Advertisement

Reviews in Fish Biology and Fisheries

, Volume 24, Issue 3, pp 943–954 | Cite as

The use (and misuse) of archaeological salmon data to infer historical abundance in North America with a focus on New England

  • Stephen F. Jane
  • Keith H. Nislow
  • Andrew R. Whiteley
Research Paper

Abstract

Information about historical animal or plant abundance often either explicitly or implicitly informs current conservation practice. If it can be shown that an organism was not historically abundant in a region, its conservation importance may be downgraded. In contrast to abundant archaeological support for historic importance of salmon in the Pacific Northwest, historic abundance of Atlantic salmon in New England has been called into question based on the rarity of salmon bones in archaeological sites. These data have been used to argue that the importance of salmon to the region has been exaggerated and that expensive restoration efforts in some rivers should be reconsidered. Here, we argue that lack of archaeological bone fragment abundance does not make a convincing case against historical Atlantic salmon abundance in New England for three primary reasons. First, salmon bones were rare or absent at sites that still have large salmon runs. Second, the lack of salmonid bones in general at archaeological sites suggests poor preservation and/or recovery of bone for these species relative to bones of other fishes. Third, given the presence of large numbers of non-salmonid anadromous fish in the site areas where people fished and deposited fish bones, power to detect salmon bones in studies to date may have been generally low. We present reliable historical accounts that help build a convincing case that salmon were historically abundant in New England rivers. We suggest that rarity of salmon bones in the existing archaeological data should not have unwarranted influence on present-day conservation decision-making in New England.

Keywords

Archaeological Calcined Middens Bone Conservation decision making Historical abundance Pacific salmon Atlantic salmon 

Notes

Acknowledgments

The authors wish to thank B. Ardren and four anonymous reviewers for input that helped to improve the final version of this manuscript. In addition, thanks to D. Glassberg for providing a forum that sparked the writing of this manuscript.

References

  1. Barber JW (1836) Connecticut historical collections. John W. Barber, New HavenGoogle Scholar
  2. Butler VL, Campbell SK (2004) Resource intensification and resource depression in the Pacific Northwest of North America: a zooarchaeological review. J World Prehist 18(4):327–405CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Butler VL, Chatters JC (1994) The role of bone density in structuring prehistoric salmon bone assemblages. J Archaeol Sci 21:413–424CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Cannon A (1991) The economic prehistory of namu. Archaeology Press Simon Fraser University, BurnabyGoogle Scholar
  5. Cannon A (1996) The early Namu archaeofauna. In: Carlson RL, Dalla Bona LR (eds) Early human occupation in British Columbia. UBC Press, VancouverGoogle Scholar
  6. Cannon A (2000) Assessing variability in Northwest Coast salmon and herring fisheries: bucket-auger sampling of shell midden sites on the central coast of British Columbia. J Archaeol Sci V 27:725–737CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Carlson CC (1988) Where’s the salmon? A reevaluation of the role of anadromous fisheries in aboriginal New England. In: Nicholas GP (ed) Holocene human ecology in Northeastern North America. Plenum Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  8. Carlson CC (1992) The Atlantic salmon in New England prehistory and history: social and environmental implications. Ph.D. Dissertation. University of Massachusetts at AmherstGoogle Scholar
  9. Casteel RW (1976) Fish remains in archaeology and paleo-environmental studies. Academic Press, LondonGoogle Scholar
  10. Chaput GJ (1995) Temporal distribution, spatial distribution, and abundance of diadromous fish in the Miramichi River Watershed. In: Chadwick EMP (ed) Water, science, and the public: the miramichi ecosystem. Canadian Special Publication of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada. pp 121–139Google Scholar
  11. Chaput GJ (2012) Overview of the status of Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) in the North Atlantic and trends in marine mortality. ICES J Mar Sci 69:1538–1548CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. CRASC (1998) Strategic plan for the restoration of Atlantic salmon to the Connecticut RiverGoogle Scholar
  13. Cressman LS, Cole DL, Davis WA, Newman TM, Scheans DJ (1960) Cultural sequences at the Dalles, Oregon: A contribution to Pacific Northwest prehistory. Trans Am Philos Soc 50(10):1–108CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Department of Fisheries and Oceans Canada (2010) Assessment of Atlantic salmon in the Miramichi River (NB), 1998 to 2009. Canadian Science Advisory Secretariat Science Response 2010/005Google Scholar
  15. Durbin A, Nixon S, Oviatt C (1979) Effects of the spawning migration of the Alewife, Alosa-Pseudoharengus, on freshwater ecosystems. Ecology 60:8–17CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Elliott JM, Elliott JA (2010) Temperature requirements of Atlantic salmon Salmo salar, brown trout Salmo trutta and Arctic charr Salvelinus alpinus: predicting the effects of climate change. J Fish Biol 77:1793–1817PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Facey DE, Avyle Van Den, Michael J (1986) Species profiles: life histories and environmental requirements of coastal fishes and invertebrates (South Atlantic). Am Shad 82:1–18Google Scholar
  18. Foster CHW (1991) Yankee salmon: the Atlantic salmon of the Connecticut River. CIS, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  19. Freeman S (2003) Ladders give lift to returning shad. The Republican A:1Google Scholar
  20. General Court of Massachusetts (1781, reprinted 1890) Acts and laws of the commonwealth of Massachusetts pp 1780–1781Google Scholar
  21. General Court of Massachusetts (1786, reprinted 1893) Acts and Laws of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, 1786–1787Google Scholar
  22. General Court of Massachusetts (1788, reprinted 1894) Acts and laws of the commonwealth of Massachusetts, 1788–1789Google Scholar
  23. General Court of Massachusetts (1790, reprinted 1895) Acts and laws of the commonwealth of Massachusetts, 1790–1791Google Scholar
  24. General Court of Massachusetts (1905) The Acts and resolves, public and private of the province of Massachusetts Bay, 1741–1746Google Scholar
  25. Gonter NH (2010) Fish Passage Urged for Manhan Dam. The Republican:3Google Scholar
  26. Green MA, Springfield (Mass.) (1888) Springfield, 1636–1886: history of town and city: including an account of the quarter-millennial celebration at Springfield, Mass., May 25 and 26, 1886. C.A. Nichols, [Springfield, Mass.]Google Scholar
  27. Greenberg P (2010) Four fish: the future of the last wild food. Penguin Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  28. Griffin SG, Whitcomb FH, Applegate O (1904) A history of the town of Keene from 1732, when the township was granted by Massachusetts, to 1874, when it became a city. Sentinel Print, Keene, New Hampshire (NH)Google Scholar
  29. Hansen LP, Quinn TP (1998) The marine phase of the Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) life cycle, with comparisons to Pacific salmon. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 55:104–118CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Haro A, Castro-Santos T (2012) Passage of American shad: paradigms and realities. Mar Coast Fish 4:252–261CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Hudy M, Thieling TM, Gillespie N, Smith EP (2005) Distribution, status and threats to brook trout within the eastern United States. Report Submitted to the Eastern Brook Trout Joint Venture, International Association of Fish and Wildlife Agencies, Washington, DCGoogle Scholar
  32. Hudy M, Thieling TM, Gillespie N, Smith EP (2008) Distribution, status, and land use characteristics of subwatersheds within the native range of brook trout in the Eastern United States. North Am J Fish Manag 28:1069–1085CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Jones R (2008) More Interesting Numbers… The Connecticut River Salmon Association NewsletterGoogle Scholar
  34. Juanes F, Gephard S, Beland KF (2004) Long-term changes in migration timing of adult Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) at the southern edge of the species distribution. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 61:2392–2400CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Judd S, Boltwood LM (1863) History of hadley. Metcalf and Company, NorthamptonGoogle Scholar
  36. Klemetsen A, Amundsen P, Dempson J, Jonsson B, Jonsson N, O’Connell M, Mortensen E (2003) Atlantic salmon Salmo salar L., brown trout Salmo trutta L. and Arctic charr Salvelinus alpinus (L.): a review of aspects of their life histories. Ecol Freshw Fish 12:1–59CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Leggett WC (1976) The American shad (Alosa sapidissima), with special reference to its migration and population dynamics in the Connecticut River. In: Merriman D, Thorpe LM (eds) The Connecticut River ecological study, vol 1. American Fisheries Society, Washington, pp 169–225Google Scholar
  38. Levin PS, Schiewe MH (2001) Preserving salmon biodiversity. American Scientist 89Google Scholar
  39. Limburg K, Hattala K, Kahnle A (2003) American shad in its native range. Biodivers Status Conserv World’s Shads 35:125–140Google Scholar
  40. Loesch JG (1987) Overview of life history aspects of anadromous alewife and blueback herring in freshwater habitats. In: Dadswell MJ, Klauda RJ, Moffitt CM, Saunders RL, Rulifson RA, Cooper JE (eds) Common strategies of anadromous and catadromous fishes. American Fisheries Society, Bethesda, pp 89–103Google Scholar
  41. Marschall EA, Allison GW, Mather ME, Parrish DL, McMenemy JR (2011) Migration delays caused by anthropogenic barriers: modeling dams, temperature, and success of migrating salmon smolts. Ecol Appl 21:3014–3031CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Massachusetts, Thomas I (1799) The perpetual laws of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, from the establishment of its constitution… [1780–1799]. Compiled, arranged and printed to the wishes of many respectable law characters, and the approbation of the honourable judges of the Supreme Judicial Court. Carefully compared with the original acts. II. Thomas, WorcesterGoogle Scholar
  43. Mather ME, Frank HJ, Smith JM, Cormier RD, Muth RM, Finn JT (2012) Assessing freshwater habitat of adult anadromous alewives using multiple approaches. Mar Coast Fish 4:188–200CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Matson RG (1992) The evolution of Northwest Coast subsistence. In: Croes DR, Hawkins RA, Isaac BL (eds) Long-term subsistence change in prehistoric North America. JAI Press Inc, GreenwichGoogle Scholar
  45. Matsui A (1996) Archaeological investigations of anadromous salmonid fishing in Japan. World Archaeol 27:444–460CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Maymon JH, Bolian CE (1992) The Wadleigh falls site: an early and middle Archaic period site in southeastern New Hampshire. In: Robinson BS, Petersen JB, Robinson AK (eds) Early holocene occupation in Northern New England, vol 9. Occasional Publications in Maine Archaeology, Augusta p 117Google Scholar
  47. Merrill E, Merrill P (1817) Gazetteer of the state of New-Hampshire… C. Norris, ExeterGoogle Scholar
  48. Meyer K (2009) Turners falls turnaround. Sanctuary magazine. http://www.massaudubon.org/sanctuary/features.php?id=12. Accessed 26 April 2012
  49. Naylor R, Hindar K, Fleming IA, Goldburg R, Volpe J, Whoriskey F, Eagle J, Kelso D, Mangel M, Williams S (2005) Fugitive salmon: assessing the risks of escaped fish from net-pen aquaculture. Bioscience 55:427–437CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. New Hampshire, United States (1797) The laws of the State of New Hampshire: the Constitution of the State of New-Hampshire, and the Constitution of the United States: with its proposed amendments. John Melcher, PortsmouthGoogle Scholar
  51. Northampton Town Meeting (1844) Memorial of the inhabitants of Northampton to the Massachusetts general court. Hampshire Gazette:1Google Scholar
  52. Parrish DL, Behnke RJ, Gephard SR, McCormick SD, Reeves GH (1998) Why aren’t there more Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar)? Can J Fish Aquat Sci 55:281–287CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Partlow MA (2006) Sampling fish bones: a consideration of the importance of screen size and disposal context in the North Pacific. Arct Anthropol 43:67–79CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Pease JC, Niles JM (1819) Gazetteer of the states of Connecticut and Rhode Island. HartfordGoogle Scholar
  55. Peters S (1782) A general history of Connecticut, 2nd edn. LondonGoogle Scholar
  56. Petersen JB, Maine Archaeological Society, Maine Historic Preservation Commission (1991) Archaeological testing at the Sharrow site: a deeply stratified early to late Holocene cultural sequence in central Maine. Maine Archaeological Society, Maine Historic Preservation Commission, AugustaGoogle Scholar
  57. Rensel JEJ, Haigh N, Tynan TJ (2010) Fraser river sockeye salmon marine survival decline and harmful blooms of Heterosigrna akashiwo. Harmful Algae 10:98–115CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Robinson BS, Jacobson GL, Yates MG, Spiess AE, Cowie ER (2009) Atlantic salmon, archaeology and climate change in New England. J Archaeol Sci 36:2184–2191CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Sanger D (2003) Who lived in pre-European Maine? A cosmology approach to social patterning on the landscape. Northeast Anthropol V 66:29–39Google Scholar
  60. Scott WB, Scott MG (1988) Atlantic fishes of Canada. Published by the University of Toronto Press in cooperation with the Minister of Fisheries and Oceans and the Canadian Govt. Pub. Centre, Supply and Services Canada, TorontoGoogle Scholar
  61. Spiess AE (1992) Archaic period subsistence in New England and the Atlantic provinces. In: Robinson BS, Petersen JB, Robinson AK (eds) Early holocene occupation in Northern New England. Maine Historic Preservation Commission, Augusta, pp 163–180Google Scholar
  62. Spiess AE, Lewis RA, Maine State Museum, Maine Historic Preservation Commission, Maine Archaeological Society (2001) The turner farm fauna: 5000 years of hunting and fishing in Penobscot Bay, Maine. Maine State Museum, Maine Historic Preservation Commission, Maine Archaeological Society, AugustaGoogle Scholar
  63. Stiner MC, Kuhn SL, Weiner S, Ofer B (1995) Differential burning, recrystallization and fragmentation of archaeological bone. J Archaeol Sci 22(2):223–237CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  64. United States. National Marine Fisheries Service., and U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. Region 5. 2005 Recovery plan for the Gulf of Maine distinct population segment of Atlantic Salmon (Salmo salar)Google Scholar
  65. Zimmerman JKH, Letcher BH, Nislow KH, Lutz KA, Magilligan FJ (2010) Determining the effects of dams on subdaily variation in river flows at a whole-basin scale. River Res Appl 26:1246–1260CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media Dordrecht 2013

Authors and Affiliations

  • Stephen F. Jane
    • 2
  • Keith H. Nislow
    • 1
  • Andrew R. Whiteley
    • 2
  1. 1.U.S. Forest Service, Northern Research StationUniversity of MassachusettsAmherstUSA
  2. 2.Department of Environmental ConservationUniversity of MassachusettsAmherstUSA

Personalised recommendations