Science & Education

, Volume 16, Issue 3–5, pp 371–391 | Cite as

The History of Teaching Quantum Mechanics in Greece

Article

Abstract

In this work, our goal is to examine the attitude of the Greek scientific community towards Quantum Mechanics and establish the history of teaching of this theory in Greece. We have examined Physics textbooks written by professors of the University of Athens, as well as records of public speeches, university yearbooks from 1923 to 1970, articles in popular scientific magazines, political and philosophical publications and lemmas of encyclopedias that were influencing the public at the time.

Our research shows that Quantum Mechanics in Greece was involved in the debate between the political left and right and the church organizations of the period, leading to an extremely idealistic misinterpretation of the theory. As a result, Quantum Mechanics was late to establish itself in Greece, with the first structured and autonomous course on Quantum Mechanics appearing as late as 1962.

Keywords

Greece history of science teaching Quantum mechanics reception 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Antoniou, D.: 1987, The Curriculum of Greek Secondary Education, Three volumes, IAEN, Athens (\(\hbox{A}\nu\tau \omega\nu{\acute \iota}o\upsilon,\;\Delta\).: 1987, T\(\alpha\;\pi\rho o\gamma\rho{\acute \alpha}\mu\mu\alpha\tau\alpha\;\hbox{M}{\acute \varepsilon}\sigma\eta\varsigma\;\hbox{E}\kappa\pi\alpha{\acute \iota}\delta\varepsilon\upsilon\sigma\eta\varsigma,\;\hbox{T}\rho\varepsilon{\acute \iota}\varsigma\;\tau{\acute o}\mu o\iota\), IAEN,\(\hbox{A}\theta{\acute \eta}\nu\alpha\))Google Scholar
  2. Baltas, A.: 1993, ‘Production of Science Versus Reception: Some Methodological Remarks’ in Vlahakis, G.N. (ed.): Newtonian Physics and its Diffusion in the Balkans – Proceedings of the International Scientific Symposium, Athens (\(\hbox{M}\pi \alpha\lambda\tau{\acute \alpha}\varsigma,\;\hbox{A}\).: 1993, ‘\(\Pi\alpha\rho \alpha\gamma\omega\gamma{\acute \eta}\;<$> <$>{\acute \varepsilon}\nu\alpha\nu\tau\iota\;\upsilon\pi o\delta o\chi {\acute \eta}\varsigma<$> <$>\;\tau\eta\varsigma\;\varepsilon\pi \iota\sigma\tau{\acute \eta}\mu\varepsilon\varsigma:\hbox{M} \varepsilon\rho\iota\kappa{\acute \varepsilon} \varsigma\;\mu\varepsilon\theta o\delta o\lambda o\gamma\iota\kappa{\acute\varepsilon}\varsigma\;\pi \alpha\rho\alpha\tau\eta\rho{\acute \eta}\sigma \varepsilon\iota\varsigma',\; \sigma\tau o\; \hbox{B}\lambda \alpha\chi{\acute \alpha}\kappa\eta\varsigma,\;<$> <$>\Gamma\).N.\((\varepsilon\pi\iota\mu.),\; H\; N\varepsilon\upsilon\tau{\acute \omega}\nu \varepsilon \iota\alpha\; \Phi\upsilon\sigma \iota\kappa{\acute \eta} \; \kappa\alpha\iota\;\eta \;\delta\iota{\acute \alpha} \delta o\sigma\eta\; \tau\eta\varsigma\;\sigma\tau o\nu\;\varepsilon \upsilon\rho{\acute \upsilon}\tau \varepsilon\rho o\; \beta\alpha\lambda\kappa\alpha\nu \iota\kappa{\acute o}\;\chi{\acute \omega}\rho o,\; <$> <$>\Pi \rho\alpha\kappa\tau\iota\kappa{\acute \alpha}\;\Delta \iota\varepsilon\theta\nu o{\acute \upsilon}\varsigma\; E\pi\iota\sigma\tau\eta\mu o\nu\iota \kappa o{\acute \upsilon}\;\Sigma\upsilon\mu\pi o\sigma {\acute \iota}o\upsilon,\;\hbox{A}\theta{\acute \eta}\nu\alpha\))Google Scholar
  3. Brush S.G. (1999) Why Was Relativity Accepted? Physics in perspective 1, 184–214CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Clogg R. (2002) A Concise History of Greece, 2nd edn. CUP, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  5. Dialetis, D., Gavroglu, K. & Patiniotis M.: 1997, ‘The Sciences in the Creek Speaking Regions During the 17th and 18th Centuries. The Process of Appropriation and the Dynamics of Reception and Resistance’, Archimedes Vol. 2, KluwerGoogle Scholar
  6. Dimaras, A.: 1973, Greek Education: The Reformation that Never Happened, Two volumes, Estia, Athens (\(\Delta\eta\mu \alpha\rho {\acute \alpha}\varsigma,\;{\rm A}\).: 1973,\(N\varepsilon o\varepsilon\lambda\lambda\eta\nu\iota\kappa {\acute \eta}\; E\kappa\pi\alpha{\acute \iota}\delta \varepsilon\upsilon\sigma\eta ,\;H \; \mu\varepsilon \tau\alpha\rho\rho{\acute \upsilon}\theta\mu\iota \sigma\eta\;\pi o\upsilon\;\delta\varepsilon\nu \;{\acute \varepsilon}\gamma\iota<$> <$>\nu\varepsilon,\; \Delta {\acute \upsilon}o \; \tau{\acute o}\mu o\iota, \;\hbox{E}\sigma\tau{\acute \iota}\alpha, \;\hbox{A}\theta {\acute \eta}\nu\alpha\))Google Scholar
  7. Gavroglu, K.: 1998, “The Trasnmission and Assimilation of Scientific Ideas to the Greek Speaking World ca. 1700–1900: The Case of Chemistry”, Chemistry in Europe 1750–1900, CUP, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  8. Gavroglu, K.: 2003, “The Centre from the Periphery: Appropriating Scientific Ideas During the Eighteenth Century”, Revue de la Maison Française d’Oxford Volume I, no 2 Google Scholar
  9. Georgiadou M. (2004) Constantin Caratheodory: Mathematics and Politics in Turbulent Times. Springer-Verlag, Berlin, Heidelberg, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  10. Glick T.F. (ed) (1987) The Comparative Reception of Relativity. Reidel, DordrechtGoogle Scholar
  11. Glick T.F. (ed.) (1988) The Comparative Reception of Darwinism. University of Chicago Press, Chicago and LondonGoogle Scholar
  12. Jammer, M.: 1985, The Conceptual Development of Quantum Mechanics, AIPGoogle Scholar
  13. Karas, Y.: 1993, ‘Newtonian Physics and Scientific Thought During The Period of Greek Enlightment’, in Vlahakis, G.N. (ed.): Newtonian physics and its diffusion in the Balkans – Proceedings of the International Scientific Symposium, Athens (\(\hbox{K}\alpha\rho{\acute \alpha} \varsigma,\;\Gamma\).: 1993, ‘\(\hbox{`N}\varepsilon\upsilon\tau{\acute \omega}\nu\varepsilon\iota\alpha\;\Phi\upsilon \sigma\iota\kappa{\acute \eta}\;\kappa\alpha\iota\;\eta \; \varphi\upsilon\sigma\iota\kappa{\acute \eta}\;\sigma\kappa{\acute \varepsilon}\psi\eta\;\kappa\alpha\tau{\acute \alpha}\;\tau\eta\nu\;\pi\varepsilon\rho{\acute \iota}o\delta o\; \tau\eta\varsigma\; {N} \varepsilon o\varepsilon\lambda\lambda\eta\nu \iota \kappa{\acute \eta}\varsigma\;{A}\nu\alpha\gamma{\acute \varepsilon}\nu\nu\eta\sigma\eta\varsigma\hbox{'},<$> <$>\; \sigma\tau o\; \hbox{B}\lambda\alpha\chi {\acute \alpha} \kappa\eta\varsigma,\;\Gamma. \hbox{N}.(\varepsilon\pi\iota\mu.),\;H\;N \varepsilon\upsilon\tau {\acute \omega}\nu\varepsilon\iota\alpha\;\Phi\upsilon \sigma\iota\kappa{\acute \eta}\;\kappa\alpha\iota\;\eta \; \delta\iota{\acute \alpha}\delta o\sigma\eta\;\tau \eta\varsigma\;\sigma\tau o\nu<$> <$>\;\varepsilon\upsilon \rho{\acute \upsilon}\tau\varepsilon\rho o\;\beta\alpha \lambda\kappa\alpha \nu\iota\kappa{\acute o}\;\chi {\acute \omega}\rho o,\; \Pi\rho\alpha\kappa\tau\iota \kappa{\acute \alpha}\;\Delta\iota \varepsilon\theta\nu o{\acute \upsilon}\varsigma\; E\pi\iota\sigma \tau \eta\mu o\nu\iota\kappa o{\acute \upsilon}\;\Sigma \upsilon\mu\pi o\sigma{\acute \iota}o\upsilon,\; \hbox{A}\theta<$> <$>{\acute \eta}\nu\alpha\))Google Scholar
  14. Karas, Y. & Vlahakis, G.N. (eds.): 2004, History and Philosophy of Science in the Greek Region (17th–19th Century), Metaihmio, Athens (\(\hbox{K}\alpha \rho{\acute \alpha}\varsigma,\;\Gamma. \&\hbox{B}\lambda\alpha\chi{\acute \alpha}\kappa \eta\varsigma, \;\Gamma.\hbox{N}. (\varepsilon\pi\iota\mu): 2004,\; I\sigma\tau o<$> <$>\rho{\acute \iota} \alpha \;\kappa\alpha\iota\;\Phi\iota\lambda o\sigma o\varphi {\acute \iota}\alpha\;\tau\omega\nu\;E \pi\iota \sigma\tau\eta\mu{\acute \omega}\nu\;\sigma\tau o\nu\; E\lambda\lambda\eta\nu\iota\kappa {\acute o}\;{\rm X}{\acute \omega}\rho o,\; (17^{o\varsigma}\)\(19^{o\varsigma}\alpha\iota{\acute \omega}\nu \alpha\varsigma),\; \hbox{M}\varepsilon\tau\alpha {\acute \iota}\chi\mu\iota o,<$> <$>\; \hbox{A}\theta{\acute \eta} \nu\alpha)\) Google Scholar
  15. Kritikos, Th.: 1991, ‘The Phycisists in Greece in the Beggining of the 20th Century (1900–1912)’, Historica 14, 141–156. (\(\hbox{K}\rho\eta\tau\iota\kappa {\acute o}\varsigma, \;\Theta.: 1991,\; `\hbox{O}\iota\;\varphi\upsilon\sigma\iota \kappa o{\acute \iota}\;\sigma\tau\eta\nu\;\hbox{E}\lambda\lambda{\acute \alpha}\delta\alpha\;\sigma\tau \eta\nu\;\alpha<$> <$>\rho\chi{\acute \eta}\;\tau o\upsilon\;20^{o\upsilon}\; \alpha\iota{\acute \omega}\nu \,\alpha\) (1900–1912),\(T\alpha\;I\sigma\tau o\rho\iota \kappa{\acute \alpha}\) 14, σɛλ. 141–156)Google Scholar
  16. Kritikos, Th.: 1993a, ‘Physics in Greece Between 1900 and 1930’, Conference Proceedings, Vol. 42, History of Physics in Europe in the 19th and 20th Centuries, SIF, Bologna, pp. 221–237Google Scholar
  17. Kritikos, Th.: 1993b, Physics in Greece (1900–1930), PhD. Dissertation, Ionian UniversityGoogle Scholar
  18. Kritikos, Th.: 1995, The Reception of Scientific Thought in Greece, Papazisi, Athens. (\(\hbox{K}\rho\eta\tau\iota\kappa {\acute o}\varsigma,\;\Theta.:\;1995,\; H\; \upsilon\pi o\delta o\chi{\acute \eta}\;\tau\eta\varsigma \;\varepsilon\pi\iota\sigma\tau\eta \mu o\nu \iota \kappa{\acute \eta}\varsigma\;\sigma\kappa {\acute \varepsilon}\psi\eta\varsigma\;\sigma\tau\eta \,\nu\; E\lambda\lambda{\acute \alpha}\delta\alpha,\; \Pi\alpha \pi\alpha\zeta{\acute \eta}\sigma\eta,<$> <$>\;\hbox{A} \theta{\acute \eta}\nu\alpha\).)Google Scholar
  19. Kritikos Th. (1999) Science and Religion in Greece at the End of the Nineteenth Century. Historein 1:35–50Google Scholar
  20. Lappas, K.: 2004, University and Students in the Greek State of 19th Century, INR/NHRF, Athens (\(\Lambda{\acute \alpha} \pi\pi\alpha\varsigma,\;\hbox{K}.:\; 2004,\; \Pi\alpha\nu \varepsilon\pi\iota\sigma\tau{\acute \eta}\mu\iota o \; \kappa\alpha\iota\;\varphi o\iota\tau\eta\tau {\acute \varepsilon}\varsigma\;\sigma\tau\eta\nu\;E\lambda\lambda{\acute \alpha}\delta\alpha\;\kappa\alpha\tau{\acute \alpha}\;\tau o\nu 19^{o}\alpha\iota{\acute \omega}\nu\alpha,<$> <$> \hbox{IAEN/}\Gamma\Gamma \hbox{N}\Gamma,\; \hbox{A}\theta {\acute \eta}\nu\alpha\))Google Scholar
  21. Lefkaditis, G.: 1927, ‘An Index of Foreign Magazines of Physics & Chemistry in Athens’, Erga 64, p. 426. (\(\Lambda\varepsilon \upsilon\kappa\alpha\delta{\acute \iota}\tau o\upsilon,\;\Gamma.:\; 1927,\; `\hbox{K}\alpha\tau{\acute \alpha}\lambda o \gamma o\varsigma\;\tau\omega\nu\;\varepsilon\nu\;\hbox{A}\theta{\acute \eta}\nu\alpha\iota\varsigma\; \xi {\acute \varepsilon}\nu\omega \nu\;\pi\varepsilon\rho\iota o\delta\iota\kappa{\acute \omega}\nu\;\Phi \upsilon\sigma<$> <$>\iota\kappa{\acute \eta}\varsigma\& \hbox{X}\eta\mu\varepsilon{\acute \iota}\alpha\varsigma',\; {\acute E}\rho\gamma\alpha\; 64,\; \sigma\varepsilon \lambda\). 426)Google Scholar
  22. Mpiris, K.: 1957, History of the National Metsovian Technical University, NMPS, Athens (\(\hbox{M}\pi{\acute \iota}\rho \eta \varsigma,\;\hbox{K}.:\; 1957,\; I \sigma\tau o\rho {\acute \iota}\alpha\;\tau o\upsilon\;E\theta\nu \iota\kappa o{\acute \upsilon}\; M\varepsilon\tau\sigma{\acute o}\beta\varepsilon\iota o\upsilon\;\Pi o\lambda\upsilon\tau\varepsilon\chi\nu\varepsilon {\acute \iota}o\upsilon,\; \hbox{EM}\Pi,\;\hbox{A}\theta {\acute \eta}\nu\alpha\))Google Scholar
  23. Nikolaidis, E. & Chatzis, K. (eds.): 2000, Science, Technology and the 19th Century State, Conference Proceedings, NHRF, AthensGoogle Scholar
  24. Nikolaidis, E. & Chatzis, K. (eds.): 2003, Science, Technology and the 19th Century State: The Role of the Army, Conference Proceedings, NHRF/C.N.R.S., AthensGoogle Scholar
  25. Patiniotis, M.: 2000, The Scientific Travels of the Greek Scholars During the 18th Century, Science and Technology in the European Periphery, LisbonGoogle Scholar
  26. Patiniotis, M.: 2004, ‘Periphery Reassessed: Newtonianism in the Greek Context’, Science in Europe – Europe in Science: 1500–2000, MaastrichtGoogle Scholar
  27. Paty M. (1999) La réception de la théorie de la relativité au Brésil et l’influence des traditions scientifiques européenes. Archives Internationales d’Histoire des Sciences 49: 331–368Google Scholar
  28. Psomiades, P., Nicolaidis, E. & Skordoulis, C.: 2005, ‘The Presence of Soviet Science in Greece in the Period 1945–1992’, Proceedings of the International Conference HPST 2005, LeedsGoogle Scholar
  29. Stefanidis, M.: 1948, History of the School of Mathematics and Physics, Two volumes, National Printery, Athens. (\(\Sigma\tau \varepsilon\varphi\alpha\nu{\acute \iota}\delta\eta \varsigma, \;\hbox{M}.:; 1948,\; I\sigma\tau o\rho {\acute \iota}\alpha\; \tau\eta\varsigma\;\Phi\upsilon \sigma\iota\kappa o\mu\alpha\theta\eta\mu\alpha \tau\iota\kappa{\acute \eta}\varsigma\;\Sigma\chi<$> <$> o\lambda{\acute \eta}\varsigma,\; \Delta{\acute \upsilon}o\;\tau{\acute o}\mu o\iota, \;\hbox{E} \kappa\;\tau o\upsilon\; \hbox{E}\theta\nu\iota\kappa o{\acute \upsilon}\; \hbox{T}\upsilon\pi o\gamma\rho\alpha\varphi \varepsilon {\acute \iota}o\upsilon,\; \hbox{A}\theta{\acute \eta}\nu \alpha\))Google Scholar
  30. Stachel J. (1998) Obituary: Achilleas Papapetrou. Physics Today 51(12): 74Google Scholar
  31. Tampakis, K.: 2004, The Reception of Quantum Mechanics in Greece (1900–1965), MSc dissertation, Department of Primary Education, University of Athens, Athens (\(\hbox{T}\alpha\mu \pi{\acute \alpha}\kappa \eta\varsigma,\; \hbox{K}.:\; 2004,\; H\; \upsilon\pi o\delta o\chi{\acute \eta}\;\tau\eta\varsigma\; K\beta\alpha\nu\tau o\mu\eta\chi\alpha \nu \iota\kappa{\acute \eta}\varsigma\;\sigma\tau\eta\nu\;E\lambda\lambda{\acute \alpha}\delta\alpha,\;\hbox{M}\varepsilon\tau\alpha\pi\tau\upsilon\chi \iota \alpha\kappa{\acute \eta}\;\pi\tau\upsilon<$> <$>\chi\iota \alpha\kappa{\acute \eta}\;\delta\iota\alpha\tau\rho \iota\beta{\acute \eta},\;\Pi\hbox{T}\Delta\hbox{E},\;\hbox{ EK}\Pi\hbox{A, A}\theta{\acute \eta}\nu\alpha\))Google Scholar
  32. Vlahakis, G.N.: 2005a, ‘Early Critique of Modern Science by Greek Christian Circles ’, Critical Science & Education, 2, Athens. (\(\hbox{B}\lambda\alpha\chi{\acute \alpha}\kappa\eta\varsigma, \;\Gamma.\;\hbox{N}.:\; 2005,; \Pi\rho{\acute \omega}\iota\mu \eta \;\kappa\rho\iota\tau\iota\kappa{\acute \eta}\;\chi\rho<$> <$> \iota\sigma\tau\iota\alpha\nu\iota\kappa {\acute \omega}\nu\;\kappa{\acute \upsilon}\kappa\lambda \omega\nu\;\sigma\tau\eta\;\sigma{\acute \upsilon}\gamma \chi\rho o\nu\eta\;\varepsilon\pi\iota\sigma\tau {\acute \eta}\mu\eta. {\acute {\rm O}}\psi\varepsilon\iota \varsigma\;\kappa\alpha\iota\;\alpha\pi{\acute o}\psi \varepsilon\iota\varsigma',\; K\rho\iota\tau \iota\kappa{\acute \eta}\;\varepsilon\pi\iota\sigma\tau {\acute \eta}\mu\eta\& E\kappa\pi\alpha<$> <$> {\acute \iota}\delta\varepsilon\upsilon\sigma\eta \, 2, \hbox{A}\theta{\acute \eta}\nu\alpha\))Google Scholar
  33. Vlahakis, G.N.: 2005b, The Reception of Einstein’s Ideas in Greece, EEF, Athens (\(\hbox{B}\lambda\alpha\chi{\acute \alpha} \kappa\eta \varsigma,\;\Gamma.\hbox{N}.:\; 2005, H\; \upsilon\pi o\delta o\chi{\acute \eta}\;\tau\omega\nu\;\iota \delta\varepsilon{\acute \omega}\nu\;\tau o\upsilon\;A {\ddot \iota}\nu\sigma\tau{\acute\alpha}\iota \nu,\; \hbox{EE}\Phi,\;\hbox{A}\theta{\acute \eta}\nu\alpha\))Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media, Inc. 2006

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Department of Primary Education, Athens Science and Education LaboratoryUniversity of AthensAthensGreece

Personalised recommendations