Springer Nature is making SARS-CoV-2 and COVID-19 research free. View research | View latest news | Sign up for updates

Contributions of moral education lectures and moral discussion in Hong Kong secondary schools

Abstract

Moral education in the traditional form of classroom didactic lectures in secondary schools has been prevailing in Hong Kong since the initiation of moral education in the 1980s. However, such a traditional form has not received credit from research in the West. Instead, discussion of moral issues would be a more effective way of moral education than would didactic lectures. Because of the differential ways of moral education in Hong Kong, findings from other places can be subject to a test in Hong Kong. As such, this study employed panel data from 19,069 secondary school students in Hong Kong to analyze the impacts of moral education on moral commitment to sustain societal interests. Findings indicated a weak contribution of moral discussion and an even weaker contribution of moral education lectures to moral commitment. These findings therefore echo those in other places and suggest that real-life moral education contributes in the expected way, albeit weakly.

This is a preview of subscription content, log in to check access.

References

  1. Arthur, J. (2008). Traditional approaches to character education in Britain and America. In L. P. Nucci & D. Narvaez (Eds.), Handbook of moral and character education (pp. 80–98). New York: Routledge.

  2. Bandura A. (1991) Social cognitive theory of moral thought and action. In: Kurtines W. M., Gerwirtz J. L. (eds) Handbook of moral behavior and development. Lawrence Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ, pp 45–103

  3. Bandura A. (2002) Selective moral disengagement in the exercise of moral agency. Journal of Moral Education 31: 101–119

  4. Bast J., Reitsma P. (1997) Matthew effects in reading: A comparison of latent growth curve models and simplex models with structural means. Multivariate Behavioral Research 32: 135–167

  5. Beck L., Ajzen I. (1991) Predicting dishonest actions using the theory of planned behavior. Journal of Research in Personality 25: 285–301

  6. Bergman R. (2002) Why be moral? A conceptual model from developmental psychology. Human Development 45: 104–124

  7. Berkowitz M. W., Bier M. C. (2008) Research-based character education. Annals of the American Academy of Political & Social Science 591: 72–85

  8. Berkowitz M. W., Battistich V. A., Bier M. C. (2008) What works in character education: What is known and what needs to be known. In: Nucci L. P., Narvaez D. (eds) Handbook of moral and character education. Routledge, New York, pp 414–431

  9. Berzonsky M. D. (1988) Self-theorists, identity states, and social cognition. In: Lapsley D. K., Power F. C. (eds) Self, ego, and identity: Integrative approaches. Springer, New York, pp 243–262

  10. Billington R. (1988) Living Philosophy: An introduction to moral thought. Routledge, London

  11. Blasi A. (1980) Bridging moral cognition and moral action: A critical review of the literature. Psychological Bulletin 88: 1–45

  12. Bredemeier B. Jr. (1983) Athletic aggression: A moral concern. In: Goldstein J. H. (eds) Sports violence. Springer, New York, pp 49–81

  13. Brugman D., Podolskij A. I., Heymans P. G., Boom I., Karabanova O., Idobaeva O. (2003) Perception of moral atmosphere in school and norm transgression behavior in adolescents: An intervention study. International Journal of Behavioral Development 27: 289–300

  14. Carpendale J. I., Krebs D. L. (1992) Situational variation in moral judgment: In a stage or on a stage?. Journal of Youth & Adolescence 21: 203–224

  15. Carr D. (2005) On the contribution of literature and the arts to the educational cultivation of moral virtue, feeling and emotion. Journal of Moral Education 34: 137–151

  16. Catsambis S., Mulkey L. M., Crain R. L. (1999) To track or not to track? The social effects of gender and middle school tracking. Research in Sociology of Education & Socialization 12: 135–163

  17. Cheng R. H. M. (2004) Moral education in Hong Kong: Confucian-parental, Christian-religious and liberal-civic influences. Journal of Moral Education 33: 533–551

  18. Cheung C. K., Lee T. Y., Chan W. T., Liu S. C., Leung K. K. (2001) Structure of moral consciousness and moral intentions among youths in Hong Kong. International Journal of Adolescence and Youth 9(2/3): 83–116

  19. Colby A., Ehrlich T., Beaumont E., Stephens J. (2003) Educating citizens: Preparing America’s undergraduates for lives of moral and civic responsibility. Josey-Bass, San Francisco, CA

  20. Colby A., Kohlberg L., Candee D., Gibbs J. C., Hewer A., Hewer A., Kaufman K., Power C., Speicher-Dubin B. (1987) The measurement of moral judgment. Cambridge University Press, New York

  21. Conroy J. C. (1999) Poetry and human growth. Journal of Moral Education 28: 491–510

  22. Damon W., Gregory A. (2003) Bringing in a new era in the field of youth development. In: Lerner R. M., Benson P. L. (eds) Development assets and asset-building communities: Implications for research, policy, and practice. Kluwer, New York, pp 47–64

  23. De Haan R., Hanford R. (1997) Promoting ethical reasoning, affect, and behavior among high school students: An evaluation of three teaching strategies. Journal of Moral Education 26: 5–20

  24. De Haan R., Hanford R., Kinlaw K., Philler D., Snarey J. (1997) Promoting ethical reasoning, affect, and behavior among high school students: An evaluation of three teaching strategies. Journal of Moral Education 26: 5–20

  25. Eisenberg N., Carlo G., Murphy B., van Court P. (1995) Prosocial development in late adolescence: A longitudinal study. Child Development 66: 1179–1199

  26. Furnham A., Stacey B. (1991) Young people’s understanding of society. Routledge, London

  27. Galston W. A. (2001) Political knowledge, political engagement, and civic education. Annual Review of Political Science 4: 217–234

  28. Gillis A. R., Hagan J. (1990) Delinquent Samaritans: Network structure, social conflict, and the willingness to intervene. Journal of Research in Crime & Delinquency 27: 30–50

  29. Haan N., Aerts E., Cooper B. A. B. (1985) On moral grounds: The search for practical morality. New York University Press, New York

  30. Halstead J. M., Taylor M. J. (2000a) Learning and teaching about values: A review of recent research. Cambridge Journal of Education 30: 169–202

  31. Halstead J. M., Taylor M. J. (2000b) The development of values, attitudes and personal qualities: A review of recent research. National Foundation for Educational Research, Slough, UK

  32. Heyns, B. (1996). Creating capitalists: The social origins of entrepreneurship in post-communist Poland. In A. C. Kerckhoff (Ed.), Generating social stratification: Toward a new research agenda (pp. 257–289). Boulder, CO: Westview.

  33. Ho K. K., Ho B. (2004) A review of moral education curriculum materials in Hong Kong. Journal of Moral Education 33: 631–636

  34. Hoffman M. L. (1991) Empathy, social cognition, and moral action. In: Kurtines W. M., Gerwirtz J. L. (eds) Handbook of moral behavior and development. Lawrence Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ, pp 275–301

  35. Holmes R. L. (2003) Basic moral philosophy (3rd ed.). Wadsworth, Belmont, CA

  36. Hu L. T., Bentler P. M. (1999) Cutoff criteria for fit indexes in covariance structure analysis: Conventional criteria versus new alternatives. Structural Equation Modeling 6: 1–55

  37. Ikels C. (1989) Becoming a human being in theory and practice: Chinese views of human development. In: Kertzer D. I., Schaie K. W. (eds) Age structuring in comparative perspective. Lawrence Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ, pp 109–134

  38. Ip W. Y., Lee D. T. F., Lee I. F. K., Chau J. P. C., Wootton Y. S. Y., Chang A. M. (2000) Disposition toward critical thinking: A study of Chinese undergraduate nursing students. Journal of Advanced Nursing 32: 84–90

  39. Joseph P. B., Efron S. (2005) Seven worlds of moral education. Phi Delta Kappan 86: 525–533

  40. Kahane R. (1997) The origin of postmodern youth: Informal youth movements in a comparative perspective. Walter de Gruyter, Berlin, Germany

  41. Kohlberg L. (1985) The just community approach to moral education. In: Berkowitz M. W., Oser F. (eds) Moral education: Theory and application. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Hillsdale, NJ, pp 27–87

  42. Kohlberg L. (1987) Child psychology and childhood education: A cognitive-developmental view. Longman, New York

  43. Kohlberg L., Candee D. (1984) The relationship of moral judgment to moral action. In: Kurtines W. M., Gerwirtz J. L. (eds) Morality, moral behavior, and moral development. Wiley, New York, pp 52–73

  44. Kohlberg L., Levine C., Hewer A. (1983) Moral stages: A current formulation and a response to critics. S. Karger, Basel, Switzerland

  45. Kristjansson K. (2006) Emulation and the use of role models in moral education. Journal of Moral Education 35: 37–49

  46. Lapsley D. K., Narvaez D. (2006) Character education. In: Renninger K. A., Sigel I. E. (eds) Handbook of child psychology: Child psychology in practice. John Wiley & Sons, Hoboken, NJ, pp 248–296

  47. Larson R. W. (2000) Toward a psychology of positive youth development. American Psychologist 55: 170–183

  48. Lau S.-k., Kuan H.-c. (1988) The ethos of the Hong Kong Chinese. Chinese University Press, Hong Kong

  49. Leming J. (2008) Research and practice in moral and character education: Loosely coupled phenomena. In: Nucci L. P., Narvaez D. (eds) Handbook of moral and character education. Routledge, New York, pp 134–157

  50. Lerner R. M. (2004) Liberty: Thriving civic engagement among America’s youth. Sage, Thousand Oaks, CA

  51. Leung J. Y. M. (1992) Education in Hong Kong and China: Toward convergence? In: Postiglione G. A. (eds) Education and society in Hong Kong: Toward one country and two systems. Hong Kong University Press, Hong Kong, pp 265–272

  52. Ma H. K., Cheung C. K. (1996) A cross-cultural study of moral stage structure in Hong Kong Chinese, English, and Americans. Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology 27: 700–713

  53. Mahy, B., & Vandeville, V. (1996). Youth training schemes in the Walloon Region of Belgium: A microeconomic evaluation. In M. P. M. De Goede, P. M. De Klaver, J. A. C. van Ophem, H. A. Verhaar, & A. Vriesde (Eds.), Youth unemployment, identity and policy (pp. 173–189). Aldershot, UK: Avebury.

  54. Marcia J. E. (1980) Identity in adolescence. In: Adelson J. (eds) Handbook of adolescent psychology. Wiley, New York, pp 159–187

  55. Markoulis D., Valanides N. (1997) Antecedent variables for sociomoral reasoning development: Evidence from two cultural settings. International Journal of Psychology 32: 301–313

  56. Marsh H. W., Hau K. T., Wen Z. (2004) In search of golden rules: Comment on hypothesis-testing approaches to setting cutoff values for fit indexes and dangers in overgeneralizing Hu and Bentler’s (1999) findings. Structural Equation Modeling 11: 320–341

  57. McCann J. A. (1997) Electoral choices and core value change: The 1992 presidential campaign. American Journal of Political Science 41: 564–583

  58. Mihalic S. W., Elliott D. (1997) Short- and long-term consequences of adolescent work. Youth & Society 28: 464–498

  59. Miller T. N., Kraus R. F., Veltkamp L. J. (2005) Character education as a prevention strategy in school-related violence. Journal of Primary Prevention 26: 455–466

  60. Muthen B. O., Satorra A. (1995) Complex sample data in structural equation modeling. In: Marsden P. V. (eds) Sociological methodology. Blackwell, Oxford, UK, pp 216–316

  61. Muthen L. K., Muthen B. O. (2006) Mplus user’s guide. Muthen & Muthen, Los Angeles, CA

  62. Nucci L. P. (2001) Education in the moral domain. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK

  63. O’Brien R. M. (1990) Estimating the reliability of aggregate-level variables based on individual-level characteristics. Sociological Methods & Research 18: 473–504

  64. Pace K. L. (2003) The character of moral communities: A community youth development approach to enhancing character development. In: Villarruel F. A., Perkins D. F., Borden L. M., Keith J. G. (eds) Community youth development: Programs, policies, and practices. Sage, Thousand Oaks, CA, pp 248–272

  65. Paulhus D. L. (1991) Measurement and control of response bias. In: Robsinson J. P., Shaver P. R., Wrightsman L. S. (eds) Measures of personality and social psychological attitudes, Vol. 1: Measures of social psychological attitudes. Academic Press, San Diego, CA, pp 17–60

  66. Postiglione G. A. (1991) From capitalism to socialism? Hong Kong education within a transitional society. Comparative Education Review 35: 627–649

  67. Postiglione G. A. (1992) The decolonization of Hong Kong education. In: Postiglione G. A. (eds) Education and society in Hong Kong: Toward one country and two systems. Hong Kong University Press, Hong Kong, pp 3–38

  68. Powers F. C., Higgins A. (1992) The just community approach to classroom participation. In: Garrod A. (eds) Learning for life: Moral education theory and practice. Praeger, Westport, CT, pp 228–245

  69. Power F. C., Higgins A., Kohlberg L. (1989) Lawrence Kohlberg’s Approach to moral education. Columbia University Press, New York

  70. Raw J. S., Marjoribanks K. (1991) Family and school scorrelates of adolescents’ creativity, morality and self concept. Educational Studies 17: 183–190

  71. Rest J. R. (1984) The major components of morality. In: Kurtines W. M., Gerwirtz J. L. (eds) Morality, moral behavior, and moral development. Wiley, New York, pp 24–38

  72. Rest J., Narvaez D., Bebeau M. J., Thoma S. J. (1999) Postconventional moral thinking: A neo-Kohlbergian approach. Lawrence Erlbaum, Mahwah, NJ

  73. Richmond A. S., Cummings R. (2004) In support of the cognitive-developmental approach to moral education: A response to David Carr. Journal of Moral Education 33: 197–205

  74. Romanowski M. H. (2003) Through the eyes of students: High school students’ perspectives on character education. American Secondary Education 32: 3–20

  75. Siegal M. (1982) Fairness in children: A social-cognitive approach to the study of moral development. Academic Press, London

  76. Skaggs G., Bodenhern N. (2006) Relationships between implementing character education, student behavior, and student achievement. Journal of Advanced Academics 18: 82–114

  77. Smagorinsky P., Taxel J. (2005) The discourse of character education: Culture wars in the classroom. Lawrence Erlbaum, Mahwah, NJ

  78. Snarey J., Pavkov T. (1991) Beyond socialization versus development: Kohlberg’s approach to moral education. Sociological Focus 24: 105–115

  79. Snarey, J., & Pavkov, T. (1992). Moral character education in the united states: Beyond socialization ersus development. In A. Garrod (Ed.), Learning for life: Moral education theory and practice (pp. 25–46). Westport, CT: Praeger.

  80. Stanton M. (1980) Moral judgments among students: A cross-cultural study. Adolescence 25: 231–242

  81. Steutel J., Spiecker B. (2004) Cultivating sentimental dispositions through aristotelian habituation. Journal of Philosophy of Education 38: 531–549

  82. Valette-Florence P., Jolibert J. (1990) Social values, A.I.O., and consumption patterns: Exploratory findings. Journal of Business Research 20: 109–122

  83. Veugelers W. (2000) Different ways of teaching values. Educational Review 52: 37–40

  84. Walker L. J. (1996) The role of the family in moral functioning and development. In: Lo L. N. K., Man S. W. (eds) Research and endeavours in moral and civic education. Hong Kong Institute of Educational Research, Chinese University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, pp 203–214

  85. Wang F. (2004) Confucian thinking on traditional moral education: Key ideas and fundamental features. Journal of Moral Education 33: 429–447

  86. Wark G. R., Krebs D. L. (1996) Gender and dilemma differences in real-life moral judgment. Developmental Psychology 32: 220–230

  87. Waterman A. S., Archer S. L. (1993) Identity status during the adult years: Scoring criteria. In: Marcia J. E., Waterman A. S., Matterson D. R., Archer S. L., Orlofsky J. L. (eds) Ego identity: A handbook for psychosocial research. Springer, New York, pp 241–279

  88. Weinreich-Haste, H. (1986). Kohlberg’s contribution to political psychology: A positive view. In S. Modgil & C. Modgil (Eds.), Lawrence Kohlberg: Consensus and controversy (pp. 337–361). Philadelphia, PA: Falmer Press.

  89. Wentzel K. R. (2003) Sociometric status and adjustment in middle school: A longitudinal study. Journal of Early Adolescence 23: 5–28

  90. Wickrama K. A., Lorenz F. O., Conger R. D. (1997) Parental support and adolescent physical health status: A latent growth-curve analysis. Journal of Health & Social Behavior 38: 149–163

  91. Williams M. M. (2000) Models of character education: Perspectives and developmental issues. Journal of Humanistic Counseling Education & Development 39: 82–116

  92. Youniss J., Yates M. (1999) Youth service and moral-civic identity: A case for everyday morality. Educational Psychology Review 11: 361–376

Download references

Author information

Correspondence to Chau-kiu Cheung.

Rights and permissions

Reprints and Permissions

About this article

Cite this article

Cheung, C., Lee, T. Contributions of moral education lectures and moral discussion in Hong Kong secondary schools. Soc Psychol Educ 13, 575–591 (2010). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11218-010-9127-x

Download citation

Keywords

  • Moral education
  • Moral discussion
  • Cognitive development