What is Wrong with “What is Wrong with Rational Suicide”
- 615 Downloads
In “What is Wrong with Rational Suicide,” Pilpel and Amsel develop a counterexample that allegedly confounds attempts to condition the moral permissibility of suicide on its rationality. In this counterexample, a healthy middle aged woman with significant life accomplishments, but no dependents, disease, or mental disorder opts to end her life painlessly after reading philosophical texts that persuade her that life is meaningless and bereft of intrinsic value. Many people would judge her suicide “a bad mistake” despite its meeting “robust” conditions for rationality. Hence, Pilpel and Amsel conclude, even robust conditions for the rationality of suicide “fail to do their job: to exclude intuitively unacceptable suicides from being permissible.” I argue here that this counterexample fails to cast doubt on philosophical attempts to account for the moral permissibility of suicide in terms of its rationality.
KeywordsSuicide Rationality Right to die Autonomy
- Battin, M. (1995). The death debate: Ethical issues in suicide. New York: Prentice-Hall.Google Scholar
- Brandt, R. (1992). The morality and rationality of suicide. In his Morality, utilitarianism, and rights (pp. 315–335). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
- Hill, T. E. (1991). Self-regarding suicide: A modified Kantian view. In his Autonomy and self- respect (pp. 85–103). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
- Kamm, F. M. (1997). A right to choose death? Boston review (available at: http://bostonreview.net/BR22.3/Kamm.html).
- Lebacqz, K., & Engelhardt, H. T. (1980). Suicide. In D. J. Horan & D. Mall (Eds.), Death, dying, and euthanasia. Frederick: Praeger.Google Scholar
- Luper, S. (2009). Philosophy of death. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
- Mill, J. S. (1869). On liberty. Google Scholar
- Nozick R. et al. (1997). Assisted suicide: The philosophers’ brief. New York review of books (available at: http://www.nybooks.com/articles/archives/1997/mar/27/assisted-suicide-the-philosophers-brief/).
- Quinn, W. (1993). Morality and action. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
- Velleman, J. D. (1992). Against the right to die. The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy, 17, 665–681.Google Scholar