Pollution abatement with limited enforcement power and citizen suits
- 151 Downloads
Federal environmental laws in the U.S. can be enforced by government agencies or by private parties through citizen suits against polluters. Here, I extend the standard enforcement model to examine the role played by citizen suits. The main results from the paper suggest that in a model with limited enforcement power and citizen suits the regulator fully exercises his enforcement power when the expected penalty from a citizen suit is low, but increases his reliance on citizen suits as the expected penalty rises. Whether an enforcement regime that allows private enforcement is efficient depends not only on the relative costs of private and agency enforcement, but also on the changes in inspection costs that may be caused by private enforcement and the expected penalty from losing a citizen suit. These results suggest that in practice private enforcement may lower social costs as long as relatively inexpensive agency enforcement options, such as administrative proceedings, do not preclude citizen suits.
KeywordsPollution control Environmental regulation Compliance Self-reporting Enforcement Citizen suits
JEL ClassificationsD62 L51 K32 K42 Q25
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
- Fadil A. (1985). Citizen suits against polluters: Picking up the pace. Harvard Environmental Law Review, 9(1):23–84Google Scholar
- Hall, R. M., Jr. (2000). EPA’s administrative enforcement: Where the action is. C&M Toxic Torts and Environmental Litigation Newsletter, Spring 2000. Online at http://www.crowell.com/content/resources/publications/browsebyPracticeGroup/NaturalResources/, visited 6/20/2005.Google Scholar
- Macfarlane R., Terry L. (1997). Citizen suits: Impacts on permitting and agency enforcement. Natural Resources and Environment, 11(4):20–25Google Scholar
- May, J. R. (2003). Now more than ever: Recent trends in environmental citizen Suits. Manuscript, Widener University School of Law Symposium. Environmental Citizen Suits at Thirty something: A Celebration and Summit.Google Scholar
- Miller, J. G., & Environmental Law Institute. (1987). Citizen suits: Private enforcement of federal pollution control laws. New York, NY: John Wiley & Sons.Google Scholar
- Russell, C. S. (1990). Monitoring and enforcement. In, Public policies for environmental protection. Paul R. Portney (Ed.), Washington, DC: Resources for the Future.Google Scholar
- Russell C.S., Harrington W., Vaughan W.J. (1986). Enforcing pollution control laws. Washington, DC, Resources for the FutureGoogle Scholar
- Settle, C., Hurley, T. M. & Shogren, J. F. (2001). Citizen suits. In, The law and economics of the environment. Anthony G. Heyes (Ed.), Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.Google Scholar
- Yaeger P. (1991). The limits of the law: The public regulation of private pollution. Cambridge, Cambridge University PressGoogle Scholar