Science & Education

, Volume 15, Issue 1, pp 31–54 | Cite as

Generative Role of Experiments in Physics and in Teaching Physics: A Suggestion for Epistemological Reconstruction

  • Ismo T. Koponen
  • Terhi Mäntylä
Article

Abstract

In physics teaching experimentality is an integral component in giving the starting point of knowledge formation and conceptualization. However, epistemology of experiments is not often addressed directly in the educational and pedagogical literature. This warrants an attempt to produce an acceptable reconstruction of the epistemological role of experiments in physics by drawing insight from history and philosophy of physics. Towards that end, the experiments’ role in the 19th-century physics is discussed. We propose here a reconstruction, which is based on the idea that in epistemology of experiments the inductive-like generative justification of knowledge is central. A generative view makes it possible to retain those aspects of experiments which make them purposeful for learning and can give a starting point for students’ own construction of knowledge. The reconstruction also helps to conceive the experiments with their correct historical role and helps to bring back the generative use of experiments in teaching, which, after all, has never vanished from the practice of physics.

Keywords

Physic Teaching Teaching Experimentality Generative View Integral Component Pedagogical Literature 
These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Arons, A. 1993‘Guiding Insight and Inquiry in the Introductory Physics Laboratory’The Physics Teacher31278282Google Scholar
  2. Bagno, E., Eylon, B.-S., Ganiel, U. 2000‘From Fragmented Knowledge to a Knowledge Structure: Linking the Domains of Mechanics and Electromagnetism’American Journal of Physics68S16S26CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Berry, J., Sahlberg, P. 1996‘Investigating Pupils’ Ideas of Learning’Learning and Instruction61936CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Brush, S.G. 1983Statistical Physics and the Atomic Theory of MatterPrinceton University PressPrincetonGoogle Scholar
  5. Buchwald, J.D. 1994The Creation of Scientific EffectsUniversity of Chicago PressChicagoGoogle Scholar
  6. Cartwright, N. 1983How the Laws of Physics LieClarendon PressOxfordGoogle Scholar
  7. Chang, H. 2001‘Spirit, Air and Quicksilver: The Search for the “Real” Scale of Temperature’Historical studies in the physical and biological sciences31249284CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Darrigol, O. 2000Electrodynamics from Ampere to EinsteinOxford University PressOxfordGoogle Scholar
  9. Duhem P. 1914/1954, The Aim and Structure of Physical Theory (translation of La Théorie Physique: Son Objet, Sa Structure, 2nd edn, 1914 Paris), Princeton University Press, Princeton.Google Scholar
  10. Duit, R., Confrey, J. 1996‘Reorganizing the Curriculum and Teaching to Improve Learning in Science and Mathematics’Treagust, D.F.Duit, R.Fraser, B.J. eds. Improving Teaching and Learning in Science and MathematicsTeachers College Press, Columbia UniversityNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  11. Einstein, A. 1970‘Autobiographical Notes’Schilpp, P. eds. Albert Einstein: Philosopher-Scientist. The Library of Living PhilosophersMJF BooksNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  12. Etkina, E., Heuvelen, A., Brookes, D.T., Mills, D. 2002‘Role of Experiments in Physics Instruction – a Process Approach’The Physics Teacher40351355Google Scholar
  13. Feynman, R.P., Leighton, R.B., Sands, M. 1963The Feynman Lectures on PhysicsAddison-WesleyReading, MAGoogle Scholar
  14. Franklin, A. 1986The Neglect of ExperimentCambridge University PressCambridgeGoogle Scholar
  15. Franklin, A. 1999‘The Roles of Experiment’Physics in Perspective13553CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Fine, A. 1986The Shaky GameUniversity of Chicago PressChicagoGoogle Scholar
  17. Galison, P. 1997Image and LogicUniversity of Chicago PressChicagoGoogle Scholar
  18. Giere, R.N. 1988Explaining Science: A Cognitive ApproachUniversity of Chicago PressChicagoGoogle Scholar
  19. Giere, R.N. 1999Science without LawsUniversity of Chicago PressChicagoGoogle Scholar
  20. Gil-Pérez, D., Guisásola, J., Moreno, A., Cachapuz, A., Pessoade Carvalho, A.M., Martínez Torregrosa, J., Salinas, J., Valdés, P., González, E., Gené Duch, A., Dumas-Carré, A., Tricárico, H., Gallego, R. 2002‘Defending Constructivism in Science Education’Science & Education11557571Google Scholar
  21. Gooding, D. 1990Experiment and the Making of MeaningKluwer Academic PublisherDordrechtGoogle Scholar
  22. Gooding, D.Pinch, T.Schaffer, S eds. 1993The Uses of Experiment: Studies in the Natural SciencesCambridge University PressCambridgeGoogle Scholar
  23. Hacking, I. 1983Representing and InterveningCambridge University PressCambridgeGoogle Scholar
  24. Hammer, D. 1996‘More than Misconceptions: Multiple Perspectives on Student Knowledge and Reasoning, and an Appropriate role for Education Research’American Journal of Physics6413161325CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Hanson, N.R. 1958Patterns of DiscoveryCambridge University PressCambridgeGoogle Scholar
  26. Heidelberger, M. 1998‘From Helmholtz’s Philosophy of Science to Hertz’ Picture Theory’Baird, D.Hughes, R.I.G.Nordmann, A. eds. Heinrich Hertz: Classical Physicist, Modern PhilosopherKluwer Academic PublisherDordrechtGoogle Scholar
  27. Hestenes, D. 1992‘Modeling Games in the Newtonian World’American Journal of Physics60732748Google Scholar
  28. Hestenes, D. 1998‘Who Needs Physics Education Research?’American Journal of Physics66465467CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Hodson, D. 1992‘In Search of a Meaningful Relationship: An Exploration of some Issues Relating to Integration in Science and Science Education’International Journal of Science Education14541562Google Scholar
  30. Hodson, D. 1993‘Re-Thinking Old Ways: Towards a More Critical Approach to Practical Work in Science’Studies in Science Education2285142Google Scholar
  31. Hodson, D. 1996‘Laboratory Work as Scientific Method: Three Decades of Confusion and Distortion’Journal of Curriculum Studies28115135Google Scholar
  32. Hon, G. 2003‘From Propagation to Structure: The Experimental Technique of Bombardment as Contributing Factor to the Emerging Quantum Physics’Physics in Perspective5150173Google Scholar
  33. Izquierdo-Aymerich, M., Adúriz-Bravo, A. 2003‘Epistemological Foundations of School Science’Science & Education122743Google Scholar
  34. Jungnickel C., McCormmach R. (1986). Intellectual Mastery of Nature: Theoretical Physics from Ohm to Einstein,Vol. 1: The Torch of Mathematics, 1800–1870, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.Google Scholar
  35. Jurkowitz, E. 2002‘Helmholtz and the Liberal Unification of Science’Historical Studies in the Physical and Biological Sciences32291317CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Kim, D.-W. 2002Leadership and Creativity: A History of the Cavendish Laboratory, 1871–1919Kluwer Academic PublisherDordrechtGoogle Scholar
  37. Koponen, I.T., Mäntylä, T., Lavonen, J. 2004‘The Role of Physics Departments in Developing Student Teachers’ Expertise in Teaching Physics’European Journal of Physics25645653CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Kuhn, T.S. 1996The Structure of Scientific Revolutions3University of Chicago PressChicagoGoogle Scholar
  39. Lavonen, J., Jauhiainen, J., Koponen, I.T., Kurki-Suonio, K. 2004‘Effect of a Long-term in-service Training Program on Teachers’ Beliefs about the Role of Experiments in Physics Education’International Journal of Science Education26309328CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Lazarowitz, R., Tamir, P. 1994‘Research on Using Laboratory Instruction in Science’Gabel, D.L. eds. Handbook of Science Teaching and LearningMacmillan Publishing CompanyNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  41. Matthews, M.R. 1997‘Introductory Comments on Philosophy and Constructivism in Science Education’Science & Education6514Google Scholar
  42. Matthews, M.R. 2000‘Editorial’Science & Education9491505Google Scholar
  43. May, D.B., Etkina, E. 2002‘College Physics Students’ Epistemological Self-Reflection and its Relationship to Conceptual Learning’American Journal of Physics7012491258CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. McDermott, L., Shaffer, P.S., Constantinou, C.P. 2000‘Preparing Teachers to Teach Physics and Physical Science by Inquiry’Physics Education35411416CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Millar, R. 1989‘What is Scientific Method and Can it be Taught?’Wellington, J. eds. Skills and Processes in Science EducationRoutledgeLondonGoogle Scholar
  46. Nersessian, N. 1984Faraday to Einstein: Constructing Meaning in Scientific TheoryKluwer Academic PublisherDordrechtGoogle Scholar
  47. Nersessian, N. 1995‘Should Physicists Preach What They Practise?’Science & Education4203226CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Niaz, M., Abd-El-Khalick, F., Benarroch, A., Cardellini, L., Laburú, C.E., Marín, N., Montes, L.A., Nola, R., Orlik, Y., Scharmann, L.C., Tsai, C.-C., Tsaparlis, G. 2003‘Constructivism: Defense or a Continual Critical Appraisal – A Response to Gil-Perez et al.’Science & Education12787797CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Nickles, T. 1993‘Justification and Experiment’Gooding, D.Pinch, T.Schaffer, S. eds. The Uses of Experiment: Studies in the Natural SciencesCambridge University PressCambridgeGoogle Scholar
  50. Nola, R. 1997‘Constructivism in Science and Science Education: A Philosophical Critique’Science & Education65583Google Scholar
  51. Popper, K.: 1935/2002, The Logic of Scientific Discovery, (translation of Logik der Forschung, 1935), Routledge Classics, Routledge, London.Google Scholar
  52. Redish, E. 1994‘The Implications of Cognitive Studies for Teaching Physics’American Journal of Physics62796803CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Redish, E.F. 1999‘Millikan Lecture 1998: Building a Science of Teaching Physics’American Journal of Physics67562573CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Reichenbach, H. 1951The Rise of Scientific PhilosophyCalifornia University of California PressBerkeleyGoogle Scholar
  55. Reif, F. 1987‘Instructional Design, Cognition and Technology: Applications to the Teaching of Scientific Concepts’Journal of Research in Science Teaching24309324Google Scholar
  56. Reif, F. 1995‘Millikan Lecture 1994: Understanding and Teaching Important Scientific Thought Processes’American Journal of Physics631732CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. Reif-Acherman, S. 2004‘Heike Kamerlingh Onnes: Master of Experimental Technique and Quantitative Research’Physics in Perspective6197223CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Robin, G. 1904Oeuvres Scientifiques. Thermodynamique GénéraleGauthier VillarsParisGoogle Scholar
  59. Sokoloff, D., Thornton, R. 1997‘Using Interactive Lecture Demonstrations to Create an Active Learning Environment’The Physics Teacher35340347Google Scholar
  60. Smith, C., Wise, M.N. 1989Energy and Empire: A Biographical Study of Lord KelvinCambridge University PressCambridgeGoogle Scholar
  61. Suppe, F. 1977The Structure of Scientific Theories2University of Illinois PressUrbanaGoogle Scholar
  62. Toulmin, S. 1969The Philosophy of Science: An IntroductionHutchinsonLondonGoogle Scholar
  63. Trumper, R. 2003‘The Physics Laboratory – A Historical Overview and Future and Perspectives’Science & Education12645670Google Scholar
  64. Fraassen, B. 1980The Scientific ImageClarendon PressOxfordGoogle Scholar
  65. Heuvelen, A. 1991‘Learning to Think like a Physicist: A Review of Research-Based Instructional Strategies’American Journal of Physics59891897Google Scholar
  66. Helmholtz, H. 1886‘On the Relation of Natural Science to Science in General’Cahan, D. eds. Helmholtz, Science and Culture: Popular and philosophical EssaysUniversity of Chicago PressChicagoGoogle Scholar
  67. Watson, J.R., Prieto, T., Dillon, J. 1995‘The Effects of Practical Work on Students’ Understanding of Combustion’Journal of Research in Science Teaching32487502Google Scholar
  68. Weinberg, S. 1993Dreams of a Final TheoryVintageLondonGoogle Scholar
  69. Wellington, J. 1998‘Practical Work in Science’Wellington, J. eds. Practical Work in School Science: Which Way Now?RoutledgeLondonGoogle Scholar
  70. Wells, M., Hestenes, D., Swackhamer, G. 1995‘A Modeling Method for High School Physics Instruction’American Journal of Physics63606619CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  71. Whewell, W. 1847Philosophy of Inductive SciencesJ. W. ParkerLondonGoogle Scholar
  72. White, T. 1996‘The Link Between the Laboratory and Learning’International Journal of Science Education18761774Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer 2006

Authors and Affiliations

  • Ismo T. Koponen
    • 1
  • Terhi Mäntylä
    • 1
  1. 1.Department of Physical SciencesUniversity of HelsinkiFinland

Personalised recommendations