Environmental impacts of alternative antifouling methods and use patterns of leisure boat owners
Leisure boaters in the Baltic Sea apply more copper as antifoulant than needed and permitted. Initiatives have been started to identify efficient means making boat owners comply with regulations through changed consumer behavior. We compare the environmental impacts of conventional and alternative antifouling methods, using Life Cycle Assessment methodology.
Two non-toxic methods were compared with biocide paint. To study the influence of boat owner use patterns, paint and brush washer scenarios (e.g., different paints, amounts, and maintenance) were created based on current use and recommendations. The functional unit was an average Swedish leisure boat kept fouling free for 1 year and impact categories studied were freshwater eco-toxicity and greenhouse gas emissions. Production of paints, fuel, electricity, and material used in the non-toxic methods was included. Sensitivity analysis was performed regarding the characterization method for toxicity, the fuel consumption data, and the copper release data.
Results and discussion
The non-toxic methods, hull cover and brush washer, performed best, but a trade-off was identified when the brush washer was located further away from the home port, when additional transportation increased greenhouse gas emissions. The resources needed for the non-toxic methods (production of materials and electricity used) cause considerably lower toxic emissions than paint. In the paint scenarios, using less paint and cleaning the boat over a washing pad with water treatment reduces aquatic emissions significantly. Fuel-related emissions were consistently lower than paint-related emissions. In the best-performing paint scenario, fuel- and paint-related emissions represented 26 and 67% of total emissions, respectively.
The non-toxic methods hull cover and brush washers lead to lower emissions, especially when brush washers were located close to the home port. Lacking such infrastructure, “painting less” is a way to reduce emissions, by using lower amounts of paint and painting less frequently. More widespread use of these antifouling strategies would considerably reduce copper emissions from leisure boating to the Baltic Sea. We suggest that support to marinas for investments in brush washers and washing pads should be further developed to enable boat owners to choose more sustainable antifouling methods and that information campaigns on the combined economic, health, and ecosystem impacts of antifouling are especially designed for boaters, marinas, market actors, and policy makers for a change to take place towards more sustainable practices.
KeywordsAntifouling Baltic Sea Boating Copper Environmental impacts LCA Leisure boats Zinc
We are grateful to the CHANGE team for the valuable questions and comments along the way, and for new insights about antifouling. We also thank Odd Klofsten for contributing with information on brush washers. This work resulted from the BONUS CHANGE project and was supported by BONUS (Art 185), funded jointly by the EU and the Swedish Environmental Protection Agency.
- Cerne O, Strandberg J, Fridell E, Peterson K, Allard AS, Rydberg T, Vaske B, Jägersten C, Östman N, Eklund B (2008) Rena Turen–Utvärdering av miljöanpassade bränslen i fritidsbåtar (Pure luck- Evaulation of environmentally adapted fueld in leisure boats, in Swedish). IVL Svenska Miljöinstitutet, StockholmGoogle Scholar
- Dahlström M, Elwing H, Ytreberg E, Solér C, Dahlström M (2014) Bland borsttvättar och fartygsfärger – En studie av fritidsbåtsägares attityder till och användning av olika antifoulingtekniker (Among brush washers and shiping paints- A study of boaters attitudes to and use of various antifouling techniques, in Swedish) http://changeantifouling.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Ut%C3%B6kad_rapport_bilaga4.pdf
- Eklund B, Haaksi H, Syversen F, Eisted R (2013) Disposals of plastic end-of-life boats. TemaNord 2013:582, Nordic Council of Ministers 2013, ISBN 978-92-893-2651-3Google Scholar
- European Commission (2010) Joint Research Centre - Institute for Environment and Sustainability: international reference life cycle data system (ILCD) handbook - general guide for life cycle assessment - detailed guidance. First edition march 2010. EUR 24708 EN. Luxembourg. Publications Office of the European UnionGoogle Scholar
- International Organization for Standardization (2006a) ISO14040:2006 environmental management – life cycle assessment – principles and framework. ISO, GenevaGoogle Scholar
- International Organization for Standardization (2006b) ISO 14044:2006 Environmental Management – Life Cycle Assessment – Requirements and Guidelines. ISO, GenevaGoogle Scholar
- IPCC (2013) Climate change 2013: the physical science basis: working group I contribution to the fifth assessment report of the intergovernmental panel on climate change. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
- Koroschetz B, Solér C, Mäenpää E (2017) Bonus Change Deliverable 2.2 Report/Scientific article on Leisure boat owners’ ways of using of antifouling products and techniques and their understanding of environmental consequencesGoogle Scholar
- Swedish International Development Authority/FAO Gulbrandsen O (1986) Reducing the fuel costs of small fishing boatsGoogle Scholar
- Swedish Transport Agency (2010) Båtlivsundersökningen 2010. En undersökning om svenska fritidsbåtar och hur de används (Boat survey 2010. A study on Swedish leisure boats and how they are used, in Swedish)Google Scholar
- Swedish Transport Agency (2016) Båtlivsundersökningen 2015. En undersökning om svenska fritidsbåtar och hur de används (boat survey 2015. A study on Swedish leisure boats and how they are used, in Swedish) Report number TSG 2016–534Google Scholar
- Swedish Transport Agency (2018) Ren båtbotten (Clean boat hull, in Swedish) https://www.transportstyrelsen.se/sv/sjofart/Fritidsbatar/Batlivets-miljofragor/Ren-batbotten/. Accessed 26 Feb 2018
- Voulvoulis N (2006) Antifouling paint booster biocides: occurrence and partitioning in water and sediments. In: Antifouling paint biocides. Springer Berlin Heidelberg, pp 155–170Google Scholar
- Yamaha (2002) Yamaha körfakta. (Yamaha driving facts, In Swedish) http://www.batvaruhuset.se/documents/batvaruhuset/documents/korfakta_2002_tcm36-34329.pdf2002. Accessed 13 July 2015