The End of ‘the end of impunity’? The International Criminal Court and the Challenge from Truth Commissions
With its express intention ‘to put an end to impunity’, the International Criminal Court (ICC) faces a substantial challenge in the shape of conditional amnesties granted in future national truth commissions (TCs)—a challenge that invokes fundamental considerations of criminal justice ethics. In this article, I give an account of the challenge, and I consider a possible solution to it presented by Declan Roche. According to this solution the ICC-prosecutor should respect national amnesties and prosecute and punish only those perpetrators who have refused to cooperate with the TC. I argue, however, that this compromise is untenable. As a general rule, if we justify the ICC on grounds of deterrence we should not accept conditional amnesties granted in national TCs.
KeywordsInternational Criminal Court Deterrence Truth commissions Amnesties Restorative justice Declan Roche
- Acorn, A.E. 2004. Compulsory compassion: A critique of restorative justice. Vancouver: UBC Press.Google Scholar
- Aristotle, 1987. Nichomachean ethics. In A new Aristotle reader, ed. J.L. Ackrill. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
- Braithwaite, J. 1989. Crime, shame and reintegration. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
- Braithwaite, J. 2002. Restorative justice & responsive regulation. Oxford; New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Brudholm, T. 2008. Resentment’s virtue: Jean Améry and the refusal to forgive. Philadelphia, PA.; Chesham: Temple University Press; Combined Academic. [distributor].Google Scholar
- Christie, N. 1977. Conflicts as property. The British Journal of Criminology 17(1): 1–15.Google Scholar
- Clinton, B. 2000. Statement by the president, http://clinton4.nara.gov/library/hot_releases/December_31_2000.html, accessed on November 26, 2008.
- Dignan, J. 2003. Towards a systemic model of restorative justice. In Restorative justice and criminal justice: Competing or reconcilable paradigms?, ed. A. Von Hirsch, J. Roberts, A.E. Bottoms, K. Roach, and M. Schiff, 135–156. Oxford; Portland, OR: Hart.Google Scholar
- Dugard, J. 2002. Possible conflicts of jurisdiction with truth commissions. In The Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court: A commentary, ed. A. Cassese, P. Gaeta, and J.R.W.D. Jones, 693–704. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Dworkin, R. 1986. Law’s empire. Oxford: Hart, 1998.Google Scholar
- Ellis, A. 2001. What should we do with war criminals? In War crimes and collective wrongdoing: A reader, ed. A. Jokic, 97–112. Malden, MA; Oxford: Blackwell Publishers.Google Scholar
- Ellis, A. 2010. War crimes, punishment and the burden of proof. Res Publica 16(1). doi: 10.1007/s11158-010-9110-6.
- Hughes, L.N. 1997. Don’t make a federal case out of it: The constitution and the nationalization of crime. American Journal of Criminal Law 25(1): 151–163. Fall 1997.Google Scholar
- International Criminal Court. 2008. Twelfth diplomatic briefing of the International Criminal Court.Google Scholar
- Johnstone, G. 2002. Restorative justice: Ideas, values, debates. Cullompton, Devon, UK; Portland, OR: Willan Publishers.Google Scholar
- Marshall, T.F. 2003. Restorative justice: An overview. In A restorative justice reader: Texts, sources, context, ed. G. Johnstone, 28–45. Cullompton, UK; Portland, OR: Willan Publishing.Google Scholar
- May, L. 2005. Crimes against humanity: A normative account. Cambridge, UK; New York: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
- McCold, P. 2000. Toward a holistic vision of restorative juvenile justice: A reply to the maximalist model. Contemporary Justice Review 3(4): 357–414.Google Scholar
- Minow, M. 2000. The hope for healing: What can truth commissions do? In Truth vs. justice: The morality of truth commissions, ed. R.I. Rotberg, and D. Thompson, 235–260. Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
- Rotberg, R.I., and D.F. Thompson. 2000. Truth vs. justice: The morality of truth commissions. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
- Thomas, A.S. 1964. Summa Theologiæ. Latin text and English translation, introductions, notes, appendices and glossaries. London: Blackfriars in conjunction with Eyre & Spottiswoode.Google Scholar
- Tutu, D. 2005. Tutu urges apartheid prosecutions, BBC News, Africa, http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/africa/4534196.stm. Accessed 26/11/08.
- Van Ness, D.W. 2002. Creating restorative systems. In Restorative justice and the law, ed. L. Walgrave, 130–149. Devon, UK: Willan Publishing.Google Scholar
- Walgrave, L. 2002. Restorative justice and the law: Socio-ethical and juridical foundations for a systemic approach. In Restorative justice and the law, ed. L. Walgrave, 191–218. Devon, UK: Willan Publishing.Google Scholar
- Wippman, D. 1999. Atrocities, deterrence, and the limits of international justice. Fordham International Law Journal 23: 473–488.Google Scholar
- Zehr, H. 2005. Changing lenses: A new focus for crime and justice. Scottdale, PA: Herald Press.Google Scholar