China’s passage of the Real Property Rights Law in 2007 undoubtedly marked a milestone of its economic transition to market economy. It delineates the boundary of property belongings and the authority of disposition by including or excluding specific individual and groups of individuals. The purpose of this paper is to trace the debate, deliberation, and decision of the law-making process to show the process of bargaining and compromise of various political interests in China’s complex and difficult economic transition.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in to check access.
Buy single article
Instant access to the full article PDF.
Price includes VAT for USA
Subscribe to journal
Immediate online access to all issues from 2019. Subscription will auto renew annually.
This is the net price. Taxes to be calculated in checkout.
For an excellent summary of socialist legal system of property, please see Heller .
In this case, getihu is defined as individual business entity with less than eight employees. See Zhang Houyi, Ming Lizhi, and Liang Zhuanyun, ed.s., siying qiye lanpishu: zhongguosiying qiye fazhan baogao [Blue Book of Private Enterpreises: A Report on the Development of China’s Private Enterprises], data in various years compiled by Tsai , Table 3.1, 55.
The debate between Li Yining’s advocacy of ownership reform and Wu Jinglian’s suggestion of price reform in 1986 can be found in Fewsmith [24: 184–187].
Fewsmith [24: 186–87]. Li Yining is nicknamed “Mr. Stock Market” because of his suggestion that China’s state-owned enterprises could be transformed into shareholder-owned companies with the condition that the government would still retain a substantial interest.
zhonghua renmin gongheguo qiye pochanfa (shixing) (Law of the PRC Enterprise Bankruptcy (for trial implementation)), <www.6law.idv.tw/aa.htm>. Accessed January 4, 2008.
Beijing qingnian baoshe [Beijing Youth Daily Press] and Zhongguo shehui kexueyuan qingnian renwen shehui kexue yanjiu zhongxin [Center of Youth, Humanities, Social Sciences, Chinese Academy of Social Sciences], ed., Zhongguo paixing lanpishu (Chinese people blue book) (Beijing: Liberty Army Arts Press, 2002), 10–11. It is difficult to give an approximate value of these private enterprises in US dollars during the 1990s due to the upward exchange rate of Chinese currency against US currency in 1994. See Obstfeld .
Doug Guthrie offered an interesting discussion of China’s economic reform and the rule of law. Please see Cuthrie .
“zhonggong zhongyang guanyu jianli shehui zhuyi shichang jingji tizhi ruogan wenti de jueding” [CCP central authority’s decision on several issues related to the establishment of socialist market economic system] <www.china.org.cn/chinese/archive/131747.htm>, accessed January 6, 2008; Zhang . For an analysis of Deng’s trip to southern China in 1992, please see Zhao .
A list of laws and administrative acts related to property rights in China can be found in Newly Edited Little Encyclopedia of Real Property Rights 2007.
See chapter 5 of zhonghua renmin gongheguo gongsifa (The PRC Company Law), <www.6law.idv.tw/aa.htm>.
Data can be found in Naughton [23: 300–302].
The 1982 Constitution and its amendments in 1988, 1993, 1999, and 2004 can be found in Chinese government official site, <english.people.com.cn/constitution/constitution.html>.
A comparison of various drafts of the Real Property Right Law in different years can be found in Zhesheng et al. .
According to the government, there were 11,543 pieces of comments and suggestions sent to the NPC. Zhihui [51: 16–18].
See xinben wuquanfa xiaoquanshu (Law and Regulations on Real Rights) (Beijing: Law Press China, 2007), 198.
Natural villages and administrative villages are actually not clearly delineated. The number of natural villages also varies in different sources. Peter Ho indicated that there were approximately 1.5 million natural villages. However, the statistical information in this paper is from zhongguo xianyu shehui jingji nianjian, 2000–2005 (Chinese Yearbook of Society and Economy of County Areas, 2000–2005) and zhongguo jingshen wenming jianshe nianjian, 2002 (Chinese Yearbook of Constructing Spiritual Civilization, 20002) <number.cnki.net/cyfd>. Accessed February 24, 2008. Also see Ho [54: 28].
Xiaohu ; Li Yingli, “Wuquanfa caoan de zongti pingjia ji 80 tiao juti xiugai jianyi” (Overall Assessments of the Real Property Rights Law and Eighty Concrete Proposals for Revision), <forum.lnnu.edu.cn/showpost.php?p=1367005>; Chen Yufeng and Xu Shaohua, “buke qiujie de yidao fangzhengshi: pancguan wuquanfa zhi shi”(One Unresolvable Equation: Problems with the Draft of the Real Property Rights Law), <www.tecn.cn/data/detail.php?id=14122>.
See quanguo renda chanweihui fazhi gongzuo weiyuanhui minfashi (Civil Code Office, Legal Affairs Committee, National People’s Congress, Standing Committee, with Yao Hong as the editor-in-chief), ed., zhonghua renmin gongheguo wuquanfa jingjie (Detailed Interpretation of the PRC’s Real Property Rights Law), 103.
Some reports even indicated an alarming loss of RMB 353 billion (US$45.1 billion) in state assets in 2004. Please see “qunian guyou zichan liushi 3,500 yiyuan” (Last Year State Assets Lost 350 billion RMB), Nov. 8, 2005, <www.southcn.com/news/china/zgkx/2000511080386.htm>; “Li Jinghua: guoyou ziyuan duochu liushi…” (Li Jinghua: Losses of National Resources in Many Places…), May 10, 2007. <news.qq.com/a/20070510/000493.htm>; Jie .
Bo ; Zhao Xiao, “shengshi weiyan” (Alarming Words in the Flourishing Age). <news.xinhuanet.com/newmedia/2006-10/20/content_5227379.htm>.
In December 2006, the petition continued. The petition letter with 718 signatures was posted on the web to encourage more people to join. See <my.opera.com/Alex-AU/blog/show.dml/622399>.
“Your Guide to ‘New Socialist Countryside’,” People’s Daily Online. March 8, 2006. <english.peopledaily.com.cn/200603/08/eng20060308_248839.html>.
The debate can be found in Shuoming .
The term of China’s land utilization rights varies. Residential land is contracted for 70 years; industrial land is 50 years; commercial land is for 40 years; land for mixed purposes is 50 years. According to the Real Property Rights Law, residential land utilization right will be automatically extends after its expiration date. See United Daily, Taipei, May 19, 2007, p. A20; Ying and Lin [53: 190–194].
According to Zhang Fuliang, the NPC passed a law to reduce the level of representation of rural population. The ratio of urban population to rural population in the election of NPC representatives has been changed from 8:1 at the beginning of reform era to 4:1 in 1995. Moreover, the law stipulated that one representative be allocated for 960,000 rural residents. Therefore, with an estimate of 782,410,000 peasants in late 2002, there should be 815 representatives in the 10th NPC. The real number elected from the rural area was 251, 30.8% of the allocated number of NPC representatives. See Fuliang .
The petition letter remained only 2 to 3 days on the web. However, the letter later was reposted in a different site. See Dong fang .
“Rule of Law Progresses Steadily in China,” China Daily, Nov. 12, 2002, p. 2.
“China’s Me Generation,” Time, Nov. 5, 2007, 51.
Michael A. Heller. The tragedy of the anticommons: Property in the transition from Marx to markets. Harvard Law Review 111(3): 621–688.
Gray, Cheryl W., Rebecca J. Hanson, and Michael Heller. 1992–93. Hungarian legal reform for the private sector. George Washington Journal of International Law and Economics 26: 307–311.
Anderson, Terry L., and Laura E. Huggins. 2003. Property rights: A practical guide to freedom and prosperity, 19–28. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
Jieming Zhu. 2000. Urban physical development in transition to market. The case of China as a transitional economy. Urban Affairs Review 36
Zhu, Jieming. 2002. Urban development under ambiguous property rights: a case of China’s transition economy. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 26(1): 41–57.
Milliband, Ralph. 1991. Divided Societies: Class struggle in contemporary capitalism. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Stiglitz, Joseph E. 1989. On the economic role of the state. In The economic role of the state, ed. Joseph E. Stiglitz, et al., 39–40. Oxford: Basil Blackwell, in association with Bank Insinger de Beaufort NV.
Vogel, Steven K. 1996. Freer markets, more rules: Regulatory reform in advanced industrialized countries. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
George-Mulgan, Aurelia. 2005. Japan’s interventionist state: The role of the MAFF, 35–38. London: RoutledgeCurzon.
Polanyi, Karl. 1944. The great transformation. Boston: Beacon.
Demsetz, Harold. 1988. Toward a theory of property rights. In Ownership, control, and the firm: The organization of economic activity, ed. Demsetz Harold, 104–106. Oxford: Blackwell.
Christman, John. 1994. The myth of property: Toward an Egalitarian theory of ownership, 7–8. New York: Oxford University Press.
Humphrey, Caroline, and Katherine Verdery. 2004. Introduction: Raising questions about property. In Property in question: Value transformation in the global economy, ed. Katherine Verdery, and Caroline Humphrey, 1–25. Oxford: Berg.
The World Bank. 1996. World development report 1996: From plan to market, 49. New York: Oxford University Press.
Bayles, Michael D. 1987. Principles of law: A normative analysis. Boston: D. Reidel. Chap. 3.
Hohfeld, Wesley Newcomb. 1919. In Fundamental legal conceptions as applied in judicial reasoning, ed. Walter Wheeler Cook. New Haven: Yale University Press. (Westport, CT: Greenwood Press, 1978), 64, 96–97.
Heller, Michael A. 1998. The tragedy of the anticommons: property in the transition from Marx to markets. Harvard Law Review 111(3): 662.
Verdery, Katherine. 2004. The property regime of socialism. Conservation and Society 2(1): 191.
Verdery, Katherine. 2003. The vanishing hectare: Property and value in postsocialist Transylvania, 14. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
Schurmann, H.F. 1956. Traditional property concepts in China. The Far Eastern Quarterly 15(4): 507–516.
Bell, Daniel A. 2006. Beyond liberal democracy, 231–254. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Saich, Tony. 2004. Governance and politics in China, 33–35. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Naughton, Barry. 2007. The Chinese economy: Transitions and growth. Cambridge: The MIT.
Fewsmith, Joseph. 1994. Dilemmas of reform in China. Armonk: M.E. Sharpe.
Pei, Minxin. 1994. From reform to revolution: The demise of communism in China and the Soviet Union. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Tsai, Kellee S. 2007. Capitalism without democracy: The private sector in contemporary China. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
Marcuse, Peter. 1996. Privatization and its discontents: Property rights in land and housing in the transition in Eastern Europe. In Cities after socialism: Urban and regional change and conflict in post-socialist societies, ed. Gregory D. Andrusz, Michael Harloe, and Ivan Szelenyi, 135. Cambridge: Oxford University Press.
Gilboy, George J. 2004. The myth behind China’s miracle. Foreign Affairs 83(4): 33–48.
Obstfeld, Maurice. 2006. The Renminbi’s dollar peg at the crossroads. Berkeley: Institute of Business and Economic Research, Center for International and Development Economics Research, University of California. Paper No. 148, 2006, 3. repositories.cdlib.org/iber/cider/C06-148.
Dickson, Bruce J. 2004. Dilemmas of party adaptation: The CCP’s strategies of survival. In State and society in 21st Century China, ed. Peter Hays Gries, and Stanley Rosen, 147. New York: RoutledgeCurzon.
Dickson, Bruce J. 2003. Red capitalists in China: The party, private entrepreneurs, and prospects for political change. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Sun, Yan. 2004. Corruption and market in contemporary China. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
Manion, Melanie. 2004. Corruption by design: Building clean government in mainland China and Hong Kong. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Kwong, Julia. 1997. The political economy of corruption in China, 11–16. Armonk: M.E. Sharpe.
Susumu Yabuki. 1995. China’s new political economy: The giant awakes (translated by Stephen M. Harner), 4–5. Boulder: Westview.
Kahler, Miles. 1990. Orthodoxy and its alternatives: explaining approaches to stabilization and adjustment. In Economic crisis and policy choice: The politics of adjustment in the third world, ed. Joan M. Nelson, 33–62. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Lin, Kun-chin. 2006. Disembedding socialist firms as a statist project: restructuring the Chinese oil industry, 1997–2002. Enterprise and Society 7(1): 64–65.
Rudolf von Jhering. 1915. The struggle for law (translated from the 5th German edition by John Joseph Lalor), 99–100. Chicago: Callaghan and Company, 2nd ed.
Cuthrie, Doug. 2006. China and globalization, 217–255. New York: Routledge.
Zhang, Zhengjun. 2006. China: Policy implications. Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), corporate governance of non-listed companies in emerging markets, 146. Paris: OECD.
Zhao, Suisheng. 1993. Deng Xiaoping’s southern tour: elite politics in Post-Tiananmen China. Asian Survey 33(8): 739–756.
Gallagher, Mary E. 2002. ‘Reform and openness’ why China’s economic reforms have delayed democracy. World Politics 54: 351.
Sunstein, Cass R. 2001. Designing democracy: What constitutions do, 25. New York: Oxford University Press.
Liberthal, Kenneth. 2004. Governing China: From revolution through reform, 73. New York: W.W. Norton.
Huixing, Liang, et al. 2000. zhongguo wuquanfa caoan jianyigao (Drafted proposed version of Chinese real property law). Beijing: Shehui kexue wenxian.
Xiuping, Ji. 2007. wuquan zonglun (General introduction of real property rights). Beijing: Zhongguo fazhi.
Frank Xianfeng Huang. 2004. The path to clarity: development of property rights in China. Columbia Journal of Asian Law 17(2)
Guanghui, Guo, and Wang Lijun. 2005. woguo suoyouquan zhidu de bianqian yu chonggou (The change and restructure of our country’s ownership system). Beijing: zhongguo jiancha chubanshe.
Liming, Wang. 2001. zhongguo wuquanfa caoan jianyigao yu shuoming (Proposed draft of Chinese real property right law and explanation). Beijing: zhongguo fazhi.
Zhesheng, Xie, Chang Pengao, and Wu Chunqi. 2006. zhongguo minfadian lifa yanjiu (Legislative study of China’s civil code), 93–135. Beiing: Peking University Press.
Zhihui, Liu (ed). 2007. Wuquanfa lifa guannian yu yinan shidu pingzhu (The real property right law: Notes and commentary of legislative concept and difficult system). Nanjing: Jiangsu People.
Chen, Chih-jou Jay. 2005. The path of Chinese privatization: a case study of village enterprises in Southern Jiansu. Corporate Governance 13(1): 72.
Zhao Ying, and Yu Lin. 2007. caichan de baohushen: shenghuo zhong ni bixu liaojie de wushige wuquanfa wenti (Guardian of wealth: Fifty questions of the real property rights law that you must understand. Beijing: Law Press, 138–146.
Ho, Peter. 2005. Institutions in transition: Land ownership, property rights, and social conflict in China. New York: Oxford University Press.
Chow, Daniel C.K. 2003. The legal system of the People’s Republic of China, 330–331. St. Paul: West Group.
Shi Xiaohu. 2006. wuquanfa caoan de falu luoji quexian (Legal flaws in logic in the draft of the real property laws), Dec. 13, 2006. www.tecn.cn/data/detail.php?id=12194.
Liu Jie. 2004. lun guoyou zichan liushi de chengyin yu duice (Reasons and countermeasures to the losses of national properties), July 19, 2004, information website of the Disciplinary Committee of the Shanxi Provincial Party Branch, Chinese Communist Party. www.qinfeng.gov.cn/admin/pub_journalshow.asp?id=100151&chid=100075.
Wang Weiguo. 2007. wuquanfa dui qiye huanjin de yingxiang (The impact of the real property rights law on enterprise environment), talk at a conference held by the Sino-foreign Management magazine, Nov. 3–5, 2007. www.zwgl.com.cn/News_list.asp?Article_ID=1780.
Li Li. 2007. The property debate. Beijing Review, March 1, 22.
Zhao Lei. 2006. yifeng xin dangzhu wuquanfa caoan? (One letter stopped the real property rights law?) nanfang zhoumo (Southern Weekend), Feb. 23, 2006, www.nanfangdaily.com.cn/zm/20060223/.
Tong Zhiwei. 2006. wuquanfa ‘caoan’ gairuhe tongguo xianfa zhi men (How can the draft of the real property rights law enter the constitutional gate?), March 30, 2006. www.law-frontier.com/ReadNews.asp?NewsID=174&BigClassID=21&SmallClassID=28&SpecialID=16.
Xu Bo. 2007. zhongguo wuquanfa caoan yinfa gejie zhongda zhengyi (Chinese real property rights law generated disputes in many circles), Voice of America, May 8, 2007. voanews.com/chinese/archive/2007-03/.
Bell, Stephen, and Hui Feng. 2007. Made in China: IT infrastructure policy and the politics of trade opening in Post-WTO China. Review of International Political Economy 14(1): 56–57.
Lung Weiqiu. 2006. wuquan lifa de hexianxing wenti (The question of the constitutionality of the legislation of real property rights), May 7, 2006. www.law-frontier.com/ReadNews.asp?NewsID=175&BigClassID=21&SmallClassID=28&SpecialID=16.
Fei-long, Tian. 2007. Issue and ism of ‘post property law times’: observation and thinking on anti-constitution dispute of property law draft. US-China Law Review 4(4): 58–59.
Rossum, Ralph A., and G.A. Tarr. 1995. American constitutional law, Volume I: The structure of government, 7–9. New York: St. Martin.
So, Bennis Wai Yip. 2006. Privatization. In Critical issues in contemporary China, ed. Tubilewicz Caeslaw, 55–56. New York: Routledge. Hong Kong: Open University of Hong Kong Press.
Su Yongtong. 2007. zhongguo wuquanfa lifa guocheng (The legislative process of China’s real property rights law), nanfang zhoumo (Southern Weekend), March 22, 2007.
Ji Shuoming. 2004. guotui minjin huo minjin guojin” (The retreat of state enterprises for the advance of the private enterprises, or the advance of private enterprises along with the progress of state enterprises), yazhou zhoukan (Hong Kong), 18(40), Oct. 3, 2004, 26–29.
Chen, Lei. 2007a. The new Chinese property code: a giant step forward? Electronic Journal of Comparative Law 11(2): 17–18. www.ejcl.org/112/article 112-2.pdf.
Shirk, Susan L. 2007. China: Fragile superpower, 56–57. New York: Oxford University Press.
Joseph Kahn. 2007. China backs property law, buoying middle class. New York Times, March 16, 2007. www.nytimes.com.
Richard McGregor, James Kynge, and Mure Dickie. 2003. Shanghai tycoons. Financial Times 13, June 17.
Feng Yifei. 2007. wuguanfa, rangshui mozhe shitou guohei (The real property rights law, allow whom to cross the river by groping the rock below?) hushengdun guancha zhoukan (Washington Observer Weekly), no. 9, March 14, 2007. www.washingtonobserver.org.
Edmonds, Richard Louis. 2006. China’s environmental problems. In Critical issues in contemporary China, ed. Czeslaw Tubilewicz, 119. New York: Routledge. (Hong Kong: Open University of Hong Kong Press).
Zhang Fuliang. 2006. zhengzhi zhidu de queshi yu nongmin quanyi baohu (The deficiencies of political system and the protection of peasant rights and interests), China Elections and Governance, April 3, 2006. www.chinaelections.org/NewsInfo.asp?NewsID=40714.
Chen, Lei. 2007b. The new chinese property code: a giant step forward? Electronic Journal of Comparative Law 11(2). www.ejcl.org/112/article112-2.pdf.
Dong fang. 2005. wuquanfa shifei gongguo (The rights, wrongs, contributions, and defects of the real property rights law), Voice of America, May 25, 2005. www.voanews.com/chinese/archieve 2007-3/w2007-03-30-voa47.cfm.
Nathan, Andrew. 1985. Chinese democracy, 107. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Fligstein, Neil. 1996. Markets as politics: a political-cultural approach to market institutions. American Sociological Review 61(4): 656–673.
Migdal, Joel S. 1994. The state in society: An approach to struggles for domination. In State power and social forces: Domination and transformation in the third world, ed. Joel S. Migdal, Atul Kohli, Vivienne Shue, et al., 12. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Shue, Vivienne. 1994. State power and social organization in China. In State power and social forces: Domination and transformation in the third world, ed. Joel S. Migdal, et al., 65–88. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Howard W. French. 2007. Homeowner stares down wreckers, at least for a while. New York Times, March 27, 2007. www.nytimes.com/2007/03/27/world/asia/27china.html.
Perry, Elizabeth J. 2008. Chinese consciousness of ‘rights’: from Mencius to Mao—and now. Perspectives on Politics 6(1): 37–50.
About this article
Cite this article
Lee, W. Yours, Mine, or Everyone’s Property? China’s Property Law in 2007. J OF CHIN POLIT SCI 15, 25–47 (2010). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11366-009-9081-7
- Property Law
- Economic Transition
- Property Rights
- Real Property
- Civil Code