Discretionary loan loss provision behavior in the US banking industry

  • Dung Viet Tran
  • M. Kabir Hassan
  • Reza HoustonEmail author
Original Research


Earnings management can be opportunistic and add noise to earnings, or informative about a firm’s underlying economic performance and add information to financial reports. Our study examines earnings management in banks with different levels of information asymmetry. We compare earnings management between public and private banks by using discretionary loan loss provisions (DLLPs) as a proxy. We use a dataset of US public and private banks from 1986:Q1 to 2013:Q4 and provide evidence of greater earnings management in public banks than private banks. We also examine the conditions that motivate managers to engage in earnings management. DLLPs are used to send private information to investors, consistent with our signaling hypothesis. We also find evidence that capital requirements alter DLLPs, consistent with our capital management hypothesis. Banks with relatively low (high) earnings tend to decrease (increase) their earnings through manipulation of DLLPs, inconsistent with our income-smoothing hypothesis. This study extends the current literature on earnings management between public and private banks. Our discussion provides a better understanding of the determinants of bank earnings management.


Bank listing status Discretionary loan loss provisions Earnings management Information asymmetry 

JEL Classification

G21 G28 G34 G38 



Funding was provided by National Foundation for Science and Technology Development.


  1. Ahmed A, Takeda C, Thomas S (1999) Bank loan loss provisions: a reexamination of capital management, earnings management and signaling effects. J Account Econ 28:1–25CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Ali A, Zhang W (2015) CEO tenure and earnings management. J Account Econ 59(1):60–79CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Ball R, Shivakumar L (2005) Earnings quality in UK private firms: comparative loss recognition timeliness. J Account Econ 39:83–128CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Barton J, Waymire G (2004) Investor protection under unregulated financial reporting. J Account Econ 38:65–116CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Bartov E, Givoly D, Hayn C (2002) The rewards to meeting or beating earnings expectations. J Account Econ 33:173–204CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Beatty A, Harris DE (1999) The effects of taxes, agency costs and information asymmetry on earnings management: a comparison of public and private firms. Rev Account Stud 4:299–326CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Beatty AL, Liao S (2014) Financial accounting in the banking industry: a review of the empirical literature. J Account Econ 58:339–383CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Beatty A, Chamberlain S, Magliolo J (1995) Managing financial reports of commercial banks: the influence of taxes, regulatory capital, and earnings. J Acc Res 33:231–261CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Beatty AL, Ke B, Petroni KR (2002) Earnings management to avoid earnings declines across publicly and privately held banks. Account Rev 77:547–570CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Beaver WH, Engel EE (1996) Discretionary behavior with respect to allowances for loan losses and the behavior of security prices. J Account Econ 22:177–206CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Beaver W, Eger C, Ryan S, Wolfson M (1989) Financial reporting, supplemental disclosures, and bank share prices. J Account Res 27:157–178CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Bebchuk L, Cohen A, Ferrell A (2009) What matters in corporate governance? Rev Financ Stud 22:783–827CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Beck PJ, Narayanamoorthy GS (2013) Did the SEC impact banks’ loan loss reserve policies and their informativeness? J Account Econ 56:42–65CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Berger AN, Bouwman CH (2013) How does capital affect bank performance during financial crises? J Financ Econ 109:146–176CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Berger AN, Herring RJ, Szegö GP (1995) The role of capital in financial institutions. J Bank Finance 19:393–430CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Bergstresser D, Philippon T (2006) CEO incentives and earnings management. J Financ Econ 80:511–529CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Black BS (1992) Institutional investors and corporate governance: the case for institutional voice. J Appl Corp Finance 5:19–32CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Brown JR, Ivković Z, Smith PA, Weisbenner S (2008) Neighbors matter: causal community effects and stock market participation. J Finance 63:1509–1531CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Burgstahler D, Dichev I (1997) Earnings management to avoid earnings decreases and losses. J Account Econ 24:99–126CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Burgstahler DC, Hail L, Leuz C (2006) The importance of reporting incentives: earnings management in European private and public firms. Account Rev 81:983–1016CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Bushman RM, Williams CD (2012) Accounting discretion, loan loss provisioning, and discipline of Banks’ risk-taking. J Account Econ 54:1–18CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Cheng Q, Warfield TD (2005) Equity incentives and earnings management. Account Rev 80:441–476CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Chiang TF, Wu EC, Yu MT (2007) Premium setting and bank behavior in a voluntary deposit insurance scheme. Rev Quant Finance Account 29:205–222CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Collins JH, Shackelford DH, Wahlen JM (1995) Bank differences in the coordination of regulatory capital, earnings, and taxes. J Account Res 33:263–291CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Cornett MM, McNutt JJ, Tehranian H (2009) Corporate governance and earnings management at large US bank holding companies. J Corp Finance 15:412–430CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Dechow PM, Dichev ID (2002) The quality of accruals and earnings: the role of accrual estimation errors. Account Rev 77:35–59CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Dechow PM, Sloan RG, Sweeney AP (1995) Detecting earnings management. Account Rev 70(2):193–225Google Scholar
  28. Dechow P, Ge W, Schrand C (2010) Understanding earnings quality: a review of the proxies, their determinants and their consequences. J Account Econ 50:344–401CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. DeFond ML, Jiambalvo J (1994) Debt covenant violation and manipulation of accruals. J Account Econ 17:145–176CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. DeFond ML, Park CW (1997) Smoothing income in anticipation of future earnings. J Account Econ 23:115–139CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Degeorge F, Patel J, Zeckhauser R (1999) Earnings management to exceed thresholds. J Bus 72:1–33CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Dichev ID, Graham JR, Harvey CR, Rajgopal S (2013) Earnings quality: evidence from the field. J Account Econ 56:1–33CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Docking DS, Hirschey M, Jones E (2000) Reaction of bank stock prices to loan-loss reserve announcements. Rev Quant Finance Account 3:277–297CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Doyle JT, Ge W, McVay S (2007) Accruals quality and internal control over financial reporting. Account Rev 82:1141–1170CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Elliot JA, Hanna JD (1991) The evaluation by the financial markets of changes in bank loan loss reserve levels. Account Rev 66:847–861Google Scholar
  36. Fama EF, Jensen MC (1983) Agency problems and residual claims. J Law Econ 26:327–349CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Ferreira D, Manso G, Silva AC (2014) Incentives to innovate and the decision to go public or private. Rev Financ Stud 27:256–300CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Fonseca AR, González F (2008) Cross-country determinants of bank income smoothing by managing loan loss provisions. J Bank Finance 32:217–228CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Francis J, Olsson P, Schipper K (2006) Earnings quality. Found Trends Account 1:259–340CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Frankel RM, Johnson MF, Nelson KK (2002) The relation between auditors’ fees for nonaudit services and earnings management. Account Rev 77:71–105CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Gao H, Harford J, Li K (2017) CEO turnover-performance sensitivity in private firms. J Financ Quant Anal 52:583–611CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Givoly D, Hayn CK, Katz SP (2010) Does public ownership of equity improve earnings quality? Account Rev 85:195–225CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Goel AM, Thakor AV (2003) Why do firms smooth earnings? J Bus 76:151–192CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Graham JR, Harvey CR, Rajgopal S (2005) The economic implications of corporate financial reporting. J Account Econ 40:3–73CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Greenawalt MB, Sinkey JF (1988) Bank loan loss provisions and the income-smoothing hypothesis: an empirical analysis, 1976–1984. J Financ Serv Res 1:301–318CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Hazarika S, Karpoff JM, Nahata R (2012) Internal corporate governance, CEO turnover, and earnings management. J Financ Econ 104(1):44–69CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Healy PM (1985) The effect of bonus schemes on accounting decisions. J Account Econ 7:85–107CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Healy PM, Wahlen JM (1999) A review of the earnings management literature and its implications for standard setting. Account Horiz 13:365–383CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Heckman JJ, Ichimura H, Todd PE (1997) Matching as an econometric evaluation estimator: evidence from evaluating a job training programme. Rev Econ Stud 64:605–654CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Hong Y, Huseynov F, Sardarli S, Zhang W (2019) Bank earnings management and analyst coverage: evidence from loan loss provisions. Rev Quant Finance Account. CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Hope OK, Thomas WB, Vyas D (2013) Financial reporting quality of U.S. private and public firms. Account Rev 88:1715–1742CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Huizinga H, Laeven L (2012) Bank valuation and accounting discretion during a financial crisis. J Financ Econ 106:614–634CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Jensen MC, Meckling WH (1976) Theory of the firm: managerial behavior, agency costs and ownership structure. J Financ Econ 3:305–360CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Jiang L, Levine R, Lin C (2016) Competition and bank opacity. Rev Financ Stud 29:1911–1942CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. Jones JJ (1991) Earnings management during import relief investigations. J Account Res 29(2):193–228CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Kai L, Prabhala NR (2007) Chapter 2: self-selection models in corporate finance. In: Eckbo BE (ed) Handbook of empirical corporate finance. Handbooks in Finance. Elsevier, San DiegoGoogle Scholar
  57. Kanagaretnam K, Lobo GJ, Mathieu R (2003) Managerial incentives for income smoothing through bank loan loss provisions. Rev Quant Finance Accoun 1:63–80CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Kanagaretnam K, Lobo GJ, Yang DH (2004) Joint tests of signaling and income smoothing through bank loan loss provisions. Contemp Account Res 21:843–884CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Kanagaretnam K, Krishnan GV, Lobo GJ (2010) An empirical analysis of auditor independence in the banking industry. Account Rev 85:2011–2046CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Kane EJ, Yu MT (1995) Measuring the true profile of taxpayer losses in the S & L insurance mess. J Bank Finance 19(8):1459–1477CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Kim MS, Kross W (1998) The impact of the 1989 change in bank capital standards on loan loss provisions and loan write-offs. J Account Econ 25:69–99CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. Kim JB, Yi CH (2006) Ownership structure, business group affiliation, listing status, and earnings management: evidence from Korea. Contemp Account Res 23:427–464CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  63. Koh K, Matsumoto DA, Rajgopal S (2008) Meeting or beating analyst expectations in the post-scandals world: Changes in stock market rewards and managerial actions. Contemp Account Res 25(4):1067–1098CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  64. Kothari SP, Leone AJ, Wasley CE (2005) Performance matched discretionary accrual measures. J Account Econ 39:163–197CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  65. Kwak W, Lee HY, Eldridge SW (2009) Earnings management by Japanese bank managers using discretionary loan loss provisions. Rev Pac Basin Financ Mark Policies 12(1):1–26CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  66. Lee SC, Lin CT, Yu MT (2013) A fractional cointegration approach to testing the Ohlson accounting based valuation model. Rev Quant Finance Account 41:535–547CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  67. Leuz C, Nanda D, Wysocki PD (2003) Earnings management and investor protection: an international comparison. J Financ Econ 69:505–527CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  68. Levitt (1998) The numbers game. Speech delivered at New York University Center for Law and Business, September 28Google Scholar
  69. Liu CC, Ryan SG (1995) The effect of bank loan portfolio composition on the market reaction to and anticipation of loan loss provisions. J Account Res 33(1):77–94CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  70. Liu CC, Ryan SG, Wahlen JM (1997) Differential valuation implications of loan loss provisions across banks and fiscal quarters. Account Rev 72(1):133–146Google Scholar
  71. Lobo GJ, Yang DH (2001) Bank managers’ heterogeneous decisions on discretionary loan loss provisions. Rev Quant Finance Account 16:223–250CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  72. Moyer SE (1990) Capital adequacy ratio regulations and accounting choices in commercial banks. J Account Econ 13:123–154CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  73. Nichols DC, Wahlen JM, Wieland MM (2009) Publicly traded versus privately held: implications for conditional conservatism in bank accounting. Rev Account Stud 14:88–122CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  74. Penman SH, Richardson SA, Tuna I (2007) The book-to-price effect in stock returns: accounting for leverage. J Account Res 45:427–467CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  75. Rosenbaum PR, Rubin DB (1983) The central role of the propensity score in observational studies for causal effects. Biometrika 70:41–55CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  76. Scholes MS, Wilson GP, Wolfson MA (1990) Tax planning, regulatory capital planning, and financial reporting strategy for commercial banks. Rev Financ Stud 3:625–650CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  77. Skinner DJ, Sloan RG (2002) Earnings surprises, growth expectations, and stock returns or don’t let an earnings torpedo sink your portfolio. Rev Account Stud 7:289–312CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  78. Teoh SH, Welch I, Wong TJ (1998) Earnings management and the long-run market performance of initial public offerings. J Finance 53:1935–1974CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  79. Tran DV, Hassan MK, Houston R (2019) Ownership structure and bank risk: the effects of crisis, market discipline and regulatory pressure. N Am J Econ Finance. CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  80. Wahlen JM (1994) The nature of information in commercial bank loan loss disclosures. Account Rev 69(3):455–478Google Scholar
  81. Warfield TD, Wild JJ, Wild KL (1995) Managerial ownership, accounting choices, and informativeness of earnings. J Account Econ 20:61–91CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  82. Yang DH (2009) Signaling through accounting accruals vs. financial policy: evidence from bank loan loss provisions and dividend changes. Rev Pacific Basin Financ Mark Policies 12(1):63–80CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  83. Yu F (2008) Analyst coverage and earnings management. J Financ Econ 88:245–271CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media, LLC, part of Springer Nature 2019

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Banking University Ho Chi Minh CityHo Chi Minh CityVietnam
  2. 2.Institute of Research and DevelopmentDuy Tan UniversityDa NangVietnam
  3. 3.College of Business Administration, Kirschman HallUniversity of New OrleansNew OrleansUSA
  4. 4.Miller College of BusinessBall State UniversityMuncieUSA

Personalised recommendations