Synthese

, Volume 190, Issue 13, pp 2573–2593 | Cite as

The epistemology of absence-based inference

  • Nikolaj Jang Lee Linding Pedersen
  • Jesper Kallestrup
Article

Abstract

Our main aim in this paper is to contribute towards a better understanding of the epistemology of absence-based inferences. Many absence-based inferences are classified as fallacies. There are exceptions, however. We investigate what features make absence-based inferences epistemically good or reliable. In Section 2 we present Sanford Goldberg’s account of the reliability of absence-based inference, introducing the central notion of epistemic coverage. In Section 3 we approach the idea of epistemic coverage through a comparison of alethic and evidential principles. The Equivalence Schema–a well-known alethic principle–says that it is true that \(p\) if and only if \(p\). We take epistemic coverage to underwrite a suitably qualified evidential analogue of the Equivalence Schema: for a high proportion of values of \(p\), subject \(S\) has evidence that \(p\) due to her reliance on source \(S^{*}\) if and only if \(p\). We show how this evidential version of the Equivalence Schema suffices for the reliability of certain absence-based inferences. Section 4 is dedicated to exploring consequences of the Evidential Equivalence Schema. The slogan ‘absence of evidence is evidence of absence’ has received a lot of bad press. More elaborately, what has received a lot of bad press is something like the following idea: absence of evidence sufficiently good to justify belief in \(p\) is evidence sufficiently good to justify belief in \(\sim p\). A striking consequence of the Evidential Equivalence Schema is that absence of evidence sufficiently good to justify belief in p is evidence sufficiently good to justify belief in \(\sim p\). We establish this claim in Section 4 and show how this supports the reliability of an additional type of absence-based inference. Section 4 immediately raises the following question: how can we make philosophically good sense of the idea that absence of evidence is evidence of absence? We address this question in Section 5. Section 6 contains some summary remarks.

Keywords

Fallacy of ignorance Epistemic coverage Absence-based inference Absence-based belief Sanford Goldberg Alethic principles Evidential principles Absence of evidence Evidence of absence Reliabilism 

References

  1. Copi, I. (1953). Introduction to logic. New York: Macmillan.Google Scholar
  2. Gelfert, A. (forthcoming). Coverage-reliability, epistemic dependence, and the problem of rumor-based belief. Philosophia. doi:10.1007/s11406-012-9408-z.
  3. Goldberg, S. (2011). If that were true I would have heard about it by now. In A. Goldman & D. Whitcomb (Eds.), The Oxford handbook of social epistemology (pp. 92–108). Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  4. Goldberg, S. (2010a). Relying on others: An essay in epistemology. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Goldberg, S. (2010b). The epistemology of silence. In A. Haddock, A. Millar, & D. Pritchard (Eds.), Social epistemology (pp. 243–261). Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Hurley, P. (2011). A concise introduction to logic (11th ed.). Boston: Wadsworth Publishing.Google Scholar
  7. Sober, E. (2009). Absence of evidence and evidence of absence: Evidential transitivity in connection with fossils, fishing, fine-tuning, and firing squads. Philosophical Studies, 143, 63–90.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Walton, D. (1999). The appeal to ignorance, or argumentum ad ignorantiam. Argumentation, 13, 367–377.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media Dordrecht 2013

Authors and Affiliations

  • Nikolaj Jang Lee Linding Pedersen
    • 1
  • Jesper Kallestrup
    • 2
  1. 1.Underwood International College, Yonsei University International Campus, Veritas Hall B, 434IncheonSouth Korea
  2. 2.Department of Philosophy, School of Philosophy, Psychology and Language Sciences, University of EdinburghEdinburghUK

Personalised recommendations