Landscape and Ecological Engineering

, Volume 1, Issue 1, pp 53–59

Nature in the city, city in the nature: case studies of the restoration of urban nature in Tokyo, Japan and Toronto, Canada

Original Paper

Abstract

Increasing demands for the restoration of nature in cities have led planners to seek an effective form, configuration and maintenance scheme for parks and open spaces in urban areas. This paper aims to introduce two contrasting examples of ways that planners have met the challenge of restoring nature in the city. It takes Tokyo Bay Bird Sanctuary Park (TBBSP), Tokyo, Japan, and Tommy Thompson Park (TTP), Toronto, Canada, as case studies. TBBSP is located on reclaimed land facing Tokyo Bay, and is surrounded by heavily industrialized areas. The absence of green corridors which connect TBBSP to surrounding green patches have turned TBBSP into an isolated oasis for migrating birds. TTP in Toronto is also located on reclaimed land facing Lake Ontario. However, TTP has become to be an indispensable green patch of the open space network of Toronto because it is located at the node of green corridors. The principles of landscape ecology may dictate that TTP, integrated in the green network of the area, is in far better condition than isolated TBBSP. However both case studies are based on the same early post-war parks and open space planning concept, which aimed to clearly separate urban greens from surrounding urban fabrics. To restore nature in cities it is important to understand that alternative models of parks and open space planning can exist. We therefore refer to the authentic urban pattern found in Japanese cities, which historically have not intended to clearly separate each land use types but have sustained a mix of open spaces and urban fabrics. In the context of the global concern to realize ecological cities, restoring a city by integrating greens in the urban fabric should be understood as a way of achieving a “city in nature”.

Keywords

Avifauna Greenway Mixture of urban and agricultural land uses Tokyo Bay Bird Sanctuary Park Tommy Thompson Park Waterfront 

References

  1. Abercrombie P (1945) Greater London Plan: 1944. Master plan. HMSO, LondonGoogle Scholar
  2. Ashihara Y (1986) The hidden order. Kodansha International, TokyoGoogle Scholar
  3. Banville D (1990) The vascular plants of metropolitan Toronto. Toronto Field Naturalists, TorontoGoogle Scholar
  4. Catling PM, McIntosh KL, McKay SM (1977) The vascular plants of the Leslie Street Headland. Ontario Field Biologist 31:23–39Google Scholar
  5. Fujii, M, Yokohari M, Watanabe T (2002) Identification of the distribution pattern of farmlands in Edo (in Japanese with English abstract). City Plan Rev Spec Issue 37:931–936Google Scholar
  6. Ishida Y (ed) (1992) Incomplete city plan of Tokyo (in Japanese). Chikuma-shobo, TokyoGoogle Scholar
  7. Kito H (1996) Environmentally advanced nation, Edo (Kankyo Senshinkoku Edo). PHP Shinso, TokyoGoogle Scholar
  8. Koen-Ryokuchi-Kyokai (1939) Special issue on the parks and open space plan of Tokyo (in Japanese), vol 3 (1&2)Google Scholar
  9. MTRCA (1977) Aquatic Park Executive SummaryGoogle Scholar
  10. MTRCA (1989) Tommy Thompson Park; Master Plan and Environmental AssessmentGoogle Scholar
  11. MTRCA (1991) Lake Ontario Waterfront Regeneration ProjectGoogle Scholar
  12. MTRCA (1992a) Don River Watershed; State of the EcosystemGoogle Scholar
  13. MTRCA (1992b) Addendum; Tommy Thompson Park Master Plan and Environmental AssessmentGoogle Scholar
  14. Parker BD (1983) Toronto region bird chart. Toronto Field Naturalists, TorontoGoogle Scholar
  15. Royal Commission on the Future of the Toronto Waterfront (1992) RegenerationGoogle Scholar
  16. Spirn AW (1984) The granite garden. Basic, BostonGoogle Scholar
  17. Steers S (1979) A bird census conducted at the Leslie street spit, spring and summer 1978. Ontario Field Biologist 33:35–45Google Scholar
  18. Tamura A (1992) City planning of Edo and Tokyo (Edo Tokyo Machizukuri Monogatari) (in Japanese). Jiji-tsushin-sha, TokyoGoogle Scholar
  19. Temple PJ (1980) Plants of the Leslie Street Headland, Toronto, Ontario. Ontario Field Biologist 34:19–32Google Scholar
  20. Tokyo Metropolitan Government (2000) City Planning of TokyoGoogle Scholar
  21. Tokyo JA (1992) Vegetables and flowers from Edo and Tokyo (Edo Tokyo Yukari no Yasai to Hana) (in Japanese)Google Scholar
  22. Ueno Y, Ogawara T (1994) Tokyo Bay Bird Sanctuary Park. In: Landscape works 1994 (in Japanese), edited by Japanese Institute of Landscape Architecture, pp 20–21Google Scholar
  23. Watanabe Z (1983) Between cities and the country (Toshi to Nouson no Aida) (in Japanese). Ronso-sha, TokyoGoogle Scholar
  24. Yokohari M, Takeuchi K (1995) Restoration of urban ecosystem on the Lake Ontario waterfront of Toronto, Canada: Tommy Thompson Park case study. J Jpn Inst Landsc Architect 58:53–56Google Scholar
  25. Yokohari M, Takeuchi K, Watanabe T, Yokota S (2000) Beyond greenbelts and zoning: future directions of the environment of Asian mega-cities. Landsc Urban Plan 47:159–171Google Scholar

Copyright information

© International Consortium of Landscape and Ecological Engineering and Springer-Verlag Tokyo 2005

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Graduate School of Systems and Information SciencesUniversity of TsukubaTsukubaJapan

Personalised recommendations