Economics at the FTC: Retrospective Merger Analysis with a Focus on Hospitals

  • Joseph Farrell
  • Paul A. Pautler
  • Michael G. Vita


Economists at the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) support the agency’s competition and consumer protection missions. In this year’s essay we discuss efforts at the FTC and elsewhere to examine empirically the competitive effects of mergers. This work has ranged from subjective interview-based reports on post-merger behavior to more objective analyses of post-merger performance based on rigorous empirical analysis of prices. In this essay we discuss the merger retrospective literature generally, and focus on the FTC staff’s recent empirical analyses of consummated hospital mergers.


Antitrust Consumer protection FTC Mergers Merger retrospectives 


  1. Ashenfelter, O. C., & Hosken, D. S. (2010). The effect of mergers on consumer prices: Evidence from five mergers on the enforcement margin. Journal of Law & Economics (forthcoming).Google Scholar
  2. Ashenfelter O., Hosken D. S., Weinberg M. (2009) Generating evidence to guide merger enforcement. Competition Policy International 5(1): 57–75Google Scholar
  3. Baker J. B. (2009) Efficiencies and high concentration: Heinz proposes to acquire Beech-Nut. In: Kwoka J. E., White L. J. (eds) The antitrust revolution: Economics, competition, and policy. Oxford University Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  4. Balan, D. J., & Brand, K. J. (2009). Simulating hospital merger simulations. Retrieved from
  5. Barton D. M., Sherman R. (1984) The price and profit effects of horizontal merger: A case study. Journal of Industrial Economics 33: 165–177CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Biscourp, P., Boutin, X., & Vergé, T. (2008). The effects of retail regulations on prices: Evidence from the Loi Galland. Institut National De La Statistique Et Des Études ÉconomiquesGoogle Scholar
  7. Breen D. A. (2004) The Union Pacific/Southern Pacific rail merger: A retrospective on merger benefits. The Review of Network Economics 3(3): 283–322Google Scholar
  8. Capps C., Dranove D., Satterthwaite M. (2003) Competition and market power in options markets. RAND Journal of Economics 34: 737–763CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Carlton D. W. (2009) Why we need to measure the effect of merger policy and how to do it. Competition Policy International 5(1): 76–90Google Scholar
  10. Chen, V. (2009). The evolution of the baby food industry 2000–2008. Bureau of Economics, Federal Trade Commission, Working Paper # 297.Google Scholar
  11. Coate, M. B., & Heimert, A. J. (2009). Merger efficiencies at the Federal Trade Commission 1997–2007. Retrieved from Federal Trade Commission website
  12. Cooper J., Froeb L., O’Brien D., Vita M. (2005) Vertical antitrust policy as a problem of inference. International Journal of Industrial Organization 23: 639–664CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. European Commission., Buccirossi, P., Ciari, L., Duso, T., Fridolfsson, S., Spagnolo, G., & Vitale, C. (2006). Ex-post review of merger control decisions. Laboritorio di economica, antitrust, regolamentazione (Lear) for the European Commission’s DG Competition.Google Scholar
  14. Elzinga K. G., Hogarty T. F. (1974) The problem of geographic market delineation in antimerger suits. Antitrust Bulletin 18: 45–81Google Scholar
  15. Farrell, J., & Shapiro, C. (2008). Antitrust evaluation of horizontal mergers: An economic alternative to market definition. Working Paper presented at Federal Trade Commission/Northwestern University microeconomics conference, November 2008.Google Scholar
  16. Gaynor M., Vogt W. B. (2003) Competition among hospitals. RAND Journal of Economics 34(4): 764–785CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. General Accounting Office. (2004). The effects of mergers and market concentration in the US petroleum industry. Report to the Ranking Minority Member, Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations, Committee on Governmental Affairs, US Senate, United States General Accounting Office.Google Scholar
  18. Haas-Wilson, D., & Garmon, C. (2009). Two hospital mergers on Chicago’s North Shore: A retrospective study. Bureau of Economics, Federal Trade Commission, Working Paper # 294.Google Scholar
  19. Hunter G., Leonard G. K., Olley G. S. (2008) Merger retrospective studies: A review. Antitrust 23(1): 34–41Google Scholar
  20. Imbens G.W., Wooldridge J.M. (2009) Recent developments in the econometrics of program evaluation. Journal of Economic Literature 47(1): 5–86 (especially 67–70)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Ippolito P. M. (1991) Resale price maintenance: Empirical evidence from litigation. Journal of Law & Economics 34: 263–294CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Ippolito P. M., Overstreet T. R. (1996) Resale price maintenance: An economic assessment of the Federal Trade Commission’s case against the corning glass works. Journal of Law & Economics 39: 285–328CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Meyer B. (1995) Natural and quasi-experiments in economics. Journal of Business & Economic Statistics 13: 151–161CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Muris, T. J. (2002). Everything old is new again: Health care and competition in the 21st century. Prepared remarks at the 7th Annual competition in health care forum, Chicago, November 2.Google Scholar
  25. Pautler P. A. (2003) Evidence on mergers and acquisitions. Antitrust Bulletin 48: 119–221Google Scholar
  26. Peters C. (2006) Evaluating the performance of merger simulations: Evidence from the US airline industry. Journal of Law & Economics 49: 627–649CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Phillipson T. J., Posner R. A. (2009) Antitrust in the not-for-profit sector. Journal of Law & Economics 52(1): 1–18CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Prager R. A., Hannan T. H. (1998) Do substantial horizontal mergers generate significant price effects? Evidence from the banking industry. Journal of Industrial Economics 46: 433–452CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Richman B. D. (2007) Antitrust and nonprofit hospital mergers: A return to basics. University of Pennsylvania Law Review 156: 121–150Google Scholar
  30. Schumann, L., Rogers, R. P., & Reitzes, J. D. (1992). Case studies of the price effects of horizontal mergers. Federal Trade Commission, Bureau of EconomicsGoogle Scholar
  31. Simpson J., Taylor C. T. (2008) Do gasoline mergers affect consumers’ prices: The Marathon-Ashland and UDS transaction. Journal of Law & Economics 51(1): 135–152CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Steiger, J. (1990). Report from official Washington. Prepared remarks before the American bar association. March, pp. 10–16.Google Scholar
  33. Taylor C. T., Hosken D. S. (2007) The economic effects of the Marathon-Ashland joint venture: The importance of industry supply shocks and vertical market structure. Journal of Industrial Economics 55(3): 421–453CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Taylor, C. T., Kreisle, N., & Zimmerman, P. R. (2007). Vertical relationships and competition in retail gasoline markets: Comment. FTC Bureau of Economics, Working Paper # 291 (Accepted by AER April 2009, forthcoming 2009 or 2010).Google Scholar
  35. Tenn, S. (2008). The price effects of hospital mergers: A case study of the Sutter-Summit transaction. Bureau of Economics, Federal Trade Commission, Working Paper # 293.Google Scholar
  36. Thompson, A. (2009). The effect of hospital mergers on inpatient prices: A case study of the New Hanover-Cape Fear transaction. Federal Trade Commission, Bureau of Economics, Working Paper # 295.Google Scholar
  37. UK Office of Fair Trading. (2008). An evaluation of the impact upon productivity of ending resale price maintenance on books. Report prepared for the OFT by the Centre for Competition Policy at University of East Anglia.Google Scholar
  38. UK Office of Fair Trading., & Competition Commission. (2005). Ex-post evaluation of mergers. March, 2005. Morrison & Elliot of PricewaterhouseCoopers. Retrieved from
  39. UK Office of Fair Trading, Competition Commission, Dept. For Business Enterprise and Regulatory Reform (BERR), Deloitte LLP, and Steve Davies (University of East Anglia). (2009, March 18), Review of merger decisions under the Enterprise Act 2002.Google Scholar
  40. Vita M. G., Sacher S. (2001) The competitive effects of not-for-profit hospital mergers: A case study. Journal of Industrial Economics 49(1): 63–84CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Weinberg, M., & Hosken, D. (2008). Using mergers to test a model of oligopoly. Retrieved from
  42. Weinberg M. (2008) The price effects of horizontal mergers. Journal of Competition Law & Economics 4: 433–447CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Werden G. J., Froeb L. M. (1994) The effects of mergers in differentiated products industries: Logit demand and merger policy. Journal of Law, Economics, & Organization 10: 407–426Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media, LLC. 2009

Authors and Affiliations

  • Joseph Farrell
    • 1
  • Paul A. Pautler
    • 1
  • Michael G. Vita
    • 1
  1. 1.Federal Trade Commission, Bureau of EconomicsWashington, DCUSA

Personalised recommendations