Advertisement

Philosophia

, Volume 47, Issue 4, pp 959–976 | Cite as

Why Aren’t More Philosophers Interested in Freud? Re-Evaluating Philosophical Arguments against Psychoanalysis

  • Michael T. MichaelEmail author
Article
  • 219 Downloads

Abstract

Despite its profound influence on modern thought, psychoanalysis remains peripheral to the concerns of most analytic philosophers. I suggest that one of the main reasons for this is intellectual reservation, and explore some philosophical arguments against psychoanalysis that may be contributing to such reservation. Specifically, I address the objections that psychoanalytic theories are unfalsifiable, that the purported findings of psychoanalysis are readily explained as due to suggestion, that there is a troubling lack of consensus in psychoanalytic interpretation, and that there is a lack of support for psychoanalysis within mainstream science. I also consider a major obstacle to the acceptance of contemporary defenses of psychoanalysis: the “bad lot” argument against Inference to the Best Explanation. My conclusion is that, though these objections have some merit, they are not sufficient reasons for not taking psychoanalytic ideas seriously.

Keywords

Psychoanalysis Falsifiability Suggestion Inference to the best explanation The bad lot argument 

References

  1. Andersen, S. M., & Glassman, N. S. (1996). Responding to significant others when they are not there: Effects on interpersonal inference, motivation, and affect. In R. M. Sorrentino & E. T. Higgins (Eds.), Handbook of motivation and cognition (Vol. 3, pp. 262–321). New York: Guildford.Google Scholar
  2. Andersen, S. M., & Przybylinski, E. (2012). Experiments on transference in interpersonal relations: Implications for treatment. Psychotherapy, 49, 370–383.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Anderson, M. C., & Green, C. (2001). Suppressing unwanted memories by executive control. Nature, 410, 366–369.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Anderson, M. C., & Levy, B. J. (2006). Encouraging the nascent cognitive neuroscience of repression. Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 29(5), 511–513.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Anderson, M. C., & Levy, B. J. (2009). Suppressing unwanted memories. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 18(4), 189–194.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Anderson, M. C., Ochsner, K. N., Kuhl, B., Cooper, J., Robertson, E., Gabrieli, S. W., Glover, G. H., & Gabrieli, J. D. (2004). Neural systems underlying the suppression of unwanted memories. Science, 303(5655), 232–235.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Aybek, S., Nicholson, T. R., Zelaya, F., O’Daly, O. G., Craig, T. J., David, A. S., & Kanaan, R. A. (2014). Neural correlates of recall of life events in conversion disorder. JAMA Psychiatry, 71(1), 52–60.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Baker, V. R. (2014). Terrestrial analogs, planetary geology, and the nature of geological reasoning. Planetary and Space Science, 95, 5–10.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Berk, M. S., & Andersen, S. M. (2000). The impact of past relationships on interpersonal behavior: Behavioral confirmation in the social–cognitive process of transference. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 79(4), 546–562.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Carhart-Harris, R. L., & Friston, K. J. (2010). The default-mode, ego-functions and free-energy: A neurobiological account of Freudian ideas. Brain: A Journal of Neurology, 133(4), 1265–1283.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Colace, C. (2010). Children's dreams: From Freud's observations to modern dream research. London: Karnac Books.Google Scholar
  12. Colace, C. (2014). Drug dreams: Clinical and research implications of dreams about drugs in drug-addicted patients. London: Karnac Books.Google Scholar
  13. Dawes, G. W. (2013). Belief is not the issue: A Defence of inference to the best explanation. Ratio, 26(1), 62–78.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Douven I. (2017). Abduction. In E. N. Zalta (Ed.), The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (summer 2017 edition). https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/sum2017/entries/abduction/.
  15. Edelson, M. (1985). The hermeneutic turn and the single case study in psychoanalysis. Psychoanalysis & Contemporary Thought, 8(4), 567–614.Google Scholar
  16. Epstein, M. (2013). Thoughts without a thinker: Psychotherapy from a Buddhist perspective. Basic Books.Google Scholar
  17. Erwin, E. (1996). A final accounting: Philosophical and empirical issues in Freudian psychology. MIT Press.Google Scholar
  18. Fosshage, J. L., & Loew, C. A. (Eds.). (1987). Dream interpretation: A comparative study (2nd ed.). New York: PMA Publishing Corp.Google Scholar
  19. Foulkes, D. (1982). Children's dreams: Longitudinal studies. New York: Wiley.Google Scholar
  20. Freud, S. (2001a). Fragment of an analysis of a case of hysteria. In J. Strachey (Ed. and Trans.), The standard edition of the complete psychological works of Sigmund Freud (Vol. 7, pp. 1 - 122). London: Vintage. (Original work published 1905)Google Scholar
  21. Freud, S. (2001b). Introductory lectures on psycho-analysis (Part II). In J. Strachey (Ed. and Trans.), The standard edition of the complete psychological works of Sigmund Freud (Vol. 15). London: Vintage. (Original work published 1916)Google Scholar
  22. Frodeman, R. (1995). Geological reasoning: Geology as an interpretive and historical science. Geological Society of America Bulletin, 107(8), 960–968.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Gardner, S. (1993). Irrationality and the philosophy of psychoanalysis. Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
  24. Gillies, D. (1998). The Duhem thesis and the quine thesis. In M. Curd & J. A. Cover (Eds.), Philosophy of science: The central issues (pp. 302–319). New York: Norton.Google Scholar
  25. Grayling, A. C. (2002). Scientist or storyteller. The Guardian. 22 June 2002. https://www.theguardian.com/books/2002/jun/22/socialsciences.gender.
  26. Grünbaum, A. (2005). Critique of psychoanalysis. In L. Gomez (Ed.), The Freud wars: An introduction to the philosophy of psychoanalysis (pp. 109–137). London & New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
  27. Grünbaum, A. (2006). Is Sigmund Freud’s psychoanalytic edifice relevant to the 21st century? Psychoanalytic Psychology, 23(2), 257–284.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Hansson, S. O. (2017). Science and pseudo-science. In E. N. Zalta (Ed.), The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (summer 2017 edition). https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/sum2017/entries/pseudo-science/.
  29. Harman, G. H. (1965). The inference to the best explanation. The Philosophical Review, 74(1), 88–95.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Hassa, T., Sebastian, A., Liepert, J., Weiller, C., Schmidt, R., & Tüscher, O. (2017). Symptom-specific amygdala hyperactivity modulates motor control network in conversion disorder. NeuroImage: Clinical, 15, 143–150.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Hopkins, J. (1982). Introduction: Philosophy and psychoanalysis. In R. Wollheim & J. Hopkins (Eds.), Philosophical Essays on Freud (pp. vii-xlvi). Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
  32. Hopkins, J. (1988). Epistemology and depth psychology: Critical notes on The Foundations of Psychoanalysis. In P. Clark & C. Wright (Eds.), Mind, psychoanalysis and science (pp. 33–60). Oxford: Blackwell.Google Scholar
  33. Hopkins, J. (2013). Psychoanalysis, philosophical issues. In B. Kaldis (Ed.), Encyclopedia of philosophy and the social sciences (pp. 769–771). Los Angeles: Sage Publishers.Google Scholar
  34. Jones, E. (1957). Sigmund Freud: Life and work, vol. 3, The last phase 1919-1939 . London: Hogarth Press.Google Scholar
  35. Kächele, H., Joseph S., Helmut T., & The Ulm Psychoanalytic Process Research Study Group. (2009). From psychoanalytic narrative to empirical single case research: Implications for psychoanalytic practice. New York and London: Routledge.Google Scholar
  36. Kahn, C. H. (1987). Plato’s theory of desire. The Review of Metaphysics, 41, 77–103.Google Scholar
  37. Kanaan, R. A., Craig, T. K., Wessely, S. C., & David, A. S. (2007). Imaging repressed memories in motor conversion disorder. Psychosomatic Medicine, 69(2), 202–205.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Kikuchi, H., Fujii, T., Abe, N., Suzuki, M., Takagi, M., Mugikura, S., Takahashi, S., & Mori, E. (2010). Memory repression: Brain mechanisms underlying dissociative amnesia. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience, 22(3), 602–613.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Lacewing, M. (2013). The problem of suggestion in psychoanalysis: An analysis and solution. Philosophical Psychology, 26(5), 718–743.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Lambert, A. J., Good, K. S., & Kirk, I. J. (2010). Testing the repression hypothesis: Effects of emotional valence on memory suppression in the think–no think task. Consciousness and Cognition, 19(1), 281–293.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Lipton, P. (1993). Is the best good enough? Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, 93, 89–104.Google Scholar
  42. Lipton, P. (2004). Inference to the best explanation. London & New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
  43. Lynch, K. (2014). The vagaries of psychoanalytic interpretation: An investigation into the causes of the consensus problem in psychoanalysis. Philosophia, 42(3), 779–799.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Manson, N. C. (2003). Freud's own blend: Functional analysis, idiographic explanation, and the extension of ordinary psychology. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, 103(1), 179–195.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Mele, A. R. (2014). Free: Why science hasn't disproved free will. Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  46. Michael, M. T. (2008). On the validity of Freud's dream interpretations. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences, 39(1), 52–64Google Scholar
  47. Michael, M. T. (2015). Freud's theory of dreams: A philosophico-scientific perspective. Rowman & Littlefield.Google Scholar
  48. Michael, M. T. (2018). The case for the Freud-Breuer theory of hysteria: A response to Grünbaum’s foundational objection to psychoanalysis. The International Journal of Psychoanalysis.  https://doi.org/10.1080/00207578.2018.1489705.
  49. Midgley, N. (2006). The ‘inseparable bond between cure and research’: Clinical case study as a method of psychoanalytic inquiry. Journal of Child Psychotherapy, 32(2), 122–147.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Milton, J., Polmear, C., & Fabricius, J. (2011). A short introduction to psychoanalysis. Sage.Google Scholar
  51. Nicholson, T., Aybek, S., Craig, T., Harris, T., Wojcik, W., David, A., & Kanaan, R. (2016). Life events and escape in conversion disorder. Psychological Medicine, 46(12), 2617–2626.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Popper, K. (1963). Conjectures and refutations: The growth of scientific knowledge. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
  53. Popper, K. (1983). Realism and the Aim of Science: From the Postscript to the Logic of Scientific Discovery, ed. W. W. Bartley, III. London and New York: Routledge. Citations refer to the 2005 printing of the paperback edition.Google Scholar
  54. Popper, K. (2002). Unended quest: An intellectual autobiography. London: Routledge. Citations refer to the 2010 printing.Google Scholar
  55. Puett, M., & Gross-Loh, C. (2016). The path: What Chinese philosophers can teach us about the good life. Simon and Schuster.Google Scholar
  56. Putnam, H. (1974). The corroboration of theories. In P. A. Schilpp (Ed.), The philosophy of Karl popper (Vol. 1). La Salle, Illinois: Open Court.Google Scholar
  57. Resnick, J., Stickgold, R., Rittenhouse, C. D., & Hobson, J. A. (1994). Self-representation and bizarreness in children’s dream reports collected in the home setting. Consciousness and Cognition, 3(1), 30–45.Google Scholar
  58. Rhee, D. (1990). The Tao, psychoanalysis and existential thought. Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics, 53(1–4), 21–27.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Rorty, A. (1996). The two faces of stoicism: Rousseau and Freud. Journal of the History of Philosophy, 34(3), 335–356.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Ruse, M. (1999). The Darwinian revolution: Science red in tooth and claw. University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
  61. Ryckman, N. A., Addis, D. R., Latham, A. J., & Lambert, A. J. (2018). Forget about the future: Effects of thought suppression on memory for imaginary emotional episodes. Cognition and Emotion, 32(1), 200–206.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. Seligman, A. B., Weller, R. P., Puett, M., & Simon, B. (2008). Ritual and its consequences: An essay on the limits of sincerity. Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  63. Shedler, J. (2001). A new language for psychoanalytic diagnosis. Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association, 50(2), 429–456.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  64. Shedler, J., & Westen, D. (1998). Refining the measurement of Axis II: A Q-sort procedure for assessing personality pathology. Assessment, 5(4), 333–353.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  65. Sherman, N. (2000). Is the ghost of Aristotle haunting Freud's house? Proceedings of the Boston Area Colloquium in Ancient Philosophy, Volume 16, eds. J. J. Cleary & G. M. Gurtler.Google Scholar
  66. Solms, M. (1995). New findings on the neurological organization of dreaming: Implications for psychoanalysis. The Psychoanalytic Quarterly, 64, 43–67.Google Scholar
  67. Solms, M. (2000). Dreaming and REM sleep are controlled by different brain mechanisms. Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 23(6), 793–1121.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  68. Solms, M., & Turnbull, O. (2002). The brain and the inner world. New York: Other Press.Google Scholar
  69. Thagard, P. (1993). Computational philosophy of science. MIT press.Google Scholar
  70. Turri, M. G. (2015). Transference and katharsis, Freud to Aristotle. The International Journal of Psychoanalysis, 96(2), 369–387.Google Scholar
  71. Van Fraassen, B. C. (1980). The scientific image. Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  72. Van Fraassen, B. C. (1989). Laws and symmetry. Clarendon.Google Scholar
  73. Waldron, W. S. (2008). A Buddhist theory of unconscious mind (ālaya-vijñāna). In K. Rao, A. C. Paranjpe, & A. Dalal (Eds.), Handbook of Indian psychology. Cambridge University Press India/Foundation Books.Google Scholar
  74. Westen, D. (1998). The scientific legacy of Sigmund Freud: Toward a psychodynamically informed psychological science. Psychological Bulletin, 124(3), 333–371.Google Scholar
  75. Wollheim, R. (1981). Sigmund Freud. Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
  76. Yahalom, J. (2014). Freud and epicurean philosophy: Revisiting drive theory. Contemporary Psychoanalysis, 50(3), 395–417.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Nature B.V. 2018

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Underwood International CollegeYonsei UniversitySeoulRepublic of Korea

Personalised recommendations