Springer Nature is making SARS-CoV-2 and COVID-19 research free. View research | View latest news | Sign up for updates

Structural Analyses Of The Quality Of Life Of Children At Risk

  • 100 Accesses


Quality of life (QOL) is usually assessed in terms of levels. This paper, in contrast, examines the structure of the quality of life of its subjects: two groups of children at risk, children who were kept at home and those who were removed from home. The social workers who made the decisions were asked to assess the children’s quality of life using Shye’s Systemic Quality of Life Model. The study’s main finding is that the QOL structure of the two groups of children differs both from the theoretical “ideal” (or “healthy” structure) and from each other. The QOL structure of the children who were kept at home was closer to the ideal than that of the children who were removed. The difference from the ideal in both groups is consistent with the fact that both groups of children at risk, whose QOL is compromised by definition. The greater proximity to the “ideal” of the QOL structure of the children who were kept at home suggests that the social workers who made the decisions viewed these children as having a healthier QOL than the children who were removed from home.

This is a preview of subscription content, log in to check access.


  1. D. J. Besharov (1985) ArticleTitle‘Right versus right The dilemma of child protection’ Public Welfare 43 IssueID2 19–27

  2. D. J. Besharov (1986) ArticleTitle‘Child welfare liability: The need for immunity legislation’ Children Today 15 IssueID5 17–20

  3. D. Cairns (1990) ‘Quality of life, Assessment of haemodialysis patients: An application of a systemic life quality model Macquarie University Doctoral Thesis Sydney

  4. B. S. Chapman (1997) ArticleTitle‘Child Protection Risk Assessment and African–American children: Cultural ramifications for families and communities Child Welfare 76 IssueID1 45–63 Occurrence Handle8995779

  5. D. Cicchetti M. Lynch (1995) ‘Failures in the expectable environment and their impact on individual development: The case of child maltreatment’ D. Cicchetti D. J. Cohen (Eds) Developmental psychopathology: Risk, disorder and adaptation Willy NY 32–71

  6. J.M. Clausen J. Landsverk W. Ganger D. Chadwick A. Litrownik (1998) ArticleTitle‘Mental health problems of children in foster care’ Journal of Child and Family Studies 7 283–296 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1022989411119

  7. B. Davidson-Arad (2001a) ArticleTitle‘Predicted changes in children’s Quality of Life in decision regarding the removal of children at risk from their homes’ Children and Youth Services Review 22 IssueID1 31–55

  8. B. Davidson-Arad (2001b) ArticleTitle‘Predicted changes in children’s Quality of Life in Decisions Regarding the Removal of Children at Risk from their Homes’ Children and Youth Services Review 23 IssueID2 127–143 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0190-7409(01)00130-X

  9. B. Davidson-Arad Y. Wozner (2001) ArticleTitle‘The use of the Shye’s Systemic Quality of Life model in the examination of child protection officers decision’ Social Indicators Research 56 1–20 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1011809104824

  10. B. Davidson-Arad Y. Wozner (2001) ArticleTitle‘The least detrimental alternative: Deciding whether to remove children at risk from their homes’ International Social Work 44 IssueID2 229–239

  11. B. Davidson-Arad D. Englechin-Segal Y. Wozner (2001) ArticleTitle‘Short-term follow-up of children at risk: Comparison of the quality of life of children removed from home and children remaining at home’ Child Abuse and Neglect 27 170–175

  12. D. DePanfilis M. Scannapieco (1994) ArticleTitle‘Assessing the safety of children at risk of maltreatment; Decision making models’ Child Welfare 73 IssueID3 229–245 Occurrence Handle8005017

  13. T. Dolev D. Rivkin (1996) Children and families in care of Child Protection Officers - Characteristics, Needs, Services and Policies. JDC - Brookdale Center for Children and Youth Jerusalem

  14. L. Eckenrode M. Laird J. Doris (1993) ArticleTitle‘Scholl performance and disciplinary problems among abused and neglected children’ Developmental Psychology 29 53–62 Occurrence Handle10.1037//0012-1649.29.1.53

  15. D. Elizur S. Shye (1990) ArticleTitle‘Quality of work life and its relation to quality of life’ Applied Psychology: An International Review 39 IssueID3 275–291

  16. M. F. Fatout (1990) ArticleTitle‘Consequences of abuse on the relationships of children’ Families in Society: The Journal of Contemporary Human Services 71 IssueID2 76–81

  17. R. J. Gelles (1996) ‘The book of David’ Basic Books NY

  18. Guttman L. (1957). ‘Introduction to facet design and analysis’ In Proceeding of the Fifteenth International Congress of Psychology,. North Holland Publishing, Brussels Amsterdam

  19. M. Jonson-Reid (1998) ArticleTitle‘Youth violence and exposure to violence in childhood An ecological review’ Aggression and Violent Behavior 3 159–179 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S1359-1789(97)00009-8

  20. E.M. Kinard (1980) ArticleTitle‘Emotional development in physically abused children’ American Journal of Orthopsychiatric 50 IssueID4 686–696

  21. C. Krunttschnitt D. Ward M.A. Sheble (1987) ArticleTitle‘Abuse resistant youth: Some factors that may inhibit violent criminal behavior’ Social Forces 66 IssueID2 501–519

  22. M.P. Lawton (1991) ‘A Multidimensional view of Quality of Life in Frail Eldies J.E. Birrer J.E. Lubben J.C. Rowe Deutchman (Eds) The concept and Measurement of Quality of Life in the Frail Elderly. Academic Press Inc. Harcourt Brace Jovanouich Pablishers San Diego California 3–27

  23. L.K. Leslie J. Landsverk Ezzet-Lofstrom J.M. Tschann D.J. Slymen A.F. Garland (2000) ArticleTitle‘Children in foster care: Factors influencing outpatient mental health service use’ Child Abuse & Neglect 24 IssueID4 465–476

  24. D. Lindsey (1995) The welfare of children Oxford University press NY

  25. D. O. Lewis S. S. Shanok J. H. Pincus G. H. Glaser (1979) ArticleTitle‘Violent juvenile delinquents: Psychiatric, neurological, psychological and abuse factors Journal of the American Academy of Child Psychiatry 18 IssueID2 307–319 Occurrence Handle447962

  26. G. P. Mallon B. R. Leashore (2002) ArticleTitle‘Preface to a special issue: Contemporary issues in permanency planning’ Child Welfare LXXXI IssueID2 95–99

  27. P. E. Mullen J. L. Martin J. C. Anderson S. E. Romans G. P. Herbison (1996) ArticleTitle‘The long term impact of the physical, emotional and sexual abuse of children: A community study’ Child Abuse, and Neglect 20 IssueID1 7–21

  28. E. Munro (1996) ArticleTitle‘Avoidable and Unavoidable mistakes in child protection work’ British Journal of Social Work 26 793–808

  29. J.P. Nasuti (1998) ArticleTitleRisk assessment in child protective services: Challenges in measuring child well being’ Journal of Family Social Work 3 IssueID1 55–68

  30. J.G. Orme C. Buehler (2001) ArticleTitle‘Foster family characteristics and behavioral and emotional problems of foster children: A narrative review’ Family Relations 50 3–15 Occurrence Handle10.1111/j.1741-3729.2001.00003.x

  31. P. H. Rossi J. Schuerman S. Budde (1999) ArticleTitle‘Understanding Decisions about Child Maltreatment Evaluation Review’ A Journal of Applied Social Research 23 IssueID6 579–598

  32. K.D. Retting (1991) ArticleTitle‘Family life Quality: Theory and Assessment in economically stressed form families’ Social Indicators Research 24 269–299 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00306083

  33. S. Shye D. Elizur M. Hoffman (1994) Introduction to Facet Theory. Content Design an Intuinsic Data Analysis in Behavioral Research Sage Publication Thousand Oaks, California

  34. S. Shye (1979) A Systemic Facet Theoretical Approach to the Study of Quality of Life Institute of Applied Social Research Jerusalem Israel

  35. Shye, S.: 1985a, ‘Human life quality: An action system’, in S. Shye (ed.), Multiple Scaling, The Theory and Application of Partial Order Scalogram Analysis. Elsevier Science Amsterdam, pp. 245–256

  36. S. Shye (1985b) ‘Nonmetric multivariate models for behavioral action systems’ D. Canter (Eds) Facet Theory, Approaches to Social Research Springer Verlag NY/Berlin

  37. S. Shye (1989) ArticleTitle‘The systemic quality of life model A basis for urban renewal evaluation’ Social Indicators Research 21 243–378 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00303952

  38. Shye, S. 1999, Facet theory, in Encyclopedia of Statistical Science, Update, Vol. 3 (Wily, NY).

  39. S. Shye J. Doochin (1996) QOL Index in Israel The Guttman institute of Applied Social Research Jerusalem in Hebrew

  40. C. Verduyn R. Calam (1999) ArticleTitle‘Cognitive behavioral interventions with maltreated children and adolescent’ Child Abuse & Neglect 23 IssueID2 197–207

  41. J.S. Wodarski P.D. Kurtz J.M. Gaudin P.T. Howing (1990) ArticleTitleMaltreatment and the School-age child. Major academic, socioemotional and adaptive outcomes Social Work 35 IssueID6 506–513 Occurrence Handle2284600

  42. M. Wolins Y. Wozner S. Shye (1980) ArticleTitle‘Rejuvenating the asylum: A field study’ Social Work Research and Abstracts 16 IssueID1 17–25 Occurrence Handle10313889

  43. Y. Wozner M. Golan B. Davidson-Arad (1993) The Quality of Life in institutions for children and Youth in Israel. Ramot Publication The Bob Shapel school, Tel-Aviv University, Romot Publications Tel Aviv

  44. Wozner, Y., M. Golan, G. Rahav, B. Arad and B. Pinhassi: 1994, Social work and welfare services in prisons. Research report.

Download references

Author information

Correspondence to Bilha Davidson-Arad.

Rights and permissions

Reprints and Permissions

About this article

Cite this article

Davidson-Arad, B. Structural Analyses Of The Quality Of Life Of Children At Risk. Soc Indic Res 73, 409–429 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11205-004-2010-4

Download citation


  • children at risk
  • quality of life structure
  • social workers