Frontiers of Philosophy in China

, Volume 3, Issue 4, pp 558–576 | Cite as

The tradition of the virtue of qian and its contemporary fate

Research Article


The virtue of qian, one of the traditional Chinese virtues, usually refers to humbleness, humility and modesty. Ancient thinkers in China not only expounded on the meaning and basis of qian, but also argued for its value. It was usually thought that the value of qian rested in its ability to cultivate virtue, promote scholarship, get along with people, and maintain enterprises. Ancient thinkers in China placed so much emphasis on the virtue of qian that there was a tendency to overemphasize qian. There is also a tradition of qian in the West, which is less likely to become excessive compared to that in the East. Presently, Chinese society is transitioning into a modern society, but the virtue of qian still has value. While continuing to embrace its traditional essence, we should adopt useful aspects from the Western concept of qian to reshape the virtue of qian so that it conforms to modern Chinese society.


virtue of qian virtue traditional morality 


作为中国传统德性之一的 “谦” 德, 一般指谦톷、 谦놰和谦虚。 中国古代思想家不仅阐述了 “谦” 的含义和根据, 而且还论证了 “谦” 的价值。 一般认为, “谦” 的价值在于其有益于修德、 为学、 待人和持业。 中国古代思想家特别重视 “谦” 德, 以至于出现了某种过谦的倾向。 西方亦有 “谦” 的传统, 不过与中国古代的 “谦” 德相比, 西方的 “谦” 德不易走向极端化。 当代中国社会虽然正在向现代性社会转型, 但 “谦” 德仍然有其价值。 我们应当在接续传统精华的同时, 吸取西方 “谦” 德的有益成分, 以重塑适应当代中国社会的 “谦” 德。


“谦” 德 德性 传统道德 


Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.


  1. Aristotle (1984). Nicomachean Ethics. In: Hippocrates G. Apostle (translation with commentaries and glossary), Aristotle’s Nicomachean Ethics. Grimell, Lome: The Peripatetic PressGoogle Scholar
  2. Augustine, A. (1963). Confessiones (Chinese edition), Vol. 1, Section 4, translated by Zhou Shiliang. Beijing: Shangwu YinshuguanGoogle Scholar
  3. Chen Lu (1927). Shan you wen 善폕컄 (Persuasive Essays). Shanghai: Shangwu YinshuguanGoogle Scholar
  4. Cheng Hao, Cheng Yi (2004). Er Cheng ji 뛾돌벯 (The Collected Works of Cheng Hao and Cheng Yi). Beijing: Zhonghua ShujuGoogle Scholar
  5. Comte-Sponville, A. (1997). Petit Traite Des Grandes Vertus (Chinese edition), translated by Wu Yuetian. Beijing: Zhongyang Bianyi ChubansheGoogle Scholar
  6. Confucius (1980). Lunyu 싛폯 (Analects). In: Ruan Yuan, ed. Shisan jing zhushu 쪮죽뺭힢쫨 (Comments to the Thirteen Classics). Beijing: Zhonghua ShujuGoogle Scholar
  7. Driver, J. (1999). Modesty and Ignorance. Ethics 109, No. 4Google Scholar
  8. Ge Hong (1955). Baopuzi 놧웓子 (The Works of Ge Hong). Guiyang: Guizhou Renmin ChubansheGoogle Scholar
  9. Xie Haofan (1996). Guanzi quanyi 맜子좫틫 (Interpretation of Guanzi). Guiyang: Guizhou Renmin ChubansheGoogle Scholar
  10. Han Ying (2005). Hanshi waizhuan jishi 몫쪫췢뒫벯쫍 (The Collected Interpretation of Han Ying’s Biographical Commentaries to The Book of Songs). Beijing: Zhonghua ShujuGoogle Scholar
  11. Hu Daoyuan. Chong qianrang 돧잫죃 (The value of self-effacement). In: Zhijia liangyan huibian 훎볒솼퇔믣뇠 (Compiled Proverbs for the Governance of Households)Google Scholar
  12. Huang Shouqi, Zhang Shanwen (1989). Zhouyi yizhu 훜틗틫힢 (Translation and Commentaries of The Book of Changes). Shanghai: Shanghai Guiji ChubansheGoogle Scholar
  13. Hu Yijia (1986). Zhouyi benyi fulu zuanshu 훜틗놾틥뢽슼纂쫨 (Detailed Records for the Compilation of Appendixes for the Proper Meaning of The Book of Changes). Taipei: Shijie ShujuGoogle Scholar
  14. Kangxi (1994). Tingxun geyan 춥통룱퇔 (Maxims for Household Teaching). Zhengzhou: Zhongzhou Guji ChubansheGoogle Scholar
  15. Kant, I. (1987). Anthropology from a Pragmatic Point of View (Chinese edition), translated by Deng Xiaomang. Chongqing: Chongqing ChubansheGoogle Scholar
  16. Kant, I. (2003). Critique of Practical Reason (Chinese edition), translated by Deng Xiaomang. Beijing: Renmin ChubansheGoogle Scholar
  17. Kong Yingda (2004). Zhouyi zhengyi 훜틗헽틥 (Proper Commentaries of the Book of Changes). Beijing: Jiuzhou ChubansheGoogle Scholar
  18. Laozi (2006). Daode jing 뗀뗂뺭 (The Dao and Its Virtues). Changchun: Jilin Wenshi ChubansheGoogle Scholar
  19. Ling Geng (2002). Wang Chang zhuan 췵昶뒫 (Biography of Wang Chang). Shanghai: Xuelin ChubansheGoogle Scholar
  20. Lu Jiuyuan (1980). Lu Jiuyuan ji 슽뻅풨벯 (Collected Works of Lu Jiuyuan). Beijing: Zhonghua ShujuGoogle Scholar
  21. Luo Guojie, Song Xiren (1985). Xifang lunli sxiang shi 컷랽싗샭쮼쿫쪷 (History of Western Ethics). Beijing: Zhongguo Renmin Daxue ChubansheGoogle Scholar
  22. Lü Buwei (2008). Shi jun lan 쫑뻽샀 (Review on Arrogant Monarchs). In: Lüshi Chunqiu 싀쫏뒺쟯 (Springs and Autumns of Lü Buwei). Huhehaote: Neimenggu Renmin ChubansheGoogle Scholar
  23. MacIntyre, A. (1995). After Virtue (Chinese edition), translated by Gong Qun. Beijing: Zhongguo Shehui Kexue ChubansheGoogle Scholar
  24. Nan Huaijin, Xu Qingting (1988). Baihua Yijing 냗뮰틗뺭 (Modern Chinese Version of the Book of Changes). Changsha: Yuelu ShusheGoogle Scholar
  25. Pang Shangpeng (1831). Duan hao shang 뛋뫃짐 (Valued Civility and Etiquettes). In: Pang shi jiaxun 엓쫏볒통 (Pang Shangpeng’s Household Instruction)Google Scholar
  26. Paulsen, F. (1988). A System of Ethics (Chinese editon), translated by He Huaihong and Liao Shenbai. Beijing: Zhongguo Shehui Kexue ChubansheGoogle Scholar
  27. Schueler, G. F. (1999). Why Is Modesty a Virtue?. Ethics 109, No. 4Google Scholar
  28. Smith, A. (1998). The Theory of Moral Sentiments (Chinese edition), translated by Jiang Ziqiang et al. Beijing: Shangwu YinshuguanGoogle Scholar
  29. Spinoza, B. (1983). The Ethics (Chinese edition), translated by He Lin. Beijing: Shangwu YinshuguanGoogle Scholar
  30. Sun Qifeng (1984). Xiao you tang jiaxun 킢폑쳃볒통 (Household Instruction for Filial Piety and Friendliness). Beijing: Zhonghua ShujuGoogle Scholar
  31. Tang Zhen (1955). Qianshu 잱쫩 (Unpopular Book). Beijing: Zhonghua ShujuGoogle Scholar
  32. Wang Shishun (1982). Shangshu shizhu 짐쫩쫍힢 (The Annotation and Interpretation of Shangshu). Chengdou: Sichun Renmin ChubansheGoogle Scholar
  33. Wang Shouren (1940). Wang Wenchenggong quanshu 췵컄돉릫좫쫩 (Collected Works of Wang Yangming). Shanghai: Shanghai Shangwu YinshuguanGoogle Scholar
  34. Wang Yangming (2004). Chuanxi lu 뒫쾰슼 (Records of Confucian Transmission and Practices). Changsha: Yuelu ShusheGoogle Scholar
  35. Wu Jing (2006). Zhenguan zhengyao 헪맛헾튪 (Primary Political Affairs of the Zhenguan Reign). Beijing: Xinhua ChubansheGoogle Scholar
  36. Xunzi (2007). Xunzi 荀子 (The Works of Xunzi). Beijing: Yanshan ChubansheGoogle Scholar
  37. Zhang Shizai (1989). Kezi suibi chao 뿎子쯦뇊뎭 (Transcribed Essays in Teaching Sons). Taibei: Xin Wen Feng Chuban GongsiGoogle Scholar
  38. Zhou Fucheng (1964). Xifang lunlixue mingzhu xuanji 컷랽싗샭톧쏻훸톡벭 (Selection of Western Ethical Masterpieces). Beijing: Shangwu YinshuguanGoogle Scholar
  39. Zhu Xi (1936). Zhuzi wenji 훬子컄벯 (Collected Works of Zhu Xi). Beijing: Shangwu YinshuguanGoogle Scholar
  40. Zhu Xi (1990). Zhuzi yulei 훬子폯샠 (Topically Arranged Conversations of Master Zhu). Beijing: Zhonghua ShujuGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Higher Education Press and Springer-Verlag GmbH 2008

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Politics and Public Governance DepartmentSuzhou Technology InstituteSuzhouChina

Personalised recommendations