“I Thought I was Less Worthy”: Low Sexual and Body Esteem and Increased Vulnerability to Intimate Partner Abuse in Women with Physical Disabilities Article DOI:
Cite this article as: Hassouneh-Phillips, D. & McNeff, E. Sex Disabil (2005) 23: 227. doi:10.1007/s11195-005-8930-3 Abstract
Several studies have documented disproportionately low sexual and body esteem in women with high degrees of physical impairment. Moreover, other studies have begun to examine the problem of intimate partner and other forms of abuse in women with physical disabilities. In this article we examine the link between low sexual and body esteem and intimate partner abuse in women with physical disabilities based on findings obtained from an in-depth qualitative study. Findings indicate that women with high degrees of physical impairment are more likely to perceive themselves as sexually inadequate and unattractive than women with mild impairment. These negative perceptions, when combined with a strong desire to be partnered, increased women’s vulnerability to getting into and staying in abusive relationships over time. Major themes presented in the article include: societal devaluation, low sexual and body esteem, preference for non-disabled men, desire to be partnered, and relationship decision-making. We depict the relationships between each of these themes in a simple model to further aid the reader’s understanding.
Keywords intimate partner violence sexual esteem body esteem women with physical disabilities References Mayers, K, Heller, D, Heller, J. 2003 Damaged sexual self-esteem: a kind of disability Sex Disabil. 21 269 282 Google Scholar Mayer, J, Eisenberg, M. 1988 Mental representation of the body: stability and change in response to illness and disability Rehabilit Psychol. 33 155 171 Google Scholar McCabe, M, Taleporos, G. 2003 Sexual esteem, sexual satisfaction, and sexual behavior among people with physical disability Arch Sex Behav. 32 359 369 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Taleporos, G, McCabe, M. 2002 Development and validation of the physical disability sexual and body esteem scale Sex Disabil. 20 159 176 Google Scholar Taleporos, G, McCabe, M. 2001 The impact of physical disability on body esteem Sex Disabil. 19 293 308 Google Scholar Taleporos, G, McCabe, M. 2002 The impact of sexual esteem,body esteem, and sexual satisfaction on psychological well-being in people with physical disability Sex Disabil. 20 177 183 Google Scholar Taleporos, G, McCabe, M. 2001 Physical disability and sexual esteem Sex Disabil. 19 131 148 Google Scholar Taleporos, G, McCabe, M. 2003 Relationships, sexuality and adjustment among people with physical disability Sex Relationship Therapy. 18 5 6 Google Scholar Benrud-Larson, L, Heinberg, L, Boling, C, Reed, J, White, B, Wigley, F, Haythornthwaite, J. 2003 Body image dissatisfaction among women with scleroderma: extent and relationship to psychosocial function Health Psychol. 22 130 139 PubMed Google Scholar Kettl, P, Zarefoss, S. 1991 Female sexuality after spinal cord injury Sex Disabil. 9 287 295 CrossRef Google Scholar Hassouneh-Phillips, D, McNeff, E. 2004 Understanding and defining care-related violence against women with spinal cord injury J Spinal Cord Injury Nurs. 21 75 81 Google Scholar
Gill C: Dating and relationship issues. In Women with Physical Disabilities – Achieving and Maintaining Health and Well-being, Krotoski M, Nosek M, Turk M. (eds.) Baltimore: Paul Brooks, 1996, pp. 117–124.
Rintala, D, Howland, C, Nosek, M, Bennett, J, Young, M, Foley, C, RossiC Chanpong, G. 1997 Dating issues for women with physical disabilities Sex Disabil. 15 219 242 CrossRef Google Scholar Basson, R. 1998 Sexual health of women with disabilities Can Med J. 159 359 362 Google Scholar Chance, R. 2002 To love and be loved: sexuality and people with physical disabilities J Psychol Theol. 30 195 208 Google Scholar Nosek, M, Rintala, D, Young, M, Howland, C, Foley, C, Rossi, C, Chanpong, G. 1996 Sexual functioning among women with physical disabilities Arch Phys Med Rehabilit. 77 107 115 Google Scholar Vansteenwegen, A, Jans, I, Revell, A. 2003 Sexual experience of women with a physical disability: a comparative study Sex Disabil. 21 283 290 CrossRef Google Scholar Lawrence, B. 1991 Self concept formation and physical handicap: some educational implications for integration Disabil, Handicap Soc. 6 139 146 Google Scholar Wendell, S. 1996The Rejected Body – Feminist Philosophical Reflections on Disability. Routledge New York. Google Scholar
Jans L, Stoddard S: Chartbook on Women and Disability in the United States. An Info-use Report. Washington DC: National Institute of Disability and Rehabilitation Research, 1999.
Curry, MA, Hassouneh-Phillips, D, Johnston-Silverberg, A. 2001 Abuse of women with disabilities: an ecological model and review Violence Against Women – An Int Interdisciplin J. 7 60 79 Google Scholar Hassouneh-Phillips, D, Curry, MA. 2002 Abuse of women with disabilities: state of the science Rehabilit Counsel Bull. 45 96 104 Google Scholar Young, E, Nosek, M, Howland, C, Changpon, G, Rintala, D. 1997 Prevalence of abuse of women with physical disabilities Arch Phys Med Rehabilit Special Issue. 78 S34 S38 Google Scholar
Nosek M, Howland C, Rintala D, Young E, Changpon G: National Study of Women with Physical Disabilities: Final Report. Houston, TX: Center for Research on Women with Disabilities, 1997.
Powers, L, Curry, MA, Oschwald, M, Saxton, M, Eckels, K. 2002 Barriers and strategies in addressing abuse: a survey of disabled women’s experiences J Rehabilitat. 68 4 13 Google Scholar Milberger, S, Israel, N, LeRoy, B, Martin, A, Potter, L, Patchak-Schuster, P. 2003 Violence against women with physical disabilities Violence Vict. 18 581 591 PubMed Google Scholar
Riddington J: “Beating the Odds”: Violence and Women with Disabilities (position paper 2). Vancouver, B.C.: DisAbled Women’s Network of Canada, 1989.
Berkeley Planning Associates. Priorities for future research: results of BPA’s Delphi survey of disabled women. Oakland, California: Berkeley Planning Associates, 1996.
Nosek, M, Foley, C, Hughes, R, Howland, C. 2001 Vulnerabilities for abuse among women with disabilities Sex Disabil. 19 177 189 Google Scholar
Mertens D: Mixed methods and the politics of human research: the transformative-emancipatory perspective. In Handbook of Mixed Methods in Social and Behavioral Research, Tashakkori A, Teddlie C. (eds.) Thousand Oaks: Sage, 2003, pp. 135–164.
Seidman, I. 1991Interviewing as Qualitative Research: A Guide for Researchers in Education and the Social Sciences Teachers College Press New York. Google Scholar
Benner P: The tradition and skill of interpretive phenomenology in studying health, illness, and caring practices. In Interpretive Phenomenology: Embodiment, Caring, and Ethics in Health and Illness, Benner P. (ed.) Thousand Oaks: Sage, 1994, pp. 99–128.
QSR Ltd. NVivo 2.0. Thousand Oaks: Sage, 2003.
Parker, B, Ulrich, Y, Bullock, L, Campbell, D, Cambell, J, King, C, Laudenburger, K, McFarlane, J, Ryan, J, Sheridan, D, Smith-McKenna, L, Torres, S. 1990 A protocol of research on abuse of women Nurs Res. 39 248 250 PubMed Google Scholar
Creswell J: Qualitative Inquiry and Research Design: Choosing Among Five Traditions. Thousand Oaks: Sage, 1998.
Lincoln, Y, Guba, E. 1985Naturalistic Inquiry Thousand Oaks Sage. Google Scholar Tilley, C. 1996 Sexuality in women with physical disabilities: a social justice or health issue? Sex Disabil. 14 139 151 Google Scholar
Campbell J: Making the health care system an empowerment zone for battered women: health consequences, policy recommendations, introduction, and overview. In Empowering Survivors of Abuse: Health Care for Battered Women and Their Children, Campbell J, (ed.) Thousand Oaks: Sage, 1998, pp.3–22.
Campbell, JC, Webster, D, Koziol-McLain, J, Block, C, Campbell, D, Curry, MA, Gary, F, Glass, N, McFarlane, J, Sachs, C, Sharps, P, Ulrich, Y, Wilt, SA, Manganello, J, Xu, X, Schollenberger, J, Frye, V, Laughon, K. 2003 Risk factors for femicide in abusive relationships: results from a multisite case control study Am J Public Health. 93 1089 1097 PubMed CrossRef Google Scholar Cunradi, CB, Caetano, R, Schafer, J. 2002 Alcohol-related problems, drug use, and male intimate partner violence severity among US couples Alcoholism: Clin Exp Res. 26 493 500 Google Scholar Stark, A, Flitcraft, E. 1995 Killing the beast within: woman battering and female suicidality Int J Health Serv. 25 43 64 PubMed Google Scholar
Sutherland C, Bybee D, Sullivan C: The long-term effects of battering on women’s health. World Health Res Gen Behav Pol, 1998.
Walton-Moss, B, Morrison, C, Yeo, T, Woodruff, K, Woods, N, Campbell, JC, Kub, J, Dennison, C, McCaul, M. 2003 Interrelationships of violence and psychiatric symptoms in women with substance use disorders J Addict Nurs. 14 193 200 CrossRef Google Scholar Watson, CG, Barnett, M, Nikunen, L, Schultz, C, Randolph-Elgin, T, Mendez, CM. 1997 Lifetime prevalences of nine commonpsychiatric/personality disorders in female domestic abuse survivors J Nerv Mental Dis. 185 645 647 Google Scholar Copyright information
© Springer Science+Business Media, Inc. 2005