Environmental impact and cost assessment of incineration and ethanol production as municipal solid waste management strategies
- 1.3k Downloads
Municipal solid waste (MSW) can be handled with several traditional management strategies, including landfilling, incineration, and recycling. Ethanol production from MSW is a novel strategy that has been proposed and researched for practical use; however, MSW ethanol plants are not widely applied in practice. Thus, this study has been conducted to analyze and compare the environmental and economic performance of incineration and ethanol production as alternatives to landfilling MSW.
The ISO 14040 life cycle assessment framework is employed to conduct the environmental impact assessment of three different scenarios for the two MSW management strategies based on processing 1 ton of MSW as the functional unit. The first scenario models the process of incinerating MSW and recovering energy in the form of process heat; the second scenario also includes the process of incinerating MSW but yields in the recovery of energy in the form of electricity; and the third scenario models the process of converting MSW into ethanol. The economic impacts of each scenario are then assessed by performing benefit-to-cost ratio (BCR) and net present value (NPV) analyses.
Results and discussion
The results from the environmental impact assessment of each scenario reveal that scenario 2 has the highest benefits for resource availability while scenario 3 is shown to be the best alternative to avoid human health and ecosystems diversity impacts. Scenario 1 has the worst environmental performance with respect to each of these environmental endpoint indicators and has net environmental impacts. The results of the economic analysis indicate that the third scenario is the best option with respect to BCR and NPV, followed by scenarios 2 and 1, respectively. Furthermore, environmental and economic analysis results are shown to be sensitive to MSW composition.
It appears municipalities should prefer MSW incineration with electricity generation or MSW-to-ethanol conversion over MSW incineration with heat recovery as an alternative to landfilling. The contradiction between the environmental impact assessment results and economic analysis results demonstrates that the decision-making process is sensitive to a broad set of variables. Decisions for a specific MSW management system are subject to facility location and size, MSW composition, energy prices, and governmental policies.
KeywordsCost analysis Environmental Impact Ethanol production Incineration Life cycle assessment Municipal solid waste
The authors wish to express their gratitude to Mr. James Titmas of GeneSyst International, Inc. (Hudson, OH) who graciously provided his input on the GPV process.
- Aden A, Ruth M, Ibsen K, Jechura J, Neeves K, Sheehan J, Wallace B (2002) Lignocellulosic biomass to ethanol process design and economics utilizing co-current dilute acid prehydrolysis and enzymatic hydrolysis for corn stover. National Renewable Energy Laboratory, Golden, CO. Available from http://www1.eere.energy.gov/biomass/pdfs/32438.pdf. Accessed 17 April 2012
- Al-Salem SM, Lettieri P (2009) Life cycle assessment (LCA) of municipal solid waste management in the state of Kuwait. Euro J Sci Res 34:395–405Google Scholar
- Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve (2012) Selected interest rates (Daily)-H15: historical data. In: Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System. Available from http://www.federalreserve.gov/releases/h15/data.htm. Accessed 9 Sep 2012
- Curtiss PS, Kreider JF (2009) Life cycle analysis of automotive ethanol produced from municipal solid waste. ASME 3rd Int Conf Energy Sustain 2009, pp. 181–186Google Scholar
- EPA (2010) Municipal solid waste generation, recycling, and disposal in the United States: Facts and figures for 2010. Environmental Protection Agency http://www.epa.gov/osw/nonhaz/municipal/pubs/msw_2010_rev_factsheet.pdf. Accessed 17 April 2012
- EPA of Ireland (2004) Municipal solid waste incineration as part of Ireland’s integrated waste management Strategy. Environmental Protection Agency of Ireland http://www.stefanomontanari.net/sito/images/pdf/epa_incinerators%20_ireland.pdf. Accessed 17 April 2012
- GeneSyst International (2012) Waste conversion technology. Available from http://www.genesyst.com/. Accessed 18 Apr 2012
- Goedkoop M, Heijungs R, Huijbregts M, Schryver AD, Struijs J, Zelm R (2009) ReCiPe 2008. A life cycle impact assessmentmethod which comprises harmonised category indicators at the midpoint and the endpoint level. First edition. Report I:characterisation. VROM, Den Haag, The Netherlands. Available from http://www.pre-sustainability.com/download/misc/ReCiPe_main_report_final_27-02-2009_web.pdf. Accessed 17 April 2012
- Hogg D (2002) Costs for municipal waste management in the EU - Final report to directorate general environment, Eur. Commission. Eunomia Research & Consulting. Available from http://ec.europa.eu/environment/waste/studies/pdf/financingmuncipalwaste_management.pdf. Accessed 17 April 2012
- Holstein B (2010) Analysis of WTE incinerator cost and sources of funding. Available from http://www.wastenotcarroll.org/Marschner %20July %2023.doc. Accessed 17 April 2012
- ICIS (2012) Indicative Chemical Prices A-Z. Available from http://www.icis.com/chemicals/channel-info-chemicals-a-z/. Accessed 13 May 2012
- Katz J (2002) What a waste: the generation and disposal of trash imposes costs on society and the environment: should we be doing more? Reg Rev, Federal Reserve Bank of Boston, pp 22–30Google Scholar
- Li AD, Khraisheh M (2010) Bioenergy II: bio-ethanol from municipal solid waste (MSW): the role of biomass properties and structures during the ethanol conversion process. Int J Chem React Eng 8: Article A85Google Scholar
- Liamsanguan C, Gheewala S (2007) Environmental assessment of energy production from municipal solid waste incineration. Int J Life Cycle Assess 12:529–536Google Scholar
- Maynard RL, Walton H, Pollit F, Fielder R (2010) The impact on health of emissions to air from municipal waste incinerators. Health Protection Agency, LondonGoogle Scholar
- Ni JR, Wei HL, Liu YS, Zhao ZJ (2002) Life cycle analysis of sanitary landfill and incineration of municipal solid waste. Trans Nonferrous Metals Soc China 12:545–548Google Scholar
- Sakamoto O (2004) The financial feasibility analysis of municipal solid waste to ethanol conversion. Master of Science, Department of Agricultural Economics, Michigan State University. Available from http://ageconsearch.umn.edu/bitstream/11179/1/pb04sa01.pdf. Accessed 17 April 2012
- Sundqvist JO (1999) Life cycles assessments and solid waste-guidelines for solid waste treatment and disposal in LCA. Swedish Environmental Research Institute, Stockholm, Sweden. Available from http://www.naturvardsverket.net/Documents/publikationer/afr-r-279-se.pdf. Accessed 17 April 2012
- The World Bank (1999) Municipal solid waste incineration: A decision maker’s guide. The World Bank. Available from http://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTUSWM/Resources/463617-1202332338898/incineration-dmg.pdf. Accessed 17 April 2012
- US Department of Labor (2012) Inflation calculator: Bureau of labor statistics. In: United States Department of Labor. Available from http://www.bls.gov/data/inflation_calculator.htm. Accessed 8 Sep 2012
- US DOE (2012a) Alternative fuels and advanced vehicles data center: Ethanol feedstocks. In: US Department of Energy, Energy Efficiency & Renewable Energy. Available from http://www.afdc.energy.gov/afdc/fuels/ethanol_feedstocks.html. Accessed 17 Apr 2012
- US DOE (2012b) Alternative fuels and advanced vehicles data center: Alternative fuel price report. http://www.afdc.energy.gov/afdc/price_report.html. Accessed 30 May 2012