The conditional performance of US mutual funds over different market regimes: do different types of ethical screens matter?
- 504 Downloads
We investigate the performance of US mutual funds that employ different ethical criteria: religious, socially responsible, and irresponsible. Performance is evaluated over different market regimes using a Markov-switching conditional CAPM approach that endogenously defines different states of the market. This model is also extended to a multifactor context. The results show that estimates of performance vary across different market regimes. The Vice Fund, which invests in unethical firms, outperforms in low-volatility regimes, but underperforms in high-volatility regimes. These results contradict the Vice Fund’s claim that it constitutes a “solid investment during recessionary periods”. Our results show that socially responsible and morally responsible funds exhibit different performance across different market conditions, thereby supporting the use of performance evaluation models that take into account different market regimes. Overall, different types of ethical screens seem to lead to different performance patterns across different market regimes.
KeywordsSocially responsible mutual funds Vice fund Fund performance evaluation Market regimes Markov-switching conditional models
JEL ClassificationG10 G11 M14
We thank Markus M. Schmid (the editor) and an anonymous referee, as well as participants at the PFN 2010 and EFMA 2011 conferences, for valuable comments and suggestions.
- Boasson, E., Boasson, V., Cheng, J.: Investment principles and strategies of faith-based funds. Manag. Fin. 32, 837–845 (2006)Google Scholar
- Capelle-Blancard, G., Monjon, S.: The performance of socially responsible funds: does the screening process matter?. Eur. Financ. Manag. (2013) (forthcoming)Google Scholar
- Ferson, W., Qian, M.: Conditional performance evaluation revised. Research Foundation Monograph of the CFA Institute (2004).Google Scholar
- Hoepner, A., Zeume, S.: The dark enemy of responsible mutual funds: does the Vice Fund offer more financial virtue? SSRN eLibrary (2009)Google Scholar
- Huimin, L., Kong, C.A.W., Eduardo, R.: Socially responsible investment in good and bad times. Int. Res. J. Financ. Econ. 54, 152–165 (2010)Google Scholar
- Statman, M.: Socially responsible investments. J. Invest. Consult. 8, 17–37 (2007)Google Scholar
- Sun, Z., Wang, A., Zheng, L.: Do active funds perform better in down markets? New evidence from cross-sectional study. Working Paper, SSRN eLibrary (2009)Google Scholar
- Wang, X.: On time varying mutual fund performance. University of Toronto, Working paper, Rotman School of Management (2009)Google Scholar