Empirical incoherence and double functionalism
- 31 Downloads
Recent work on quantum gravity (QG) suggests that neither spacetime nor spatiotemporally located entites exist at a fundamental level. The loss of both brings with it the threat of empirical incoherence. A theory is empirically incoherent when the truth of that theory undermines the empirical justification for believing it. If neither spacetime nor spatiotemporally located entities exist as a part of a fundamental theory of QG, then such a theory seems to imply that there are no observables and so no way that the theory can be confirmed. The threat of empirical incoherence can be addressed by treating spacetime and spatiotemporally located entities as emergent. The question then arises as to what the metaphysical nature of this emergence might be. In this paper, I explore a functionalist approach to this kind of emergence in the context of loop quantum gravity. I begin by rehearsing the spacetime functionalist’s account of emergence, clarifying the view along the way. I proceed to sketch out a functionalist treatment of spatiotemporally located entities and combine the two forms of functionalism into a double functionalism, according to which both spacetime and matter have the same functional realisers.
KeywordsSpacetime Functionalism Loop quantum gravity Quantum gravity Empirical incoherence Observation Helon
Funding was provided by The Australian Research Council (Grant No. DE180100414), Australian Research Council (Grant No. DP180100105).
- Barrett, J. A. (1999). The quantum mechanics of minds and worlds. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Bilson-Thompson, S., Hackett, J., Kauffman, L., & Wan, Y. (2012). Emergent braided matter of quantum geometry. SIGMA, 8, 14–47.Google Scholar
- Bilson-Thompson, S. O. (2005). A topological model of composite preons. arXiv:hep-ph/0503213.
- Butterfield, J., & Isham, C. (1999). On the emergence of time in quantum gravity. In J. Butterfield (Ed.), The arguments of time (pp. 111–168). Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Lehmkuhl, D. (2016). The metaphysics of super-substantivalism. Noüs, 52, 2.Google Scholar
- Norton, J. D. (ms). Loop quantum ontology: spin-networks and spacetime. http://philsci-archive.pitt.edu/12016/.
- Wüthrich, C. (2017). Raiders of the lost spacetime. In D. Lehmkuhl, G. Schiemann, & E. Scholz (Eds.), Towards a theory of spacetime theories. Birkhäuser: Basal.Google Scholar
- Wüthrich, C. (2019). The emergence of space and time. In S. Gibb, R. F. Hendry, & T. Lancaster (Eds.), Routledge handbook of emergence. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
- Yates, D. (forthcoming). Thinking about spacetime. In C. Wüthrich, B. Le Bihan, & N. Huggett (Eds.), Philosophy beyond spacetime. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Google Scholar