Consequential life cycle assessment: a review
- 3.2k Downloads
Over the past two decades, consequential life cycle assessment (CLCA) has emerged as a modeling approach for capturing environmental impacts of product systems beyond physical relationships accounted for in attributional LCA (ALCA). Put simply, CLCA represents the convergence of LCA and economic modeling approaches.
In this study, a systematic literature review of CLCA is performed.
While initial efforts to integrate the two modeling methods relied on simple partial equilibrium (PE) modeling and a heuristic approach to determining affected technologies, more recent techniques incorporate sophisticated economic models for this purpose. In the last 3 years, Multi-Market, Multi-Regional PE Models and Computable General Equilibrium models have been used. Moreover, the incorporation of other economic notions into CLCA, such as rebound effects and experience curves, has been the focus of later research. Since economic modeling can play a prominent role in national policy-making and strategic/corporate environmental planning, developing the capacity to operate LCA concurrent to, or integrated with, these models is of growing importance.
This paper outlines the historical development of such efforts in CLCA, discusses key methodological advancements, and characterizes previous literature on the topic. Based on this review, we provide an outlook for further research in CLCA.
KeywordsExperience curves CLCA Partial equilibrium modeling Computable general equilibrium modeling Consequential life cycle assessment Rebound effects
- Adams D, Alig R, McCarl B et al. (2005) FASOMGHG Conceptual Structure and Specification: Documentation. Retrieved September 28, 2010 from: http://agecon2.tamu.edu/people/faculty/mccarl-bruce/papers/1212FASOMGHG_doc.pdf
- Earles JM, Halog A (2010a) Partial Equilibrium Modeling and LCA in the Forest Biorefinery Context. Proceedings from Cycle 2010—4th Canadian Forum on the Life Cycle Management of Products and Services. Presented on May 4th, 2010Google Scholar
- Earles JM, Halog A (2010b) Integrating Partial Equilibrium Modeling and LCA in the Forest Biorefinery Context. Proceedings from Life Cycle Assessment X Conference. Presented on November 3 rd, 2010. <http://www.lcacenter.org/LCAX/presentations-final/184.pdf>
- Francois JF, Hall HK (1997) Partial equilibrium modeling. In: Francois J, Reinert K (eds) Applied methods for trade policy analysis, 1st edn. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 122–155Google Scholar
- Kløverpris J, Wenzel H, Nielsen P (2008) Life cycle inventory modeling of land use induced by crop consumption part 1: conceptual analysis and methodological proposal. In J Life Cycle Assess 13(1):12–21Google Scholar
- Lesage P, Ekvall T, Deschenes L, Samson, RJ (2007b) Environmental assessment of brownfield rehabilitation using two different life cycle inventory models: part 2. Int J Life Cycle Assess 12(7):497–513Google Scholar
- Marshall A (1920) Principles of Economics. Library of Economics and Liberty. Retrieved September 28, 2010 from: http://www.econlib.org/library/Marshall/marP33.html
- Roningen VO (1997) Multi-market, multi-region partial equilibrium modeling. In: Francois J, Reinert K (eds) Applied methods for trade policy analysis, 1st edn. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 231–257Google Scholar
- Tillman A-M, Baumann H, Eriksson E, Rydberg T (1991) Life cycle analysis of packaging materials. Calculation of environmental load. Chalmers Industriteknik, GöteborgGoogle Scholar
- US EPA (2010) Renewable Fuel Standard Program (RFS2) Regulatory Impact Analysis. EPA-420-R-10-006. February, 2010Google Scholar
- Vigon BW, Tolle DA, Cornaby BW et al. (1993) Life cycle assessment: Inventory guidelines and principles. Washington D.C. & Cincinnati: United States Environmental Protection Agency, Office of Research and Development. (EPA/600/R-92/245)Google Scholar
- Weidema BP (2003) Market information in life cycle assessment. Copenhagen: Danish Environmental Protection Agency. (Environmental Project no. 863): http://www2.mst.dk/Udgiv/publications/2003/87-7972-991-6/pdf/87-7972-992-4.pdf
- Zamagni A, Buttol P, Porta PL, Buonamici R, Masoni P, Guinée J, Heijungs R, Ekvall T, Bersani R, Biekowska A, Pretato U (2008) Critical review of the current research needs and limitations related to ISO-LCA practice. Deliverable D7 of Work Package 5 of the CALCAS project: http://fr1.estis.net/sites/calcas/default.asp?site=calcas&page_id=E2669B0F-9DB7-4D1E-95B0-407BC7949030