Intuition and Visualization in Mathematical Problem Solving Article First Online: 09 February 2010
3
Citations
423
Downloads
Abstract In this article, I will discuss the relationship between mathematical intuition and mathematical visualization. I will argue that in order to investigate this relationship, it is necessary to consider mathematical activity as a complex phenomenon, which involves many different cognitive resources. I will focus on two kinds of danger in recurring to visualization and I will show that they are not a good reason to conclude that visualization is not reliable, if we consider its use in mathematical practice. Then, I will give an example of mathematical reasoning with a figure, and show that both visualization and intuition are involved. I claim that mathematical intuition depends on background knowledge and expertise, and that it allows to see the generality of the conclusions obtained by means of visualization.

Keywords Mathematical intuition Mathematical visualization Diagrammatic reasoning Problem-solving

References Barwise J, Etchemendy J (1996) Visual information and valid reasoning. In: Allwein G, Barwise J (eds) Logical reasoning with diagrams. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 3–25

Google Scholar Bråting K, Pejlare J (2008) Visualizations in mathematics. Erkenntnis 68(3):345–358

CrossRef Google Scholar Cantor G (1915) Contributions to the founding of the theory of transfinite numbers (transl: Jourdain PEB). Dover Publications, New York

Google Scholar Feferman S (2000) Mathematical intuition vs. mathematical monsters. Synthese 125:317–332

CrossRef Google Scholar Fischbein E (1987) Intuition in science and mathematics. Kluwer, Dordrecht

Google Scholar Giardino V, Piazza M (2008) Senza Parole. Ragionare con le Immagini. Milan, Bompiani

Google Scholar Gödel K (1986) Collected works. Oxford University Press, Oxford

Google Scholar Hadamard J (1945) An essay on the psychology of invention in the mathematical field. Princeton University Press, Princeton

Google Scholar Klein F (2004) Elementary mathematics from an advanced standpoint (transl: Hedrick ER, Noble CAM). Courier Dover Publications. The first German edition is 1908

Google Scholar Mancosu P (2001) Mathematical explanation: problems and prospects. Topoi 20:97–117

CrossRef Google Scholar Mancosu P (2005) Visualization in logic and mathematics. In Mancosu P, Jørgensen KF, Pedersen SA (eds) Visualization, explanation and reasoning styles in mathematics. Springer-Verlag, Berlin, pp 13–30

CrossRef Google Scholar Nelsen R (1997) Proofs without words: exercises in visual thinking. The Mathematical Association of America, Washington, DC

Google Scholar Nelsen R (2001) Proofs without words II: more exercises in visual thinking. The Mathematical Association of America, Washington, DC

Google Scholar Netz R (1999) The shaping of deduction in Greek mathematics: a study in cognitive history. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge

CrossRef Google Scholar Polya G (1945) How to solve it. Princeton University Press, Princeton

Google Scholar Rota GC (1997) The phenomenology of mathematical proof. In: Kamamori A (ed) Proof and progress in mathematics. Kluwer, Dordrecht, pp 183–196

Google Scholar Shin S-J (1994) The logical status of diagrams. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge

Google Scholar Shin S-J (2004) Heterogenous reasoning and its logic. The Bullettin of Symbolic Logic 10:86–106

CrossRef Google Scholar © Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2010

Authors and Affiliations 1. Institut Jean Nicod CNRS Paris France