Physical consequences of falls in the elderly: a literature review from 1995 to 2010
- 6.8k Downloads
In the last decade, population ageing has been registered as a global phenomenon. A relation exists between falling and ageing, since falling frequency increases significantly with age. In fact, one in three older adult falls annually. Although ageing is generically associated with decrease and degeneration of psychological and physical functions, it is still not common for the correct identification of risk factors to lead to a clinical prognosis of the elder being in risk of falling. Therefore, the goal of this review article is to identify, categorise and analyse typical ageing and fall factors mentioned in the literature as well as to quantify the number of times they were referenced. The research considered hundreds of publications, but analysis was then restricted to the 87 most pertinent articles written in English and published in journals or scientific magazines between 1995 and 2010. We concluded that falls among older adults can be characterised by the following: anatomic characteristics and physiological consequences of ageing; the pathologies that induce falls, which can be neurological, musculoskeletal, cardiovascular and other diseases; causes and risk factors of falls that can be behavioural, biological, environmental or socio-economic; type of physical consequences of falls, including fractures, bruises, injuries or other physical consequences; and strategies to prevent, mitigate or rehabilitate, which can be of a physical, environmental or behavioural nature.
KeywordsAgeing Elderly falls Accidental falls Risk factors Physical consequences of falls
Elderly are currently considered the fastest growing age group worldwide . In the last decades, the number of elderly people in the world has been consistently and proportionally increasing. In 1996, there were a total of 323 million people in the world aged above 65 years . That number increased in 2010 to 440 million  and is forecasted to be 1,555 million by 2050 .
The physical changes inherent to ageing can reduce autonomy and functional independence, which may directly or indirectly lead to falls. Falls are coded as E880–E888 in the International Classification of Disease-9 (ICD-9) and as W00–W19 in ICD-10, being commonly defined as “inadvertently coming to rest on the ground, floor or other lower level, excluding intentional change in position to rest in furniture, wall or other objects” . About one third of the population over 65 suffers at least one indoor fall every year [33, 47], and about half of the population in this age group who is institutionalised fall each year . Among the elderly, falls are one of the main causes of injuries, physical incapacity and even death. Each year, around 37.3 million falls among elderly will require health care, and about 424,000 lead to death of the faller .
It is thus obvious that the problem of falls among the elderly population has epidemiological levels with a global incidence and dimension. Therefore, the following question was posed: What are the physical consequences of falls in the elderly population?
In order to answer this question, a quantitative review was conducted. This paper aims at identifying, categorising and analysing the typical ageing and fall factors mentioned in the literature as well as quantifying the number of times these factors were referenced. This study considered the incidence of the anatomic characteristics and physiological consequences of ageing, the pathologies that power falls, causes and risk factors for falls, physical consequences of falls and strategies to prevent, mitigate and rehabilitate.
This work is focused on providing an overview of the published literature to researchers, academics and practitioners, who deal with this issue; it does not cover the entire research area of elderly population falls.
Materials and methods
The research was limited to peer-reviewed articles, written in English and published in scientific journals or magazines between the years 1995 and 2010. The research was restricted to the following databases: PubMed, Access Medicine, Science Direct, Oxford Journals and Taylor & Francis Online. Additionally, a manual search was carried out for the other publishers in the areas already mentioned, such as McGraw-Hill and BioMed Central as well as publications edited by organisations that focus the problem of falls in the elderly people, such as the National Center for Injury Prevention and Control and the World Health Organization.
The keywords used, as title and/or abstract and/or keywords of the articles, either for searching scientific publications databases or for manual search in other online publications, were the following: “physical consequences of falls”, “senior population and falls”, “falls pathologies”, “anatomy of ageing”, “causes of falls” and “risk factors”.
After the search, the titles and abstracts were analysed in order to eliminate duplicates and publications with topics that did not meet the purpose of this review work. The remaining publications were thoroughly read and analysed, and all references to the topics addressed in the review article were identified and quantified.
A total of 87 publications were selected and analysed, from which 81 were journal publications from scientific database and 6 were articles published in book chapters or specialty reports obtained from the manual search. The publications came from 25 different countries in the world and represent all continents with the exception of Africa. The strongest geographic incidence, with about 82 % of the total publications was identified in two continents: North America and Europe. South America and Asia represent 18 % of the total publications. Publications from Turkey, Israel and Iran were considered as being from the Asian continent.
Ageing pathologies that potentiate falls
Identification of references for pathologies of ageing that may cause falls
Loss of muscle density
Problems in the lower extremities
Deformities in the joints
Pneumonia and bone infections
In the selected literature, the neurological diseases, such as stroke (13.7 %), dementia (10.3 %), vestibular disorders/balance (10.3 %) and Parkinson (9.1 %), are the most referenced ageing pathologies as propitiating falls in the elderly population.
In terms of musculoskeletal pathologies, osteoporosis was the pathology with a higher incidence of references (16 %), followed by loss of muscle density (9.1 %) and arthritis (6.8 %). Problems in the lower extremities and joint deformities were also diseases common in the falling elderly, but with a lower incidence of references (3.4 and 2.2 %, respectively).
Cardiovascular diseases, such as orthostatic hypotension (6.8 %), arrhythmias (3.4 %) and syncope (3.4 %), are also common pathologies due to the ageing process and may also lead to falls.
In the “other pathologies” category, the following typical pathologies of ageing that can lead to falls were identified: diabetes and depression (4.5 %), pneumonia and lung infections (2.2 %) and sleep disorders (1.1 %).
The causes and risk factors of falls
Identification of references and percentage of incidence of the causes and risk factors for falls
Fear of falling (after the first fall)
Fear of falling (without ever having fallen)
Reduction of physical activity
Activities of daily living
Direction of fall (sideways)
Direction of fall (forward)
Difficulties in dressing
Level/angle/position of the impact
Lack of balance while walking
Musculoskeletal and sensory degradation
Functional dependence on mobility
Sex (higher incidence in females)
Decreased bone density
Lack of vision
Decrease in body mass index
Changes in soft tissues
Weight (body mass that falls)
Unsafe home environments
Height of fall
Collision with objects
Falls hospital beds
Level of education and income
Access to social services and health
Lack of social interaction
Behavioural, characteristics of human actions, emotions or daily choices;
Biological, individual's characteristics pertinent to the human body;
Environmental, interactions between the individual's physical condition and the surrounding environment;
Socio-economic, related to the individual's social and economic situation.
The results of this analysis are shown in Table 2. The behaviour causes and risk factors most referenced in the reviewed literature were overdose of medication (with 32.1 %) and the fear of falling—without having ever fallen before or after the first fall (29.8 and 22.9 %, respectively). The reduction in physical activity (16 %), carrying out activities of daily living (11.4 %) and alcohol consumption (10.3 %) are located in the intermediate incidence group. In the smallest incident group, the following were identified: slip (6.8 %), fainting (4.5 %) as well as smoking and an inappropriate use of footwear (both with 3.4 %).
Concerning the biological causes and risk factors, highest incidence was on a lack of balance during gait (33.3 %), musculoskeletal and sensory degradation (26.4 %), functional dependence in the mobility (25.2 %), cognitive impairment (24.1 %), age (19.5 %) and sex (18.3 %) with higher incidence in females. The decrease in bone density and lack of vision (with 14.9 % each), chronic diseases (13.7 %), depression (12.6 %), occurrence of dizziness and vertigo (11.4 %) and decrease of index bone mass (10.3 %), which weakens the ability to absorb and dissipate impact forces, were intermediate incidence factors. Finally, urinary incontinence, orthostatic hypotension, pain, soft tissue changes, hearing problems and body weight, with between 3.4 and 4.5 % incidence, were identified as causes and behaviour risk factors with least references in the reviewed literature.
With respect to the environmental causes and risk factors, unsafe domestic (17.2 %) and outdoors (16 %) environments were found to have the highest incidence. Falls from hospital beds, mobility aids (for example walkers) and the collision against objects were referenced only one to two times.
Last, the socio-economic causes and risk factors of falls included limited access to health and social services (2.2 %), low income and low educational level (2.2 %) and lack of social interactions (1.1 %). This category had the lowest number of references in the literature, when compared with the other categories of causes and risk factors.
If a profile is established for a senior individual with a high risk of falling based simultaneously on the causes and risk factors more referenced on the four categories, the overall risk of falling and consequent injury gravity for that individual can be expected to be very high.
Physical consequences of falls and physiological effects
Falls among the elderly are associated with a large diversity and heterogeneity of undesired physical consequences, which can be more or less severe. Four main categories were considered for the physical consequences: fractures, bruises, injuries and “other” physical consequences. A fifth category was also defined, focused on the physiological effects associated to the physical consequences of falls.
Identification of references of physical consequences of falls and its physiological effects
Undifferentiated bone fractures
Trochanteric femoral fractures
Fractures in the trunk
Fractures of the upper limbs
Fracture of the humerus
Fractures in the chest
Bruises and abrasions
Bruises with blood loss
Soft tissue injuries
Injuries in the upper extremities
Traumatic brain injury
Injuries in wrists
Injuries in the lower extremities
Injuries in the elbow
Death or morbidity
Functional dependency and loss of autonomy
Loss of self-confidence
Loss of self-efficacy
The head bruises due to falls, with 10.3 % incidence, were the more referred physical consequence in the bruises category.
For the injuries category, the incidence of references in the literature is more homogeneous than in other categories. The most referenced injuries are soft tissues and the upper extremities, respectively with 6.8 and 5.7 % incidence. Injuries on the elbows are the ones that had the least incidence, namely 2.2 %.
For other consequences, lacerations with 8 % and dislocations with 5.7 % incidence were the most referenced in the literature. This category also included sprains, hematomas and pain, but these were identified in the literature to a smaller extent.
The physiological effects of elderly falls were also identified. The two effects with higher incidence of references were death and morbidity, with 21.8 %, and functional decline, with 20.6 %. Other still significant effects were inactivity, with 14.9 %, functional dependence and loss of autonomy, with 13.7 %, and depression, with 10.3 % incidence.
This analysis reveals a possible cause–effect relation between the different physiological effects. For example, depression can lead to higher functional dependence; in the same way, inactivity can lead to functional decline. On the other hand, the state of physical incapacity and functional dependence as a result of a fall can retract the ability to participate in everyday life activities and increase the chance of depression. These interrelations between causes will be further explored in future work.
Interventions for prevention, rehabilitation and minimization of falls
Many actions, strategies and mechanisms can—and have been—employed for the prevention, minimization and rehabilitation aspects of elderly falls. The different interventions can be categorised into three groups: the first group consists of physical interventions, the second of environmental interventions, and the third with behavioural interventions. For each of those, one can correspond them to the three stages associated with falls: the moment before the fall (interventions to prevent falls), the time during the fall (interventions to minimise the consequences of falls) and the moment after the fall (interventions related with the rehabilitation of the consequences of falls).
Identification of references and percentage of incidence, for physical, environmental and behavioural interventions for prevention, minimization and rehabilitation of falls in the elderly
Adjustment of medication
Protective coating systems can reduce hip fracture risk in the event of a fall.
Use of nutrition programmes (calcium and vitamin D)
Increase and maintain bone mass and strength through exercise
Vision interventions (cataract surgery)
Use of appropriate footwear
Changes in the home and public environment to reduce the risk of falling
Removal of obstacles in the household
Increased physical activity and exercise
Methods based on the rehabilitation gait training
Evaluation and management of risk factors for multiple falls
Evaluation of the people who have fallen or at risk of falling, to identify modifiable risk factors
Strategies to modify risk behaviours of the patient falling
Mechanisms that characterise the cognitive changes associated with ageing.
The physical interventions are those that represented the highest incidence: most notably, adjustment of medication with 18.3 % incidence, hip protection coating systems with 17.2 % incidence and the use of strengthening nutrition programmes with 11.4 % incidence.
The environmental interventions were those that exhibited the lowest incidence and were essentially limited to changes in the home and public environments to reduce the risk of fall, with 11.4 % incidence. Note also that the other intervention “removal of obstacles in the household” is directly related to the former.
Finally, in the behavioural interventions, the highest incidence, of 21.8 %, was found for carrying out activities and exercise. The use of rehabilitation methods based on gait training and management of risk factors of multiple falls, with an incidence of 14.9 and 10.3 %, respectively, were also relevant types of behavioural interventions.
In this review article, we have quantitatively characterised relevant research efforts on this issue of great social relevant over the last decade and a half, by identifying the incidence of articles concerning the anatomic characteristics and physiological consequences of ageing, the pathologies that propitiate falls, the causes and risk factors for falls, the physical consequences of falls and the strategies to prevent, minimise or rehabilitate.
This study will be useful both for those who want to identify key research issues and those who study ageing from the perspective of social sciences. In the future, repeating this study for the period of 2011–2025 will provide a historical time frame for analysis and comparison.
In subsequent work, we aim to study the economic impact of falls, from the individual and societal perspectives.
We acknowledge the Foundation for Science and Technology (FCT), Lisbon, through the 3º Quadro Comunitario de Apoio, the POCTI and FEDER programmes, project PEst-C/CTM/LA0025/2013, and FCT scholarship SFRH/PROTEC/67465/2010. Partial support has been provided by project PT21, no. 13848, co-financed by the European Community Fund through COMPETE Programa Operacional Factores de Competitividade. The financial sponsors played no role in the design, execution, analysis and interpretation of data or writing of the study.
Conflict of interest
The authors have no conflict of interest to disclose.
- 6.Canning C, Sherrington C, Lord S, Fung V, Close J, Latt M, Howard K, Allen N, O'Rourke S, Murray S (2009) Exercise therapy for prevention of falls in people with Parkinson's disease: a protocol for a randomised controlled trial and economic evaluation. BioMed Central Neurology. http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2377/9/4. Accessed Oct 2010
- 17.Easterbrook L, Horton K, Arber S, Davidson K (2001) International review of interventions in falls among older people. London: a report for the Health Development Agency, Department of Trade and Industry. http://www.viewcare.co.uk/Publications/fallsint.pdf. Accessed Sep 2010
- 18.Faes M, Reelick M, Melis R, Borm G, Esselink R, Olde M (2010) Multifactorial fall prevention for pairs of frail community-dwelling older fallers and their informal caregivers: a dead end for complex interventions in the frailest fallers. Journal of American Medical Directors Association 12(6):451–458CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- 19.Falls (2010) Geneva: World Health Organization, media centre, fact sheet no. 344, August. http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs344/en. Accessed Mar 2011
- 28.Hill A, Hill K, Brauer S, Oliver D, Hoffmann T, Beer C, Mcphail S, Haines T (2009) Evaluation of the effect of patient education on rates of falls in older hospital patients: description of a randomised controlled trial. BioMed Central Geriatrics. http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2318/9/14. Accessed Oct 2010
- 33.Kane RL, Ouslander JG, Abrass IB, Resnick B (2009) Essentials of clinical geriatrics, 6th edn. McGraw-Hill, New York, pp 265–295, Chapter 9Google Scholar
- 48.Mcclure R, Hughes K, Mckenzie K, Dietrich U, Vardon P, Davis E, Newman B (2010) The population approach to falls injury prevention in older people: findings of two community trial. BMC Public Health. http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2458/10/79. Accessed Jan 2011
- 51.Michael Y, Lin J, Whitlock E, Gold R, Fu R, O'Connor E, Zuber S, Beil T, Lutz K (2010) Interventions to prevent falls in older adults. Evidence Syntheses, no. 80Google Scholar
- 53.Moyland K, Binder E (2007) Falls in older adults: risk assessment, management and prevention. Am J Med 120:493–497Google Scholar
- 72.Stevens J, Sogolow E (2008) Preventing falls: what works. National Center for Injury Prevention and Control, Atlanta. http://www.cdc.gov/ncipc/preventingfalls. Accessed Jan 2011
- 73.Sturnieks D, Tiedemann A (2008) Falls. International Encyclopedia of Public Health, pp 563-569Google Scholar
- 84.World Health Organization (2007) WHO global report on falls prevention in older age. World Health Organization, Geneva. http://www.who.int/entity/ageing/publications/Falls_prevention7March.pdf. Accessed Mar 2011