New data on the representation of women in philosophy journals: 2004–2015
- 768 Downloads
This paper presents new data on the representation of women who publish in 25 top philosophy journals as ranked by the Philosophical Gourmet Report (2015) for the years 2004, 2014, and 2015. It also provides a new analysis of Schwitzgebel’s 1955–2015 journal data (women-in-philosophy.org). The paper makes four points while providing an overview of the current state of women authors in philosophy. In all years and for all journals, the percentage of female authors was extremely low, in the range of 14–16%. The percentage of women authors is less than the percentage of women faculty in different ranks and at different kinds of institutions. In addition, there is great variation across individual journals, and the discrepancy between women authors and women faculty appears to be different in different subfields. Interestingly, journals which do not practice anonymous review seem to have a higher percentage of women authors than journals which practice double anonymous or triple anonymous review. This paper also argues that we need more data on academic publishing to better understand whether this can explain why there are so few full-time female faculty in philosophy, since full-time hiring and tenuring practices presumably depend on a candidate’s academic publishing.
KeywordsDiversity Philosophy journals Proportions by sub-discipline Influence of review type
We are indebted support provided by the Demographics in Philosophy Project advisory board, with special thanks to Julie Van Camp, Ruth Chang, Tom Dougherty, Edouard Machery, and Eric Schwitzgebel for providing feedback on early drafts. Thanks also to Ben Bronner, Mark Fortney, and Morgan Thompson for helping to collect the data. Finally, we thank Irina Artamonova, Lucio Esposito, Shen-yi Liao, anonymous referees, as well as the editors of Philosophical Studies, for comments on later drafts.
- Ahmed, S. (2013). Making feminist points. Feministkilljoys: Blog. Available from http://feministkilljoys.com. 20 Jan 2017.
- Arvan, M. (2015). Philosophers don’t read and cite enough (guest post by Marcus Arvan). Daily Nous: Blog. Available from http://dailynous.com/. 6 June 2016.
- Beebee, H., & Saul, J. (2011). Women in philosophy in the UK. A Report by the British Philosophical Association and the Society for Women in Philosophy UK. Joint BPA/SWIP Committee for Women in Philosophy. Available from http://www.bpa.ac.uk. 30 Nov 2015.
- Brogaard, B. (2012). The journal reviewing process isn’t anonymous. Did you really think it was? Think again! New APPS: Blog. Available from http://www.newappsblog.com. 12 Jan 2017.
- Critical Ethnic Studies Journal. (2015). Citation practices. Available from http://www.criticalethnicstudiesjournal.org/citation-practices/. 31 Jan 2017.
- De Cruz, H. (2014a). Anonymous reviewing is not enough to counter implicit bias, so what can we do to mitigate it? New APPS: Blog. http://www.newappsblog.com. 28 July 2016.
- De Cruz, H. (2014b). A bechdel test for philosophy papers. New APPS: Blog. Available from http://www.newappsblog.com. 28 July 2016.
- Dotson, K. (2012). How is this paper philosophy? Comparative Philosophy, 3(1), 3–29.Google Scholar
- Dougherty, T., Baron, S., & Miller, K. (2015). Female under-representation among philosophy majors: A map of the hypotheses and a survey of the evidence. Feminist Philosophical Quarterly 1(1). http://ir.lib.uwo.ca/fpq/vol1/iss1/4.
- Dunleavy, P. (2014). Poor citation practices are a form of academic self-harm in the humanities and social sciences. Writing For Research: Blog. Available from https://medium.com. 16 Jan 2017.
- Goddard, E. (2008). Improving the participation of women in the philosophy profession. Report C: Students by Gender in Philosophy Programs in Australian Universities. Australasian Association of Philosophy. Available from http://www.aap.org.au. 30 Nov 2015.
- Haslanger, S. (2013). Survey of earned doctorates % women. Data on Women in Philosophy: Website APA Committee on the Status of Women. Available from http://www.apaonlinecsw.org. 12 Jan 2015.
- Hassoun, N., & Conklin, S. (2015) Data on women in philosophy. Available from http://women-in-philosophy.org. 19 April 2017.
- Healy, K. (2013). Lewis and the women. Kieran Healy: Blog. Available from http://kieranhealy.org. 3 Dec 2015.
- Healy, K. (2015). Gender and citation in four general-interest philosophy journals, 1993–2013. Kieran Healy: Blog. Available from http://kieranhealy.org. 30 Nov 2015.
- Irvin, S. (2014). Diversity in aesthetics publishing. Aesthetics for Birds: Blog. Available from http://www.aestheticsforbirds.com/. 4 Aug 2016.
- Jennings, C. D. (2014a). Job placement 2011–2014: Overview on gender. New APPS: Blog. Available from http://www.newappsblog.com. 2 Dec 2015.
- Jennings, C. D. (2014b). Job placement 2011–2014: Overview on AOS. New APPS: Blog. Available from http://www.newappsblog.com. December 02, 2015.
- Jennings, C. D. (2015a). An empirical look at gender and research specialization. Invited colloquium presentation for the Metaphilosophy & Diversity Colloquium at Boston University: March 2015.Google Scholar
- Jennings, C. D. (2015b). Tracking the job market: A start. New APPS: Blog. Available from http://www.newappsblog.com. 2 Dec 2015.
- Jennings, C. D., Kyrilov, A., Cobb, P., Vlasits, J., Vinson, D. W., Montes, E., & Franco, C. (2015). Academic placement data and analysis: 2015 final report. New APPS: Blog. Available from http://www.newappsblog.com. 30 Nov 2015.
- Journal of the American Philosophical Association [JAPA]. (2015). Instructions for contributors. Revised 16 June 2015. Available from http://journals.cambridge.org/. 8 Aug 2016.
- Junn, J. (2012). Analysis of data on tenure at USC Dornsife. Memo to USC Dornsife faculty council. University of Southern California.Google Scholar
- Krishnamurthy, M. (2014). The underrepresentation of women in elite ethics journals: To quota or not to quota? Available from https://meenakrishnamurthy.net/. 15 July 2016.
- Lee, C. J., & Schunn, C. D. (2010). Philosophy journal practices and opportunities for bias. APA Newsletters: Newsletter on Feminism and Philosophy, 10(1), 5–9.Google Scholar
- Leiter, B. (2015). The top 20 “general” philosophy journals, 2015. Leiter Reports: A Philosophy Blog. Available from http://leiterreports.typepad.com. 7 June 2016.
- Midsummer Philosophy Workshop. (2016). Review policies. Available from http://midsummerphilosophy.squarespace.com/.
- Norlock, K. (2006). Women in the profession: A report to the CSW. Data on Women in Philosophy. APA Committee on the Status of Women. Available from http://www.apaonlinecsw.org. 30 Nov 2015.
- Norlock, K. (2011). Update. Data on Women in Philosophy. APA Committee on the Status of Women. Available from http://www.apaonlinecsw.org. 30 Nov 2015.
- Norlock, K. (2014). Gender ratios of papers published in ethics and the journal of moral philosophy. New APPS: Blog. Available from http://www.newappsblog.com. 12 Dec 2015.
- Philosophical Review. (2016). Philosophical review editorial policies for authors. The Philosophical Review. https://www.dukeupress.edu. 12 Jan 2017.
- Schwitzgebel, E. (2014a). Citation of women and minorities in the Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Blog post at The Splintered Mind. Available from http://schwitzsplinters.blogspot.com.
- Schwitzgebel, E. (2014b). The 267 most-cited authors in the Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. The Splintered Mind: Underblog 7 August 2015. Available from http://schwitzsplintersunderblog.blogspot.com.
- Schwitzgebel, E. (2015a). How prominently is women’s philosophical work discussed? One empirical measure. The Splintered Mind: Blog. Available from http://schwitzsplinters.blogspot.com. 4 Aug 2016.
- Schwitzgebel, E. (2015b). Only 13% of authors in five leading philosophy journals are women. The Splintered Mind: Blog. Available from http://schwitzsplinters.blogspot.com. 18 Dec 2015.
- Thompson, M., Adleberg, T., Sims, S., & Nahmias, E. (2016). Why do women leave philosophy? Surveying Students at the Introductory Level. Philosopher’s Imprint, 16(6), 1–36.Google Scholar
- Valian, V. (1998). Why so slow? The advancement of women. Cambridge: MIT Press.Google Scholar
- Van Camp, J. (2004). Tenured/tenure-track faculty women at 98 U.S. doctoral programs in philosophy. Website. Available from https://web.csulb.edu/~jvancamp/doctoral_2004.html. 1 Jan 2015.
- Weinberg, J. (2014). Making philosophy journal statistics publicly available. Blog post at The Daily Nous. Available from http://dailynous.com/. 12 Jan 2017.