Pro-competitive Price Beating Guarantees: Experimental Evidence
Article
- 92 Downloads
- 8 Citations
Abstract
We report experimental results on duopoly pricing with and without price beating guarantees (PBG). In two control treatments, price beating is either imposed as an industry-wide rule or offered as a business strategy. Our major finding is that when price beating guarantees are imposed as a rule or offered as an option, effective prices are equal to or lower than those in a baseline treatment in which price beating is forbidden. Also, when price beating is treated as a business strategy, less than 50% of subjects adopted the guarantee, suggesting that, subjects realize the pro-competitive effects of the guarantee.
Keywords
experimental oligopolies price beating guaranteesPreview
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
References
- Arbatskaya Maria, Morten Hviid and Greg Shaffer (1999) ‘Promises to Match or Beat Rival Prices’, in M. Baye, ed., Advances in Applied Microeconomics Vol. 8. JAI Press Inc, pp. 123--138.Google Scholar
- Arbatskaya, Maria 2001‘Can Low-Price Guarantees Deter Entry?’International Journal of Industrial Organization1913871406Google Scholar
- Baye, Michael R., Kovenock, Dan 1994‘How to Sell a Pickup Truck: ‘‘Beat-or Pay’’ Advertisement as Facilitating Devices’International Journal of Industrial Organization122133Google Scholar
- Corts, Kenneth S. 1995‘On the Robustness of the Argument that Price Matching is Anti-competitive’Economic Letters47417421Google Scholar
- Corts, Kenneth S. 1996‘On the Competitive Effects of Price Matching Policies’International Journal of Industrial Organization15283299Google Scholar
- Deck, Cary A., Wilson, Bart J. 2003‘Automated Pricing Rules in Electronic Posted Offer Markets’Economic Inquiry41208223Google Scholar
- Dixit, Avinah K., Nalebuff, Barry J. 1991Thinking StrategicallyW.W. Norten & Company. Inc.New York, NYGoogle Scholar
- Dobson, Paul W., Sinclair, C. Donald 1990‘On the Possibility of Price Wars when Firms Use a ‘Tit-for-tat’ Strategy’Economics Letters32115119Google Scholar
- Doyle, Christopher 1988‘Different Selling Strategies in Bertrand Oligopoly’Economic Letters28387390Google Scholar
- Edlin, Aaron S 1997‘Do Guaranteed-Low Price Policies Guarantee High Prices and Can Antitrust Rise to the Challenge?’Harvard Law Review111528575Google Scholar
- García-Gallego, Aurora 1998‘Oligopoly Experimentation of Learning with Simulated Markets’Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization35333355Google Scholar
- García-Gallego, Aurora, Georgantzís , Nikolaos 2001‘Multiproduct Activity in an Experimental Differentiated Oligopoly’International Journal of Industrial Organization19493518Google Scholar
- Green, Edward J., Porter, Robert H. 1984‘Noncooperative Collusion under Imperfect Price Information’Econometrica5287100Google Scholar
- Hess, James D., Gertsner, Eitan 1991‘Price Matching Policies: An Empirical Case’ Managerial and Decision Economics12305315Google Scholar
- Hviid, Morten and Greg Shaffer (1994) ‘Do Low Price Guarantees Facilitate Tacit Collusion?’, University of Michigan working paper 94–02.Google Scholar
- Hviid, Morten, Shaffer, Greg 1999‘Hassle Costs: the Achilles’ Heel of Price-Matching Guarantees’Journal of Economics and Management Strategy8489521Google Scholar
- Kaplan, Todd R. 2000‘Effective Price-Matching: A Comment’ International Journal of Industrial Organization1812911294Google Scholar
- Park, Byeong U., Marron, J.S. 1990‘Comparison of Data-Driven Bandwidth Selectors’Journal of the American Statistical Association856672Google Scholar
- Porter, Robert H. 1983a‘Optimal Trigger Price Strategies’Journal of Economic Theory29313338Google Scholar
- Porter, Robert H. 1983b‘A study of Cartel Stability: The Joint Executive Committee, 1880–1886’Bell Journal of Economics14301314Google Scholar
- Salop, Steven C. 1986‘Practices that (Credibly) Facilitate Oligopoly Coordination’Stiglitz, J.Mathewson, F. eds. New Developments in the Analysis of Market StructureMIT pressCambridge, MA265290Google Scholar
- Sargent, Mark T.L. 1993‘Economics Upside-Down: Low Price Guarantees as Mechanism for Facilitating Tacit Collusion’University of Pennsilvania Law Review14120552118Google Scholar
- Sheater, S.J., Jones, M.C. 1991‘A Reliable Data-Based Bandwidth Selection Method for Kernel Density Estimation’Journal of the Royal Statistical Society53683690Google Scholar
- Smith, Michael D., Bailey, Joseph P., Brynjolfsson, Erik 2000‘Understanding Digital Markets: Review and Assesment’Brynjolfsson, Kahin, eds. Understanding the Digital Economy: Data, Tools and ResearchMIT PressCambridge, MA99136Google Scholar
- Stigler, George 1964‘A Theory of Oligopoly’Journal of Political Economy724461Google Scholar
Copyright information
© Springer 2005