Does Price Transparency Legislation Allow the Uninsured to Shop for Care?
The majority of states have enacted price transparency laws to allow patients to shop for care and to prevent price discrimination of the uninsured. In California, hospitals must provide a price estimate to a requesting uninsured patient and cannot bill for an amount greater than the reimbursement the hospital would receive from a government payer.
To assess the response rate of California hospitals to a patient price request and to compare the price estimates received to Medicare reimbursement.
We sent letters to California acute-care hospitals from a fictional uninsured patient requesting an estimate for one of three common elective procedures: a laparoscopic cholecystectomy, a hysterectomy, or routine screening colonoscopy.
Three hundred and fifty-three hospitals in California.
Hospital response rates, difference between price estimates received, and Medicare reimbursement for equivalent procedures.
Only 28% (98/353) of hospitals responded and their response varied in content. Of the 98 responses, 15 (15%) did not provide a quote and instead asked for more information such as the billing code, 55 (56%) provided a price estimate for hospital services only, 10 (10%) included both physician and hospital services, and 18 (18%) did not specify what was covered. The median discounted price estimate was higher than Medicare reimbursement rates for all procedures: hysterectomy ($17,403 vs. $5,569; p < 0.001), cholecystectomy ($14,014 vs. $7,196; p < 0.001) and colonoscopy ($2,017 vs. $216; p < 0.001).
Current California legislation fails to meet its objective of enabling uninsured patients to compare prices for hospital-based health care services.
KEY WORDStransparency uninsured shopping legislation out-of-pocket costs hospital costs
- 5.Abelson R, Glater JD. Suits Challenge Hospital Bills of Uninsured. New York Times, June 17, 2004; 2004, Business.Google Scholar
- 7.State Legislation Relating to Disclosure of Health and Hospital Charges. 2007. http://www.ncsl.org/programs/health/Transparency.htm. Published Last Modified Date|. Accessed Dated Accessed October 13, 2009|.
- 8.California Health and Safety Code, 1339.585. 2005; http://www.oshpd.ca.gov/HID/Products/Hospitals/FairPricing/index.html. Accessed October 13, 2009.
- 9.California Health and Safety Code, 127405. 2007; http://www.oshpd.ca.gov/HID/Products/Hospitals/FairPricing/FAQGen.html. Accessed October 13, 2009.
- 10.US Department of Health and Human Services. Value Driven Health Care. undated; http://www.hhs.gov/valuedriven/. Accessed October, 2009.
- 13.Schatz E. Texas Legislates Medical Price Transparency. Health Care News; 2007, November.Google Scholar