Life without definitions
- First Online:
The question ‘what is life?’ has long been a source of philosophical debate and in recent years has taken on increasing scientific importance. The most popular approach among both philosophers and scientists for answering this question is to provide a “definition” of life. In this article I explore a variety of different definitional approaches, both traditional and non-traditional, that have been used to “define” life. I argue that all of them are deeply flawed. It is my contention that a scientifically compelling understanding of the nature of life presupposes an empirically adequate scientific theory (vs. definition) of life; as I argue, scientific theories are not the sort of thing that can be encapsulated in definitions. Unfortunately, as I also discuss, scientists are currently in no position to formulate even a tentative version of such a theory. Recent discoveries in biology and biochemistry have revealed that familiar Earth life represents a single example that may not be representative of life. If this is the case, life on Earth today provides an empirically inadequate foundation for theorizing about life considered generally. I sketch a strategy for procuring the needed additional examples of life without the guidance of a definition or theory of life, and close with an application to NASA’s fledgling search for extraterrestrial life.
KeywordsLife Definition Theory Theoretical identity Natural kinds Anomalies
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
- Ainsworth G. C. (1976) Introduction to the history of mycology. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
- Boyd R. (1999a) Homeostasis, species, and higher taxa. In: Wilson R. (ed.) Species: New interdisciplinary essays. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 141–185Google Scholar
- Cleland C. E. (2006) Understanding the nature of life: A matter of definition or theory?. In: Seckbach J. (ed.) Life as we know it. Springer, Dordrecht, pp 589–600Google Scholar
- Cleland C. E. (2007) Epistemological issues in the study of microbial life: Alternative terran biospheres?. Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences 38: 847–861Google Scholar
- Cleland C. E., Chyba C. F. (2007) Does ‘life’ have a definition?. In: Sullivan W. T., Baross J. A. (eds) Planets and life. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 119–131Google Scholar
- Cleland C. E., Copley S. D. (2005) The possibility of alternative microbial life on earth. International Journal of Astrobiology 2: 165–173Google Scholar
- Dupré J. (1993) The disorder of things. Harvard University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
- Jakosky B. M., Westall F., Brack A. (2007) Mars. In: Sullivan W. T., Baross J. A. (eds) Planets and life. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 357–387Google Scholar
- Joyce, G. F. (1995). The RNA world: Life before DNA and protein. In B. Zuckerman & M. Hart (Eds.), Extraterrestrials—where are they? (Vol. II, pp. 139–151). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
- Keller E. F. (2002) Making sense of life. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, pp 284–294Google Scholar
- Kripke S. (1972) Naming and necessity. Harvard University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
- Kuhn T. (1962) The structure of scientific revolutions. University of Chicago Press, ChicagoGoogle Scholar
- Lavoisier, A. L. (1783). On the nature of water and on experiments which appear to prove that this substance is not strictly speaking an element but that it is susceptible of decomposition and recomposition. Observations sur la Physique, 23, 452–455 (trans. Carmen Giunta. http://webserver.lemoyne.edu/faculty/giunta/laveau.html).
- Locke J. (1689) An Essay Concerning Human Understanding. Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
- Putnam, H. (1975). The meaning of ‘meaning’. In K. Gunderson (Ed.), Language, mind and knowledge: Minnesota studies in the philosophy of science (Vol. VII, pp. 131–193). Minneapolis, MN: Minnesota University Press.Google Scholar
- Psillos S. (1999) Scientific realism: How science tracks truth. Routledge, LondonGoogle Scholar
- Roberts G. (1994) The mirror of alchemy. University of Toronto Press, TorontoGoogle Scholar
- Ward P. D., Brownlee D. (2000) Rare Earth. Copernicus, New YorkGoogle Scholar