Plant Ecology

, Volume 178, Issue 2, pp 249–264 | Cite as

Non-indigenous grasses impede woody succession

  • Mark A. DavisEmail author
  • Louise Bier
  • Ethan Bushelle
  • Chloe Diegel
  • Aleta Johnson
  • Brianna Kujala


With the proliferation of old fields and the decline of native grasslands in North America, non-indigenous grasses, which tend to colonize and dominate North American old fields, have become progressively more abundant. These new grasses can differ from native grasses in a number of ways, including root and shoot morphology (e.g., density of root mat, height of shoots), growth phenology (e.g., cool season vs. warm season growth), and plant–soil–water relations due to differences in photosynthetic physiology (C3 vs. C4). Woody plants have been slow to colonize some old fields in the prairie-forest border area of North America and it is hypothesized that non-indigenous grasses may be contributing to the poor establishment success of woody plants in this region, possibly through more intense competition for resources. To test this hypothesis, a multi-factorial field experiment was conducted in which water, nitrogen, and grass functional group (non-indigenous C3 and native C4 species) were manipulated in a study of survival of oak seedlings. The grass type variously affected some of the different growth measurements, however, the effects of grass type on seedling growth were small compared to the effects on seedling survival. The results showed that when grown under dry conditions, seedlings growing in non-indigenous grasses experienced up to a 50% reduction in survival compared to those growing in native grasses under the same conditions. Analyses of root and shoot competition showed that the cause for the reduced survival in the non-indigenous grasses was due primarily to underground processes. The findings confirmed our initial hypothesis that non-indigenous grasses are likely contributing to the poor establishment success of woody plants in these old fields. However, the explanation for the reduced oak seedling survival in non-indigenous grasses does not appear to be due to reduced resource availability since soil water levels did not differ between non-indigenous and native grass plots and other resource levels measured (light, NO3, and NH4) were higher in non-indigenous grass plots under dry conditions. An alternative explanation is that the non-indigenous grasses modify the soil environment in ways that, under dry conditions, are deleterious to emerging oak seedlings. Since current climate projections for the upper Midwest are for hotter and drier summers, the results suggest that the resistance of these old fields to oak encroachment will likely increase in the future.


Old fields Quercus Resource availability Succession Woody seedling establishment 


Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.


  1. Archer, S. 1989Have southern Texas savannas been converted to woodlands in recent history?Am. Natural134545561CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Augspurger, C.K. 1984Seedling survival of tropical tree species: interactions of dispersal distancelight gaps, and pathogensEcology6517051712Google Scholar
  3. Barkley, T.M. eds. 1986Flora of the Great PlainsUniversity Press of KansasLawrenceKansasGoogle Scholar
  4. Bastl, M., Kocar, P., Prach, K., Pysek, P. 1997The effect of successional age and disturbance on the establishment of alien plants in man-made sites: an experimental approachBrock, J.H.Wade, M.Pysek, P.Green, D. eds. Plant Invasions: Studies from North America and EuropeBackhuys PublishersLeiden, The Netherlands191201Google Scholar
  5. Bertness, M.D., Callaway, R. 1994Positive interactions in communitiesTrends Ecol. Evol9191193Google Scholar
  6. Bever, J.D., Westover, K.M., Antonovics, J. 1997Incorporating the soil community into plant population dynamics: the utility of the feedback approachJ. Ecol85561573Google Scholar
  7. Callaway, R.M., Aschehoug, E.T. 2000Invasive plants versus their new and old neighbors: a mechanism for exotic invasionScience290521523CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  8. Christian, J.M, Wilson, S.D. 1999Long-term ecosystem impacts of an introduced grass in the northern great plainsEcology8023972407Google Scholar
  9. Curtis, J.T. 1959The Vegetation of WisconsinUniversity of Wisconsin PressMadisonGoogle Scholar
  10. D’Antonio, C.M., Vitousek, P.M. 1992Biological invasions by exotic grasses, the grass/fire/cyle and global changeAnnu. Rev. Ecol. System236387Google Scholar
  11. Danner, B.T., Knapp, A.K. 2003Abiotic constraints on the establishment of Quercus seedlings in grasslandGlobal Change Biol9266275CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Davis, M.A., Duke, A., Ibsen, T., Tran, H., Rhodes, R. 1997Spatial distribution of Penstemon grandiflorus (Nutt.) and Geomys bursarius in a fragmented oak woodland in MinnesotaUSANat. Areas J17136143Google Scholar
  13. Davis, M.A., Pelsor, M. 2001Experimental support for a resource-based mechanistic model of invasiblityEcol. Lett4421428CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Davis, M.A., Thompson, K., Grime, J.P. 2001Charles S. Elton and the dissociation of invasion ecology from the rest of ecologyDiv. Distrib797102CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Davis, M.A., Wrage, K.J., Reich, P.B. 1998Competition between tree seedlings and herbaceous vegetation: support for a theory of resource supply and demandJ. Ecol86652661CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Davis, M.A., Wrage, K.J., Reich, P.B., Tjoelker, M.G., Schaeffer, T., Muermann, C. 1999Survival, growthand photosynthesis of tree seedlings competing with herbaceous vegetation along a water-light-nitrogen gradientPlant Ecol145341350CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. del Moral, R. 1985Competitive effects on the structure of subalpine meadow communitiesCan. J. Bot6314441452Google Scholar
  18. de Steven, D. 1991Experiments on mechanisms of tree establishment in oldfield succession: seedling survival and growthEcology7210761088Google Scholar
  19. Ganade, G., Brown, V.K. 2002Succession in old pastures of central Amazonia: role of soil fertility and plant litterEcology83743754Google Scholar
  20. Gill, D.S., Marks, P.L. 1991Tree and shrub seedling colonization of old fields in central New YorkEcol. Monogr62183205Google Scholar
  21. Goldberg, D.E., Gross, K.L. 1988Disturbance regimes of mid-successional old fieldsEcology6916771688Google Scholar
  22. Gordon, D.R., Welker, J.M., Menke, J.W., Rice, K.J. 1989Competition for soil water between annual plants and blue oak (Quercus douglasii) seedlingsOecologia79533541CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Grayston, S.J., Griffith, G.S., Mawdsley, J.L., Campbell, C.D., Bardgett, R.D. 2001Accounting for variability in soil microbial communities of temperate upland grassland ecosystemsSoil Biol. Biochem33533551CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Grigal D.F., Chamberlain L.M., Finney H.R., Wroblewki D.V. and Gross E.R. 1974. Soils of the Cedar Creek Natural History Area. Miscellaneous Report 123, University of Minnesota Agricultural Experiment Station, St. Paul, Minnesota.Google Scholar
  25. Hobbs, R.J., Huenneke, L.J. 1992Disturbancediversity and invasion: implications for conservationConserv. Biol6324337CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Holmgren, M., Scheffer, M., Huston, M.A. 1997The interplay of facilitation and competition in plant communitiesEcology7819661975Google Scholar
  27. Inouye, R.S., Allison, T.D., Johnson, N.C. 1994Old field succession on a Minnesota sand plain: effects of deer and other factors on invasion by treesBull. Torrey Bot. Club121266276Google Scholar
  28. Jackson, R.B., Canadell, J., Ehleringer, J.R., Mooney, H.A., Sala, O.E., Schulze, E.D. 1996A global analysis of root distribution for terrestrial biomesOecol108389411CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. James, S.E., Meelis, P., Wilson, S.D., Peltzer, D.A. 2003Temporal heterogeneity of soil moisture in grassland and forestJ. Ecol91234239CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Johnson, N.C., Tilman, D., Wedin, D. 1992Plant and soil controls on mycorrhizal fungal communitiesEcology7320342042Google Scholar
  31. Johnson, N.C., Zak, D.R., Tilman, D., Pfleger, F.L. 1991Dynamics of vesicular-arbuscular mycorrhizae during old field successionOecologia86349358CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Kling, G.W., Hayhoe, K., Johnson, L.B., Magnuson, J.J., Polasky, S., Robinson, S.K., Shuter, B.J., Wander, M.M., Wuebbles, D.J., Zak, D., Lindroth, R.L., Moser, S.C., Wilson, M.L.R. 2003Confronting Climate Change in the Great Lakes Region; Impacts on our Communities and EcosystemsUnion of Concerned ScientistsCambridgeMassachusettsEcological Society of AmericaWashington, DC.Google Scholar
  33. Kloss S. and McBride J.R. 2002. Geographic variation in biomass production of California blue oak seedlings and water. USDA Forest Service General Technical Report PSW-GTR-184.Google Scholar
  34. Kochy, M., Wilson, S.D. 2001Nitrogen deposition and forest expansion in the northern Great PlainsJ. Ecol89807817CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Lawson, D., Inouye, R.S., Huntly, N., Carson, W.P. 1999Patterns of woody plant abundancerecruitmentmortality and growth in a 65 year chronosequence of old-fieldsPlant Ecol145267279CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. McArthur E.D., Blauer A.C., Monsen S.B. and Sanderson S.C. 1995. Plant inventory, succession and reclamation alternatives on disturbed lands in Grand Teton National Park. In: Roundy B.A., McArthur E.D., Haley J.S., Mann D.K. (eds), Proceedings: Wildland Shrub and Arid Land Restoration Symposium 1993, October 19–21, Las Vegas, NV, U.S. Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Intermountain Research Station. General Technical Report INT-GTR-315, Ogden, UT, pp. 343-358Google Scholar
  37. McPherson, G.R. 1997Ecology and Management of North American SavannasUniversity of Tucson PressTucson, AZGoogle Scholar
  38. Myster, R.W., McCarthy, B.C. 1989Effects of herbivory and competition on survival of Carya tomentosa (Juglandaceae) seedlingsOikos56145148Google Scholar
  39. Packer, A., Clay, K. 2000Soil pathogens and spatial patterns of seedling mortality in a temperate treeNature404278281CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  40. Peterson, D.W., Reich, P.B. 2001Prescribed fire in oak savanna: fire frequency effects on stand structure and dynamicsEcol. Appl11914927Google Scholar
  41. Rejmánek, M. 1989Invasibility of plant communitiesDrake, J.Mooney, H.A.Di Castri, F.Groves, R.H.Kruger, F.J.Rejmánek, M.Williamson, M. eds. Biological Invasions: a Global PerspectiveWileyChichester369388Google Scholar
  42. Rice, K.J., Gordon, D.R., Hardison, J.L., Welker, J.M. 1993Phenotypic variation in seedlings of a “keystone” tree species (Quercus douglasii): the interactive effects of acorn source and competitive environmentOecologia96537547CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Tilman, D. 1987Secondary succession and the pattern of plant dominance along experimental nitrogen gradientsEcol. Monogr57189214Google Scholar
  44. Tilman, D., Wedin, D. 1991Plant traits and resource reduction for five grasses growing on a nitrogen gradientEcology72685700Google Scholar
  45. Van Auken, O.W. 2000Shrub invasions of North American semiarid grasslandsAnnu. Rev. Ecol. System31197215CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Vitousek, P.M., Walker, L.R., Whiteaker, L.D., Mueller-Dombois, D., Matson, P.A. 1987Biological invasion by Myrica faya alters ecosystem development in HawaiiScience238802804Google Scholar
  47. Weltzin, J., Archer, S., Heitschmidt, R. 1997Small-mammal regulation of vegetation structure in a temperate savannaEcology78751763Google Scholar
  48. Weste, G. 1986Vegetation changes associated with invasion by Phytophthora cinnamomi of defined plots in the Brisbane Ranges, Victoria1975–1985Aust. J. Bot34633648Google Scholar
  49. Westover, K.M., Kennedy, A.C., Kelley, S.E. 1997Patterns of rhizosphere microbial community structure associated with co-occurring plant speciesJ. Ecol85863873Google Scholar
  50. Williams, P.A. 1983Secondary vegetation succession on the Port Hills Banks PeninsulaCanterbury, New ZealandNew Zealand J. Bot21237247Google Scholar
  51. Williams, P.A. 1992Hakea salicifolia: biology and role in succession in Abel Tasman National Park, New ZealandJ. R. Soc. New Zealand22118Google Scholar
  52. Wilson, S.D. 1993Belowground competition in forest and prairieOikos68146150Google Scholar
  53. Wilson, S.D. 2000Heterogeneity, diversity, and scale in plant communitiesHutchings, M.J.John, E.A.Stewart, A.J. eds. Ecological Consequences of Habitat HeterogeneityBlackwell ScienceOxford5369Google Scholar
  54. Wilson, S.D., Tilman, D. 1991Components of plant competition along an experimental gradient of nitrogen availabilityEcology7210501065Google Scholar
  55. Wovcha, D.S., Delaney, B.C., Nordquist, G.E. 1995Minnesota’s St. Croix River Valley and Anoka SandplainUniversity of Minnesota PressMinneapolis, MNGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer 2005

Authors and Affiliations

  • Mark A. Davis
    • 1
    Email author
  • Louise Bier
    • 1
  • Ethan Bushelle
    • 1
  • Chloe Diegel
    • 1
  • Aleta Johnson
    • 1
  • Brianna Kujala
    • 1
  1. 1.Department of BiologyMacalester CollegeSaint PaulUSA

Personalised recommendations