Tertiary Education and Management

, Volume 11, Issue 3, pp 239–258 | Cite as

Quality Assurance of Higher Education in Transition Countries: Accreditation -- Accountability and Assessment



One issue facing countries in transition concerns how to ensure quality for a broader and more diverse set of institutions. Quality assurance processes (i.e. accreditation, accountability and assessment) have particular relevance today as higher education undergoes dramatic changes in countries in transition, as the world becomes more internationalised, and as private higher education institutions increase in number and enrol increasing numbers of students. Three questions emerge. Do differences among transition countries relative to central control prior to independence explain the current set of quality assurance mechanisms? Has the growth of private higher education in transition countries affected how quality assurance is conceptualised? Have quality assurance mechanisms been affected by the opening of branch campuses in transition countries?


Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.


  1. Alexander, F.K. 2000The changing face of accountability: Monitoring and assessing institutional performance in higher educationThe Journal of Higher Education71411431Google Scholar
  2. Anderson C.J. (1987). Survey of Accreditation Issues, 1986. (Higher Education Panel Report No. 74). Washington, DC: American Council on Education. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED283427)Google Scholar
  3. Barbee, D.E., Bouck, A.J. 1974Accountability in educationPetrocelliNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  4. Bartlett, T. & Smallwood S. (2004, June 25) What’s a diploma mill? The Chronicle of Higher Education A1Google Scholar
  5. Bloland, H.G. 2001Creating the Council for Higher Education AccreditationGreenwood Publishing Group, Inc. and American EducationWestport, CTGoogle Scholar
  6. Bogue, E.G., Aper, J. 2000Exploring the Heritage of American Higher Education: The Evolution of Philosophy and PolicyAmerican Council on Education and Oryx PressPhoenix, AZGoogle Scholar
  7. Bok, D. 2003Universities in the Marketplace: The Commercialization of Higher EducationPrinceton University PressPrinceton, NJGoogle Scholar
  8. Bollag, B. (2004, July 14). Opening the door on accreditation. The Chronicle of Higher Education A22–A24Google Scholar
  9. Clark, B.R. 1998Creating Entrepreneurial UniversitiesPergamonNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  10. Collinge, B. 2004Impact of private-sector university growth on the societies of post-communist Europe: A case study from SlovakiaQuality Assurance in Education12186196Google Scholar
  11. Conway, M.W. 1979The commissioner’s authority to list accrediting agencies and associations: Necessity for an eligibility issueJournal of Higher Education50158170Google Scholar
  12. Council of Europe (1997). Convention on the recognition of qualifications concerning higher education in the European Region. European Treaty Series No. 165, Council of Europe, LisbonGoogle Scholar
  13. Dons bring in the dough. (2003, December 5). The Economist 53–54Google Scholar
  14. Eaton, J.S. (2001, March/April). Regional accreditation reform: Who is served? Change 39–45Google Scholar
  15. El Khawas, E., Pietro-Jurand, R., Holm-Nielsen, L. 1998Quality assurance in higher education: Recent progress challenges aheadThe World BankWashington, DCGoogle Scholar
  16. El-Khawas, E. 2002

    Quality assurance for higher education: Shaping effective policy in developing countries

    Chapman, D.W.Austin, A.E. eds. Higher Education in the Developing World: Changing Contexts and Institutional ResponsesGreenwood Publishing Group IncWestport, CT197215
    Google Scholar
  17. Elman, S.E. 1994Academic freedom and regional accreditation: Guarantors of quality in the academyNew Directions for Higher Education8889100Google Scholar
  18. Engdahl, L.E. 1981Objectives, objections, and opinions: Current perceptions of regional accreditationNorth Central Association Quarterly56313Google Scholar
  19. Ezeamii, H.C. 1996Cultural diversity and regional accreditation: A summary of issues and a survey of academic leadersEquity & Excellence in Education298291Google Scholar
  20. Foster, A.L. (2002, April 12). Moonlighting for an unaccredited university. The Chronicle of Higher Education A35–A36Google Scholar
  21. Geiger L.G. (1970). Voluntary Accreditation: A history of the North Central Association – 1945-Menasha. WI: George Banta CompanyGoogle Scholar
  22. Gratch-Lindauer, B. (2002, Jan–Mar). Comparing regional accreditation standards: Outcomes assessment and other trends. The Journal of Academic Librarianship 28, 14–25Google Scholar
  23. Johnstone, D.B. 2001The Financing and Management of Higher Education: A Status Report on Worldwide ReformsThe World BankWashington, DCGoogle Scholar
  24. Keller, R.J. 1980

    Accreditation of higher education in the USA

    Synn, I. eds. The Pursuit of Excellence in Higher EducationKeimyuing UniversityDaegu Korea423456
    Google Scholar
  25. Kells, H.R. 1976The Reform of Regional Accrediting AgenciesEducational Record572424Google Scholar
  26. Kells, H.R. (1997, March). The Higher Education Quality: Evaluation and Accreditation Movement: An International Retrospective Analysis. Paper presented at the staff workshop of the World Bank, Washington, DCGoogle Scholar
  27. Kells, H.R., Kirkwood, R. 1979Institutional self-evaluation processesEducational Record602545Google Scholar
  28. Knight, J. 1999

    Internationalisation of higher education

    de Wit, H.Knight, J. eds. Quality and Internationalization in Higher EducationOrganisation for Economic Co-operation and DevelopmentParis1328
    Google Scholar
  29. Kouptsov, O. & Tatur, Y. (2001). Quality Assurance in Higher Education in the Russian Federation. (Papers on Higher Education). Bucharest: UNESCO-CEPESGoogle Scholar
  30. Layzell, D.T. 1998Linking performance to funding outcomes for public institutions of higher educationThe US European Journal of Education33103111Google Scholar
  31. Leatherman, C. (1993, January 6). Regional accrediting agencies face questions about why- and when- they sanction colleges. The Chronicle of Higher Education A15–A16Google Scholar
  32. Lenn, M.P. (2002, March 1). The right way to export higher education. The Chronicle of Higher Education B24Google Scholar
  33. Levine, A. 1997How the academic profession is changing DaedalusThe American academic profession126120Google Scholar
  34. Lewis, D.R., Hearn, J. 2003The Public Research UniversityUniversity Press of AmericaLanham, MDGoogle Scholar
  35. Lewis, D.R., Hendel, D., Demyanchuk, A. 2003Private Higher Education in Transition CountriesPublishing House KM AcademiaKiev, UkraineGoogle Scholar
  36. Lin-Liu, J. (2001, September 14). A developing country attempts accreditation. The Chronicle of Higher Education A49–A50Google Scholar
  37. Lopez, C. (1999, Summer). General education: Regional accreditation standards and expectations. Liberal Education 85, 46–51Google Scholar
  38. Macwilliams, B. (2001, December 14). For Russia’s universities, a decade of more freedom and less money. The Chronicle of Higher Education A42–A46Google Scholar
  39. Martin, G. (2004). Quality assurance in the global higher education market. Birmingham, UK: University of Birmingham. Unpublished manuscriptGoogle Scholar
  40. McMurthie, B. (2001, January 12). Regional accreditors punish colleges rarely and inconsistently. The Chronicle of Higher Education, A27–A29Google Scholar
  41. Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. (1999). Tertiary education and research in the Russian federation. Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, Center for Co-operation with Non-Members. Paris: OECD PublicationsGoogle Scholar
  42. Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. (2001). Reviews of national policies for education: Estonia Education and skills. Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. Center for Co-operation with Non-Members. Paris: OECD PublicationsGoogle Scholar
  43. Patton, G.W. 1999Outcomes for improvement and accountability: The role of state and regional accreditation boardsJournal of Staff, Program & Organization Development16221224Google Scholar
  44. Peterson, M.W., Augustine, C.H. 2000Organizational practices enhancing the influence of student assessment information in academic decisionsResearch in Higher Education412152CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Phillips, B.C., Song, L., Tom, D. 2001Evaluating the Evaluators: Round 2, How Participants View Accreditation Standards, Practices, and ResultsAccrediting Commission for Community and Junior Colleges of the Western Association of Colleges and SchoolsAptos, CAGoogle Scholar
  46. Pigge, F.L. (1979). Opinions About Accreditation and Interagency Cooperation: The Results of a Nationwide Survey of COPA Institutions. Washington, DC: Council on Postsecondary Accreditation. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED177944)Google Scholar
  47. Private education in Central Europe: Less of the state, please. (2002, January 5). The Economist 41Google Scholar
  48. Proffitt, J.R. 1979The federal connection for accreditationJournal of Higher Education50145157Google Scholar
  49. Purposes, Policies, and Performance: Higher Education and the Fulfillment of a State’s Public Agenda. (2003, February). The National Center for Public Policy and Higher EducationGoogle Scholar
  50. Regel, O. (1992). The academic credit system in higher education: Effectiveness and relevance in developing countries (PHREE Background Paper Series No. 92/59). Washington, DC: The World BankGoogle Scholar
  51. Robinson-Weening, L. 1994An Assessment of the Effectiveness of Regional AccreditationNew England Association of Schools and Colleges, Commission on Institutions of Higher EducationBedford, MAGoogle Scholar
  52. Romine, S. 1979Objectives, objections, and opinions: Some perceptions of regional accreditationNorth Central Association Quarterly49365375Google Scholar
  53. Ruch, R.S. (2001). Higher Ed. Inc.: The rise of the for-profit university. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University.Google Scholar
  54. Sadlak, J. 1994The emergence of a diversified system: The state/private predicament in transforming higher education in RomaniaEuropean Journal of Education291323Google Scholar
  55. Second Newman report: National policy and higher education. (1973). Report of a Special Task Force to the Secretary of Health, Education, and Welfare. Cambridge, MA: MIT PressGoogle Scholar
  56. Shawen, N.M. 1983The evolution of regional accreditation in higher education: The role of the North Central Association, 1895-1934Assessment and Evaluation in Higher Education8118Google Scholar
  57. Stetar, J., Stocker, J. 1997Reform and innovation: Ukraine’s new private universitiesInternational Higher Education71415Google Scholar
  58. Task Force on Higher Education and Society (2000). Higher Education in Developing Countries: Peril and Promise. Washington, DC: The World Bank/UNESCOGoogle Scholar
  59. Thrash, P. 1979Accreditation: A perspectiveThe Journal of Higher Education50115120Google Scholar
  60. Troutt, W.E. 1979Regional accreditation evaluative criteria and quality assuranceJournal of Higher Education5199210Google Scholar
  61. UNESCO Center for Higher Education. (2000). Peril and Promise: Higher Education in Developing Countries. Washington, DC: World/Bank/UNESCO.Google Scholar
  62. Van der Wende, M. 1999

    Quality assurance of internationalisation and internationalisation of quality assurance

    H. de, WitJ., Knight eds. Quality and Internationalisation in Higher EducationOrganisation for Economic Co-operation and DevelopmentParis225240
    Google Scholar
  63. Von Alt, K. 20022001–2002 Accredited Institutions of Postsecondary EducationGreenwood Publishing Group and American Council on EducationWestport, CTGoogle Scholar
  64. Wellman, J.V. (2001, March/April). Assessing state accountability systems. Change, 47–52Google Scholar
  65. Whiteside, J., Hendel, D.D., Dundar, H. & Kvavik R. (1977, May). Closing the Loop: Institutional Performance Measures. Presentation at the 37th Annual Forum of the Association for Institutional Research, Orlando, FloridaGoogle Scholar
  66. Williams, G. (ed). (2003). The Enterprising University: Reform, Excellence and Equity. London: The Society for Research into Higher Education and Open University PressGoogle Scholar
  67. Woodhouse, D. 1999

    Quality and quality assurance

    Wit, H.Knight, J. eds. Quality and Internationalisation in Higher EducationOrganisation for Economic Co-operation and DevelopmentParis2944
    Google Scholar
  68. Wooodard, C. (2002, May 5). Worldwide tuition increases send students into the streets. The Chronicle of Higher Education A54–A56Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer 2005

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Department of Educational Policy and AdministrationCollege of Education and Human DevelopmentMinneapolisUSA

Personalised recommendations