Soil and sediment quality and composition as factors in the distribution of damage at the December 26, 2003, Bam area earthquake in SE Iran (Ms = 6.6)
Background, aim, and scope
The rapid growth of the world’s population over the past few decades has led to a concentration of people, buildings, and infrastructure in urban areas. The tendency of urban areas to develop in sedimentary valleys has increased their vulnerability to earthquakes due to the presence of soft soil and sediment. Several earthquakes have clearly demonstrated that local soil and sediment conditions can have a significant influence on earthquake-induced ground motion and damage pattern, respectively. Many studies confirm the relationship between site effect and ground motion (Borcherdt in Bull Seismol Soc Am 60:29–61, 1970; Bouckovalas et al. in Geotech Geolog Eng (Historical Archive) 14(2):111–128, 1996; Fäh et al. in Seismology 1:87–10, 1997; Atakan et al. in Nat Hazards 15(2–3):139–164, 1997; Christaras et al. in Geodynamics 26(2–4):393–411, 1998; Raptakis et al. in Bull Earthquake Eng 2(3):285–301, 2004a; Raptakis et al. in Soil Dyn Earthq Eng 25:871–887, 2005; Marka et al. in Pure Appl Geophys 158:2349–2367, 2001; Marka et al. in Soil Dyn Earthq Eng 25(4):303–315, 2005; Importa et al. in Seismology 9(2):191–210, 2005; Tyagunov et al. in Nat Hazards 38:199–214, 2006; Lombardo et al. in Nat Hazards 38:339–354, 2006; Rayhani et al. in Geotech Geol Eng 21(1):91–100, 2008). In order to classify the suitability of the soil and subsurface sediment units for urban planning and compare their mechanical behavior with the non-uniform damage observed in the 2003 earthquake, we performed some geotechnical and geophysical analyses of soil and sediment samples collected from different locations in Bam City.
Geophysical and geotechnical properties, such as grain size distribution, sorting, plasticity, Poison’s ratio, shear strength, compression index, permeability, and P and S wave velocities in soil and subsurface sediments, were measured. Maps (in GIS environment) and cross-sections were prepared for the study area.
According to our observations, a great number of buildings were damaged in areas of the city where silty and clayey soils dominate, presenting very low permeability, low wave velocity together with high plasticity, and compressibility. In the study area, we recognized eight sediment types. Shear wave propagation velocities allowed for the identification of four seismic layers referred to as the surface layer, second layer, and third layer and seismic bedrock. We found that the damages observed in the Bam area were related to the physical and mechanical properties of the soil and subsurface sediment units. We also found that the soil thickness that was estimated by geophysical surveying shows a direct relationship with damage rate observations. Furthermore, we observed that landslide and qanat collapses have occurred in some areas where sand and silty sand soils and subsurface sediments dominate.
The distribution of the damage shows a microzonation that is very serious in some points in the city along the main fault, especially where it is located on thick, fine, medium, and loose soil and sediments. In general, there is a discernable west to east increase in the damage across the city. The average level of destruction for the entire city was ~75%, while the eastern part of the city locally reached 100% destruction level. The major factors that influenced the damage and destruction in the Bam region were the distance of a given site from the seismic source, the quality of foundation soil and subsurface sediment, and the type of building. The Bam earthquake occurred on a single fault network comprising the Bam and Arg-e-Bam faults (Funning et al. in J Geophys Res 100(B09406):1–23, 2005). The sediments and soil of the area (unconsolidated silty sand and sandy gravel) belong to braided fluvial and alluvial facies. Most of the buildings near the epicenter area were old and constructed of mud bricks using mud cement.
Recommendations and perspectives
A combined sedimentological, geological, neotectonic, geotechnical, paleoseismological, and geophysical investigation in urban areas (especially in alluvial valleys) will give the detailed knowledge of the subsurface structure required for the accurate and precise seismic hazard assessments needed for effective earthquake protection planning. This paper shows that for the Bam situation, sedimentological data are required to provide an interpretive context for the geophysical data.
KeywordsBam Earthquake Ground motion Iran Sediment Site effect Soil
- Ambraseys N, Melville C (1982) A history of Persian earthquakes. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UKGoogle Scholar
- ASTM (1989) Sec. 4 construction. Annual book of ASTM standards. V04.08 Soil and Rock Building Stone Geotextiles, PhiladelphiaGoogle Scholar
- Bauer E, Tejchman J (1998) Influence of density, pressure and mean grain diameter on shear band localization in granular material. Proceedings of the 3rd International conference on Mechanic of Faulted Rock, Wien, Austria, 6–9 April 1998. Balkema, pp 151–156Google Scholar
- BHRC (2005) Seismic microzonation project for Bam city. Building and Housing Research Center, Iran, N-101547-V.1Google Scholar
- Borcherdt RD (1970) Effects of local geology on ground motion near San Francisco Bay. Bull Seismol Soc Am 60:29–61Google Scholar
- Fäh D, Rüttener E, Noack Th, Kruspan P (1997) Microzonation of the city of Basal. Seismology 1:87–10Google Scholar
- Funning GJ, Parsons B, Wright T, Jackson JA, Fielding EJ (2005) Surface displacements and source parameters of the 2003 Bam earthquake from ASAR. J Geophys Res 100(B09406):1–23Google Scholar
- Hassami Kh, Tabbassi H, Abbassi MR, Azuma T, Okumura K, Echigo T, Kondo H (2004) Surface expression of the Bam fault zone in southeastern Iran: causative fault of the December 26, 2003 earthquake. JSEE Spring 5(4):1–10Google Scholar
- Hoseini A, Ghafouri M, Lashkaripour MA (2005) Geotechnical investigation of soils in Bam city. MSc thesis, Department of Geology, Ferdowsi University Mashhad, pp 160 (in Persian)Google Scholar
- IAEG (1981) Rock and soil description and classification for engineering geological mapping report by the IAEG Commission on engineering geological mapping. Bull IAEG 24:235–274Google Scholar
- Jafari MK, Ghayamghamian MR, Davoodi M, Kamalian M, Sohrabi-Bidar A (2005) Site effects of the 2003 Bam, Iran earthquake. J Seismol Inst Iran 22:1–18Google Scholar
- Jafargandomi A, Fatemi aghda SM, Suzuki S, Nakamura T (2004) Strong ground motions of the 2003 Bam earthquake SE Iran (M w = 6.5). Bull Earthqu Res Inst Univ Tokyo 79:47–57Google Scholar
- Lewis DW, McConchie D (1994) Analytical sedimentology. Chapman and Hall, LondonGoogle Scholar
- Marka K, Chavez-Garcia FJ, Raptakis DG, Pitilakis KD (2005) Parametric analysis of the seismic response of a 2D sedimentary valley: implications for code implementations of complex site effects. Soil Dyn Earthqu Eng 25(4):303–315Google Scholar
- Nakamura T, Suzuki S, Sadeghi H, Fatemi Aghda SM, Matsushima T, Ito Y, Hosseini SK, Jafar Gandomi A, Maleki M (2005) Source fault structure of the 2003 Bam earthquake, southeastern Iran, inferred from aftershock distribution and its relation to heavily damaged area: existence of the Arg-e-Bam fault proposed. Geophys Res Lett 32:L09380Google Scholar
- Raptakis D, Makra K, Anastasiadis A, Pitilakis K (2004a) Complex site effects in Thessaloniki (Greece): I. Soil structure and comparison of observations with 1D analysis. Bull Earthqu Eng 2(3):285–301Google Scholar
- USAE (1953) The unified soil classification system. Tech Memo N3-357, l.1, 30, US Army Engineer Waterways Experiment StationGoogle Scholar