## Abstract

This paper aims to shed some light on the way lay consumers forecast by comparing survey expectations on two different—but linked—fundamentals. Specifically, we study the central tendencies and cross-sectional dispersions of predictions on individual-level and aggregate income dynamics. The proposed joint analysis highlights several interesting outcomes. Agents’ predictions on micro and macroeconomic evolutions do not drift apart despite (possibly composite) shocks have permanent effects on expectations. When shocks create a gap between the two expectations, in fact, individuals revise only forecasts about GDP dynamics. Otherwise stated, predictions on personal stances are much stickier. With respect to these latter, then, expectations on aggregate dynamics overreact to shocks and, amazingly from an objective standpoint, they are systematically bleaker. As per second moments evidence shows, in sharp contrast with the typical assumption maintained in the macroeconomic literature, that disagreement among agents is persistently high. Moreover, the comparison makes astonishingly clear that when predicting the same macro fundamental the consensus is even lower. Finally, our setting allows testing whether cross sectional disagreement and time series volatility in expectations are equal.

## Keywords

Expectations Heterogeneous information Aggregate shocks Survey data## JEL Classification

C83 D83 D84 E37## References

- Anderson, O.: The Business Test of the Ifo-institute for Economic Research, Munich, and Its Theoretical Model. Revue de l'Institut International de Statistique/Review of the International Statistical Institute.
**20**(1), 1–17 (1952)Google Scholar - Bachmann, R., Elstner, S., Sims, E.: Uncertainty and Economic Activity: Evidence from Business Survey Data. Am. Econ. J. Macroecon.
**5**, 217–249 (2013)Google Scholar - Badarinza, C., Buchmann, M.: Inflation Perceptions and Expectations in the Euro Area—The Role of News. ECB Working Paper 1088 (2009)Google Scholar
- Batchelor, R.A.: Quantitative v. qualitative measures of inflation expectations. Oxford Bull. Econ. Stat.
**48**, 99–120 (1986)CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Batchelor, R.A., Orr, A.B.: Inflation expectations revisited. Economica
**55**, 317–331 (1988)CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Baron, J.: Thinking and Deciding, 4th edn. Cambridge University Press, New York (2007)Google Scholar
- Berk, J.M.: Measuring inflation expectations: a survey data approach. Appl. Econ.
**31**, 1467–1480 (1999)CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Bertrand, M., Mullainathan, S.: Do people mean what they say? Implications for subjective survey data. Am. Econ. Rev.
**91**(2), 67–72 (2001)CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Bovi, M.: Economic versus psychological forecasting. Evidence from consumer confidence surveys. J. Econ. Psychol.
**30**(4), 563–574 (2009)CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Bovi, M.: Are the representative agent’s beliefs based on efficient econometric models? J. Econ. Dyn. Control
**37**, 633–648 (2013)CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Buckle, R.A., Meads, C.S.: How do firms react to surprising changes to demand? A vector autoregressive analysis using business survey data. Oxford Bull. Econ. Stat.
**53**(4), 451–466 (1991)CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Capistrán, C., Timmermann, A.G.: Disagreement and biases in inflation expectations. J. Money Credit Bank.
**41**(2–3), 365–396 (2009)CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Carlson, J.A., Parkin, M.: Inflation expectations. Economica
**42**, 123–138 (1975)CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Carroll, C.D.: How does future income affect current consumption? Q. J. Econ.
**109**(1), 111–147 (1994)CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Cavaliere, G., Xu, F.: Testing for unit roots in bounded time series. J. Econom.
**178**, 259–272 (2013)CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Caballero, R.J.: Earnings Uncertainty, Precautionary Savings and Aggregate Wealth Accumulation. Columbia University Discussion Papers, 1990_26, Department of Economics (1990)Google Scholar
- Clements, M.P., Hendry, D.F. (eds.): The Oxford Handbook of Economic Forecasting. Oxford University Press, Oxford (2011)Google Scholar
- Dasgupta, S., Lahiri, K.: A comparative study of alternative methods of quantifying qualitative survey responses using NAPM data. J. Bus. Econ. Stat.
**10**, 391–400 (1992)Google Scholar - de Bruin, W.B., Manski, C.F., Topa, G., van der Klaauw, W.: Measuring consumer uncertainty about future inflation. J. Appl. Econom.
**26**, 454–478 (2011)CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Della Vigna, S.: Psychology and Economics: Evidence from the Field. J. Econ. Lit.
**47**(2), 315–372 (2009)Google Scholar - Dominitz, J., Manski, C.F.: Eliciting student expectations of the returns to schooling. J. Hum. Resour.
**31**(1), 1–26 (1996)CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Doms, M., Morin, N.: Consumer Sentiment, the Economy, and the News Media, Finance and Economics Discussion Series, vol. 51. Divisions of Research & Statistics and Monetary Affairs Federal Reserve Board, Washington, DC (2004)Google Scholar
- Driver, C., Urga, G.: Transforming qualitative survey data: comparisons for the UK. Oxford Bull. Econ. Stat.
**66**(1), 71–89 (2004)CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Engle, Robert F., Granger, C.W.J.: Co-integration and error correction: representation, estimation, and testing. Econometrica
**55**, 251–276 (1987)CrossRefGoogle Scholar - European Commission: The Joint Harmonised EU Programme of Business and Consumer Surveys, User Guide. European Commission. Directorate General for Economic and Financial Affairs (2007)Google Scholar
- European Commission: The Joint Harmonised EU Programme of Business and Consumer Surveys, User Guide. European Commission. Directorate General for Economic and Financial Affairs (2014)Google Scholar
- Elliott, G., Rothenberg, T.J., Stock, J.H.: Efficient tests for an autoregressive unit root. Econometrica
**64**, 813–836 (1996)CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Evans, G., Honkapohja, S.: Learning as a Rational Foundation for Macroeconomics and Finance. In: Frydman, R., Phelps, E. (eds.) Rethinking Expectations: The Way Forward for Macroeconomics. Princeton University Press, Princeton (2013)Google Scholar
- Frydman, R., Phelps, E.S. (eds.): Rethinking Expectations: The Way Forward for Macroeconomics. Princeton University Press, Princeton (2013)Google Scholar
- Fullone, F., Gamba, M., Giovannini, E., Malgarini, M.: What do citizens know about statistics? The results of an OECD/ISAE survey on Italian consumers. In Statistics, Knowledge and Policy 2007: Measuring and Fostering the Progress of Societies, OECD, Paris (2008)Google Scholar
- Galì, J., Monacelli, T.: Optimal monetary and fiscal policy in a currency union. J. Int. Econ.
**76**(1), 116–132 (2008)CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Granger, C.W.J.: Some thoughts on the development of cointegration. J. Econ.
**158**(1), 3–6 (2010)Google Scholar - Guvenen, F.: Macroeconomics With Heterogeneity: A Practical Guide. NBER Working Paper, 17622 (2011)Google Scholar
- Hall, R.E., Mishkin, F.S.: The sensitivity of consumption to transitory income: estimates from panel data on households. Econometrica
**50**(2), 461–481 (1982)CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Hayashi, F.: Econometrics. Princeton University Press, Econometrics (2000)Google Scholar
- Hendry, D.F., Juselius, K.: Explaining cointegration analysis: part II. Energy J.
**22**, 75–120 (2001)CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Hommes, C.: Heterogeneous agent models in economics and finance. In: Judd, K.L., Tesfatsion, L. (eds.) Handbook of Computational Economics, vol. 2. Agent-Based Computational Economics (2006)Google Scholar
- Jaimovich, N., Rebelo, S.T.: Behavioural Theories of the Business Cycle. CEPR Discussion Paper 5909 (2006)Google Scholar
- Johansen, S.: Likelihood-based Inference in Cointegrated Vector Autoregressive Models. Oxford University Press, Oxford (1995)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Kapteyn, A., Kleinjans, K., Van Soest, A.: Intertemporal consumption with directly measured welfare functions and subjective expectations. J. Econ. Behav. Organ.
**72**(1), 425–437 (2009)CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Krueger, K., Perri, F., Pistaferri, L., Violante, G.L.: Cross sectional facts for macroeconomists. Rev. Econ. Dyn.
**13**(1), 1–14 (2010)CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Lacy, M.G.: An explained variation measure for ordinal response models with comparisons to other ordinal R2 measures. Sociol. Methods Res.
**34**, 469–520 (2006)CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Lahiri, K., Sheng, X.: Measuring forecast uncertainty by disagreement: the missing link. J. Appl. Econom.
**25**, 514–538 (2010)CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Lucas, R.E.: Some international evidence on output-inflation trade-offs. Am. Econ. Rev.
**63**, 326–334 (1973)Google Scholar - Ludvigson, S.: Consumer confidence and consumer spending. J. Econ. Perspect.
**18**, 29–50 (2004)CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Maag, T.: On the Accuracy of the Probability Method for Quantifying Beliefs about Inflation. Working papers, KOF Swiss Economic Institute, ETH Zurich, 09-230 (2009)Google Scholar
- Mankiw, N.G., Reis, R.: Sticky information in general equilibrium. J. Eur. Econ. Assoc.
**5**(2–3), 603–613 (2007)CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Mankiw, N.G., Wolfers, J., Reis, R.: Disagreement about inflation expectations. NBER Macroecon. Annu.
**18**, 209–248 (2003)CrossRefGoogle Scholar - MacKinnon, J.G., Haug, A., Michelis, A.: Numerical distribution functions of likelihood ratio tests for cointegration. J. Appl. Econom.
**4**(5), 563–577 (1999)CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Morris, S., Shin, H.S.: Social value of public information. Am. Econ. Rev.
**92**(5), 1521–1534 (2002)Google Scholar - Nardo, M.: The quantification of qualitative survey data: a critical assessment. J. Econ. Surv.
**17**, 645–668 (2003)CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Ng, S., Perron, P.: lag length selection and the construction of unit root tests with good size and power. Econometrica
**69**(6), 1519–1554 (2001)CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Orphanides, A., D’Amico, S.: Uncertainty and Disagreement in Economic Forecasting. Finance and Economics Discussion Series, Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (2008)Google Scholar
- Papacostas S.: Special eurobarometer: European knowledge on economical indicators. In: Statistics, Knowledge and Policy 2007: Measuring and Fostering the Progress of Societies, OECD, Paris (2008)Google Scholar
- Pesaran, M.H.: The Limits to Rational Expectations. Basic Blackwell, Oxford (1987)Google Scholar
- Pesaran, M.H., Weale, M.: Survey Expectations. Handbook of Economic Forecasting. Elsevier, Amsterdam (2006)Google Scholar
- Pohl, R.F.: Cognitive Illusions: A Handbook on Fallacies and Biases in Thinking, Judgment and Memory. Psychology Press, Hove (2004)Google Scholar
- Reis, R.: Inattentive Consumers. J. Monet. Econ.
**53**(8), 1761–1800 (2006)CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Rich, R., Tracy, J.: The relationship among expected inflation, disagreement, and uncertainty: evidence from matched point and density forecasts. Rev. Econ. Stat.
**92**, 200–207 (2010)CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Rich, R., Song, J., Tracey, J.: The Measurement and Behavior of Uncertainty: Evidence from the ECB Survey of Professional Forecasters. Federal Reserve Bank of New York Staff Report No. 588 (2012)Google Scholar
- Rossi, B., Sekhposyan, T.: Macroeconomic uncertainty indices based on nowcast and forecast error distributions. Am. Econ. Rev.
**105**, 650–655 (2015)CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Sims, C.: Implications of rational inattention. J. Mon. Econ.
**50**, 665–690 (2003)Google Scholar - Skinner, J.: Risky income, life cycle consumption, and precautionary savings. J. Monet. Econ.
**22**(2), 237–255 (1988)CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Smith, J., McAleer, M.: Alternative procedures for converting qualitative response data to quantitative expectations: an application to australian manufacturing. J. Appl. Econom.
**10**, 165–185 (1995)CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Theil, H.: On the shape of micro-variables and the munich business test. Revue de l’Institut International de Statistique
**20**, 105–120 (1952)CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Tversky, A., Kahneman, T.: Judgment under uncertainty: heuristics and biases. Science
**185**(4157), 1124–1131 (1974)CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Zarnowitz, V., Lambros, L.A.: Consensus and uncertainty in economic prediction. J. Polit. Econ.
**95**, 591–621 (1987)CrossRefGoogle Scholar