Incorporation of in silico biodegradability screening in early drug development—a feasible approach?
The concentration of a pharmaceutical found in the environment is determined by the amount used by the patient, the excretion and metabolism pattern, and eventually by its persistence. Biological degradation or persistence of a pharmaceutical is experimentally tested rather late in the development of a pharmaceutical, often shortly before submission of the dossier to regulatory authorities.
Materials and methods
To investigate whether the aspect of persistence of a compound could be assessed early during drug development, we investigated whether biodegradation of pharmaceuticals could be predicted with the help of in silico tools. To assess the value of in silico prediction, we collected results for the OECD 301 degradation test (“ready biodegradability”) of 42 drugs or drug synthesis intermediates and compared them to the prediction of the in silico tool BIOWIN.
Results and discussion
Of these compounds, 38 were predictable with BIOWIN, which is a module of the Estimation Programs Interface (EPI) Suite™ provided by the US EPA. The program failed to predict the two drugs which proved to be readily biodegradable in the degradation tests. On the other hand, BIOWIN predicted two compounds to be readily biodegradable which, however, proved to be persistent in the test setting.
The comparison of experimental data with the predicted one resulted in a specificity of 94% and a sensitivity of 0%. The results of this study do not indicate that application of the biodegradation prediction tool BIOWIN is a feasible approach to assess the ready biodegradability during early drug development.
KeywordsGreen chemistry Biodegradability Pharmaceuticals
- EMEA. Guideline on environmental risk assessment of medicinal products for human use. CPMP/SWP/4447/00, London, June 2006.Google Scholar
- European Commission (1997a) Classification, packaging and labelling of dangerous substances in the European Union. Part 2—testing methods. Part C. 4-B—modified OECD screening test. European Commission, Luxembourg, pp 310–314Google Scholar
- European Commission (1997b) Classification, packaging and labeling of dangerous substances in the European Union. Part 2—testing methods. Part C.4-C—carbon dioxide evolution test. European Commission, Luxembourg, pp 315–319Google Scholar
- Informationsdienst Wissenschaft: 1st international conference on Sustainable Pharmacy; http://idw-online.de/pages/de/event22661 (last accessed: Dec 2009).
- Management Strategies for Pharmaceuticals in Drinking Water—website of the START project; http://www.start-project.de/downloads/start_Flyer_neu.pdf (last accessed: Dec 2009).
- McFarland MJ (Chair). Science Advisory Board (SAB) Review of the Estimation Programs Interface Suite (EPI Suite™); U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, September 7, 2007.Google Scholar
- Neubert C, Länge R, Steger-Hartmann T (2008) In: Aga DS (ed) Gadolinium containing contrast agents for magnetic resonance imaging (MRI)—investigations on the environmental fate and effects. In: fate of pharmaceuticals in the environment and in water treatment systems. CRC Press Taylor & Francis Group, Boca Raton, p 102Google Scholar
- OECD guidelines for testing of chemicals. Ready biodegradability: no. 301. adopted 17 Jul. 1992.Google Scholar
- OECD guidelines for testing of chemicals (1993a) Ready biodegradability: no. 301E. “Modified OECD screening test”, adopted 17 Jul. 1992. OECD, Paris.Google Scholar
- OECD guidelines for testing of chemicals (1993b) Ready biodegradability: no. 301B. “CO2 evolution test”, adopted 17 Jul. 1992. OECD, Paris.Google Scholar
- OECD guidelines for testing of chemicals (1993c) Ready biodegradability: no. 301 F. “Manometric Respiration Test”, adopted 17 Jul 1992. OECD, Paris.Google Scholar
- Steger-Hartmann T (2004) In: Reichl FX, Schwenk M (eds) Computer-gestützte Vorhersagesysteme. In: Regulatorische Toxikologie. Springer, Berlin, p 97Google Scholar
- US Environmental Protection Agency website on green chemistry; http://www.epa.gov/greenchemistry/ (last accessed: Dec 2009).