A Qualitative Method for Assessing Faculty Satisfaction Article DOI:
Cite this article as: Ambrose, S., Huston, T. & Norman, M. Res High Educ (2005) 46: 803. doi:10.1007/s11162-004-6226-6
Universities attempt to hire the highest quality faculty they can, but they are not always successful at retaining them. Furthermore, some faculty members who do remain may not function as engaging colleagues who make others want to stay. This study investigates why some faculty members leave and why others stay by illuminating the complexities of individual experiences. Using semi-structured interviews rather than surveys, a matched cohort of 123 faculty members (half current and half former) from one institution was interviewed. Although some of their primary reasons for satisfaction or dissatisfaction (e.g., collegiality, mentoring) were predicted by general survey research, there were also unforeseeable issues that strongly influenced satisfaction and decisions to stay or leave, demonstrating the importance of institution-specific research. This paper provides a method for collecting institution-specific information as well as several arguments for conducting interviews instead of pre-defined surveys.
Keywords faculty retention faculty satisfaction qualitative research collegiality mentoring References Arreola, R. 1995Developing a Comprehensive Faculty Evaluation System Anker Publishing Company, Inc Bolton, MA Google Scholar Barnes, L. L. B., Agago, M. O., Coombs, W. T. 1998 Effects of job related stress on faculty intention to leave academia Research in Higher Education 39 457 469 CrossRef Google Scholar Bensimon, E. M., Polkinghorne, D. E., Bauman, G., Vallejo, E. 2004 Doing research that makes a difference Journal of Higher Education 75 23 41 Google Scholar Bluedorn, A. 1982 The theories of turnover: Causes, effects, and meaning Research in the Sociology of Organizations 1 75 128 Google Scholar Boice, R. 1992 Lessons learned about mentoring Sorcinelli, M. D. Austin, A. E. eds. Developing New and Junior Faculty. New Directions for Teaching and Learning Jossey-Bass Inc San Francisco 51 61 Google Scholar Bowen, H. R., Schuster, J. H. 1986American Professors: A Natural Resource Imperiled Oxford University Press New York Google Scholar Boyer, E. L., Altbach, P. G., Whitlaw, M. 1994The Academic Profession: An International Perspective Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching Princeton, NJ Google Scholar Boyle, P., Boice, R. 1998 Best practices for enculturation: Collegiality, mentoring, and structure Anderson, M. S. eds. The Experience of Being in Graduate School: An Exploration. New Directions for Higher Education, No 101. Jossey-Bass San Francisco 87 94 Google Scholar Brown, J. D., Rogers, R. J. 1991 Self-serving attributions: The role of physiological arousal Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 17 501 506 Google Scholar Caplow, T., McGee, R. J. 1958The Academic Marketplace Greenwood Press Westport, CT Google Scholar Chilcott, J. H. 1987 Where are you coming from and where are you going? The Reporting of Ethnographic Research American Educational Research Journal 24 199 218 Google Scholar Clark, S. M., Corcoran, M., Lewis, D. R. 1986 The case for institutional perspective on faculty development Journal of Higher Education 57 176 195 Google Scholar Creswell, J. W., Wheeler, D. W., Seagren, A. T., Egly, N. J., Beyer, K. D. 1990The Academic Chairperson’s Handbook University of Nebraska Press Lincoln, NE Google Scholar
Ehrenberg, R. G., Rizzo, M. R., and Jakubson, G. H. (2003). Who bears the growing cost of science at universities? Cornell Higher Education Research Institute, Working Paper 35
Fetterman, D. M. 1990Ethnographic Auditing: A New Approach to Evaluating Management New Directions for Institutional Research, 68 Jossey-Bass San Francisco Google Scholar Fink, L. D. 1984The First Year of College Teaching New Directions for Teaching and Learning, 17 Jossey-Bass San Francisco Google Scholar Finkelstein, M. J., LaCelle-Peterson, M. W. 1992 New and junior faculty: A review of the literature Sorcinelli, M. D. Austin, A. E. eds. Developing New and Junior Faculty. New Directions for Teaching and Learning, No 50. San Francisco Jossey-Bass Inc 5 14 Google Scholar Gartshore, R. J., Hibbard, M., Stockard, J. 1983Factors Affecting Mobility at the University of Oregon University of Oregon Eugene, OR Google Scholar Gmelch, W. H. 1987 What colleges and universities can do about faculty stressors Seldin, P. eds. Coping with Faculty Stress New Directions for Teaching and Learning Jossey-Bass San Francisco 23 31 Google Scholar Greenberg, J., Pyszczynski, T., Solomon, S. 1982 The self-serving attributional bias: Beyond self-presentation Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 18 56 67 CrossRef Google Scholar
Harrigan, M. N. (1999). An analysis of faculty turnover at the University of Wisconsin-Madison. Paper Presented at the 39th Annual AIR Forum, Seattle, WA, May 30-June 2, 1999
Johnsrud, L. K., Rosser, V. J. 2002 Faculty members’ morale and their intention to leave The Journal of Higher Education 73 518 541 Google Scholar Kerlin, S. P., Dunlap, D. M. 1993 For richer, for poorer: Faculty morale in periods of austerity and retrenchment Journal of Higher Education 64 348 377 Google Scholar Lee, T. W., Mowday, R. T. 1987 Voluntarily leaving an organization: An empirical investigation of Steers’ and Mowday’s model of turnover Academy of Management Journal 30 721 743 Google Scholar Manger, T., Eikeland, O. J. 1990 Factors predicting staff’s intentions to leave the university Higher Education 19 281 291 CrossRef Google Scholar Matier, M. W. 1990 Retaining faculty: A tale of two campuses Research in Higher Education 31 30 60 CrossRef Google Scholar Maxwell, J. A. 1996Qualitative Research Design: An Interactive Approach,Applied Social Research Methods Series, 41 Sage Publications Thousand Oaks Google Scholar Merriam, S. B. 1998Qualitative Research and Case Study Applications in Education Jossey-Bass San Francisco Google Scholar
Merriam, S. B. and Associates (2002).
Qualitative Research in Practice: Examples for Discussion and Analysis, San Francisco: Jossy-Bass Miller, D. T., Ross, M. 1975 Self-serving biases in the attribution of causality: Fact or fiction? Psychological Bulletin 82 213 225 Google Scholar Murray, M. 1991Beyond the Myths and Magic of Mentoring Jossey-Bass San Francisco Google Scholar Olsen, D. 1993 Work satisfaction and stress in the first and third year of academic appointment Journal of Higher Education 64 453 471 Google Scholar Olsen, D., Maple, S. A., Stage, F. K. 1995 Women and minority faculty job satisfaction Journal of Higher Education 66 267 293 Google Scholar Olsen, D., Sorcinelli, M. D. 1992 The pretenure years: A longitudinal perspective Sorcinelli, M. D. Austin, A. E. eds. Developing New and Junior Faculty New Directions for Teaching and Learning Jossey-Bass San Francisco 15 25 Google Scholar Philip, K., Hendry, L. B. 2000 Making sense of mentoring or mentoring making sense? Reflections on the mentoring process by adult mentors with young people Journal of Community and Applied Social Psychology 10 211 223 CrossRef Google Scholar Seldin, P. 1987 Research findings on causes of academic stress Seldin, P. eds. Coping with Faculty Stress New Directions for Teaching and Learning Jossey-Bass San Francisco 13 21 Google Scholar Sibley-Fries, M. 1986 Extended probation at research universities Academe 72 37 40 Google Scholar Smart, J. C. 1990 A causal model of faculty turnover intentions Research in Higher Education 31 405 424 CrossRef Google Scholar
Solomon, L. C. and Fagnano, C.L. (1993). The cost of hiring. In: Stein and Trachtenberg (eds.),
The Art of Hiring in America’s Colleges and Universities, Prometheus Books, New York Sorcinelli, M. D. 1992 New and junior faculty stress: Research and responses Sorcinelli, M. D. Austin, A. E. eds. Developing New and Junior Faculty New Directions for Teaching and Learning Jossey-Bass San Francisco 27 37 Google Scholar Sorcinelli, M. D. 1988 Satisfactions and concerns of new university teachers Kurfiss, J. Hilsen, L. Kahn, S. Sorcinelli, M. D. Tiberus, R. eds. To Improve the Academy: Vol. 17. Resources for Faculty, Instructional, and Organizational Development New Forums Press Stillwater, OK 121 133 Google Scholar Sorcinelli, M. D. Austin, A. E. eds. 1992Developing New and Junior Faculty New Directions for Teaching and Learning San Francisco Jossey-Bass Inc Google Scholar Tack, M. W., Patitu, C. L. 1992Faculty Job Satisfaction: Women and Minorities in Peril The George Washington University, School of Education and Human Development Washington, DC Google Scholar
Texas Higher Education Coordinating Board (March, 2001).
Faculty Turnover and Retention: A Summary of Faculty Exit Surveys at Texas Public Universities, Health-Related Institutions, and Technical Colleges Tolbert, P. S. 1995 The effects of gender composition in academic departments on faculty turnover Industrial and Labor Relations Review 48 562 579 Google Scholar
Toombs, W. and Marlier, J. (1981) Career change among academics: Dimensions of decision. Paper Presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, Los Angeles, CA
Tourangeau, R., Rips, L. J., Rasinski, K. 2000The Psychology of Survey Response Cambridge University Press Cambridge, UK Google Scholar Tucker, A. 1984Chairing the Academic Department Macmillan New York Google Scholar Turner, J. L., Boice, R. 1987 Starting at the beginning: The concerns and needs of new faculty Kurfiss, J. Hilsen, L. Mortensen, L. Wadworth, R. eds. To Improve the Academy: Vol. 6. Resources for Faculty, Instructional, and Organizational Development New Forums Press Stillwater, OK 41 47 Google Scholar Walvoord, B. E., Carey, A. K., Smith, H. L., Soled, S. W., Way, P. K., Zorn, D. 2000Academic Departments: How They Work, How They Change Jossey-Bass San Francisco Google Scholar Weiler, W. C. 1985 Why do faculty members leave the university? Research in Higher Education 23 270 277 CrossRef Google Scholar Wheeler, D. W. 1992 The role of the chairperson in support of junior faculty Sorcinelli, M. D. Austin, A. E. eds. Developing New and Junior Faculty New Directions for Teaching and Learning Jossey-Bass San Francisco 87 96 Google Scholar Wimsatt, L. A. 2003 A study of work-related satisfaction and turnover intentions of faculty in higher education Dissertation Abstracts International Section A: Humanities and Social Sciences 63 3497 Google Scholar Williams, D., Olswang, S. G., Hargett, G. 1986 A matter of degree: Faculty morale as a function of involvement in institutional decisions during times of financial distress Review of Higher Education 9 287 301 Google Scholar Copyright information
© Springer Science+Business Media, Inc. 2005