An experimental study of compressed work schedules in policing: advantages and disadvantages of various shift lengths
- 1.6k Downloads
The objectives of this research were to test the impacts of three shift lengths (8-, 10-, and 12-hour) on performance, health, safety, quality of life, sleep, fatigue, alertness, off-duty employment, and overtime among police.
This study consisted of a randomized block experimental design. There were 275 participating officers from two large police departments. Data were collected as part of a multi-site clinical trial for which we employed the same protocols in both sites. The blocks included site and time of day of the shift. Unique measures of work performance, safety, and fatigue were collected using laboratory-based simulations collected during the end of the shifts, and self-report instruments were used to capture other outcomes such as health and quality of life. The analysis model we employed was a block randomized ANCOVA in which the pre-test dependent measures served as the covariate.
The results indicated that those working 10-hour shifts had a significantly higher quality of work life (f = .16) and averaged significantly more sleep (f = .19) than those on 8-hour shifts. Furthermore, those working 8-hour shifts averaged significantly more overtime (f = .42) than did those assigned to 10- and 12-hour shifts. In addition, officers working 12-hour shifts experienced greater levels of sleepiness (f = .20) and reported lower levels of alertness (f = .21) at work than officers on 8-hour shifts.
There do not appear to be any significant health, safety, or performance problems associated with compressed work week schedules in policing. Indeed, the implementation of 10-hour shifts may be a viable alternative to traditional 8-hour schedules considering the findings of this study. It is important to note that the benefits associated with 10-hour shifts did not inure to the 12-hour shifts. Although our study did not reveal any significant effects associated with objective measures of fatigue across shifts, the implementation of 12-hour shifts should be done only after careful consideration of some of the potential concerns. Limitations of this study include lack of information regarding the methods and costs associated with implementation of compressed schedules, and the low level of reliability for driving and shooting simulation exercises. Future research should examine the impact of overtime hours on fatigue, safety, and performance, and ways to more effectively regulate hours of work in policing.
KeywordsCompressed schedules Compressed work weeks Police scheduling Police shift schedules Shift length Ten-hour shifts Twelve-hour shifts
We wish to thank collaborators Anneke Heitmann, PhD; Jon Shane, PhD; Christopher Ortiz, PhD; and Eliab Tarkghen for their significant contributions to this work who are co-authors of our complete technical report of the National Institute of Justice and available at www.ncjrs.org (Amendola et al., 2011, in press).
No project of this magnitude would be possible without the participation of dedicated and forward-thinking leaders in law enforcement agencies. As such we wish to thank Chief (ret.) Ella Bully-Cummings of the Detroit (MI) Police Department and Chief Theron Bowman, PhD of the Arlington (TX) Police Department for their participation in the study, and very much appreciate all of the officers who participated on the part of those agencies.
We also acknowledge the U.S. Department of Justice, National Institute of Justice for providing funding for this experiment under grant #: 2005-FS-BX-0057. Specifically, our thanks go to Brett Chapman, PhD, Thomas Feucht, PhD, Winifred Reed, and Director John Laub, PhD. Former NIJ personnel Maggie Heisler, Akiva Liberman, PhD, and Bryan Vila, PhD were instrumental to the research.
Finally, we are appreciative of former staff, fellows, and interns of the Police Foundation.
- Aamodt, M. G. (2010). Industrial organizational psychology: an applied approach (6th ed.). Belmont: Wadsworth CENGAGE Learning.Google Scholar
- Allen, R. W., Stein, C. A., Aponso, B. L., Rosenthal, T. J., & Hogue, J. R. (1990). Low-cost part- task driving simulator using microcomputer technology. Washington: Transportation Research Board.Google Scholar
- Amendola, Weisburd, Hamilton, Jones, Slipka, Heitmann, Shane, Ortiz, & Tarkghen (2011, in press). The impact of shift length in policing on performance, health, quality of life, sleep, fatigue and extra-duty employment. Washington, DC: Police Foundation.Google Scholar
- Ary, D., Jacobs, L. C., & Razavieh, A. (1985). Introduction to research in education (3rd ed.). New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston.Google Scholar
- Axelsson, J. (2005). Long shifts, short rests and vulnerability to shift work. (Doctoral Dissertation) Stockholm University: Stockholm. Retrieved from http://www.su.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:194082/FULLTEXT01.
- Barter Trenholm, S. B. (1997). The satisfaction of police officers and their spouses with 12-hour shift work schedules (Doctoral Dissertation). Memorial University of Newfoundland, Canada.Google Scholar
- Barton, J., Costa, G., Smitt, L. R., Spelten, E. R., Totterdell, P. A., & Folkard, S. (1995). The standard shiftwork index manual: A battery of questionnaires for assessing shiftwork- related problems. Work and Stress, 9, 3–30.Google Scholar
- Battelle Memorial Institute, JIL Information Systems (1998). An overview of the scientific literature concerning fatigue, sleep, and the circadian cycle. Retrieved from http://cf.alpa.org/internet/projects/ftdt/backgr/batelle.htm
- Bayley, D. H., & Worden, R. F. (1998). Police overtime: An examination of key issues. National Institute of Justice in Research in Brief. Retrieved from http://www.ncjrs.gov/pdffiles/167572.pdf
- Bernardi, RF. A. (1994). Validating research results when Cronbach's alpha is below .70: a methodological procedure. Educational and Psychological Measurement, 54(3), 766–775.Google Scholar
- Brown, P. (1974). “Cycle scheduling” for eight and ten hour days. The Police Chief, 38-41.Google Scholar
- Caruso, C. C., Hitchcock, E. M., Dick, R. B., Russo, J. M., & Schmit, J. M. (2004). Overtime and extended work shifts: Recent findings on illness, injuries, and health behaviors (DHHS Publication No. 2004-143). Cincinnati: National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health.Google Scholar
- Cascio, W. F. (1991). Applied psychology in personnel management (4th ed.). Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.Google Scholar
- Cohen, J. (1988). Statistical power analysis for the behavior sciences (2nd ed.). Hillsdale: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc.Google Scholar
- Coulton, G. F., & Feild, H. S. (1995). Using assessment centers in selecting entry-level police Officers: Extravagance or justified expense? Public Personnel Management, 24(2), 223–254.Google Scholar
- Cruz, C., Rocco, P. D., & Hackworth, C. (2000). Effects of quick rotating shift schedules on the health and adjustment of air traffic controllers. Aviation, Space, and Environmental Medicine, 71(4), 400–407.Google Scholar
- Czeisler, C. A., Barger, L. K., Landrigan, C., Lockley, S., Rararatnam, S., Cade, B., Ronda, J. M., O’Brien, C., & Edwards, S. (2005). Harvard Work Hours Health, and Safety Study. Unpublished instrument. Retrieved from http://sleep.med.harvard.edu/research/labs/86/Harvard+Work+Hours+Health+and+Safety+Group/.
- deCarufel, A., & Schaan, J. (1990). The impact of compressed work weeks on police job involvement. Canadian Police College Journal, 14(2), 81–97.Google Scholar
- Dowd, P. J., Oakley, C. J., French, J., Fischer Jr, J. R., & Storm, W. F. (1994). One- year results for the Kelly Air Force Base compressed work week survey. Interim Technical Report for period November 1992- August 1993. 1-10.Google Scholar
- Duchon, J. C., Keran, C. M., & Smith, T. J. (1994). Extended workdays in an underground mine: A work performance analysis. Human Factors: The Journal of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, 36(2), 258–268.Google Scholar
- Eaton, P., & Gottselig, S. (1980). Effects of longer hours, shorter week for intensive care nurses. Dimensions in Health Services, 57, 25–27.Google Scholar
- Facer, R. L., & Wadsworth, L. (2010). Four-day work weeks: Current research and practice. Connecticut Law Review, 42(4), 1031–1046.Google Scholar
- Fields, W. L., & Loveridge, C. (1988). Critical thinking and fatigue: How do nurses on 8 and 12 hour shifts compare? Nursing Economics, 6(4), 189–195.Google Scholar
- Folkard, S., & Lombardi, D. A. (2004). Modeling the impact of the components of long work hours on injuries and “accidents”. United Kingdom: Paper presented at the National Conference.Google Scholar
- Foster, L. W., Latack, J. C., & Reindl, L. J. (1979). Effects and promises of the shortened work week. Paper presented at the 39th annual meeting of the Academy of Management, Atlanta, Georgia.Google Scholar
- Glueck, W. F. (1979). Changing hours of work: A review and analysis of the research. The Personnel Administrator, 24(3), 44–67.Google Scholar
- Harrington, J. M. (1994). Shift work and health: A critical review of the literatures on working hours. Annals of the Academy of Medicine, Singapore, 23(5), 699–705.Google Scholar
- Heselgrave, R., Rhodes, W., & Gill, V. (2000). A prospective study examining the changes to worker health and safety after shifting from 9 to 12.5 hours shifts. In S. Hornberger, P. Knauth, G. Costa, et al. (Eds.), Shiftwork in the 21st Century. Frankfurt: Peter Lang.Google Scholar
- Hughes, F. (2006). Does the benefit outweigh the cost? Using assessment centers in selecting middle managers. The Police Chief, August.Google Scholar
- Jeanmonod, R., Brook, C., Winther, M., Pathak, S., & Boyd, M. (2008). Declining resident productivity over time in the emergency department. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 51(4), doi: 10.1016/j.annemergmed.2008.01.065.
- Johns, M. W. (1991). A new method for measuring daytime sleepiness: The Epworth sleepiness scale. Sleep, 14(6), 540–545.Google Scholar
- Kirk, R. E. (1995).Experimental design: procedures for the behavioural sciences, 3rd edn. Pacific Grove, CA: Brookes/ColeGoogle Scholar
- Kribbs, N. B., & Dinges, D. F. (1994). Vigilance decrement and sleepiness. In J. R. Harsh & R. D. Ogilvie (Eds.), Sleep onset mechanisms (pp. 113–125). Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.Google Scholar
- Liberman, A. M., Best, S. R., Metzler, T. J., Fagan, J. A., Weiss, D. S., & Marmar, C. R. (2002). Routine occupational stress and psychological distress in police. Policing: An International Journal of Police Strategies & Management, 25(2), 421–439. doi: 10.1108/13639510210429446.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Lindsey, D. (2007). Police fatigue: An accident waiting to happen. FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin, 76(8), 1–6.Google Scholar
- Lipscomb, J. A., Trinkoff, A. M., Geiger-Brown, J., & Brady, B. (2002). Work-schedule characteristics and reported musculoskeletal disorders or registered nurses. Scandinavian Journal of Work, Environment and Health, 28(6), 394–401.Google Scholar
- Lipsey, M. (2000). Statistical conclusion validity for intervention research: A significant (p < .05) problem. In L. Bickman (Ed.), Validity and social experimentation: Donald Campbell’s legacy (pp. 101–120). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.Google Scholar
- Lowden, A., Kecklund, G., Axelsson, J., & Akerstedt, T. (1998). Change from an 8-hour shift to a 12-hour shift, attitudes, sleep, sleepiness and performance. Scandinavian Journal of Work, Environment and Health, 24(3), 69–75.Google Scholar
- McCreary, D., & Thompson, M. (2004). The development of a reliable and valid measure of stressors in policing. A Summary of Findings from WSIB Development Grant #02-051. Toronto, ON: Stress and Coping Group, Defence R&D Canada.Google Scholar
- Melekian, B. K. (1999). Alternative work schedules and the twelve-hour shift. Subject to Debate, 13(8/9), 1–2.Google Scholar
- Nielsen, G. (2007). Managing fatigue a new approach to an old problem. Journal of California Law Enforcement, 41, 22–26.Google Scholar
- Northrup, H. R. (1991). The twelve-hour shift in the North American mini-steel industry. Journal of Labor Research, 12(3). doi: 10.1007/BF02685463.
- Oliver, B. (2005, July). Ten-hour shifts: A good fit. Law and Order. Retrieved from http://www.hendonpub.com/resources/articlearchive/details.aspx?ID=179.
- Petticrew, M., Bambra, C., Whitehead, M., Sowden, A., & Akers, J. (2007). The health and wellbeing effects of changing the organization of shift work: A systematic review. London: Public Health Research Consortium.Google Scholar
- Pilcher, J. J., & Huffcutt, A. I. (1996). Effects of Sleep deprivation on performance: A meta-analysis. Sleep, 19, 318–326.Google Scholar
- Rosa, R. R., & Colligan, M. J. (1988). Long workdays versus restdays: Assessing fatigue and alertness with a portable performance battery. Human Factors, 30(3), 305–317.Google Scholar
- Rosa, R. R., & Colligan, M. J. (1992). Application of a portable test battery in the assessment of fatigue in a laboratory and worksite studies of 12-hour shifts. Scandinavian Journal of Work, Environment and Health, 18(2), 113–115.Google Scholar
- Rosekind, M. R., & Schwartz, G. E. (1988). Perception of sleep and wakefulness: Accuracy and certainty of subjective judgments. Sleep Research, 17, 89.Google Scholar
- Rosenthal, T. J., Parseghian, Z., Allen, R. W., & Stein, A. C. (1995). STISIM: The low-cost driving simulator. Hawthorne, CA: Systems Technology, Inc.Google Scholar
- Ruegg, R. L. (1987). Reported anxiety on work shifts for coronary care nurses (Doctoral dissertation). Muncie, IN: Ball State University.Google Scholar
- Scott, A., & Kittaning, P. A. (2001, April). Shift work hazards. Jacksonville Medicine. Retrieved from http://www.dcmsonline.org/jax-medicine/2001journals/April2001/shiftwork.htm.
- Stenzel, W., & Buren, R. (1983). Police work scheduling: Management issues and practices. Evanston, IL: Northwestern University Center for Public Safety.Google Scholar
- Stone, P. W., Du, Y., Cowell, R., Amsterdam, N., Helfrich, T. A., Linn, R. W., et al. (2006). Comparison of nurse, system and quality patient care outcomes in 8-hour and 12- hour shifts. Medical Care, 44(12). doi: 10.1097/01.mlr.0000237180.72275.82.
- Sundermeier, J. (2008). A look at the 12-hour shift: The Lincoln police department study. The Police Chief, 75(3).Google Scholar
- Szczurak, T., Kaminska, E., & Szpak, A. (2007). Estimation of the psychological load in the performance of nurses’ work based on subjective fatigue symptoms. Advances in Medical Science, 52(1), 102–104.Google Scholar
- Ugrovics, A., & Wright, J. (1990). 12-hour shifts: Does fatigue undermine ICU nursing judgments? Nursing Management, 21(1), 64A–64G.Google Scholar
- van der Hulst, M. (2003). Long work hours and health. Scandinavian Journal of Work, Environment and Health, 29(3), 171–188.Google Scholar
- Vega, A., & Gilbert, M. J. (1997). Longer days, shorter weeks: Compressed work weeks in policing. Public Personnel Management, 26(3), 391–402.Google Scholar
- Walker, R. B., & Eisenberg, C. (1995). The 12-hour, fixed shift measuring satisfaction. FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin, 64, 18–20.Google Scholar
- Washburn, M. S. (1991). Fatigue and critical thinking on eight-and twelve-hour shifts. Nursing Management, 22(9), 80A, 80D, 80 F-80H.Google Scholar
- Weisburd, D., & Buerger, M. (1986). Alternative work schedules for the Piscataway (NJ) police department. Rutgers, Newark, NJ: Unpublished manuscript, School of Criminal Justice.Google Scholar
- Weiss, D. J., Dawis, R. V., England, G. W., & Lofquist, L. H. (1967). Minnesota studies in vocational rehabilitation: XXII. Manual for the Minnesota satisfaction questionnaire. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota.Google Scholar
- White, J., & Beswick, J. (2003). Working long hours. Sheffield: Health and Safety Laboratory.Google Scholar