Writing the history of Russian philosophy

Article
  • 155 Downloads

Abstract

This article addresses the writing of the history of Russian philosophy from the first of such works—Archimandrite Gavriil’s Russian Philosophy [Russkaja filosofija, 1840]—to philosophical histories/textbooks in the twenty-first century. In the majority of these histories, both past and present, we find a relentless insistence on the delineation of “characterizing traits” of Russian philosophy and appeals to “historiosophy,” where historiosophy is employed as being distinct from the historiographical method. In the 1990s and 2000s, the genre of the history of Russian philosophy has grown increasingly conservative with regards to content, with histories from this period demonstrating an almost exclusive Orthodox focus. This conservatism, in turn, has contributed to widespread contention in recent years over the status of these philosophical textbooks—disagreements that often lead to either (1) further appeals to “historiosophical” methods; or (2) denials of the domestic philosophical tradition altogether, where the response to the query “Is there philosophy in Russia?” is emphatically negative. This article argues that the contemporary disputes over the development and preservation of the Russian philosophical canon are in many ways part of a larger debate over the roles of Orthodoxy and the history of philosophy in post-Soviet philosophical thought.

Keywords

History of Russian and Soviet philosophy Philosophy textbooks Istorija russkoj filosofii 

References

  1. Anašvili, V. (2008). Intellektual’nye itogi 2008 goda. Interview with Vitalij Kurennoi, Častnyj korrespondent. http://www.chaskor.ru/p.php?id=2368. Accessed December 31, 2008.
  2. Benjamin, W. (1966). Theses on the philosophy of history. In H. Arendt (Ed.), Illuminations. Essays and reflections (pp. 253–264). New York: Schocken.Google Scholar
  3. Berdjaev, N. (1937). Ortodoksija i čelovečnost’. Put’ 53(April–July 1937). http://www.krotov.info/library/02_b/berdyaev/1937_434.html.
  4. Berdjaev, N. (1991). O russkoj filosofii. Ekaterinburg.Google Scholar
  5. Berg, A. (2008). Ivan Lopukhin and the development of mystical historiosophy in late eighteenth-century Russia. In The yearbook of the “Gheorghe Şincai” Institute for Social Sciences and the Humanities of the Romanain Academy (Vol. XI, pp. 44–57).Google Scholar
  6. Bobrov, E. (1899–1903). Filosofija v Rossii. Materialy, issledovanija i zametki, 3 vols. Kazan’: N.p.Google Scholar
  7. Broadie, A. (2009). A history of Scottish philosophy. Edinburgh: Edinburgh UP.Google Scholar
  8. Eršov, M. (1922). Put’ razvitija filosofii v Rossii. Vladivostok: N.p.Google Scholar
  9. Evgrafov, V. (1971). Istorija filosofii v SSSR (Vol. 4). Moscow: Nauka.Google Scholar
  10. Evlampiev, I. (2002). Istorija russkoj filosofii: Učebnoe posobie dlja vuzov. St. Petersburg: Aleteija.Google Scholar
  11. Florovskij, G. (1982). Puti russkogo bogoslovija. Paris: YMCA.Google Scholar
  12. Galaktionov, A., & Nikandrov, P. (1961). Istorija russkoj filosofii. Moscow: Izd-vo sotsial’no-ekon. lit-ry.Google Scholar
  13. Galaktionov, A., & Nikandrov, P. (1970). Russkaja filosofija XI-IX vekov. Leningrad.Google Scholar
  14. Gal’kovskii, D. (1995). Inoe. Khrestomatija novogo rossijskogo samosoznaniia (Vol. 3). Moscow: Agrus.Google Scholar
  15. Gromov, M. (2008). Obsuždenie knigi ‘Russkaja filosofija: entsiklopedija.’ Voprosy filosofii.Google Scholar
  16. Gromov, M., & Kozlov, N. (1990). Russkaja filosofskaja mysl’ X-XVII vekov. Moscow: Izd-vo Moskovskogo un-ta.Google Scholar
  17. Gusejnov, A., & Lektorskij, V. (2009). Philosophy in Russia: History and present state. Diogenes, 56, 3.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Gutov, E. (1998). Istoriosofija. In Kemerov (Ed.), Filosofskaja entsiklopedija. Panprint, N.p. http://www.terme.ru/dictionary/183/.
  19. Iovčuk, M. (1952). Ob istoričeskikh osobennostjakh i osnovnykh etapakh razvitija russkoj filosofii. In P. Pavelkin (Ed.), Iz istorii russkoj filosofii (pp. 3–66). Moscow: AN SSSR.Google Scholar
  20. Ivanov, A. (2006). Negumanitarnaja epokha. In V. Kurrenoj (Ed.), Mysljaščaja Rossiia. Kartografija sovremennykh intellektual’nykh napravlenij (pp. 55–57). Moscow: Nasledie Evrazii.Google Scholar
  21. Kareev, N. (2006). Filosofija istorii i istoriosofija. In L. I. Novikova & I. N. Sizemskaja (Eds.), Russkaja istoriosofija. Antologija. Moscow: Rosspen.Google Scholar
  22. Kazin, A. (1994). Vvedenie v istoriosofiju Rossii. Sfinks, 1, 58–77.Google Scholar
  23. Khoružij, S. (2008). Obsuždenie knigi ‘Russkaja filosofija: entsiklopediia.’ Voprosy filosofii, 9.Google Scholar
  24. Kotsjubinskij, D. (1999). Teoretičeskie i metodičeskie voprosy istoričeskoj psikhologii. St. Petersburg: Limbus P.Google Scholar
  25. Krasikov, V. (2008). Russkaja filosofija sevodnja. Moscow: Volodei.Google Scholar
  26. Kurennoj, V. (2009). Soblazn tekhnologii. Pushkin, 1. http://www.russ.ru/pushkin/Soblazn-tehnologii.
  27. Kuvakin, V. (1980). Religioznaja filosofija v Rossii. Moscow: Mysl’.Google Scholar
  28. Kuznetsov, P. (2000). “Filosofija v Rossii…”. Knižnoe obozrenie “Ex libris NG” (15.06.2000).Google Scholar
  29. Laurie, H. (1902). Scottish philosophy in its national development. Glasgow: J. Maclehose.Google Scholar
  30. Losskij, N. (1994). Istorija russkoj filosofii. Moscow: Progress.Google Scholar
  31. MacIntyre, A. (1984). After virtue. A study in moral theory. South Bend, IN: U of Notre Dame P.Google Scholar
  32. Masaryk, T. G. (1961–1967). The spirit of Russia. Studies in literature, history, and philosophy (Eden, Cedar Paul, Trans.) New York: Macmillan.Google Scholar
  33. Maslin, M. (2008a). Istorija russkoj filosofii (2nd ed.). Moscow: Gruppa ACT.Google Scholar
  34. Maslin, M. (2008b). Obsuždenie knigi ‘Russkaja filosofija: entsiklopedija.’ Voprosy filosofii.Google Scholar
  35. Maslin, M. (Ed.). (2008c). Istorija russkoj filosofii. Moscow: Vysshaia shkola.Google Scholar
  36. McCalla, A. (1998). A romantic historiosophy: The philosophy of history of Pierre-simon Ballanche. Boston: Brill.Google Scholar
  37. McCosh, J. (1874). The Scottish philosophy. New York: R. Carter.Google Scholar
  38. Peperzak, A. (1989). On the unity of systematic philosophy and history of philosophy. In T. Z. Lavine & V. Tejera (Eds.), History and anti-history in philosophy. Dordrecht: Springer.Google Scholar
  39. Plekhanov, G. (1925). In D. Rjazanov (Ed.), Istorija russkoj obščestvennoj mysli. Moscow: Gos. Izd-vo.Google Scholar
  40. Plotnikov, N. (2010). Susal’naja arkhaika. Puškin (June 11, 2010). http://www.russ.ru/pushkin/Susal-naya-arhaika.
  41. Podoroga, V. (2009, June). Commentary at critical thought in the 21st century conference, Moscow, Russia.Google Scholar
  42. Prozorov, S. (2008). Russian postcommunism and the end of history. Studies in East European Thought, 60, 3.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Pustarnakov, V. (2003). Universitetskaja filosofija v Rossii. St. Petersbgurg: Izd-vo Russkogo khristjanskogo gumanitarnogo in-ta.Google Scholar
  44. Radlov, E. (1912). Očerk istorii russkoj filosofii. St. Petersburg: N.p.Google Scholar
  45. Radlow, E. (1890). Bericht über Arbeiten auf dem Gebiete der Philosophie in Russland. In Archiv für Geschichte der Philosophie (Vol. 3, pp. 675–692). Berlin: N.p.Google Scholar
  46. Rybas, A. (2008). On contemporary Russian philosophy. Landshaft, 1. http://www.pitt.edu/~lands/.
  47. Rylev, K. (2009). Zamaročki russkoj filosofii. 250 let bezumstvu slavjanskoi mysli. Častnyj korrespondent. http://www.chaskor.ru/p.php?id=8956. Accessed August 6, 2009.
  48. Šapošnikov, L., & Fedorov, A. (2008). Istorija russkoj religioznoj filosofii. Moscow: Vysšaja škola.Google Scholar
  49. Schelling, F. W. J. (1927). In M. Schröter (Ed.), Werke (Vol. III). Munich: N.p.Google Scholar
  50. Sekatskij, A. (1994). Opyt tekstologičeskogo analiza sovetskoj filosofskoj literatury 50-x godov. Sfinks 7–41.Google Scholar
  51. Smirnov, I. (2009). Byvajut li bezidejnye epokhi? Paper presented at Intellektual’nyj jazyk epokhi: Istorija idei, Istorija slov conference at the Russian State University for the Humanities, Moscow, Russia, February, 16–17, 2009.Google Scholar
  52. Sukhov, A. (1995). Russkaja filosofija. Moscow: IF RAN.Google Scholar
  53. Swedenborg, E. (1961). Angelic wisdom about divine providence (W. F. Wunsch, Trans.). New York: Swedenborg Foundation.Google Scholar
  54. Swiderski, E. (1998, December). Culture, contexts, and directions in Russian post-Soviet philosophy. Studies in East European Thought, 50(4).Google Scholar
  55. Tejera, V. (1989). Intellectual history as a tool of philosophy. In T. Z. Lavine & V. Tejera (Eds.), History and anti-history in philosophy. Dordrecht: Springer.Google Scholar
  56. Tolstykh, V. (2008). My byli. Sovetskij čelovek kak on est’. Moscow: Kul’turnaja revoljutsija.Google Scholar
  57. Vaganov, A. (2001, June). Internet ešče ne stal filosofije. Nauka v Sibiri, 25, 2311. http://szmn.sbras.ru/win/elbib/hbc/ article.phtml?nid=52&id=28.
  58. Van der Zweerde, E. (1990). Recent developments in Soviet historiography of philosophy. Studies in Soviet Thought, 39(1), 1–53.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Van der Zweerde, E. (2009). The place of Russian philosophy in world philosophical history. A perspective. Diogenes, 56, 170–186.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Vertkov, K. (1948). Russkaja rogovaja muzyka. Leningrad: N.p.Google Scholar
  61. White, H. (1973). Metahistory: The historical imagination in nineteenth-century Europe. Baltimore: John Hopkins UP.Google Scholar
  62. Zamaleev, A. (2001). Novye issledovanija po russkoj filosofii. St. Petersburg: Letnii sad.Google Scholar
  63. Zen’kovskij, V. (1991). Istorija russkoj filosofii. Leningrad: Ego.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2011

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Dickinson CollegeCarlisleUSA

Personalised recommendations