The use of sewage sludge as soil amendment. The need for an ecotoxicological evaluation
- 564 Downloads
Background, aim, and scope
Sewage sludge use in agriculture should be limited by the presence of metals and other persistent environmental pollutants. The present study aims to contribute for the definition of a test battery of ecotoxicological assays that allows a proper ecotoxicological characterization of sludges, providing information on their potential hazard and identified “safe” application levels.
Materials and methods
Three sludges from distinct sources (urban, olive-processing, and electroplating industries) were tested using avoidance and reproduction tests with earthworms (Eisenia andrei) and springtails (Folsomia candida) and plant growth tests with turnips (Brassica rapa) and oats (Avena sativa). Different soil–sludge mixture concentrations mimicking recommended/realistic field dosages were tested.
Only the sludge from the electroplating industry induced an avoidance response from the earthworms (EC50 = 0.4 t/ha) and collembolans (no observed effect concentration (NOEC) = 15 t/ha). This sludge was the only sludge responsible for any effect on the reproductive output of the earthworms (EC50 = 7.74 t/ha). Regarding collembolans, none of the sludges tested caused any significant decrease in reproduction. In higher plant tests, the two industrial sludges were toxic, causing a decrease growth in both species. The EC20 values determined for B. rapa were 20.3 and 24.2 t/ha and for A. sativa 14.7 and 16.2 t/ha for sludges from olive-processing and electroplating industries, respectively.
The metal loadings of the different test sludges could partially explain the results obtained. The toxicity of the test sludge from electroplating industry observed on the tested invertebrates and plants could be explained by the high amount of total chromium from which 22.3% was in the most toxic oxidation state—Cr(VI). However, the toxicity caused by the sludge from the olive-processing industry in the test plants could be attributed to the presence of other compounds (not measured in this study) since the metal content was not high enough to induce such an effect. The absence of toxicity showed by the urban test sludge was in agreement with its low levels of metals.
The response of the different test organisms and end points varied according to the sludge type. The urban sludge was non-toxic whereas the sludge from the electroplating industry caused a toxic effect on almost all parameters measured (avoidance behavior of both test organisms, reproduction of earthworms, and growth of both plant species). Sludge from the olive-processing industry only caused a toxic effect on growth of both plant species. By analyzing the sensitivity of the different parameters for the most toxic sludge, it was found that avoidance and reproduction were more sensitive than plant growth, whereas plant seed germination was not sensitive at all.
Recommendations and perspectives
The ecotoxicological evaluation of wastes can be used as an environmental safety control of sludge use in agriculture. A tiered approach could be adopted for this purpose, incorporating avoidance tests in the first tier (screening level) and reproduction and plant growth tests in a second tier. But more evidence aiming to define the most suitable ecotoxicological test battery for specific sludges with a different contamination profile is still needed.
KeywordsAvoidance tests Higher plant growth tests Reproduction tests Sludge characterization Test battery
We would like to thank “Centro Técnico de Gestão Industrial” and “Direcção Regional de Agricultura da Beira Litoral” for the sludges and natural soil supplies, respectively. Special thanks to C. A. M. van Gestel for his valuable reviews. Thanks also to A. Allweier for English corrections.
- Bruce L, McCracken DI, Foster GN, Aitken MN (1999) The effect of sewage sludge on grassland euedaphic and hemiedaphic collembolan populations. Pedobiologia 43:209–220Google Scholar
- Elvira C, Sampedro L, Nogales R (1999) Suitability of sludges from dairy and paper industries for growth and reproduction of Eisenia andrei. Pedobiologia 43:766–770Google Scholar
- Environmental Canada (2002) Biological test methods for measuring the toxicity of contaminated soil to earthworms (Eisenia sp. or Lumbricus terrestris) (December 2002 Draft). Environmental Protection Series Biological Test Methods. Method Development and Applications Section. Reports EPS 1/RM/. Environmental Technology Centre, Environment Canada, Ottawa, OntarioGoogle Scholar
- Environmental Canada (2004) Biological Test Methods for Measuring the Survival and Reproduction of Springtails Exposed to Contaminants in Soil. (June 2004 Draft). Environmental Protection Series Biological Test Methods. Method Development and Applications Section. Reports EPS 1/RM/47. Environmental Technology Centre, Environment Canada, Ottawa, OntarioGoogle Scholar
- European Community (1986) Directive 86/278/EEC: Council Directive of 12 June 1986 on the protection of the environment, and in particular of the soil, when sewage sludge is used in agricultureGoogle Scholar
- European Community (1991) Council Directive 91/689/EEC of 12 December 1991 on hazardous waste. Off. J. Eur. Communities. L. Legis 1991; 377, 0020–0027 [31/12/1991]Google Scholar
- European Community (2001) Commission Decision 2001/118/EC of 16 January 2001 amending Decision 2000/532/EC as regards the list of wastes. Off. J. Eur. Communities. L. Legis. 2001a; 47, 0001-31 [16/2/2001]Google Scholar
- ISO (1994a) Soil quality—determination of effective cation exchange capacity and base saturation level using barium chloride solution. ISO 11260. International Organization for Standardization, GenevaGoogle Scholar
- ISO (1994b) Soil quality—determination of the effects of pollutants on soil flora. Effects of chemicals on the emergence and growth of higher plants. ISO 11269-2. International Organization for Standardization, GenevaGoogle Scholar
- ISO (1996) Soil quality—effects of pollutants on earthworms (Eisenia fetida), part 2–determination of effects on reproduction. ISO 11268-2. International Organization for Standardization, GenevaGoogle Scholar
- ISO (1999) Soil quality—inhibition of reproduction of Collembola (Folsomia candida) by soil pollutants. ISO 11267. International Organization for Standardization, GenevaGoogle Scholar
- ISO (2007a) Soil quality—avoidance test for testing the quality of soils and effects of chemicals on behaviour—test with earthworms (Eisenia fetida and Eisenia andrei). ISO Draft 17512-1. International Organization for Standardization, GenevaGoogle Scholar
- ISO (2007b) Soil quality — avoidance test for testing the quality of soils and effects of chemicals—part 2: test with collembolans (Folsomia candida). ISO Draft 17512-1. International Organization for Standardization, GenevaGoogle Scholar
- LNEC (1970) Solos—Análise granulométrica por peneiração húmida. LNEC-E 239. Laboratório Nacional de Enmgenharia Civil, LisbonGoogle Scholar
- Lubben B (1989) Influence of sewage sludge and heavy metals on the abundance of Collembola on two agricultural soils. In 3rd International Seminar on Apterygota 419–428Google Scholar
- Molnár L, Fischer E, Kállay M (1989) Laboratory studies on the effect, uptake and distribution of chromium in Eisenia fetida (Annelida, Oligochaeta). Zoo Anz 223:57–66Google Scholar
- Redborg KE, Hinesly TD, Ziegler EL (1983) Rearing Psychoda alternata (Diptera: Psychodidae) in the laboratory on digested sewage sludge with some observations on its biology. Environ Entomol 12:412–415Google Scholar
- Sachs L (2002) Angewandte Statistik: Anwendung statistischer Methoden. Springer, HeidelbergGoogle Scholar
- Sørensen PB, Carlsen L, Vikelsøe J, Rasmussen AG (2001) Modelling analysis of sewage sludge amended soil. NERI technical report. no.361. National Environmental Research Institute, Roskilde, p 40Google Scholar
- Spurgeon DJ, Hopkin SP (1996) Effects of variations of the organic matter content and pH of soil on the availability and toxicity of zinc to the earthworm Eisenia fetida. Pedobiologia 40:80–96Google Scholar
- Spurgeon DJ, Hopkin SP, Jones DT (1994) Effects of cadmium, copper, lead and zinc on growth, reproduction and survival of the earthworms Eisenia fetida (Savigny): assessing the environmental impact of point-source metal contamination in terrestrial ecosystems. Environ Poll 84:12–130CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- USEPA (1986) Mercury in solid or semisolid waste (manual cold-vapor technique). Method 7471A. United States Environmental Protection Agency, SpringfieldGoogle Scholar
- USEPA (1994) Determination of trace elements in waters and wastes by inductively coupled plasma–mass spectrometry. Method 200.8. United States Environmental Protection Agency, CincinnatiGoogle Scholar
- USEPA (2001) Determination of metals and trace elements in water and wastes by inductively coupled plasma-atomic emission spectrometry. Method 200.7. United States Environmental Protection Agency, CincinnatiGoogle Scholar
- USEPA (2005) SW846. Test methods for evaluating solid waste, physical/chemical methods. Method 6020A. United States Environmental Protection Agency, SpringfieldGoogle Scholar
- Van Gestel CAM, Van Breemen EMD, Baerselman R (1993) Accumulation and elimination of cadmium, chromium and zinc and effects on growth and reproduction in Eisenia andrei (Oligochaeta, Annelida). Sci Total Environ (Suppl) 585–597Google Scholar
- Vikelsøe J, Thomsen M, Carlsen L, Johansen E (2002) Persistent organic pollutants in soil, sludge and sediment. A multianalytical field study of selected organic chlorinated and brominated compounds. NERI technical report no. 402. National Environmental Research Institute, Denmark, p 100Google Scholar
- Zar JH (1998) Biostatistical analysis. Hall International, LondonGoogle Scholar