Accounting and litigation risk: evidence from Directors’ and Officers’ insurance pricing
- 1.7k Downloads
We study whether and how financial reporting concerns are priced by insurers that sell Directors’ and Officers’ (D&O) insurance to public firms. As D&O insurers typically assume the liabilities arising from shareholder litigation, the premiums they charge for D&O coverage reflect their assessment of a company’s litigation risk. Using a sample of public firms in the 2001–2004 Tillinghast D&O insurance surveys, we document that firms with lower earnings quality or prior accounting restatements pay higher premiums after controlling for other factors impacting litigation risk. In addition, insurers’ concerns about financial reporting are most evident for firms with restatements that are not revenue or expense related, are greater in the period following the passage of the Sarbanes–Oxley Act of 2002, and are greater for firms with financial reporting problems that linger. Our results are consistent with past restatements being viewed as evidence of chronic problems with a firm’s financial statements. By analyzing archival data, we can also quantify the effects of other determinants of D&O premiums (such as business risk, corporate governance, etc.) identified by Baker and Griffith (Univ Chic Law Rev 74(2):487–544, 2007a) through interviews regarding the D&O underwriting process.
JEL ClassificationG22 G32 K22 K41 K42 M41
KeywordsFinancial reporting quality Accounting restatements Directors’ and Officers’ insurance Litigation risk D&O Corporate governance
We thank Tillinghast–Towers Perrin for providing the insurance data. We would like to thank several industry participants who have shared their valuable time with us. In particular, we thank Elissa Sirovatka of Tillinghast, David Allan of General Reinsurance Corporation, Dan Bailey of Bailey Cavalieri LLC, Michael Early and Frank Kastelic of the Chicago Underwriting Group, Lori Fuchs of Honeywell, Phil Norton of Arthur J. Gallagher and Co., and Paul Van Zuiden of Risk Management and Insurance Consulting LLC. We acknowledge helpful comments from Stephen Penman (Editor), two anonymous reviewers, Rashad Abdel-khalik, Tom Baker, Paul Beck, Andy Bauer, Michael Donahoe, Todd Green, Dongkuk Lim, Brian Mittendorf, Scott Richardson, Roberta Romano, Theo Sougiannis, Shyam Sunder, Jake Thomas, Anne Thomson, Albert Tsang, Peter Wysocki, Frank Zhang, and seminar and conference participants at the 2012 American Accounting Association Western Region Meeting, Yale School of Management, the University of Connecticut School of Law, the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign and the University of Washington Tacoma. Any errors are our own.
- Bailey, D. A. (2002). Size of D&O settlements exploding. Available at http://library.findlaw.com/2002/Nov/1/130753.html.
- Baker, T., & Griffith, S. J. (2007a). Predicting corporate governance risk: Evidence from the Directors’ & Officers’ liability insurance market. The University of Chicago Law Review, 74(2), 487–544.Google Scholar
- Baker, T., & Griffith, S. J. (2007b). The missing monitor in corporate governance: The Directors’ & Officers’ liability insurer. Georgetown Law Journal, 95(6), 1795–1842.Google Scholar
- Black, B., Cheffins, B., & Klausner, M. (2003). Outside director liability. SSRN working paper. Available at http://papers.ssrn.com/abstractid=382422.
- Boyer, M. (2004). Is the demand for corporate insurance a habit? Evidence from Directors’ and Officers’ insurance. HEC Montreal CIRANO working paper. Available at http://www.cirano.qc.ca/pdf/publication/2004s-33.pdf.
- Boyer, M. (2005). Directors’ and Officers’ insurance and shareholder protection. HEC Montreal CIRANO working paper. Available at http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=886504.
- Brown, S., Hillegeist, S. A., & Lo, K. (2005). Management forecasts and litigation risk. SSRN working paper. Available at http://papers.ssrn.com/abstract_id=709161.
- Chen, X., Cheng, Q., & Lo, A. K. (2012). Is the decline in the information content of earnings following restatements temporary? Working paper, 2012 American Accounting Association Annual Meeting. Available at http://aaahq.org/AM2012/display.cfm?Filename=SubID%5F1993%2Epdf&MIMEType=application%2Fpdf.
- Chung, H. H., Wynn, J. P., & Yi, H. (2008). Managerial opportunism, legal liability rule, and audit pricing. Working paper, Arizona State University. Available at http://aaahq.org/meetings/AUD2009/ManagerialOpportunism.pdf.
- DeFond, M. L., & Jiambalvo, J. (1991). Incidence and circumstances of accounting errors. The Accounting Review, 66(3), 643–655.Google Scholar
- Dopuch, N., & Simunic, D. (1980). The nature of competition in the auditing profession: A descriptive and normative view. In Regulation and the accounting profession, 34(2): 283–289. Belmont, CA: Lifetime Learning Publications.Google Scholar
- Early, M., & Kastelic, F. (2004). What’s really going on in D&O insurance: Taking a look at capacity, claims and carriers. Tillinghast executive D&O seminar: D&O liability—What’s wrong with this picture? New York.Google Scholar
- Ettredge, M., Huang, Y., & Zhang, W. (2011). Restatement disclosures and management earnings forecasts. SSRN working paper. Available at http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1764524.
- Files, R., Sharp, N. Y., & Thompson, A. (2011). Why do firms restate repeatedly? SSRN working paper. Available at http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1748822.
- Jones, C. L. (1998). The association of earnings management with current returns, current market values, future returns, executive compensation and the likelihood of being a target of 10b-5 litigation. Dissertation, Stanford University.Google Scholar
- Kaltchev, G. D. (2006). Dynamic panel models with directors’ and officers’ liability insurance data. Panel Data Econometrics, 274, 351–360.Google Scholar
- Kim, I. Y. (2006). Directors’ and Officers’ insurance and opportunism in accounting choice. Working paper, Duke University. Available at http://www.efmaefm.org/efma2006/papers/764024_full.pdf.
- Knepper, W. E., & Bailey, D. A. (1998). Liability of corporate Officers & Directors (6th ed.). Charlottesville, VA: Lexis Law Pub.Google Scholar
- Lazer, R., Livnat, J., & Tan, C. E. L. 2004. Restatements and accruals after auditor changes. Working paper, New York University.Google Scholar
- Mathias, J. H., Neumeier, M. M., & Burgdoerfer, J. J. (2000). Directors and officers liability: Prevention, insurance, and indemnification. New York: American Lawyer Media Law Journal Press.Google Scholar
- Palmrose, Z.-V. (1988). An analysis of auditor litigation and audit service quality. The Accounting Review, 63(1), 55–73.Google Scholar
- PricewaterhouseCoopers. (2002). PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP 2002 securities litigation study. Available at http://10b5.pwc.com/pdf/2002_study_final.pdf.
- PricewaterhouseCoopers. (2003). PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP 2003 securities litigation study. Available at http://10b5.pwc.com/pdf/2002_study_final.pdf.
- Romano, R. (1991). The shareholder suit: Litigation without foundation? Journal of Law Economics and Organization, 7(1), 55–87.Google Scholar
- Romano, R. (2001). Less is more: Making institutional investor activism a valuable mechanism of corporate governance. Yale Journal on Regulation, 18(2), 174–251.Google Scholar
- Ronen, J. (2002). Post-Enron reform: Financial statement insurance, and GAAP re-visited. Stanford Journal of Law, Business and Finance, 8(1), 1–30.Google Scholar
- Scholz, S. (2008). The changing nature and consequences of public company financial restatements. The Department of Treasury, April, 1–54.Google Scholar
- Sennetti, J. T., & Turner, J. L. 1999. Post-audit restatement risk and brand-name audits. Working paper, Nova Southeastern University.Google Scholar
- Skinner, D. J. (1996). Why is stockholder litigation tied to accounting and disclosure problems? Unpublished manuscript, University of Michigan.Google Scholar
- Tillinghast. (2002). Directors and Officers liability survey. Available at http://www.towersperrin.com/tillinghast/publications/reports/Directors_and_Officers_2002/DO_summary2002a.pdf.
- Tillinghast. (2005). Directors and Officers liability survey. Available at http://www.towersperrin.com/tillinghast/publications/reports/2005_DO/DO_2005_Exec_Sum.pdf.