Criminal Law and Philosophy

, Volume 6, Issue 1, pp 47–63 | Cite as

Criminalizing Health-Related Behaviors Dangerous to Others? Disease Transmission, Transmission-Facilitation, and the Importance of Trust

Original Paper

Abstract

Statutes criminalizing behavior that risks transmission of HIV/AIDS exemplify use of the criminal law against individuals who are victims of infectious disease. These statutes, despite their frequency, are misguided in terms of the goals of the criminal law and the public health aim of reducing overall burdens of disease, for at least three important reasons. First, they identify individual offenders for punishment, a paradigm that is misplaced in the most typical contexts of transmission of infectious disease and even for HIV/AIDS, despite claims of AIDS exceptionalism. Second, although there are examples of individuals who transmit infectious disease in a manner that fits the criminal law paradigm of identification of individual offenders for deterrence or retribution, these examples are limited and can be accommodated by existing criminal laws not devoted specifically to infectious disease. Third, and most importantly, the current criminal laws regarding HIV/AIDS, like many other criminal laws applied to infectious disease transmission, have been misguided in focusing on punishment of the diseased individual as a wrongful transmitter. Instead of individual offenders, activities that enhance the scale of disease transmission—behaviors that might be characterized as ‘transmission facilitation’—are a more appropriate target for the criminal law. Examples are trafficking in human beings (including sex trafficking, organ trafficking, and labor trafficking), suppression of information about the emergence of infection in circumstances in which there is a legally established obligation to disclose, and intentional or reckless activities to discourage disease treatment or prevention. Difficulties remain with justifications for criminalizing even these behaviors, however, most importantly the need for trust in reducing overall burdens of disease, problems in identifying individual responsible offenders, and potential misalignment between static criminal law and the changing nature of infectious disease.

Keywords

Criminalization Infectious disease HIV/AIDS Trafficking Disease transmission 

References

  1. Ahmed, A. (2011). HIV and women: Incongruent policies, criminal consequences. Yale Journal of International Affairs, 6(1), 32–42.Google Scholar
  2. Arizona Department of Health Services, Office of Infectious Disease Services. (2011). Communicable disease reporting. http://www.azdhs.gov/phs/oids/reporting/index.htm. Accessed 24 October 2011.
  3. Associated Press. (2010). State can try to detain man who spread HIV. New York Times (July 19). http://www.nytimes.com/2010/07/20/nyregion/20nushawn.html?ref=nushawnjwilliams. Accessed 27 June 2011.
  4. Aylward, B., & Yamada, T. (2011). The polio endgame. New England Journal of Medicine, 364, 2273–2275.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Ball, C. A., & Barnes, M. (1994). Public health and individual rights: Tuberculosis control and detention procedures in New York City. Yale Law & Policy Review, 12, 38–67.Google Scholar
  6. Battin, M. P., Francis, L. P., Jacobson, J. A., & Smith, C. B. (2009). The patient as victim and vector: Ethics and infectious disease. New York: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Bayer, R. (1991). Public health policy and the AIDS epidemic: An end to HIV exceptionalism? New England Journal of Medicine, 324, 1500–1504.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Bourdain, A. (2005). Typhoid Mary: An urban historical. New York: Bloomsbury.Google Scholar
  9. Brady, R.-M. (2007). The revised international health regulations: An historical overview and an analysis of modern application. ABA Health eSource, 4(4). http://www.americanbar.org/newsletter/publications/aba_health_esource_home/Volume4_04_index.html. Accessed 6 Dec 2011.
  10. Burris, S. (1993–1994). Public health, “AIDS exceptionalism” and the law. John Marshall Law Review, 27, 251–272.Google Scholar
  11. Burris, S., Beletsky, L., Burleson, J., Case, P., & Lazzarini, Z. (2010). Do criminal laws influence HIV risk behavior? An empirical trial. Arizona State Law Journal, 467–519, 486. (2010).Google Scholar
  12. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2005). Guidelines for preventing the transmission of Mycobacterium tuberculosis in health-care settings. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report 54 (RR-17). http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/pdf/rr/rr5417.pdf. Accessed 25 June 2011.
  13. Chakraborti, C. (2009). Pandemic management and developing world bioethics: Bird flu in West Bengal. Developing World Bioethics, 9(3), 161–166.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Chalmers, J. (2008). Legal responses to HIV and AIDS. Oxford: Hart Publishing.Google Scholar
  15. Clarkson, J. T. (2010). Note: Phase six pandemic: A call to re-evaluate federal quarantine authority before the next catastrophic outbreak. Georgia Law Review, 44, 803–836.Google Scholar
  16. Cohen, J. (2000). South African leader declines to join the chorus on HIV and AIDS. Science, 289(5477), 222.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Duffy, S. T. (2009). The power of detention in the management of non-compliance with tuberculosis treatment: A survey of Irish practitioners and analysis of potential legal liability. Public Health, 123(1), 81–85.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Fallow, H. A. (2008). Reforming federal quarantine law in the wake of Andrew speaker: The “tuberculosis traveler”. Journal of Contemporary Health Law and Policy, 25, 83–106.Google Scholar
  19. Fidler, D. P. (2002). Bioterrorism, public health, and international law. Chicago Journal of International Law, 3, 7–26.Google Scholar
  20. Forum on Microbial Threats, Institute of Medicine. (2010). Infectious disease movement in a borderless world: Workshop summary. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK45728/pdf/TOC.pdf. Accessed 25 October 2011.
  21. Francis, L. P., & Francis, J. G. (2010). Stateless crimes, legitimacy, and international criminal law: The case of organ trafficking. Criminal Law and Philosophy, 4(3), 283–295.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Frey, J. (1999). Jamestown and the Story of “Nushawn’s Girls.” Washington Post (June 1), p. C1.Google Scholar
  23. Frishman, A. (2009). Major reason for Nigerian boycott of polio vaccine. Health Affairs, 28(6), 1860–1861.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Galletly, C. L., & Pinkerton, S. D. (2004). Toward rational criminal HIV exposure laws. The Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics, 32, 327–336.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Global Network of People Living with HIV. (2010). The global criminalisation scan report 2010. http://www.gnpplus.net/programmes/human-rights/global-criminalisation-scan/1648-2010-global-criminalisation-scan-report. Accessed 23 October 2011.
  26. Grant, I. (2009). Rethinking risk: The relevance of condoms and viral load in HIV nondisclosure prosecutions. McGill Law Journal, 54, 389–404.Google Scholar
  27. Hernandez, N. (2007a). Kids get vaccinated or else, parents told. Washington Post (Nov. 17), p. B02.Google Scholar
  28. Hernandez, N. (2007b). More Md. Students getting vaccinated; Pr. George’s Leads in Noncompliance. Washington Post (October 4), p. SM05.Google Scholar
  29. Hodge, J. G., & Lawrence, O. G. (2001–2002). School vaccination requirements: Historical, social, and legal perspectives. Kentucky Law Review, 90, 831–869.Google Scholar
  30. Huda, S. (2006). Sex trafficking in South Asia. International Journal of Obstetrics & Gynecology, 94(3), 374–381.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Kaufmann, J. R., & Feldbaum, H. (2009). Diplomacy and the polio immunization boycott in Northern Nigeria. Health Affairs, 28(4), 1091–1101.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Langley, E. E., & Nardi, D. J., Jr. (2010). The irony of outlawing AIDS: A human rights argument against the criminalization of HIV transmission. Georgetown Journal of Gender and the Law, 11(3), 743–794.Google Scholar
  33. Leavitt, J. K. (1996). Typhoid Mary: Captive to the public’s health. Boston: Beacon Press.Google Scholar
  34. Mahmoud-Davis, S. (2010). Note, balancing public health and individual choice: A proposal for a federal emergency vaccination law. Health Matrix, 20, 219–257.Google Scholar
  35. McDonough, M. (2007). Tests reveal lawyer’s fellow air travelers free of TB. ABA Journal. http://www.abajournal.com/news/article/tests_reveal_lawyers_fellow_air_travelers_free_of_tb/. Accessed 28 June 2011 (Nov. 28).
  36. Model State Emergency Health Powers Act. (2001). http://www.publichealthlaw.net/MSEHPA/MSEHPA.pdf. Accessed 26 October 2011.
  37. Mok, E. A., et al. (2010). Implementing public health regulations in developing countries: Lessons from the OECD countries. Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics, 38, 508–518.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Nguyen, L. (2011). Aziga claims ‘racist’ jury led to murder conviction. http://www.vancouversun.com/story_print.html?id=4851467&sponsor=. Accessed 23 June 2011.
  39. Oscherwitz, T., et al. (1997). Detention of persistently nonadherent patients with tuberculosis. Journal of the American Medical Association, 278(10), 843–846.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Parkhurst, J. O., & Lush, L. (2004). The political environment of HIV: Lessons from a comparison of Uganda and South Africa. Social Science and Medicine, 59(9), 1913–1924.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Presidential Comm’n on the Human Immunodeficiency Virus Epidemic. (1988). Report of the presidential comm’n on the human immunodeficiency virus epidemic. http://www.eric.ed.gov/PDFS/ED299531.pdf. Accessed 24 October 2011.
  42. Scharf, M. P. (1999). Clear and present danger: Enforcing the international ban on biological and chemical weapons through sanctions, use of force, and criminalization. Michigan Journal of International Law, 20, 477–521.Google Scholar
  43. Senanayake, S. N., & Ferson, M. J. (2004). Detention for tuberculosis: Public health and the law. Medical Journal of Australia, 180(11), 573–576.Google Scholar
  44. Shilts, R. (1988). And the band played on. New York: Penguin Books.Google Scholar
  45. Sidley, P. (2000). Mbeki dismisses “Durban declaration”. British Medical Journal, 321(7253), 67.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Simmons, A. (2008). Man once jailed in TB case deported. Atlanta Journal-Constitution, 5J (January 9).Google Scholar
  47. Specter, M. (2007). The denialists: the dangerous attacks on the consensus about HIV and AIDS, The New Yorker (March 12), pp. 32–38.Google Scholar
  48. Stephens, J. (2009). Pfizer to pay $75 million to settle Nigerian Trovan drug-testing suit. Washington Post. http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/07/30/AR2009073001847.html. Accessed 30 June 2011.
  49. Tayman, J. (2006). The colony. New York: Scribner’s.Google Scholar
  50. Terrence Higgins Trust. (2011). Criminalisation of HIV transmission in Europe. http://www.gnpplus.net/criminalisation/results.shtml. Accessed 24 October 2011.
  51. UNAIDS. (2002). Criminal law, public health and HIV transmission: A policy options paper. http://www.unaids.org/en/media/unaids/contentassets/dataimport/publications/irc-pub02/jc733-criminallaw_en.pdf. Accessed 24 October 2011.
  52. UNAIDS. (2004). UNAIDS recommendations for alternative language to some problematic articles in the N’Djamena legislation on HIV. http://www.unaids.org/en/media/unaids/contentassets/dataimport/pub/manual/2008/20080912_alternativelanguage_ndajema_legislation_en.pdf. Accessed 24 October 2011.
  53. UNAIDS. (2007). Criminalization of HIV transmission: Policy brief. http://www.unaids.org/en/media/unaids/contentassets/dataimport/pub/basedocument/2008/20080731_jc1513_policy_criminalization_en.pdf. Accessed 24 October 2011.
  54. United Nations General Assembly. (2009). Resolution adopted by the human rights council, promotion and protection of all human rights, civil, political, economic, social and cultural rights, including the right to development 13 (December 27). http://daccess-dds-ny.un.org/doc/RESOLUTION/GEN/G09/168/42/PDF/G0916842.pdf?OpenElement. Accessed 23 June 2011
  55. US AID and Family Health International. (2006). Promising and best practices in HIV/AIDS prevention and care for West and Central Africa (p. 13). http://www.fhi.org/NR/rdonlyres/e3e4nxkxsdbwev7hkfsac3ltmh545bmsqg4vs5nx7krsqctzkgtdaf7wpj7owhbksmioirjxvrhtuk/BestPracticesENHV.pdf. Accessed 25 October 2011.
  56. US AID and Family Health International. (2008). Disseminating and replicating best practices in West Africa. http://www.fhi.org/NR/rdonlyres/ee6tr3nar6mnnri7b5fkesexfwlau5jno4p3a4m2vzcwqzh6n4jediytkw6ceonvtdhvzvvx4bd27m/AWAREDissemBestPracticesWAHV.pdf. Accessed 25 June 2011.
  57. von Tigerstrom, B. (2005). The revised international health regulation and the restraint of national health measures. Health Law Journal, 13, 35–76.Google Scholar
  58. Webber, D. (Ed.). (2012). AIDS and the law (4th ed.). New York: Kluwer. Supp. 2010.Google Scholar
  59. WHO. (2005). International health regulations (2nd edn). http://whqlibdoc.who.int/publications/2008/9789241580410_eng.pdf. Accessed 25 October 2011.
  60. WHO. (2011). Implementation of the International Health Regulations (2005), Report of the Review Committee on the Functioning of the International Health Regulations (2005) in relation to Pandemic (H1N1) 2009. http://apps.who.int/gb/ebwha/pdf_files/WHA64/A64_10-en.pdf. Accessed 6 Dec 2011.
  61. Wolf, L. E., & Vezina, R. (2004). Crime and punishment: Is there a role for criminal law in HIV prevention policy. Whittier Law Review, 25, 821–886.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2011

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.University of UtahSalt Lake CityUSA

Personalised recommendations