On arguing for the existence of god as a synthesis between realism and anti-realism



This article examines a somewhat neglected argument for the existence of God which appeals to the divine perspective as a way of reconciling the conflicting claims of realism and anti-realism. Six representative examples are set out (Berkeley, Ferrier, T. H. Green, Josiah Royce, Gordon Clark and Michael Dummett), reasons are considered why this argument has received less attention than it might, and a brief sketch given of the most promising way in which it might be developed.


Realism Anti-realism God Existence Berkeley Ferrier T. H. Green Josiah Royce Gordon Clark Michael Dummett 


Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.


  1. Aquinas. De Veritatae.Google Scholar
  2. Armour, L. (1991–1992). Error and the Idealists. Philosophia, 21, 3–23.Google Scholar
  3. Augustine. Freedom of the Will.Google Scholar
  4. Beards, A. (2007). Dummett: Philosophy and Religion. In R. B. Auxier & L. E. Hahn (Eds.), The Philosophy of Michael Dummett (Library of Living Philosophers). Chicago, IL: Open Court Publishing Company.Google Scholar
  5. Bennett J. (1965) Berkeley and God. Philosophy 40(153): 207–221CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Berkeley, G. (1710). The Principles of human understanding.Google Scholar
  7. Berkeley, G. (1713). Three dialogues between Hylas and Philonus (page numbers Luce/Jessop Collected Works).Google Scholar
  8. Botterill G. (2007) God and the First Person in Berkeley. Philosophy 82(1): 87–114CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Clark G. (1952) A Christian view of men and things. Baker Book House, Grand Rapids, MIGoogle Scholar
  10. Dummett M. (1994) Reply to McGuiness. In: McGuinness B., Olivieri G. (eds) The philosophy of Michael Dummett. Kluwer, DordrechtGoogle Scholar
  11. Dummett M. (2006) Thought and reality. Oxford University Press, OxfordCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Dummett M. (2010) The Future and Nature of Philosophy. Columbia University Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  13. Ferrier, J. F. (1842 [1883]). Berkeley and idealism. In Philosophical works (Vol. III, pp. 291–347). Edinburgh: Blackwood.Google Scholar
  14. Ferrier J.F. (1854) Institutes of metaphysics. Blackwood, EdinburghCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Ferrier, J. F. (1856 [1866]). Appendix to Institutes of Metaphysics’ in his Lectures on Greek Philosophy and Philosophical Remains. Edinburgh: Blackwood.Google Scholar
  16. Green, T. H. (1883). Prolegomena to ethics (5th ed., 1907). Oxford: Clarendon Press.Google Scholar
  17. Green, T. H. (c.1874–76 [1885–88]). Lectures on kant. In R. L. Nettleship (Ed.), Works of T. H. Green (Vol. II, pp. 1–155). London: Longmans Green.Google Scholar
  18. Green, T. H. (c.1874–75 [1885–88]). Lectures on logic. In R. L. Nettleship (Ed.), Works of T. H. Green (Vol. II, pp. 157–306). London: Longmans Green.Google Scholar
  19. Jacquette D. (1985) Berkeley’s continuity argument. The Journal of Religion 65(1): 1–14CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Keefe J. (2007) James Ferrier and the theory of ignorance. The Monist 90: 297–309CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Leibniz, G. W. (1714). Monadology.Google Scholar
  22. Mander W. J. (1998) Royce’s argument for the absolute. Journal of the History of Philosophy 36(3): 443–457CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Mander W.J. (2006) In defence of the eternal consciousness. In: Dimova–Cookson M., Mander W.J. (eds) T. H. Green: Ethics, metaphysics and political philosophy. Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  24. Morris T. V., Menzel C. H. (1986) Absolute creation. American Philosophical Quarterly 23(4): 353–362Google Scholar
  25. Murphy, B. (2007). Review of Thought and reality. Ars Disputandi 7. http://www.ArsDisputandi.org.
  26. Nash R.H. (1988) Faith and reason. Zondervan, Grand Rapids, MIGoogle Scholar
  27. Perry R. B. (1910) The egocentric predicament. Journal of Philosophy, Psychology and Scientific Method 7(1): 5–14CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Plantinga A. (1982) How to be an anti-realist. Proceedings and Addresses of the American Philosophical Association 56(1): 47–70CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Rashdall H. (1902) Personality: Human and divine. In: Sturt H. (Ed.) Personal idealism. Macmillan, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  30. Royce, J. (1885 [1913]). The religious aspect of philosophy (2nd ed.). Boston: Houghton Mifflin.Google Scholar
  31. Royce J. (1892) The spirit of modern philosophy. Houghton Mifflin, BostonGoogle Scholar
  32. Royce, J. (1887 [1897]). The Conception of God (2nd enlarged edition).Google Scholar
  33. Royce, J. (1899–1901). The world and the individual. New York: Macmillan.Google Scholar
  34. Tyler, C. (2010). The liberal socialism of T. H.Green, Vol. I (The Metaphysics of Self-Realisation and Freedom). Exeter: Imprint Academic.Google Scholar
  35. Wainwright W.J. (2010) Jonathan Edwards, God, and ‘particular minds’. International Journal of Philosophy of Religion 68(1): 201–213CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2011

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Harris Manchester CollegeOxfordUK

Personalised recommendations