of local resources available for treatment. We measured social support using a single question with a dichotomous response, “Do you have as much contact as you would like with someone you feel close to, someone in whom you can trust and confide?”
The primary goal of this study was to investigate the independent association between the s allele variant of the 5-HTTLPR polymorphism and hopelessness. We considered autosomal dominant, autosomal recessive and dose-response effects of the s allele in our analysis. Genotypes were classified separately according to levels of transcriptional efficiency9,16, where l/l was coded as 0, s/l was coded as 1, and s/s was coded as 2. In our analysis, the dose response model best characterized the association between 5-HTTLPR genotype and hopelessness.
Differences in characteristics between participants by 5-HTTLPR genotype (l/l, l/s and s/s) were determined using chi square (for dichotomous variables) or analysis of variance (for continuous variables). We used two models to evaluate the association between 5-HTTLPR genotype and measured hopelessness: In the first, we used analysis of covariance to calculate mean hopelessness scores according to genotype. This model was used for its increased sensitivity to test for effect modifying and confounding variables to establish a final adjusted model. We considered the effects of interactions between 5-HTTLPR and potential effect modifiers including race, depressive symptoms, major depressive disorder, antidepressant use, social support, sex and age. Then, we used a proportional odds final adjusted model to estimate the independent association between 5-HTTLPR genotype and hopeless category (low, moderate, high). We verified the proportional odds assumption that the association between 5-HTTLPR genotype and each possible dichotomous outcome variable that could be constructed from the ordinal hopelessness categories (high vs. low-moderate and low vs. moderate-high) can be described by only two odds-ratios, one for l/s and the other for s/s.
In order to avoid population stratification36, 37, 38, we adjusted for self-reported race in all pooled and composite “non-white” analyses. In our final adjusted model, we also included as covariates age, antidepressant use and depressive symptoms (PHQ-9 score). These were chosen on the basis of clinical validity and prior literature demonstrating an association between age, depressive symptoms and response to antidepressants with 5-HTTLPR39,40. We tested our final model using two sensitivity analyses: 1) We excluded patients with CDIS IV current depressive disorder, and 2) we further adjusted for variables associated (p < 0.10) with either 5-HTTLPR or hopelessness score.
The effect of 5-HTTLPR on hopelessness was modified by sex (p = 0.04). We therefore stratified our analyses according to patient sex, and race, based on an a priori assumption of population stratification by race (though we found no statistical evidence) of interaction between 5-HTTLPR and race, p = 0.63). Racial subgroups were first stratified by “white” and “non-white”, in order to evaluate this association in the largest, only adequately powered subgroup (white patients). In a secondary analysis, we present the adjusted association between the s allele and hopeless category in individual minority (non-white) groups. Although underpowered, we intended to evaluate for a trend in the effect of the s allele on hopelessness across racial groups. We also present the results in only the male subgroups as the assumption of proportional odds is violated in females due to small sample size.
To assess for collinearity, we calculated a Spearman correlation coefficient between Everson hopelessness and PHQ-9 scores. The analyses were performed using STATA version 10 (STATA Corp, College Station, TX).
Characteristics of 870 Participants with Coronary Artery Disease According to 5-HTTLPR Genotype*
l/l N = 282 (32%)
l/s N = 416 (48%)
s/s N = 172 (20%)
Age in Years, mean ± SD
66.7 ± 11
66.9 ± 11
66.5 ± 11
High School Graduate
Median Income Category in $†
Benzodiazepine or anxiolytic
Angiotensin receptor blocker
Body mass index, mean ± SD
28.7 ± 6
28.1 ± 5
28.6 ± 5
Regular alcohol use
Presence of social support
Measures of Depression
Depressive Symptoms (PHQ-9 score), mean ± SD
5.2 ± 5.3
5.2 ± 5.4
5.1 ± 5.7
Current Depression by CDIS-IV
The 154 excluded patients were more likely to be Asian (21% versus 10%) or African American (26% versus 15%), largely due to increased frequency of rare 5-HTTLPR variants (15 Asians, 16 African Americans and 1 White patient), and less likely to be White (44% versus 63%) or Latino (6% versus 9%), but they did not differ according to other demographic or clinical characteristics listed in Table 1 (data not shown).
5-HTTLPR and Hopelessness
Mean Hopelessness Score by 5-HTTLPR Genotype
All study participants (n = 870)
Adjusted by race
2.5 ± 0.1
2.8 ± 0.1
3.1 ± 0.2
Adjusted by race, age, depressive symptoms and antidepressant use
2.5 ± 0.1
2.8 ± 0.1
3.1 ± 0.1
Males (n = 710)
2.5 ± 0.1
2.9 ± 0.1
3.3 ± 0.2
Females (n = 160)
2.4 ± 0.3
2.6 ± 0.2
2.2 ± 0.4
Non-depressed participants (n = 678)
Adjusted by race
2.4 ± 0.2
2.6 ± 0.2
3.0 ± 0.2
Adjusted by race, age, depressive symptoms, and antidepressant use
2.3 ± 0.2
2.5 ± 0.2
2.9 ± 0.2
Males (n = 579)
2.3 ± 0.2
2.6 ± 0.2
3.0 ± 0.2
Females (n = 99)
2.1 ± 0.5
2.2 ± 0.4
2.7 ± 0.5
Effect Modification by Sex
We did not find differences in the effect of 5-HTTLPR genotype on hopelessness by age (p-value for interaction = 0.29), race (p = 0.63) antidepressant use (p = 0.35), marital status (p = 0.94), social support (p = 0.17), depressive symptoms (p = 0.18) or CDIS IV current depression (p = 0.88). Adjusted results stratified by sex (p value for interaction = 0.04) demonstrated an association between the 5-HTTLPR genotype and mean hopelessness score in males (p = 0.001) but not in females (p = 0.76) (Table 2).
Findings in Non-Depressed Patients
Although we found no statistical evidence of interaction between 5-HTTLPR genotype and current depression (p-value = 0.88), we excluded 192 patients with current major depressive disorder as defined by CDIS-IV to evaluate the association between 5-HTTLPR genotype and hopelessness in non-depressed patients. In the 678 nondepressed patients, we found a similar trend of increasing mean hopelessness scores with each added s allele (p = 0.007 in the adjusted model) (Table 2). After stratification by sex, we observed this effect only in the male sub-group.
5-HTTLPR and Hopeless Category
In this cross-sectional study of 870 patients with stable coronary artery disease, we found that the s allele of the 5-HTT polymorphic region predicted higher propensity to hopelessness that persisted after controlling for age, depressive symptoms, major depressive disorder, and antidepressant use. Further, this association was present only in male patients, where males with the s/s genotype had more than 2-fold increased odds of a higher hopeless category than l/l males across racial subgroups. We did not find any association between 5-HTTLPR genotype and hopelessness in the female sample in this study. Additionally, we did not find that the effect between 5-HTTLPR genotype and hopelessness was modified by race, depression (CDIS IV), depressive symptoms (PHQ-9), antidepressant use, social support or age. After excluding the 192 depressed patients, we saw a similar association between 5-HTTLPR genotype and hopelessness. Our findings suggest that hopelessness may be partly heritable and that the serotonin (5-HT) system is likely to be involved. Further, these results suggest that the s allele may increase susceptibility to hopelessness in men with chronic cardiovascular disease independent of depressive symptoms or major depressive disorder.
Hopelessness is common in cardiovascular patients and leads to increased cardiovascular morbidity and mortality1. This study demonstrates that there is a dose response relationship between 5-HTTLPR s allele carriage and higher hopelessness in men with chronic cardiovascular disease. Across racial groups, the odds were more than doubled for a higher hopeless category in men with the s/s genotype compared to l/l genotype. The 2-item Everson Hopelessness scale has been validated in cardiovascular patients, and moderate and high hopelessness has been linked in a dose response fashion with all-cause and cardiovascular-specific mortality independent of depression2. The findings of this study illuminate underlying mechanisms for this important and under-recognized phenotype.
Sex and Age Effects
The marked effect of 5-HTTLPR on measured hopelessness in men but not in women is consistent with prior reports of sex-specific genetic influences on serotonergic function44. It has been demonstrated that ovarian steroids stimulate expression of the serotonin transporter45,46, and the impact of a less functional s allele may be moderated by an estrogen-induced protective effect in women. Increased age has been associated with decreased serotonergic function; however, the protective effect of age related to 5-HTTLPR moderation antidepressant response has only been found in patients under 25 years of age26. As our sample was older, it was not surprising that there was no evidence of interaction between 5-HTTLPR and age.
Although we found no statistical evidence of interaction by race, we accounted for the possibility that the allele frequency differences between racial groups modified the relationship between 5-HTTLPR and hopelessness by stratifying our analysis by race and adjusting for race in pooled analyses. This addresses the concern of bias by population stratification, where 5-HTTLPR variation between racial groups may be a marker of different genetic and environmental factors leading to hopelessness in each of these groups rather than the etiology itself41. Across races, we found a similar linear association between 5-HTTLPR and hopelessness.
Genetics of Hopelessness
There has been very little research on the genetics of hopelessness. The only prior study by Gonda and colleagues15 first identified the association between the 5-HTTLPR s allele and hopelessness as part of an evaluation of neuroticism traits in healthy, young, white women. In comparison, we found an association in older men with significant cardiovascular disease, but no effect in the minority of women in the study. Additionally, whereas our study used the Everson scale to measure hopelessness, Gonda et al. used the Beck hopelessness scale47. Although correlation between these scoring systems has not been evaluated, items on the scales are similar.
The constructs of hopelessness and depression are difficult to disentangle as hopelessness is often a fundamental characteristic of depression. However, it has been proposed that hopelessness may be a distinct phenotype from depression and the independent association between the 5-HTTLPR genotype and measured hopelessness in this sample supports this hypothesis. Scales measuring hopelessness and depression differ: whereas depression scales focus on mood alteration, hopelessness scales measure future orientation6. Our results suggest that pathophysiological differences may exist between these two constructs as well. Is hopelessness really just a marker of “sub-threshold” depression, one that is poorly measured by traditional depression scales? Or is it a separate entity often present in depression, but a functionally independent construct? The independent association with 5-HTTLPR s allele suggests that measured constructs of hopelessness and depression are independent entities. Our results may also provide new insights on the heterogeneity of results in the evaluation of 5-HTTLPR and depression.
Strengths and Limitations
Our study is the largest to date to evaluate the association between 5-HTTLPR polymorphism and hopelessness. However, it is only powered to detect associations in the largest subgroups (white race, male sex). Women were underrepresented, and our current negative results do not rule out the possibility of a type II error. Similarly, the association between 5-HTTLPR and hopelessness in males is a novel finding that will have to be tested in other large samples. Further, results in the Latino and African American groups are further limited by possible population stratification, due to the racial admixture present in these groups. However, the results in the non-white groups serve to identify trends as the basis for more robust future studies and meta-analyses. Lastly, it is not known whether increased hopelessness associated with 5-HTTLPR s allele is associated with meaningful clinical outcomes, such as increased cardiovascular mortality or SSRI resistance. Although our interaction term between 5-HTTLPR and antidepressant use was not statistically significant, only 19% of patients in our cohort were on any type of antidepressant, with only half that number on SSRIs; therefore, our power to detect the interaction in this cohort was small. Prior work by Otte et al.22 demonstrated an association between the 5-HTTLPR s allele and increased norepinephrine secretion in Heart and Soul. This finding along with other reports that the s allele moderates cardiac reactivity11 and increased cardiac events mediated by depressive symptoms,48 suggest that 5-HTTLPR may play a larger role in cardiovascular health outcomes. Lastly, although our sample included only highly educated adults with cardiovascular disease, we suspect that the association between 5-HTTLPR and hopelessness may be similar in other populations. Despite these limitations we find an independent association between the 5-HTTLPR s allele and significantly increased hopelessness in men with cardiovascular disease.
In conclusion, we found that the 5-HTTLPR s allele was associated with increased susceptibility to hopelessness in men with cardiovascular disease, independent of depressive symptoms and major depressive disorder.
Thank you to Dr. John Witte for his assistance in addressing issues related to population stratification. The Heart and Soul Study was supported by grants from the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) Epidemiology Merit Review Program, the VA Health Services Research and Development Service, the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation (Generalist Physician Faculty Scholars Program), the American Federation for Aging Research (Paul Beeson Faculty Scholars in Aging Research Program), and the Ischemia Research and Education Foundation. Dr. Kangelaris was supported by a National Research Service Award (NRSA) institutional grant (T32 HP19025). None of these funding sources had any role in the collection of data, interpretation of results, or preparation of this manuscript.
Conflict of Interest
This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial License which permits any noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and source are credited.
- 11.McCaffery JM, Bleil M, Pogue-Geile MF, Ferrell RE, Manuck SB. Allelic variation in the serotonin transporter gene-linked polymorphic region (5-HTTLPR) and cardiovascular reactivity in young adult male and female twins of European-American descent. Psychosom Med. 2003;65(5):721–8.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
- 42.Konishi T, Smith JL, Lin KM, Wan YJ. Influence of genetic admixture on polymorphisms of alcohol-metabolizing enzymes: analyses of mutations on the CYP2E1, ADH2, ADH3 and ALDH2 genes in a Mexican-American population living in the Los Angeles area. Alcohol Alcohol. 2003;38(1):93–4.PubMedGoogle Scholar